Today I stopped by the local electronics store to look at microphones and headphones. I didn’t intend to buy anything, but after a half hour browsing I found myself in line holding $170 of gadgets. I had fallen into an old trap: I was about to buy on impulse.
Back in my salad days, I was the Master of Impulse Shopping. If I stopped at a store, I left with more than I had intended. If I decided I wanted (needed) to have something, I went out and bought it. I put it all on credit, of course. I had the stuff now, and didn’t worry about the future. I figured the J.D. of 2007 would find some way to pay for it. (The J.D. of 2007 now looks at all the crap in his workshop and office and curses the J.D. of 1998.)
On one notable occasion, Kris tried to talk some sense into me. It was 1995. My brother-in-law had just introduced me to his Sega Genesis. I had to have one, too. I drove to the store, bought a Genesis and six games, and then returned home. I was ecstatic. I felt the warm fuzzy glow of a new purchase.
Kris did not share this warm fuzzy glow. “How much did that cost?” she asked. I hemmed and hawed. “How much debt do you have?”
“I don’t know,” I said. “$15,000?”
“Did you pay cash for that?”
“No. But I still have room on my credit card,” I said. “It’s not maxed out.”
I believed that I could spend as much as my credit would allow. I wasn’t limited by how much I had in the bank (because I had nothing there) — my only constraint was my credit limit. One time I actually called to ask to have a credit limit increased! The bank happily complied, and I had the card maxed out again in just a week or two.
I knew my spending was out of control, but I didn’t know how to stop it. If only I had been aware of the following strategies:
- Avoid advertising. Beware the insidious power of marketing. Steer clear of situations that expose you to advertising. You are not immune. We are all being subtly manipulated in ways we cannot possibly imagine.
- Avoid temptation. The best way to avoid impulse buy is to simply avoid situations that might tempt you to spend. If I had simply driven past the electronics store today, I never would have considered buying a microphone and a pair of headphones.
- Exercise mindfulness. Ask yourself, “Why do I want this? Why do I need to purchase this now instead of a week from now?” Try to discover what is motivating you to make the purchase, and try to find some other way to fulfill this urge.
- Remind yourself of larger goals. I’ve struggled with my weight all my life. Whenever I’m tempted to eat something bad, I ask myself, “Will this help me or hurt me?” The same question can be asked when you’re about to make an impulse purchase. Will your new toy bring you closer to your goals or move you further away?
- Use the 30-day rule. When you feel the urge to splurge, stop. Put the item down. Go home. Write down the name of the thing you want, its price, and the store where you found it, and then post it someplace obvious. If you still want the item after a month, purchase it.
- Tax yourself whenever you make an impulse purchase. Take 10% of the of what you paid and put it into savings. This action alone can make you more aware of your spending habits. (J Wynia combines the self-tax with a time delay — clever.)
- Use cash! It’s deceptively easy to splurge when you use a debit card or, worse, a credit card. When I carried a personal credit card, I splurged all the time. It didn’t feel like spending money.
I only owned that Sega Genesis for about an hour. Kris demanded that I return it to the store. But nothing had changed. I still had five years and $10,000 more debt ahead of me, much of it acquired through impulse spending.
Fortunately, I’ve learned to monitor myself.
Today I reached the front of the line, looked at the stuff in my hand, and realized what I was doing. I set the packages down and walked away. I’d like to start a podcast at some point, and for that I’ll need to purchase a microphone and a set of headphones, but I don’t need to buy these on impulse. I can take my time to research products.
GRS is committed to helping our readers save and achieve your financial goals.Savings interest rates may be low, but that’s all the more reason to shop for the best rate.Find the highest savings interest rate from Ally Bank, Capital One 360, Everbank, and more.
This article is about Hints and Tips, Psychology, Shopping
Disclaimer: This content is not provided or commissioned by American Express. Opinions expressed here are author's alone, not those of American Express, and have not been reviewed, approved or otherwise endorsed by American Express. This site may be compensated through American Express Affiliate Program.
Discover is a paid advertiser of this site. Reasonable efforts are made to maintain accurate information. See the Discover online credit card application for full terms and conditions on offers and rewards.
SEARCH FOR RECENT ARTICLES



Don’t forget my offer to GIVE you my Samson CO1U USB microphone! I don’t use it anymore, as it’s more suited to podcasting than music and I have zero interest in podcasting. It works fine with a Mac; you’d just have to wait a while to get it, as parcels I send from Canada to the US always seem to get hung up for a few weeks in customs. (I sent a flute to someone in Chicago in February and she didn’t receive it until two weeks ago.)
Honestly, if you set up a wish list here on GRS I bet people would donate stuff to you in appreciation for all the work you do on the blog, the forum, etc.
loading....
Or, scour craigslist to find em for free =)
Good Job JD. I am the same way with computer games, or was. Loved those things.
One way I combated the urge was that I simply stopped buying “the next best game”. I recently purchased company of heroes and played it for 2 months. CoH came out in 2005. Great game. Well worth the 15 bucks I paid. I don’t even notice that the graphics are bad, compared to today’s standards.
There is the added side-benefit of actually knowing the game was good too, thanks to reviews and awards and stuff that isn’t available when it first comes out.
loading....
The best way for me to avoid impulse purchases (or the urge to splurge) is to not have access to the money. I have been training myself to “tie up” any money laying around, and make it more difficult to get to- enough so that I have time for the feeling to pass trying to get the money, but not so I can’t reach it in case of emergency.
loading....
In 2001 I had the fantastic opportunity to backpack in South America for 4 months. It was a great trip, and I think I learned the best lesson about impulse buying there. Several times, I found local souvenirs I was interested in buying. The question was always the same, “Do I want this so much that its worth carrying on my back for 4 months?” After lugging the neccessities around for a while, anything new was almost never worth adding.
That is one mind trick I use when thinking of a impulse purchase.
loading....
Great story, and an even greater recovery from a near-impulse-buy…bravo!
If I had the choice of spending $170 or taking up a reader’s offer for a free mic…go the free route! Take brad up on his offer, and it sounds like it would be a good time for a craigslist scavenger hunt for some headphones
Great post!
loading....
Good post–this addresses the “inner consumer” that many of us still have. My area of impulse weakness is with food at the grocery store, but I’ve been successful at controlling it due to two other strategies:
1. I rationally think about the possible health benefits–or lack of benefits–of the food item I’ve grabbed. I think about how much sugar or processed flour the food has, the amount of additives and unnatural chemicals, etc., and almost always I realize how silly the purchase would be. I also consider these questions: “Do I *really* want this? Or do I simply want what it represents?
2. I allot myself a modest amount of “impulse” money in my grocery budget per month–usually around $40. So instead of spending all of this amount in one visit in the first week, I remind myself that I should use the money wisely and get treats that I really will enjoy. It works for me.
loading....
I had forgotten that Brad offered to send me his microphone. D’oh! I’ll take him up on the offer. I’m also going to Craigslist right now to look for headphones.
loading....
I’m also going to Craigslist right now to look for headphones.
——-
See if any of your faithful readers would like to donate a set of headphones for your cause. I personally don’t have a set, sorry
loading....
I just found the Gear Media Tech podcast http://pixelcorps.tv/gear_media_tech
which gives video reviews of gear for podcasters. Although watching some of them might make you techno-lust.
And oh no, if you did a podcast I would just have to listen to it even though I already listen to too many great podcasts. That’s the problem with the Internet, it is too easy to find stuff.
loading....
Congrats on axing the possible impulse purchase!
My trick whenever I have the urge to splurge is visualizing a past impulse purchase I made. “Remember the you just HAD to have because it was on sale? How did that work out for you, buddy?!”
My inner voice is very mean and sarcastic.
loading....
I will impulse window shop in stores and then go online when I get home to check prices. The idea of entering credit card info online is a good enough deterrent to me unless I really feel I need something.
I also have a wife. She helps too.
loading....
Hey J.D.
Sorry, don’t have headphones to donate. Are you shure you’re not my twin? Reading your article sounded just like me. As long as I had a bit of “wiggle room” on the card I could buy until it was maxed out. HAVE TO STOP!!! Just today discovered the “Get Rich Slowly” site and will subscribe. I will give the 30 day wait period a try.
Thanks for throwing it out there!!! Good luck on your NOT SPENDING
loading....
I have gradually canceled [almost]all my catalogs. I don’t shop much, since I work at home, but they’re so pretty and attractive – I would read them over lunch, in the bathroom, whatever. And of course I purchased things, almost all of which I regretted. You can cancel catalogs by going to Customer Service at their website. It takes about 6-8 weeks til they stop. There is a great company that does this for $36 a year, http://www.greendimes.com, if you think it’s worth the outlay. (And they plant a tree for you, too!) And less lugging all the recycling.
loading....
I am the anti-impulse buyer, but not because I don’t want things. Precisely the opposite, I want the BEST things.
For example, following the wii-thread in the forum, I almost broke down and bought one. When I did a little research, I found that the wii doesn’t do HDTV. I bet the next one will, so I resolved to wait. When that one comes out, it’s sure to be lacking something promised in version 3, and so on. The end result, I never wind up buying one.
loading....
I use a version of the 30 Day Rule.
I keep a notebook just for things I want or “need”. Even if I truly think I need it, it gets written in the notebook. This is a reminder that I can’t afford to buy every single thing I might want, and have to choose from among the many things that catch my eye.
I procrastinate. I also research. I seek alternatives to the thing I want, or at least cheaper ways to acquire it. Very, very often, I decide it’s not really a high enough priority for me to buy it. But I don’t take it off the list. It’s written in ink in that notebook.
I still have my list from six years ago, when I first started this. It’s a great reminder of how well the method works.
loading....
I too love the notebook for things that I want. I know that if it is in the notebook, I may buy it from my monthly allowance if I really want to. It saves me from worrying that I might forget about the item. Of course, I also do forget about the item, and then I can cross it off the list if I want.
loading....
Something everyone should do, but the lure of free credit to begin with, is too tempting for alot of folks to let go…
loading....
Regarding advertising, I find myself particularly susceptible to reviews. I enjoy reading reviews for books, movies, games, plays, and occasionally a review will convince me that I must have/see something. Reviews = ads. Resist them!
loading....
[...] How to Fight the Urge to Splurge – If you aren’t reading Get Rich Slowly everyday, you should be. J.D. is one of the best and most consistent personal finance bloggers I’ve ever read. His latest post lists several ways to avoid the temptations to spend money that surround us all every day. [...]
loading....
How To: Stop Impulse Shopping…
It’s always interesting to see how many personal finance bloggers used to be impulse buyers. Personally, we are the opposite of an impulse buyer. We think of ourselves as damn near shopping anorexic, so perhaps we are not the best……
loading....
We must be on the same wave length. I just posted 20 tips to keep from spending yesterday:
http://encouragingcoach.com/wordpress/?p=883
loading....
[...] at GetRichSlowly offers his insight into avoiding an impluse purchase by offering these tips: 1. Avoid advertising. 2. Avoid temptation. 3. Exercise mindfulness. 4. [...]
loading....
[...] at GetRichSlowly offers his insight into avoiding an impluse purchase by offering these tips: 1. Avoid advertising. 2. Avoid temptation. 3. Exercise mindfulness. 4. [...]
loading....
Or, make things work double duty.
I used to make a lot of calls via Skype; I had a USB headset/microphone combination.
It cost me $40, I think and works and sounds crystal clear.
I’m getting ready to do an audiobook of my first book, and guess what I’m going to use to record it?
Yep.
The above headset/microphone and audacity.
Done and done, baby.
loading....
[...] How to Fight the Urge to Splurge ? Get Rich Slowly “Today I stopped by the local electronics store to look at microphones and headphones. I didn’t intend to buy anything, but after a half hour browsing I found myself in line holding $170 of gadgets.” This isn’t my biggest problem, but it’s one of them. (tags: shopping interesting todo) [...]
loading....
Here’s a powerful anti-impulse trick I began using several years ago.
If you’re contemplating the purchase of some non-essential “luxury”, write the current date and the name of the item on a Post-It and promise yourself that if you still want the item fourteen days from the current date that you’ll buy it.
Almost all of the time you’ll find that you’re no longer interested in the item well before the fourteen days are up.
I believe this trick works because it replaces the impulse for action created by advertising and encouraged by retailers.
Note that after I used this system for a while I began to require it less often. It seems that acquiring initial control over impulse purchasing also “rewires” one responses to the sub-conscious cues used to induce impulse buying…
loading....
Advertisers spend millions conditioning us to buy on impulse and to reverse our needs and wants. Nothing feels better to be able to have the last say …
loading....
I’m a horrible impulse shopper. The worst. I don’t spend money on big ticket items, rather, I spend it on small things. Most recently, I spent $23 on mascara. MASCARA! Right now, I’m eating a Wendy’s baked potato. I have a kitchen full of food, but I HAD to have a baked potato.
Beware of the “Oh, it’s only a few dollars” mentality! When dealing with a basket full to the brim with groceries, those “few dollars” items add up quick!
loading....
I find paypal is my absolute weak spot wrt splurging. It’s just so EASY to buy some random thing I don’t need, because all I have to do is click “okay” a couple of times.
To be fair, I do have it linked to a debit card rather than a credit, so I can’t go into _debt_ with it, but I can damn sure go into broke with it.
loading....
To provent impulse buying I limit the amount of money I bring with me. Sometimes if I go out and don’t have anything to purchace, I don’t bring any money with me. I will just end up buying something if I bring some.
loading....
[...] to fight the urge to splurge. Related: Men’s silly underwear is now serious [...]
loading....
As another reader mentioned, I also give myself a (small) allotment each month for impulse/just-want-it buying. If I don’t spend it one month, I add it to the next. When I do buy something, I appreciate so much more.
(BTW, thanks for your response.)
loading....
I fell victim at Banana Republic. I told my story on my blog and sure enough you had a piece on the same thing! I linked to you! Youre a mind reader I swear! Keep it up!
loading....
[...] Fight the urge to splurge @ Get Rich Slowly [...]
loading....
Whenever I feel the urge to spurge, I say to myself “Oh yeah? So you’ve got an extra $40 bucks? Great! Let’s send it to Visa”
That ususally cools it down. And sometimes I actually do send it to Visa.
loading....
Great tips JDm but one REALLY EFFECTIVE way I control my gadget buying habits is to educate myself on what models are ‘coming soon’. For example, there’s a notebook computer (I write about these things for a living) i REALLLLY want, but it costs $1,600. But by exposing myself to ads and stories I KNOW there’s a much improved model just around the corner- end of May. So I convince myself that my $1,600 will buy a much better gadget if I wait a month or two.
If you rinse and repeat this method a couple of times, you’ll be able to plan your purchases much better and walk away with more bang for your buck.
loading....
One thing I’m learning to do is to try to make a more realistic assessment of how much use I’ll get out of what I’m buying. Some things I use all the time — computer, cell phone, camera, bed, etc. Other things, such as DVDs, video games, some books, I rarely have time to actually use once I get them. Most of the frequently used things are also a bit more expensive, so I put more thought into the purchase. Many of the rarely used things aren’t that expensive, but really add up over time (and add a lot of bulk to your life). So put as much thought into the cheap stuff as you do the big-ticket items and be honest about how much you’ll really use that “must have” item.
loading....
When I am tempted to impulse buy, I like to crank up the “shopping” gene. I know, I’m a guy and I’m not supposed to have it, as I have been told only women really know how to shop for a bargain.
But, I have also been accused of being “frugal” (and even down-right cheap), so sometimes I like to look around.
If I see something I really like, but I’m not sure about the price, I do look online for it first. Many times, you can find it cheaper online, just be careful. I don’t use E-Bay, because they want a credit card to verify my identity and not to make a purchase. I’m still not sure my credit card company will cover an unauthorized purchase when I use the card as ID, not to make a purchase. But in any case, if the company is a major name, you can save bundles on that online purchase and never have to tackle other shoppers to get that last one.
The second thing this allows you to do, besides enjoy the pleasure of saving big bucks on that worthless purchase, is it gives one time to cool off and decide if one really needs that item. If you give yourself a cool-off period, then you won’t buy half the things you don’t need.
However, I am sorry to report that this does not work in a 4th dimension known as the “Wally World” dimension. When you see worthless junk that you don’t need, but just have to have at this store, you cannot pass it up…..if you think about it, it will be gone before you get back. So, at this one store, consider the worthless junk carefully! LOL!
loading....
[...] Rich Slowly writes about a few good ways to channel your inner frugal-power [via The Consumerist]. One tip I especially liked, Tax yourself whenever you make an impulse [...]
loading....
You can do a good job with much less than $170 in stuff. I’ve done some pretty decent recording with a $50 Plantronics USB headset. And if you use a Mac, buy the “gaming” version if possible. It’s usually cheaper & the only difference seems to be that you don’t get all the windows software that you don’t need (& can likely download anyway).
Some samples from my Plantronics:
http://maxhedrm.montebellopark.com/blog/index.php?s=librivox
loading....
[...] is the better part of shopping. You know all those money hacks I share to trick yourself while shopping? Here’s where they come into play. Establish a 30-day waiting period before making big [...]
loading....
@YlimE08: Oh, the Bigbucks Makeup Purchase! How I understand that one! I bought a $13 cream eyeliner that was supposed to be great, but turned out to be mucky. I had saved my RiteAid receipt, however, and I brought that mucky eyeliner back and got my money back instead, and put it towards the scratching post that I trust the cats will use at least occasionally instead of my rug.
I’m struggling with the impulse purchase of clothing. It’s tough, because I am NOT an easy fit, and when something fits, I’m very strongly tempted to buy it, since I need to look professional for work. I buy in thrift shops and Daffy’s (discount chain), but it’s still money. I pay cash, and most of the time I don’t buy, but still… and then I think, I don’t go out to eat, I don’t go to movies, I don’t have a TV, I don’t drink, I don’t smoke, I buy an occasional book or some yarn. As long as it’s not out of control, how is it bad to buy a skirt and blouse for work? The control issue is the problem. And then I think that when I was married, it took me 15 years to actually spend the money for a terrycloth robe for myself. I’m trying not to let the pendulum swing too far in either direction: no buying at all, or buying something just because I like it.
loading....