If you're new here, you may want to learn what this site is about. I encourage you to subscribe to my RSS feed. Thanks for visiting!
I write a lot about personal finance, but how well do I practice what I preach? For the most part, I follow my own advice. Much of what I write here is based on personal experience. But my financial life is not without weaknesses. The good news is that the Big Picture looks fantastic. Only a few years ago my net worth was minimal. Now it’s growing consistently. In 2006 it jumped $30,000, from $176,216 to $206,368.
I’m still spending too much, though. There are areas that need attention. Most of these will come as no surprise to regular readers. Here are my biggest sources of discretionary spending:
- Books (2005: $1049.91, 2006: $692.96)
- I’ve been working to reduce my book expenses for several years. In 2003, I spent $200/month on books. I have that down to about $50/month now. Because half of that is my Audible subscription (which gives me two audiobooks per month), I’ve actually reduced my book spending to about $25/month. This is huge for me. I’ve done it by using the public library and purchasing books from my local thrift store.
- Comic Books (2005: $2810.52, 2006: $3202.91)
- This is, by far, my weak spot. I’m almost embarrassed to share these numbers. I struggled with comic book spending throughout 2006, and it shows. In the first quarter of the year, I spent $1430.03 on comics. By the last quarter, that had dropped to $466.50. I spent $178.71 on comics during December. That’s nearly double what I want to spend.
- Entertainment (2005: $479.31, 2006: $610.55)
- This includes CDs, DVDs, music downloads, movies, etc. To be honest, I don’t think this category is going too poorly. I used to buy several DVDs a month. Our Netflix subscription has reduced that to a handful each year. My big entertainment expense is iTunes downloads (TV shows and music albums). Even this is just $20/month, which doesn’t bother me.
- Food (2005: $5290.06, $5060.04)
- which includes Dining out (2005: $1648.63, 2006: $2018.81)
Ah, food, how you are a thorn in my side. I’m spending about $40/week for dining out. This is too much. (We don’t dine out often, but we dine out well.) I have high hopes that my new wellness program will allow me to save money on food. (Literally as I type this, I’ve just made reservations one of our favorite expensive Portland restaurants. sigh) - Pets (2005: $397.76, 2006: $471.03)
- There’s not much I can do to reduce this number. And since we just brought home a fourth cat, my pet expenses will actually increase. But it just costs about fifty cents a day for each animal, and they bring much more joy than that to my life.
- Sin (2005: $1055.33, 2006: $768.95)
- This includes wine, liquor, pipe tobacco, poker nights, etc. Looking at this category, you’d think I was a chain-smoking lush! It’s not true. I smoke a pipe maybe a dozen times a year. I did drink wine regularly before I started my wellness program in November, but even then most of the alcohol expense would best have been classified as “entertaining”. We serve alcohol at dinner parties and social gatherings. Because we like to entertain, we serve a lot of alcohol.
As I wrote the descriptions for these expenses, I could feel myself rationalizing. Yes I derive pleasure from each these things, and yes I can certainly afford some extravagances. Still, I need to do be more mindful about my spending. Two categories — comic books and food — deserve particular attention this year.
It’s worth noting that there’s nothing inherently wrong with purchasing things that bring you joy. Problems occur when you finance these purchases with debt, however. (Or, in my case, by failing to use the money for debt reduction.) If my IRA were fully funded and my debt paid off, then I’d be okay spending $3200 a year on comic books. But Batman and Superman won’t pay for retirement.
.jpg)

January 7th, 2007 at 11:41 am
Batman and Superman won’t pay for retirement.
True enough — but the flip side, as you’ve said, is that tomorrow is promised to no one; and thus the real challenge isn’t just to build a secure, sufficient retirement fund (which, taken alone, would be easy), but instead to strike a balance between providing for tomorrow while enjoying today.
I know how you feel, re: comics. I used to maintain a dozen subscriptions through my local store, plus whatever loose books I’d find when I visited monthly; and by the time I pulled out my wallet, I’d be carrying a pile of books that cost near $100. What’s embarrassing is that I wouldn’t even read many of them. I wanted to, and I intended to — but it just wasn’t a priority, so I ended up with expensive boxes of unread comics.
Today, I limit myself to trade paperbacks. It’s a compromise that works for me: less money, less to read, but I still get to enjoy whatever Batman storylines that DC sees fit to compile. To be honest, I think about quitting — it’s still expensive, and I’m kinda ashamed (especially as a writer) to admit how well I know the Batman canon despite not having read Les Miserables — and mostly, it’s a violation of what I consider to be the best advice I’ve ever read: “Seek elevating recreation.” But I like ‘em, so for the time being I’ll keep reading under the logic that good mental health requires indulging the occasional harmless, simple-minded vice.
January 7th, 2007 at 12:10 pm
So JD, what tool do you use to keep track of your finances and how does it treat you?
January 7th, 2007 at 12:16 pm
I, too, am a trade-paperback purchaser. When I say that I’m buying comics, I actually bought maybe two real comic books last year. The rest were compilations: hardbound, paperbound, etc. I am particularly fond of comic strips, and buy these collections when I can find them cheap. It’s all comics, though!
@Tim
I use Quicken for the Mac. Now that I have an Intel-based machine, I’m going to dig up my old copy of Quicken for PC. This is one area in which the PC version is vastly superior to the Mac version. Both work fine, but the PC version is much, much nicer to use. I’ve also been playing with Wesabe now-and-then, and I like it, but there are features in Quicken that I like and can’t get there.
January 7th, 2007 at 12:17 pm
Music spending is a **HUGE** problem around here. My husband satisfies his cravings for an ever-changing rack of CDs by using LaLa.com and I satisfy my cravings by rifling through the music selection at archive.org. LaLa reduces some of our household clutter by ensuring that CDs that aren’t in rotation go out. You pay something like $1.75 for each CD you receive and you have to send one out for every one that you get.
Archive.org has a large collection of live recordings from trade/tape friendly bands. Increasingly, the recordings are available in lossless format rather than MP3. All downloads are free and legal. In addition, they have a large collection of digitized 78rpm records that are now in public domain and there are also a lot of public domain books that have been converted to audio files for download. Like the live music archive, these 78rpm and audio book files are also free to download.
With these resources, we’ve cut down dramatically on our media expenses, and on the clutter produced by our constant acquisition of new media.
January 7th, 2007 at 12:24 pm
$3,000 on comic books but you didn’t fully fund your IRA?!?!? Ugh, that hurts.
January 7th, 2007 at 12:41 pm
January 7th, 2007 at 1:40 pm
To decrease your book spending, you might consider joining paperbackswap or bookmooch. You won’t be able to get all the books you want there, but you’ll be able to get some of them.
January 7th, 2007 at 1:54 pm
Excellent post. It really puts things in perspective when you look at your expenses on a yearly basis.
I use MS Money and have been for the past couple of years. Have you ever tried MS Money? If so, how would you compare it to Quicken?
FT
http://www.MillionDollarJourney.com
January 7th, 2007 at 5:07 pm
I just wanted to say that I so know what you mean about comic books. They’re insidious: You get hooked into a story line, and you feel like you have to follow every thread and side-plot that that story line takes.
Marvel was really good at this with the X-Men, I had a huge X-Men jones. They would make references to something and then actually put an apostrophy, saying “*To understand what Gambit is saying, check out X-Force 7″ or something like that. When the story lines got too convoluted that it seemed like even the writers couldn’t follow what they were doing, exept to reccommend more comics, I jumped off–somewhere around the Phalanx Covenant, if anyone remembers that X-Men title.
I then transferred this addiction, unfortunately, to regular books. It was pretty bad for awhile, because I worked at bookstores for about five years. I would wind up spending about half my paycheck there–thankfully, I didn’t have rent to pay.
I still love books, but the way I’m dealing with it now is to buy things at the thrift store or used bookstore. I’m getting to the point where I refuse to pay full price for the things, because I see how I can either get something at the Library, or find it for two thirds of the price at the most (including shipping) if I do a little savvy online shopping.
Although I have hooked up with some of my old bookstore friends, and am thinking about getting a job with one of them at a big chain bookstore, probably around March. I think I can restrain myself, I’ve gone in and out of there without the urge to buy, and I’m getting spoiled with the used book pricing I’ve learned to shop for.
January 7th, 2007 at 5:12 pm
It looks like you have a lot to celebrate, J.D. Just how much of your income do you set aside for retirement, savings, and debt reduction every year? If it’s a large percentage, perhaps the expenses on comics and dining out aren’t so bad, after all. You can sock away up to 15 or 20% of your income–or more–but that means you still have money to blow for things that suit you. Some people spend a lot on travel, others spend on golf, others on clothes, etc. Ya gotta have some fun while you’re alive, y’know!
Do you keep all of your comic books? Or do you resell them? Perhaps reselling them can bring down some of the cost. (Just don’t resell a future collectible!) Or perhaps you could donate some of the comic books to a local library, then they become a charitable contribution, and maybe some other people will benefit…..?
January 7th, 2007 at 5:13 pm
Wow, I can’t believe you spent so much on books! I bought one writing book last month at full price but I justified it because the author offered to sign my copy after I emailed him and asked.
What about clothing expenses? I’m assuming you don’t buy clothes often?
Thanks for sharing such specific numbers and thoughts. It doesn’t make me feel so guilty when I enjoy the things I buy.
I’ve never tried that restaurant but I love Nikolas? or Nikolai’s in the East Burnside area of Portland. Their coffee is amazing.
January 7th, 2007 at 5:15 pm
Hmm…I do recall you getting a Wii…did you include that in entertainment? Just trying to keep you honest
January 7th, 2007 at 5:23 pm
“Batman and Superman won’t pay for retirement.”
I do actually know someone who came up with the down payment for his house by selling his comic book collection.
January 7th, 2007 at 6:46 pm
“…Batman and Superman won’t pay for retirement.”
Like Peg said, I wouldn’t be too sure. It depends on which comics you are buying. There are some on ebay in excess of $1K each.
http://search.ebay.com/superman_Comics_W0QQcatrefZC6QQfromZR10QQfsooZ2QQfsopZ3QQftrtZ1QQftrvZ1QQsacatZ63QQsbrsrtZl
http://collectibles.search.ebay.com/batman_Comics_W0QQcatrefZC6QQfromZR10QQfsooZ2QQfsopZ3QQftrtZ1QQftrvZ1QQsacatZ63QQsbrsrtZlQQssPageNameZWLRS
January 7th, 2007 at 7:11 pm
The sin category is awesome!
January 7th, 2007 at 9:06 pm
The book savings category is HUGE. The average book consumer buying 3 new books per month pays close to $60 every month. Maybe buying these books isn’t necessary. BookSwim.com, http://www.bookswim.com, is a library book club service that allows book rentals, Netflix-style.
January 7th, 2007 at 9:37 pm
I have some comics to sell if you are interested
SpiderMan/Mary Jane wedding
Groo #1 ?!?
I have a semi decent comic collection, but I have them all in plastic bags (after reading them of course). I had considered them an “investment” but that is only if there is someone else out there to purchase them from me.
As with selling anyting there needs to be soneone willing to buy at the price you want.
So is there a debt repayment category or are you out of debt (excluding mortgage)?
January 7th, 2007 at 9:44 pm
Hey J.D.
I like bestwebbuys.com/books for finding cheaper books. This site will search all the major online bookstores and ranks them for you (with shipping). I got through college this way and never paid more than $150 per term for books. You can save > 50% sometimes. Try it out.
Dustin
January 8th, 2007 at 12:57 am
I love this post, J.D. It’s nice to see that no one is perfect in these categories.
A few suggestions if I may, based on my own experience/shortcomings.
- Books - I sell a lot on amazon.com. Last month, in three days, I sold close to $300 worth of used books on amazon. After amazon takes their cut, I will get about $200. Think about culling your herd and getting a positive cash flow coming back into your house. Also, my new book mantra is “Books are not trophies.”
- Comics - I’m now down to ONE TITLE. “Ultimate X-Men”. In trade paperback. Try subtracting one title per month, see what happens. Again, those titles you drop, see about selling them on amazon/eBay. “Comics are not trophies>
Best of luck!
- Bill
January 8th, 2007 at 5:53 am
I would be careful thinking that your Food budget will drop with the commencement of a wellness program. Although you may cut out some of the dining out (and that is expensive), there is a reason that people in this country are overweight - food that is good for you is expensive. Fruits, veggies, and good grains, always cost way more than the cheap stuff you can buy to fill your stomach (frozen pizzas, TV dinners, etc.).
You can definitely save some money by cutting the AMOUNT you are eating (and any good wellness program should do this, at least to an extent), but I would make the goal to break even, not to save over all. Otherwise you jeopardize the success of your wellness program, just to put a few more dollars in your IRA.
Expect being well (in every sense of the word) to cost you money - from food, to gym equipment or memberships, and personal trainers, and even the emotional wellness expenses like comic books. Don’t short-change your wellness and weight loss goals, because your health is worth more than money.
January 8th, 2007 at 6:30 am
I’m glad to see that I’m not the only one with a comic addiction. At the end of 2005, when I first started paying attention to my personal finances, I realized that throughout the year I had spent about $3500 on comics. It didn’t seem like that much until I realized that $3500 was over 10% of my income. Needless to say, in 2006, I severely cut back on my comic spending. This year I held it back to about $1500.
A lot of that savings came from realizing that my local library carries a lot of new trade paperbacks comic collections. With a branch of the library only about a mile from my home, I was easily able to start saving money.
January 8th, 2007 at 7:24 am
Mmm, Paley’s Place. If you haven’t already (I bet you have), you should stop in at Wildwood sometime–it’s right across the street.
Do you really get a chance to read $50 worth of books a month if you’re also reading comic books and watching $50 worth of Netflix DVDs and iTunes downloads? I’d love to see some sort of estimate on the cost per hour, if only to see how many hours you estimate you’re spending this way. It sounds like you have more fun than I do!
It seems to me that here is a good place to adopt “pay yourself first.” The money’s there–if you’re not fully funding your IRA, that’s a bit of a problem. What I’d do is fully fund my IRA and then see what’s left over, so, make it a goal to cut out enough of this discretionary spending that you can free up enough cash to make up the difference between what you’re currently contributing and the limit. I’d propel my progress toward that goal by automating maximum-level monthly contributions to my IRA and then trying to work out the entertainment expenses within what’s left.
Really, I just wanted to say that I think this was a great post, one that humanized your blogging persona both my admitting a financial weakness and by giving your readership a sense of what you like. This post really drives home the fact that ultimately our finances are driven by our personalities and behaviors.
January 8th, 2007 at 8:14 am
I used buy a lot of books, and I kept the ones I really liked because I figured I’d read them again sometime. But as the years rolled by it became clear that I’d never get around to re-reading them. Same goes for DVDs: I own 23 DVDs and have never watched any of them more than three times. What a waste! When I emigrated to Canada four years ago I had to prepare an inventory of everything I owned and its value in Canadian dollars. That motivated me to cut my book collection in half, and that was so painless that I’ve cut it in half again over the past few years. I now keep only reference books, a few books of poetry, two shelves of books that I use for my work, and a handful of old favorites that I can’t bring myself to part with. I rarely buy books anymore; I either use the library or get my siblings to buy them for me for Christmas (we all share our Amazon wishlists).
January 8th, 2007 at 9:21 am
Aye! take heed to the other commenters here and don’t worry too much about your comics. If you take good care of them, some of them could end up being an investment of sorts.
Especially if collect perennially popular series. Some of the comics you have may already be worth more than you paid for them, because of the limited release nature of comics.
So what you might want to consider is purging your comics archive once in a while. Sell off some of the ones that might be kind of rare, but something you aren’t likely to read and read again, or something you don’t think will really “appreciate” by comic collection standards.
Don’t just leave it as an addiction, make it a full-fledged hobby! If you do it right, who knows? It might end up paying for itself.
January 8th, 2007 at 2:28 pm
JD, it’s none of my business, but does your net worth include real property or just liquid assets? If the former I’m doing OK, if the latter, well, not so hot.
January 8th, 2007 at 2:37 pm
My net worth includes real property and associated debt. It doesn’t include any of my wife’s finances, however, or any of the assets/liabilities that she tracks. (Remember: we keeps separate finances.) Because I track the house and the mortgage, it’s in this number. I figure as long as I’m staying consistent with which numbers I’m using, I’m doing okay.
At some point, in preparation for a future entry, I’ll actually sit down and computer our household net worth, which will be much higher, I think.
January 8th, 2007 at 5:28 pm
Those must be some great comic books! Maybe there’s a Comicreaders Anonymous?
Aside from that, don’t feel too bad.
January 8th, 2007 at 7:39 pm
[...] 2006 Discretionary Spending: The Good, the Bad, and the Ugly - Get Rich Slowly JD spends $3000 on comic books a year. Awesome (but bad for your wallet)! (tags: money finance comicbooks) [...]
January 9th, 2007 at 8:52 am
Oh wow, a fellow (young!) pipe smoker! How very rare these days! I know it’s not really related to finances, but do you have a local tobacconist that you have access to or do you get your leaf from the Internet?
When I saw that, I just smiled and thought “Yeah, his personality does seem like a pipe smokers.”
Take it easy JD and may you enjoy at least a couple of good smokes this winter season!
January 9th, 2007 at 12:35 pm
You’re lucky to spend such a small amount on your pets. When my late cats were alive, I had to lay out a few hundred dollars every 3 months for testing and treatment for a chronic condition in an elderly cat, and both of my current, younger cats have had to have emergency surgeries to the tune of about $3000 each.
January 9th, 2007 at 8:23 pm
My wife and I signed up for paperbackswap.com in December. It has been great so far, I’ve sent out 6, and requested 7, exchanging books I didn’t want for ones that I do. My wife has sent out a bunch and picked up 6 books that were on her Amazon wishlist for a cost that works out to around $2/book.
January 16th, 2007 at 9:22 pm
[...] Get Rich Slowly has a list of 10 Ways to Save Money on Books that repeatedly suggests a visit to the library: I used to spend thousands of dollars a year on books, most of which I never read. Recently I’ve begun to trim my book spending. I spent nearly $3000 on books in 2003, but that number dropped to $700 last year. How did I do it? Through self-discipline and some commonsense tricks. [...]
February 18th, 2007 at 7:33 am
[...] know the value.” I am wondering how much money JD of Get Rich Slowly will make when he sells all his comics down the line. I am also wondering if there are many people who buy comics as an *investment*. The [...]
January 22nd, 2008 at 10:30 am
[...] is based on personal experience. But my financial life is not without weaknesses. Last January, I tallied my discretionary spending to see exactly how much these weaknesses cost me. This year, I’ve done the [...]