Liz Pulliam Weston suggests that you may want to consider using cash instead of a debit card. Weston admits that debit cards offer plenty of advantages, including:

  • They’re convenient.
  • They’re easier to track.
  • They may offer some protection.
  • They may offer some rewards.

Despite these advantages, she suggests that it may be better to move to a cash-only system. It’s just too easy to overspend with a debit card. She cites one family that uses the “envelope system” for allocating cash for various needs: the family places cash to envelopes (marked “food”, “gas”, “entertainment”, etc.) and uses this money for the designated purpose. This not only prevents overspending, but also serves as a sort of built-in budget. Experts advise: if you can eat it, drink it, or wear it, pay cash.

Before moving to a completely cash-based system, Weston warns to:

  • Expect some trial and error — it may take time to perfect the system.
  • Don’t carry big wads of cash — it’s too tempting to spend, and you have no protection.
  • Mind your credit scores — you’ll need them for large purchases, such as a house or a car.

I have not yet developed the strength of will required to forego my debit card completely. (Though I gave up all credit cards several years ago.) It’s too convenient. Still, there are times that I choose to use cash only.

For example, any time I go on vacation, I travel on a cash basis. I know that if I were to rely on a debit card while on holiday, I would be too inclined to buy souvenirs and to eat more expensive meals. If I’m headed to Central Oregon for a weekend vacation, I might take $100 with me, knowing that has to feed me, entertain me, and buy me gas for three days.

If you do opt to use a cash-only system, if only for a weekend vacation, be sure to track your expenses. It’s important to keep a notebook or a business card on which you write every cash expenditure; there’s no built-in record-keeping system such as the bank statements serve with a debit card.

GRS is committed to helping our readers save and achieve their financial goals. Savings interest rates may be low, but that is all the more reason to shop for the best rate. Find the highest savings interest rates and CD rates from Synchrony Bank, Ally Bank, GE Capital Bank, and more.