“Pay off your debt.” “Max out your IRA.” “Buy a house.” “Get a new job.” Personal finance advisers bombard us with a litany of things we ought to do in order to achieve financial independence. It’s overwhelming. Where’s a person to start?
Most personal finance books agree: the first thing you should do — after meeting basic needs, and while reducing spending — is to start an emergency fund.
What is an emergency fund?
An emergency fund is an easily accessible stash of money for use only in case of emergency. It is not to be used to buy a new car. It is not to be used to buy a new Playstation. It is not to be used to remodel your bathroom. It is for use only in case of emergency.
Why do you need an emergency fund?
Do you really need to ask? Here are some real-life emergencies that have happened recently to people I know:
[article continued below...]
- A client’s two children were in a horrible accident Monday night. One died and the other is in intensive care.
- My little brother decided to pack up and move across the state to start a new job.
- A friend’s garage door collapsed.
- My neighbor had a heart attack last week.
- Oregon’s largest private employer just laid off over 10,000 workers.
These are all emergencies of one degree or another. In each case, those people with an emergency fund are going to be in better shape than those without one. Studies show that those without emergency savings are more likely to accumulate debt. It may feel like you can’t afford to have one, but the truth is you can’t afford not to have one. Emergency funds are essential, even for college students.
How much is enough?
Though personal finance experts agree emergency funds are necessary, there’s no consensus on how much is enough. Some say you need save a year’s salary. Others believe $1000 is sufficient. Most advice tends to fall someplace in the middle.
How much do you really need? As usual, I recommend that you do what works for you. There is no one right answer. Examine your situation — your income and your needs — to decide how much you should save. (My wife and I have a $5000 emergency fund, which would pay the mortgage for three months, or all expenses for two months. This seems right for us.)
How do you get started?
Starting an emergency fund can be as simple as depositing $100 into your high interest savings account. But before you begin, be sure that you’re meeting your basic living expenses. And as you build your emergency fund, be sure you’re also reducing your spending and avoiding debt.
I think it’s wise to keep your emergency money someplace that’s not too easy to access. (Ignore this piece of advice if you know you’re disciplined enough not to use the money for other purposes.) You might, for example, open an account at a bank across town. Or deposit the money with an internet bank. Don’t carry a card tied to the account. You’ll still have access to the cash when you need it, but you will be forced to consider your actions before making a withdrawal.
What do the experts say?
I checked the personal finance books on my shelves to find out what the experts had to say.
In The Wealthy Barber [my review], David Chilton writes: “I’m not against emergency funds, but I do feel that $2,000 to $3,000 is much more realistic than $10,000. If you’re afraid that an expensive emergency looms in you future, establish a $10,000 credit line at your bank.” Chilton believes most people have insurance to cover many emergencies, and $2,000 or $3,000 is enough to meet the needs insurance will not cover. In the meantime, if you need more, you can liquidate investments.
Robert Pagliarini, in his forthcoming The Six-Day Financial Makeover, declares that an emergency fund is the most important financial step after taking care of basic living expenses. “Your emergency reserve is your financial cushion in case something goes wrong and you lose your job or you need access to money quickly. Your emergency reserve should consist of at least three months’ worth of cash. Once you’ve saved enough for the cushion, you can [move on] to other goals.”
The Wall Street Journal‘s Complete Personal Finance Guidebook says: “How much is enough? The answer is different for different people in different situations. For those in careers with a large, ongoing demand or who have relatively strong job security, three months’ worth of expenses is probably enough of a cushion. Those with bigger career demands, such as higher-paid managers and executives or couples who work in the same industry or at the same company, might want nine months to a year’s worth of expenses in the bank. Yes, that’s a lot of money to save, but financial security is a game won by the most prepared to outlast the tough times.” Use a money market account for your emergency fund, the book recommends, but keep several hundred dollars in cash someplace safe in your home.
In You Don’t Have to Be Rich, Jean Chatzky recommends three to six months of living expenses. Your Money or Your Life recommends six months of living expenses, but only once you’ve achieved financial independence.
In The Automatic Millionaire, David Bach recommends the following three steps:
- Decide how big a cushion you need. Bach recommends three months of living expenses, though he believes more is better.
- Don’t touch it. “The reason most people don’t have any emergency money in the bank is that they have what they think is an emergency every month…A real emergency is something that threatens your survival, not just your desire to be comfortable.”
- Put it in the right place. “Not earning interest on your emergency money is almost as bad as burying it in your backyard.”
I like the approach espoused in Dave Ramsey’s The Total Money Makeover. Ramsey’s very first step is to save $1000 in an emergency fund. Then he advocates eliminating debt via the snowball method. Only once your debt has been eliminated does he recommend building a three- to six-month cushion. This is excellent advice.





Thanks for the article.
One thing… under “Why do you need an emergency fund?”, should it say “those without emergency savings are more likely to accumulate debt” instead?
loading....
Oh, this is such a variable topic!
Right now, I am attempting to grow an emergency fund. I am doing this while I still have a car loan. This flies in the face of Dave Ramsey (my emergency fund is over $1000 now), but I am continuing to grow the emergency fund for one reason – my wife.
Ramsey rightly states that women like security. I believe this. Now, I could stop contributing to my emergency fund right now, and begin eliminating the car loan, but I know my wife would not feel comfortable in the event we had some major disaster. Frankly, I’m not sure if I would be comfortable, either, since my homeowner’s insurance has a $1000 deductible.
So what’s the happy medium? I’m contemplating getting to the $5000 mark on the emergency fund and then beginning the process of paying down the car loan. That’s a discussion I need to have with my wife first, though.
I work in IT, so people are getting laid off all the time around me. Because of that, I’m tempted to save up the full six months of expenses. Choices, choices…
loading....
I’ve been thinking of putting one month’s expenses in a 6 month CD, repeat for 6 months. Set each one to auto-reinvest unless I notify.
This way, I’ve got 6 months of expenses covered, but it’s not really available, and even when I want it, it only comes in bite sized chunks (or, I could eat a fee and get it all out, but that’d have to be a pretty serious emergency).
Another nice part of this plan is that I could build it up slowly: put in $100 a month until I get enough. Start with my mortgage as first goal, then all expenses.
What do you folks think about that?
loading....
Do you think it’s OK to keep your emergency funds in your Roth IRA?
loading....
No, because if you have to draw from it, you get hit to the tune of 40% in taxes.
loading....
Wrong. ROTH contributions can be withdrawn at any time because they were already taxed. The only penalties are when you withdraw the earnings.
loading....
I keep my emergency fund in a savings account on ING and have money from my paycheck direct deposited to it (so I *never* see it). I wouldn’t put it into a CD. You then have the complications associated with the multiple CDs, loss of liquidity (ie, what if you need more than 1 months?), and many internet banks come pretty close to CDs on rates. Definitely wouldn’t put the money in an IRA… an IRA isn’t as accessible as a savings or even a CD. It is long-term, while emergency money is mid-term.
loading....
But can’t you pull contributions out of your IRA for big emergencies (like health problems, layoffs, etc)? You use a credit card until you get the money free. I don’t want the cash to be too accessible.
loading....
Good advice! My wife and I call it “the buffer.” Basically we said our checking should have a base of $1500 and our savings should have a base of $1500. It’s not always there, but we sure feel safer when it is. I recently had to move across state for a new job, but couldn’t move my family until we could sell our place in this soft market. Living in two towns was a little expensive, but that buffer served it’s purpose. We’re all back together now, and working on rebuilding our buffer.
loading....
I agree with Spender, the IRA should be off-limits when it comes to saving for an emergency fund. That’s a completely different type of saving, and I would advise against combining the two.
Don’t use that credit card for emergencies, either, MissPinkKate. If it’s a big enough emergency, you will find that the credit card will make it even bigger when you have to pay it off.
My emergency savings is at ING. I cannot access the money directly, but I can transfer funds back into my checking account. Since the transfer is EFT, it can take a couple of days to arrive in my account. To me, that’s very unaccessible, yet accessible if I need it. Plus, interest compounds monthly instead of the quarterly junk I get from my local bank. Whee!
loading....
I tedn to be more of a leverage myself for financial growth girl. However, as a single mom with two kids, I see the value in having money set aside in case of emergency. That being said, I find more security in growing my money through investing, than I do having it just sitting there. So my emergency fund is just enough, while the rest of my money is being put tto work earning me more money.
loading....
Yes: do not put your emergency funds in a Roth IRA. The rules for penalty-free withdrawal are quite strict — Motley Fool has a reasonable explanation in plain-ish English:
http://www.fool.com/money/allaboutiras/allaboutiras07.htm
(In particular, “because I was laid off” isn’t reason enough: you can tap it for medical insurance premiums after receiving unemployment for 12 weeks, but it seems to me you’d be well into emergency already by then…)
And if nothing else: if you’re using a Roth IRA to hold emergency funds (presumably in something safe like a money market fund, as you don’t want to take investment risk on cash you might need quickly), you then can’t use it for its far more suitable purpose of investing for retirement.
Aside: are money market funds etc relevant any more, given the high rates available at internet banks? It seems to me this has radically changed the landscape and outdated a lot of previously-sensible advice.
Even CDs are less attractive now, as Spender says — for example, Emigrant Direct’s CD rate is now only 0.05% higher than its savings account rate. Why would you bother sacrificing liquidity for such a small benefit? (One possible answer: to lock in a rate now because you expect interest rates in general, or Emigrant Direct’s headline rate in particular, to fall…)
loading....
From a related page (http://www.fool.com/money/allaboutiras/allaboutiras09.htm , question 6) at the Fool: “Under the IRS ordering rules, you are allowed to remove your original contributions at any time without tax or penalty.”
James’s other arguments are still valid, and withdrawal becomes a problem for any conversions and earnings.
loading....
I like the advice given in “All Your Worth” which says to establish an emergency fund of $1000 initially, then save an additional sum to cover 6 months of “must-have expenses” (e.g. mortgage, loans, basic food needs, utilities, insurance). This savings should begin AFTER you’ve paid off your debt, but BEFORE you start saving for retirement. I don’t personally have 6 months of must-have expenses saved, and I can’t see suspending 401k, IRA and 529 contributions just to save that emergency money (it would take about a year).
loading....
Dear blog owner: I agree with those who say 3 months household income at a minumum.
http://millionairenowbook.blogspot.com/2006/06/seven-steps-i-used-to-build-my-simple.html
It’s step 2 of 7 for me. But, I am probably alone in discouraging IRAs and 401Ks. ooops
loading....
I’m currently struggling with paying off debt. Financially it seems to make more sense to pay off in advance only those loans that are, say, 6% and above. Simplistically speaking, if I think I can get 7+% back from the market while only saving 6% from a loan principal payment, I should invest in the market. However, eliminating loans seems like a good idea (though I doubt I’ll ever pre-pay on my mortgage).
I’ve never seen anywhere that explains why ridding myself of lower-interest debt would be a better option than the above.
loading....
hello,
sorry for lame question (but you are never too lame to start saving, right? and only those who don’t ask questions, don’t get answers?), what is ING account?
can people from other countries (than USA) save money in ING account? thanks for your time.
is there anything like ING in Europe?
loading....
Tomas:
ING is an online bank that offers great rates because they do not have the overhead costs that traditional banks have (the cost of dealing with a person face-to-face). You can go to their website to see if they are in your country: http://www.ing.com/index.jsp
loading....
We actually have two types of e-funds: one for short-term stuff like car repairs, and another for true “rainy day” things like job loss. The first one is in a credit union savings account, and the second one, with about a year of expenses in it, is in I-bonds.
loading....
bjhess:
you should pay down debt first because 7% return in the market is an average, and the stock market is incredibly risky. the s&p 500 is around 30% yearly volatility. so 11%, -2%, and 12% = a 7% return over 3 years.
but the rate you owe on debt – 6%, you owe every year.
so your income/outflow rates won’t match up exactly. if you can handle the risk, then yes, you should play the opportunity cost game. oh yeah, also, ridding yourself of debts helps in emergency situations that come up. so risk management is the answer.
loading....
beanspants1 -
I’m not exactly sure where you are going with that. Are you saying if I’m OK with risk I should continue carrying lower interest loans and put my money into my investments? Or are you saying there is hardly ever a scenario where investments outweigh paying off a loan?
I also wonder how compounding interest plays into this. For instance, if I missed putting $10,000 into an IRA between the ages of 22 and 24 because I was paying down debt, did I have a monster affect on my gains since I did not get to take advantage of those two or three years of compounding interest? Did I end up losing tens or hundreds of thousands of dollars in my IRA because I had to wait until 24 to begin investing? Or is that easily made up for by reduced debt and ability to contribute a lot more between the ages of 24 and 26 than I otherwise would have been able to contribute?
So if I’m O.K. with my current ratio of debt to gross income, should I continue on investing and carrying debt while making the minimum payments against my debt? Or is it simply a risk assessment…would I rather get a guaranteed 6% interest on debt prepayment or a non-guaranteed 7+% interest on an investment? (Since I’m young and have a high risk tolerance, I suspect the answer to this, for me, would be a reflection of my choice in investments. I’ve always made fairly high-risk, high-reward choices in my investments.)
I understand that this calculus is probably out the window in the situation where one is uncomfortable with one’s ratio of debt to gross income. At that point, paying off debt seems to be the most clear choice. And almost by definition, that debt is probably drawing a higher interest rate than typical.
loading....
[...] Start an emergency fund [...]
loading....
well, you are asking several different questions:
1. I’m OK with risk I should continue carrying lower interest loans and put my money into my investments?
YES
2. saying there is hardly ever a scenario where investments outweigh paying off a loan?
YES.
If you have a loan @ a lower rate than a fair average return, you can invest IFF you have the assured continued ability to pay down that loan. I would say there are 3 scenarios where investing is better than paying down debt: primary home loan, primary car loans, and student loans.
0% credit card rate? No, i’d pay down the debt rather than put the minimum towards the card and the rest towards investments.
Low HELOC? no, i’d pay down the debt.
Use your low HELOC to buy stocks that return more than your HELOC interest rate? NO, I wouldn’t, but I can’t tell you what to do.
3. Did I have a monster affect on my gains since I did not get to take advantage of those two or three years of compounding interest?
Well, a basic calculation @ 7% yearly return, $3k investment per year, for 37 or 40 years, the difference is $90,000. that’s 25-65 = $520k , or 28-65=$435k.
4. Reducing debt & investing more to make up that difference: There’s an IRA cap, so $4k (i think) is the most you can invest, so in terms of an IRA ONLY, no, you can’t invest more to catch up.
However, if you could invest more, then you could do $5k for the first 7 years, or $6k for the first 4 years to catch up.
And you can invest more, in a normal mutual fund. No tax advantages vs a IRA, but you get an income tradeoff.
loading....
[...] Featured Entries Our First Lesson in the Costs of HomeownershipCredit Card IndexHow and Why to Start an Emergency FundCoping with an Adustable Rate MortgageFrugal Fitness SolutionsFour Retirement Blind SpotsThe Science Fiction of Coupons?A College Education for $10 a CourseReader Question: Cheap World Travel?Socially Responsible Investing [...]
loading....
Carnivals – Carnival of Personal Finance hosted……
This week’s Carnival #65 of Personal Finance was hosted by NoCreditNeeded. It was a great carnival of information sharing with around 40 quality posts which made it through the final cut by NoCreditNeeded. Some of our favorite posts from this carniva….
loading....
[...] After getting rid of bad debt, set aside some amount, typically 3 to 6 months’ living expenses for the proverbial rainy day fund. In case of emergencies, use the funds here to bail you out. There are those who don’t have such funds and decide to use their credit cards as backup and the money they would otherwise put here, they shovel into the stock market; they rationalize that the risk of an emergency is worth covering with a credit card and the money would be better off growing in an equity account somewhere. [...]
loading....
[...] How and Why to Start an Emergency Fund (Get Rich Slowly) [...]
loading....
[...] difficult to find money to save. But even a little is better than nothing. Work to build an emergency fund. If you have the surplus, by all means max out your retirement [...]
loading....
A nice place the wife and I put our EF is in this money market fund:
https://www.americanfunds.com/funds/details.htm?fundGroupNumber=9&fundClassNumber=0
We’ve been averaging a 4.7% return and have easy access if needed.
loading....
[...] something bad is going to happen and you’ll be happy you saved that cash. A lot of people recommend a 3-6 month emergency savings, so I guess I’m on the higher side when I would like to recommend 6 months. The last thing [...]
loading....
[...] I wrote about how and why to start an emergency fund last summer, I noted that there doesn’t seem to be any expert consensus on how much one [...]
loading....
im new to investing and ive been wanting to start an emergency fund for a while…however i still have debt, auto and school bills to pay off, the school bills aren’t finished yet though (as im still in school and the previous bills are deferred) but im working and i want a little bit of security in my life in case i loose my job i loose everything, my car ect.
even though i havent paid off my debt would it be ok to start at least 1000.00 savings acct. now?
why does everyone say pay off your debt, as long as your payments are included in your month-to month living expenses; whats the harm in it. at least then i’ll have something to fall back on if anything should happen.
loading....
[...] haven’t prepared. An emergency fund is your own private insurance against life’s hard [...]
loading....
Agree with this article……
me and my wife keep emergency fund in one envelope and it contain 3 time of my salary. and every month we add it 5% of my salary to it.
it very useful indeed…
loading....
[...] things like an “emergency fund” and a “rainy day fund” are essential in having financial independence. Financial [...]
loading....
[...] When I found a new job, I would be certain to bolster my emergency fund. [...]
loading....
I’m surprised no one has mentioned insurance deductibles. If you have $1000 deductible, then you had better have $1000 on-hand to pay the deductible if need be. Doesn’t matter if it’s health, home, or car – you’re self-insuring for the cash.
Personally I have a fairly high emergency fund. If disaster strikes we can pay deductibles, co-pays, mortgage, and so on – even if I’m laid off. That’s what it’s for.
loading....
[...] Tuck away at least $1,000 for emergencies. [...]
loading....
[...] How and Why to Start an Emergency Fund by Get Rich Slowly [...]
loading....
[...] How and Why to Start an Emergency Fund ? Get Rich Slowly (tags: finance money planning) [...]
loading....
[...] How and Why to Start an Emergency Fund [...]
loading....
[...] Establish a $1000 emergency fund. [...]
loading....
[...] when something bad is going to happen and you’ll be happy you saved that cash. A lot of people recommend a 3-6 month emergency savings, so I guess I’m on the higher side when I would like to recommend 6 months. The last thing you [...]
loading....
[...] in other books. When you read Dave Ramsey’s recommendation to build a $1,000 emergency fund, research what other authors advise. When you read Robert Kiyosaki’s advice that the mutual funds are for losers, find out what [...]
loading....
[...] few emergency fund articles: 11 ways to jump-start your savings : Bankrate How and Why to Start an Emergency Fund : Get Rich Slowly Bouncing Back from a Financial Setback : Fidelity 8 ways to save for a short-term emergency fund [...]
loading....
[...] JD Tells us how and why we should start an emergency fund. [...]
loading....
[...] cards, instead relying on loans from family members. Now, at last, I’m finally building a real emergency fund, a cash reserve. There’s a reason many financial experts say that the first step to getting [...]
loading....
[...] Get Rich Slowly: Emergency Fund [...]
loading....
[...] fund. Now, I will say that I went “Huh?” when I first heard of this concept. However, after reading and subscribing to a bunch of financial blogs, I find that it makes absolute sense. What is an [...]
loading....
Risking the Minimal Emergency Fund…
An emergency fund is an essential part of any debt reduction plan. By creating an emergency fund you are committing a new frame of mind — moving from a spend to save mentality. You want to have som……
loading....
[...] some, this is counter-intuitive. Why save before paying off debt? Because if you don’t save first, you’re not going to be able to cope with unexpected [...]
loading....
[...] at wrote an excellent article, “How and Why to Start an Emergency Fund.” I highly recommend that you read [...]
loading....