We returned from San Francisco to find a bounty of fresh produce in our garden.

What can a fellow do with so many tomatoes? Make fresh salsa, of course. My wife has perfected a recipe she adapted from the Cook’s Illustrated cookbook, The Best Recipe. Here’s the original, followed by her modifications.
Fresh Red Table Salsa
- 3 large very ripe tomatoes (~2#), cored and quartered
- 1/2 cup tomato juice
- 1 small jalapeno or other fresh chile, chopped (remove seeds for mild salsa)
- 1 medium red onion, quartered
- 1 medium garlic clove, peeled
- 1/2 cup chopped fresh cilantro
- 1/2 cup juice from 4 medium limes
- salt to taste
Blend everything together in blender or food processor to desired chunkiness. Put the salsa in the fridge for 8+ hours (the longer the better). Enjoy!
Things we have learned with this recipe:
- Be careful with the lime juice. Some people prefer less; others prefer more. We like it, so we use 3/4 cup.
- If, like me, you’re not a fan of cilantro, be sure the leaves are chopped fine. You may want to reduce the cilantro to just 1/4 cup.
- For optimum flavor, follow J.D.’s Rule of Garlic: “Always add five times the amount of garlic called for by the recipe.” In this case, use five cloves of garlic instead of one clove. You’ll thank me later. (Kris says she usually puts in 2-3 cloves.)
- To vary the heat of the salsa, alter the number of chiles (in particular, the quantity of seeds from the chiles). It tastes great even without them.
We call this The Best Salsa Ever. It tastes best after settling for a day or two. I think it gains flavor if set in the sun for an hour before use, but Kris thinks I’m crazy. Regardless, it’s a cheap and tasty treat on a late summer afternoon. Your cost will vary based on what you’re able to grow and what you have to buy. We figure it costs about $2.50 per batch, which yields about six cups. Plus chips. We have to buy chips. (If we could grow our own limes, it would be cheaper still…)
Kris has been canning food like mad since we returned. In addition to the salsa, she’s made:
- six half-pints of apple conserve
- four pints of pickled cherry tomatoes
- two pints of pickled zucchini
- two pints of berry freezer jam
- one batch of Asian cucumber salad (another good frugal recipe I should share)
- one batch of bread-and-butter pickles
- six half-pints of elderberry-apple conserve
- a potato-tomato salad for potluck
That’s a lot of food.
I haven’t written much yet about gardening, but it’s a topic that I’ll cover well in the future. If you have the space and the time, growing your own food can be an excellent way to save money. (We’ve saved hundreds of dollars on berries alone this summer.)
GRS is committed to helping our readers save and achieve your financial goals.Savings interest rates may be low, but that’s all the more reason to shop for the best rate.Find the highest savings interest rate from Ally Bank, Capital One 360, Everbank, and more.
This article is about Food, Frugality
Disclaimer: This content is not provided or commissioned by American Express. Opinions expressed here are author's alone, not those of American Express, and have not been reviewed, approved or otherwise endorsed by American Express. This site may be compensated through American Express Affiliate Program.
Discover is a paid advertiser of this site. Reasonable efforts are made to maintain accurate information. See the Discover online credit card application for full terms and conditions on offers and rewards.
SEARCH FOR RECENT ARTICLES




I have freshly grown Jalepenos… Lemme know if you want some for your salsa.
loading....
Jd forgot to mention that I buy one large container of Campbell’s tomato juice at the beginning of the summer and freeze it in 1/2-cup portions just for this recipe. In such a flavorful mix, you can’t tell the difference, and it makes it very economical. However, this year I plan to try canning my own homegrown tomato juice. And does anyone have a good recipe for home-canned tomato soup?
loading....
Apparently “salsa” triggers Google’s Spanish-language adwords algorithm…
loading....
Hey guys,
Great recipe, I too have far too many tomatoes left over so this is much appreciated, just a quick question: do you have any tips for storing this salsa, preserving jars, freezing maybe?
cheers,
Ciaron
loading....
That sounds tasty… Although if you find that the best salsa ever, you might want to come to Mexico and ask any old lady on any old town for a great salsa recipe. You’ll be blown away.
And be sure to try using a Molcajete[1] and slowly cook the tomatoes directly on the flames for a while until all their sides are somewhat black. You can do the same with the chiles, although they’ll may become a bit too “hot” for you Americans (no offense intended).
It’s a lot more work (relatively), but it’s worth it.
[1] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Molcajete
loading....
Wow, Ivan. That sounds like something we’ll have to try. I like salsa of all kinds, that’s for sure.
Ciaron, this salsa isn’t suitable for canning. If we find a good canned salsa, I’ll share the recipe.
Lane, we have plenty of jalapenos, but if you need tomatoes, drop me a line. We have extra.
loading....
Can you freeze the salsa?
How does it come out?
loading....
Kris says that freezing the salsa would turn it to mush. This is a fresh salsa and meant to be eaten as such. Yum.
(As a sidenote, when we don’t have fresh produce to make this salsa, my favorite is the very-different Salsa Autentica from Trader Joe’s. I buy it by the case. It’s a saucey, with no chunks, but the flavor is great. A different kind of salsa, to be sure, but very good.)
loading....
[...] Kris and a friend masterminded a tomato-growing extravaganza: they ordered seeds together, and are each testing certain varieties. Kris has eight enormous plants, and she’s been harvesting the fruit every night. She’s made tomato soup, tomato sauce, marinara sauce, and, of course, many batches of our favorite salsa. Her tomato map hangs from the fridge, and she’s circled her favorite varieties (Aunt Ruby’s German Green, Yellow Pear, Bloody Butcher, Dr. Wyche’s Yellow, and maybe Caspian Pink) so that she can order them again next year. [...]
loading....
This salsa had waaaay too much lime & cilantro for my family’s taste. I was able to salvage it by adding 1 more jalapeno and 1 tablespoon of sugar. That seemed to cut the lime’s sourness and the cilantro’s bitterness.
loading....
Most frugal seeds would be heirlooms getting recycled from fruit, not hybrids.
loading....
Tomato seeds are not easy to “keep,” as the tomatoes used must be fermented before the seeds are kept and washed. Then dried and packaged in a way that will guarentee their vialibity for the next year. Most seeds have such a short shelf life that this would mean doing this complicated, time consuming process every year.
We have an organic farm and buy hybrid seeds for most everything. The disease resistance is an important factor, as well as the time. Yields are greatly improved with many hybrids, as are flavors (there is no such thing as a supersweet heirloom corn, these varieties are careful crosses designed to create sugar without allowing conversion to starch).
Seeds leftover from last year are cheap, until you have a wilt take out an entire crop. And a lot of seeds have some big cross pollination issues. Grow sweet corn within a few miles of a field corn stand, or any other sweet corn, and the hybrid that is created will be tough and starchy, instead of tender and sweet. Tomatoes aren’t as bad on this one, but it’s a risk.
You can get a big savings on seeds by buying in bulk. You would get way more seeds than one family could reasonably use in a year, but the smaller “bulk” seed amounts would be great for a neighborhood. A group of neighbors could go into a veggie project together — this one growing a lot of tomatoes, that one growin peppers, another working on corn, etc. It’s easier to keep on top of things if you only have one type of veggie to work with, then everyone shares the bounty.
Cheap and cheerful, building community, and having a good shot at getting great food.
loading....
[...] Frugal Recipes: The Best Salsa EverFrugality in Practice: Canning SeasonSave on Groceries with ‘Strike-Point Shopping’My Blogathon Command PostFrugality in Practice: Planting Time [...]
loading....
I find that this is closer to pico de gallo (which is also great) than salsa.
Laura: I agree. Thanks for the tip on the sugar/jalapeno. I will try that.
loading....
You should post a picture. Do you have any cooked salsa recipes or do you always do fresh?
loading....