Sometimes It’s Okay to Splurge Print
Friday, 9th February 2007 (by J.D.)This article is about Choices, Food, Real-Life
I feel as if I’ve been a Scrooge here lately: “don’t watch Super Bowl commercials“, “don’t buy gadgets“, “bundle up to stay warm“, etc. While it’s true that saving money requires sacrifices, I don’t mean to make it sound like drudgery. Actually, I’m elated with my progress.
When I was working with Lauren Muney to create my wellness program, she emphasized that fitness should not be a chore. “Remember that you’re working toward something positive, something long-term,” she said. “And allow yourself a treat once in a while.” She told me that as long as I stuck to my diet and fitness plan the rest of the time, I could allow myself a couple of “treat meals” during the week, meals during which I didn’t worry whether I was following the plan to the letter. This has made a huge difference.
The same concept holds true for personal finance. I’ve written before that you shouldn’t confuse frugality with depriving yourself. They’re not the same thing. It’s a good idea to allow yourself a reward now and then, to allow yourself to splurge.
In December I wrote about my financial goals. Since then I’ve had a number of major victories:
- I built my non-emergency fund savings from $0 to $700. (Kris and I have $5,000 emergency fund that represents our only joint account.)
- I paid down my home equity loan to $15,000 (which is $6,000 less than it was a year ago).
- I reduced my comic book spending from $179 in December (or my average of $250/month in 2006) to $65 in January.
- I slashed other miscellaneous discretionary spending.
I’ve made tremendous progress just one month. I even saved enough spare cash to indulge in an exorbitant treat. Kris and I joined two close friends for a meal at one of our favorite Portland restaurants, Paley’s Place.
Paley’s Place is not the sort of restaurant you enter expecting to pay less than $50. Or $100. Or $150. Kris and I spent $160 on our meal the other night and felt we escaped having spent less than we might have. (Last time we spent over $200.) But the expense was was worth it. The food is fantastic. As the restaurant’s web site says:
Paley’s Place offers Pacific Northwest regional cuisine, served in the warm and inviting setting of a Victorian home. Chef and owner, Vitaly Paley, creates seasonal menus from the bounty of the Northwest — fresh organic ingredients supplied by local farmers, growers and purveyors — with Southern French and Northern Italian influences.
Whatever. All I know is that the food is damn good. We paid $7 for french fries. You know what? They were worth it! It’s difficult for the frugal side of me to justify such an expensive meal, no matter how well I’ve been doing lately. It’s the equivalent of ten meals at other restaurants. But I ask myself: “Is the food really that much better?” The answer is “yes”. Kris put it best: “That’s a once-every-five-years restaurant.”
We had a wonderful meal and great conversation with friends. I got my money’s worth. It was a solid reminder that managing money is all about knowing when to save and knowing when to splurge.

RSS Feeds
Facebook
Twitter

February 9th, 2007 at 5:40 am
As my husband once quipped, “all things in moderation–including moderation”. While we save almost 1/2 of our take-home pay and don’t go in for such alleged neccessities as cell phone plans (my pre-paid phone works just fine, and I wouldn’t even have that if not for my 30 mile commute), netflix, etc. we budget for–and enjoy shamelessly–our monthly pilgrimage to the neighborhood sushi bar. That regular dose of high-grade tuna keeps me strong when I’m seduced by an ipod or a stack of books at B&N.
February 9th, 2007 at 6:00 am
Recently, I was following a nutrition plan that included the concept of “treat meals”, or as they called them “cheat meals”. In the context of a diet and exercise program, cheat meals are actually beneficial in that they confuse your body and prevent it from going into starvation (low metabolism) mode, which hinders futher weight loss.
Blah blah blah, the important thing to note is that cheat meals must be confined to one meal…no cheat days or cheat weeks! The same is true in personal finance…allow yourself some “once every 5 years” type of extravagance, as long as it doesn’t derail your longer term financial plan.
February 9th, 2007 at 6:24 am
Ha, Frugality in moderation…
February 9th, 2007 at 6:26 am
I’m proud of you, JD — great lifestyle application of wellness to your life, not just for your food! The answer is to consider, “What is my value here, and what is ‘most beneficial’?” In terms of eating meals, our goal was to eat nutritiously but not ascetically. In terms of spending, the idea was not to cut out comics-collecting completely, but to decide the value of the hobby and then create the purchase-point within that hobby. ($65 for a month of comics may be 16 per month –seems satisfactory, non-obsessional).
Remember one important detail: “going overboard” in any habit or hobby is often indicative of a different issue: treading lightly on this subject, an obsessional attitude towards spending, food, partying, collecting, or hobbies may be hiding an ‘emotional hole’ that the person is trying to fill. One can observe these habits to uncover this ‘unbalancing’, and make small changes bit by bit: often, those obsessions are creating the deeper hole. As the person rebalances slowly, the habits get healthier and the person gets healthier in turn!
February 9th, 2007 at 6:32 am
this article reminded me of a story my aunt told me long ago. Apparently there were these couple of old ladies that were found dead from hypothermia laying in bed with coats on and tons of blankets on top of them with empty cans of cat food nearby, which they were eating. It seems as they were trying to survive with no money. They startling thing was that they found millions in the house/bank that belonged to them. Now i am one to recommend saving, but hell as the saying goes, “you never see a bank truck following a hearse”, you have to learn how to enjoy yourself while attaining your goals. PS i like the “everything in moderation, including moderation….great saying..
February 9th, 2007 at 7:29 am
Yep, moderation is the key. Save money, pay your bills, stay fit, watch your credit, but don’t forget to also have fun. We only live once (unless you believe in reincarnation, but that’s for another blog) so take advantage of it.
February 9th, 2007 at 7:36 am
I agree, plus when you only splurge once in a while you enjoy it more. Most people splurge every day in this country. Its really no longer a treat to eat out or to make a large purchase because most people eat out all the time and put large purchases on their credit cards. I find that I enjoy my splurges a lot more now that I have so few.
February 9th, 2007 at 7:56 am
I’m a music fanatic with about 900 CDs. And I’ve been dying to get an iPod since they first arrived on the scene.
One thing that kept me personally motivated on paying off my $52K of credit cards, student loans and car loans was this fact: The day I was out of debt, I could go to the Apple store and get the most expensive iPod available.
One by one my friends, many deeper in debt than I, bought themselves iPods. A few mocked me for not just going and buying one. But finally last month we paid off that debt and I immediately snagged my iPod.
Of course, my friends toting around their three-year-old models are oohing-and-aahing over it, wondering if they should by the latest model. But they’re still in debt.
Another thing I noticed? This is the first major purchase I’ve made in years without any buyer’s remorse. I was used to feeling guilty whenever I purchased anything since it was getting me deeper in debt. I’m loving the new freedom.
February 9th, 2007 at 8:28 am
Feels good to splurge every once in a while huh JD?
Whenever I feel like I’ve reached a short-term financial goal, I splurge too. I mean that’s the whole reason why we work hard in the first place, is so we can enjoy it!
Food is my weakness too. I just spent $140 on my birthday dinner at a prime rib restaurant in SF (3 people). I paid $40 alone for my entree! It was well worth it though.
This past month, I found out why it’s important to have an emergency fund. I had 3k worth in car repairs (major tune up, brakes, tires, alignment, radiator). A family member needed help with some bills too, so I had some extra change to help her out. When it rains it pours, so you have to be prepared for the unexpected.
All the things you mention on this site have helped me tremendously. I’m now at the point in my life where I have no credit card debt, saving a % for retirement, emergencies, and still have enough to enjoy myself. That’s what it’s all about.
February 9th, 2007 at 8:36 am
Perhaps this is just me, but I don’t splurge on anything. In my mind frugality is defined as not wasting money on this that are not important to you and spending money on those things that are important to you.
So if you love movies and want a big TV. Go ahead and save up for one. Just don’t forget about the overall picture to keep saving for retriement and paying off debt.
CD
February 9th, 2007 at 9:38 am
Thanks. I needed that.
I’ve been reading here for a few months and have been feeling guilty every time a new article comes up.
I just splurged on a new Canon DSLR I’ve been pining over using our tax refund. We were going to apply it all to our dwindling credit balance. We should still be done by autumn, but we talked ourselves into splitting the refund for a splurge. My wife is much more practical than I am so she’s buying (practical) clothes and kitchen items, comparison shopping all the way.
I blew it all on my one item - but I love it. Like the poster above, I have no buyers remorse since it’s the first big reward item I’ve got in at least five years… until I read your blog.
We should probably thank our two year old… since we wouldn’t have a refund without her.
Exurbon Jon wanted his iPod, my reward item was going to be a MacBook Pro that I save for after our debt is gone. I’ll have to wait for that now. I should even wait until after we have a bigger emergency fund. After this (much cheaper) toy, I don’t feel any need for a new notebook since I already have a functional computer. I was going crazy not having a new toy, I’m a gadget hog with old gadgets. Now I feel justified in my five year splurge.
I love your blog, by the way, and tell everyone I know about it when the subject comes up. Thanks!
February 9th, 2007 at 10:26 am
JD, you are really making the most of your money. At $200+ a meal, you definitely rock ! (ok, that’s a bit too much for me, but I understand).
Money is meant to be spent (read - used wisely), not hoarded. Your happiness (or satisfaction or any other synonym) depends on how smartly you spend it.
February 9th, 2007 at 10:49 am
I need to splurge. I think it very well may be a genetic thing, probably picked up from my dad. But if I don’t have SOMETHING exciting to buy at least once a month (doesn’t matter the cost), I’ll end up splurging every weekend.
I once bought a $75 journal because I wanted AND I didn’t bother to look at the price tag until I’d had already paid and walked out of the store with it… I then felt too shameful to go back and return it after that.
So I’ve turned my splurging habit into a well-calculated monthly event. And I now only splurge with a purpose. No more $300 trips to Target for random stuff that is necessary, but not worthy of spending that much money on.
This month, I’m buying myself a Betta fish. It’s a small splurge, but that’s because it’s going to add about an extra $20 to my monthly expenses for fish food. It also needs to be small because I plan on dropping a large chunk o’ change at the end of the month on a much needed car repair.
Next month will probably be splurge free since I need to get used to paying an extra $600/mo for debt re-payment.
And then the following month my splurge will be a couple $100 to upgrade a decent computer I acquired.
It feels good to know that I CAN afford to spend a little extra money each month, so long as I account for it ahead of time.
February 9th, 2007 at 11:15 am
what comics did you buy? what do you still buy? I love comics!
February 9th, 2007 at 11:24 am
just because you did it doesn’t make it right.
February 9th, 2007 at 11:47 am
The key is to have a healthy relationship with money. Clearly, some of the most frugal have a very twisted concept of money (and many of the posts here confirm that). Excessive spending for the sake of image and to feel better about oneself through material gain is an opposite sort of insanity.
JD - you seem to have a very appropriate concept of money. It is a tool, completely under your control, to do with as you wish. And, more importantly, your wishes are grounded in a reality of what truly makes you feel happy. Splurge on!
February 9th, 2007 at 11:54 am
I am definitely willing to splurge too. Maybe too much. I guess it’s a product of the lifestyle I inherited from my parents. I have season tickets to the opera (not the cheapest, but not the most expensive either) and we usually go out for a nice dinner ($60-$80 total, for 2 people) before or after the performance. Maybe twice a year (Valentine’s and/or birthdays) we’ll go to a really extravagant place that’s $50+ per entree.
February 9th, 2007 at 2:00 pm
wow, i’m amazed you spent so much eating out without feeling guilty. but you enjoyed the meal so that’s all that matters.
you write a great blog! it keeps me in check and monitoring my budget and spending.
February 9th, 2007 at 2:31 pm
I’ve come to realize that the ‘casual dining’ restaurants don’t really offer you much value over home cooking, except convenience. On the other hand, the times I’ve been out to genuinely good restaurants have been fantastic.
$150 sounds like a lot to spend on a meal, but if you just put away $15 from every restaurant meal you didn’t eat, you’d get there pretty quickly.
February 9th, 2007 at 3:41 pm
The thing about $150 meals is that you are (usually!!) getting much more than a 10 minute feeding of ordinary food. Go to Applebees if you want to feed yourself. Go for a $150 meal if you want to DINE the way dining is supposed to be done.
You’re getting a special quality of service from a highly trained waitstaff, the artistic creation of a chef, top quality ingredients and staff highly trained in the art of food, and loads of atmosphere. At least you’re supposed to be!
I’m all for fine dining as a splurge.
February 9th, 2007 at 5:58 pm
A couple of years ago, I went with my fiancee to The White Barn Inn in Maine. One of the local food critic TV shows gave it nearly a perfect 100 (I think it was a 98). It was the highest rated at the time. We spent about $250, but it was well worth it. Everything was wonderful and perfect. The “once-in-five-years” thing sounds about right to me.
February 10th, 2007 at 7:53 am
What you’re really saying - all the time - is to spend mindfully. Be aware of obligations and commitments, and don’t spend without being aware of the overall effects.
The usual problem is the aggregate effects of not paying attention to what you are doing routinely.
February 10th, 2007 at 11:16 am
I’m not a fan of the term “splurge”. It makes absolutely no sense. I think you can have a nice dinner out, a comic book collection, a fancy watch or car so long as you plan and budget for it. The purpose behind all this financial planning, is to accomodate spending in your life. A splurge is an unexpected cost that will come at the expense of something else. It doesn’t need to, though. There are wants and needs in your budget. Identify these “splurges” as wants and plan for them accordingly. The reward for all this frugal living (I don’t see it as such) or budgeting is being able to afford those nights out.
Congrats on your positive momentum.
February 10th, 2007 at 10:55 pm
[...] A recent post at Get Rich Slowly points out that, even if you’re trying to live a frugal lifestyle, it’s okay to splurge every now and then. And it points up something that I’ve noticed, now that I’ve been following the frugal-living/money-saving blogs. They’re so delightfully middle-class. [...]
February 11th, 2007 at 3:03 am
Well said Canadian Dream…I keep trying to tell myself that frugality doesn’t mean depriving myself of what I love. I spend my money on a nice health club, a good gaming computer, and nice stuff to make my house nice…but I still always buy the second newest or out of season stuff.
February 11th, 2007 at 10:56 am
I read this a few days ago, and it still has me thinking.
We have about $15K in credit card/home equity debt(debt from stupid youth spending that we each brought into the relationship when we got married) and an $8K car loan. We have been paying about $1300 a month toward this debt, and plan to sell our house this spring for a 40-60K profit (this is a modest prediction–we’re accounting for the crappy market).
We’ll move into a slightly more expensive house (but not much), so our mortgage payment is going to go up by $150-200 a month, and we’ll wipe out our debt with the extra cash we make from the home sale (after making a big down payment and accounting for closing and moving costs).
For the last four months, we’ve also been living frugally. This has been a really exciting adventure for me, forcing me to be really creative about spending (I’ve been a shopaholic in the past) and to rethink why I spend what I do.
This month, however, I “splurged” on a $28 ring, but I had this strange response afterward. It was like the old shopping buzz in my head was reignited, and I immediately wanted to spend more. I went and dropped another $50 on stuff at the thrift store (clothes for the kids, shoes for me) afterward. This makes no sense. We didn’t really “need” these things, though I could justify buying them.
Okay, so this isn’t exactly an avalanche of spending, but it’s triggered the old feelings I used to get from spending a lot at Target, say, as if I was rebuilding my life in some way. It has made me want to go shopping more, not less.
In other words, I feel like I need to do some rewiring before I can start “splurging” safely, because for me, even small splurges make those old feelings of entitlement and excitement rear up, and I lose my sense of self and the greater goals we’ve set for ourselves (a vacation later this year, some new furniture, an emergency fund). It’s like a drug addiction, really. I love the high too much.
I’m a freak with the uber-long posts. Sorry. Your blog just gets me all excited.
Jen
February 11th, 2007 at 11:27 am
Jen, if it’s any consolation, I have been where you are now. It used to be that I couldn’t allow myself to splurge because doing so would spell trouble. In fact, there are still places I won’t allow myself to splurge. For example, I’ve been trying to control my spending on comics. Well, there were several *great* auctions on eBay yesterday, and I would dearly have loved to bid. BUT, I’ve done so well with my comic book spending lately that it would be a shame to fall off the wagon. What’s more, I know that if I had bought these I would have wanted more (they’re a part of a series I don’t collect — yet). It took some willpower, but I refrained. On the other hand, I know that my expensive dinner out isn’t likely to lead to other expensive dinners out. $160 on a meal is *always* going to seem overpriced, no matter how good the food is, so it’s not something that I’ll find myself doing on a regular basis.
I think you’re right about the “rewiring” bit. That’s an excellent way to put it. I feel like a part of me has finally been rewired, and that makes me happy.
February 11th, 2007 at 1:27 pm
[...] Blogging Away Debt was able to easily improve her credit report by getting a higher credit limit on a card with just one click. J.D. from Get Rich Slowly says it’s OK to splurge sometimes. [...]
February 11th, 2007 at 1:48 pm
We make a very good income, but have just started to indulge ourselves. For DH’s birthday in December I got a GC for $100 to Ruth’s Chris Steakhouse. We had dinner for $75 more. That was an indulgence. I’m dying to go again.
But more importantly as his Christmas present, I gave him $200 blow money for rinkside hockey tickets to his favorite hockey team. $150 ticket and another $50 for beer. I guess I should up it a bit more for dinner and stuff.
I might add my DH makes 6 figures and rarely spends any money on anything except absolute necessities. I think we’re learning slowly how to spend money now that we’re earning more. And it’s good to have a balance before you die without having enjoyed any part of life.
February 12th, 2007 at 10:03 am
Good choice of splurge. Paley’s Place is fantastic! (Of course, perhaps I’m biased, since the only time we went there was the first day of our honeymoon, before flying out of town…)
It’s definitely on our list to revisit!
February 12th, 2007 at 10:44 am
all this gourmet food stuff had me out buying winter black truffles and wild mushrooms for a mushroom extravaganza….thanks alot JD.
rewiring is correct, because you are trying to change your behavior. you do this by structuring your financial life and abiding by it. You abide by it, because you have goals that you have set out for yourself. This is why financial goals need to be realistic. If they are not, you will be more willing to see them as too daunting and fail at them and go back to your old ways. you measure goals by keeping track of your budget and seeing the progress and accomplishments as time goes by.
remember, there is no use in having money if you cannot spend it. just spend it within the parameters of your goals.
February 13th, 2007 at 10:18 pm
[...] Sloganeering posted a response to my recent story about allowing yourself to splurge. The author makes an excellent observation: There are two ways to wind up living a frugal life-style: because you want to (middle-class slumming and self-esteem boosting), or you need to (you’re just fucking poor). If you are the former, then yes, it’s okay to splurge now and then. Splurge away! But if you are the latter, then even the most occasional and modest splurging could snowball into a disaster in which you could lose everything. [...]