Clutter’s Last Stand: The Cost of Buying Things You Will Not Use
Published on - June 4th, 2007 (Modified on - June 5th, 2007) (by J.D. Roth) During the 1990s, I used credit cards to fund my every whim. I bought books and games and computers and gadgets. Now, ten years later, I’m still carrying a lot of that debt in the form of a home equity loan (into which
I rolled all my credit cards several years ago). I also still have a lot of the crap I bought.
I have a plan for getting rid of the debt by next spring, but until recently I had no intention of getting rid of the things I had bought with the money. Instead, I let them take up space in the garage, in the workshop, in the basement. Physical reminders of my foolish purchases were all around me. The clutter was as much a mental burden as the debt!
Then a reader recommended Clutter’s Last Stand: It’s Time to De-Junk Your Life. Author Don Aslett is a cleaning zealot — reading this book opened my eyes. In a chapter called “The Economy of Clutter”, Aslett lists the costs of clutter:
- Clutter makes every job take longer
- Clutter makes cleaning take longer
- The value is in the using, not the owning
- Storing clutter costs you
- Guarding clutter costs you
- Moving clutter costs you
- Even owning clutter costs you
“No matter how you look at it,” writes Aslett, “clutter is a poor investment.”
Kris and I spent Saturday sorting through my poor investment. Our community garage sale is this weekend, so this seemed like a good time to get rid of some of the junk that has been cluttering up our lives. It took a l-o-n-g time. We have way too much stuff.
We sorted through dozens of boxes, purging junk. We saved the best items to sell,
but many things went directly into the trash. Every time I pitched something, I winced. These things are physical representations of my debt. I felt like I was literally throwing my money away. It especially hurt because I’m still paying interest on this stuff!
When I tossed my electronic chess game (missing two rooks and the instructions), I recalled buying it for $79 at Radio Shack in 1995. I spent over $500 on computer programming manuals around the same time, manuals that haven’t been opened since I bought them. This morning they’re sitting at the curb in the recycling bin. I couldn’t bring myself to throw away the box full of computer games I acquired (but hardly played) over the past fifteen years, but as I write this entry, I know that when I get home today they’re all going in the trash. Is there really any reason to hold onto a copy of Duke Nukem?
I’ve written before that you should not buy things you cannot afford. Here’s another tip: Don’t buy things for which you have no use. Don’t buy things you do not need or want. This is common sense, I know. But for a decade, I bought anything that sounded bright, shiny, and new. I’m not the only one. Aslett writes:
There are people who all their lives dream [...] whatever they want above all, and as their live nears its end, they finally accumulate the cash to have the big dream come true. Even if they can’t use it much, they go buy it — thinking that the having is the ultimate. But it all comes to little because they can’t smell and feel and share the glory of daily use. The value is in the using and building and growing, not simply the having.
The value is in the using, not in the having. It has taken me 38 years to realize this!
Fortunately, I’m not the same person I was five or ten years ago. I still buy dumb things now-and-then, but mostly I’ve learned to control myself. I bring less junk into my life. What has changed?
- I’ve learned to ask myself, “Will I use this?” If I’m at a bookstore and feel the urge to buy something I ask myself, “Will I read this?” It’s shocking how often the answer is “no”. When it is, I put the book back on the shelf.
- I used to buy things on impulse, not because I wanted them. I simply had the urge to spend. Now if I really want something, I generally force myself to wait using the 30-day rule.
- I’ve also begun to purchase quality items. So much of what we threw away Saturday was cheap and shoddy. It’s worthless. Now, for example, if I decide I want a messenger bag, I save until I can afford one that is high quality. By taking the time to save, I often decide I don’t want the thing after all.
Though it hurts to think of how much money I threw away over the weekend, it’s a relief to get rid of this junk. The debt I incurred to buy it is a mental burden, but so was having this stuff in the garage. It feels great to be clearing out this space. It’ll feel even better next spring when I’ve finally paid off my home equity loan!
GRS is committed to helping our readers save and achieve your financial goals.Savings interest rates may be low, but that’s all the more reason to shop for the best rate.Find the highest savings interest rate from Ally Bank, Capital One 360, Everbank, and more.
This article is about Basics, Self-Improvement
Disclaimer: This content is not provided or commissioned by American Express. Opinions expressed here are author's alone, not those of American Express, and have not been reviewed, approved or otherwise endorsed by American Express. This site may be compensated through American Express Affiliate Program.
Discover is a paid advertiser of this site. Reasonable efforts are made to maintain accurate information. See the Discover online credit card application for full terms and conditions on offers and rewards.
SEARCH FOR RECENT ARTICLES



Hello… I am new to your site, but not new to Don Aslett’s books.
I recommend reading some of his other books too… all great material.
And I look forward to reading more of you website.
loading....
Do not throw away CDs if you still want the music unless you are extremely diligent about backups. The way I learned it as a new support tech is that there are two kids of computer users: those who have had their hard drive fail, and those who are about to….
loading....
I just bought a gasoline-powered auger for $150. It sells, new, for roughly $1,000. I had one hole in my front yard to drill and a few at my Kingdom Hall (bad drainage in a flower bed).
Maybe I’ll hire-out to drill post holes in the near future.
In that case, the purchase was a great investment. Otherwise, it becomes expensive clutter.
The question in my mind is this: when do you know something is clutter?
loading....
Good information. Way to go with the clutter! Better to learn a lesson now than many years later. I Have been working hard at letting things go, and keeping the things I truly love. “Things” can clutter our life and put us into debt. Best advise I have heard, is it a Want or a Need? Good question to ask when wanting to make a purchace. Lots of good advice and information. Everyone please regift, recycle, or best of all donate those items you no longer want!!!Totally agree with anon on post 46. We as Americans have too much stuff. Check out the Europeans and the very small closets they have, most of us would never survive! We could all take note of the enormous debt most carry in the US. Sorry, not a good thing! Keep up the good work paying off the home equity loan! May take some time but you will never BUY into junk/clutter again.
loading....
[...] tyranny of Stuff for years. I’ve even written about the problem once before, warning about the cost of buying things you will not use. I currently have two books at the top of my to-read pile that discuss coping with [...]
loading....
I’ve long thought Aslett’s books gave the best advice!
I remember reading a quote by him (I think it may be from that book) that clutter costs us much more than we ever think, especially if we buy a bigger house than necessary just to store all of our “stuff”.
We then lose money not only from buying the “stuff”, but we lose money in buying the bigger house, working longer hours to pay for the house, and paying extra taxes.
All because we bought too much “stuff” we didn’t need.
loading....
Ah Yes, Don Aslett! I’m a fan of his, and I like his style. He’s blunt, to the point, opinionated, and really gets to the core of things. I’ve had his book “How to Have a 48 Hour Day” for many years, and I turn back to it time and again
.
Our house overall is clutter free except for two places… my office and our garage. The reason is that these are the two least traveled areas in the house, and everything just seems to end up there. To this end, I’ve decided to spend more of my time in both of these areas. By doing so, I will have to face the inconvenience and problems associated with these areas and be inspired to continue whittling away at them.
loading....
Don’t throw it out before you try to Freecycle it, first! Someone may have had that exact same electronic chessboard, missing the knight
loading....