This is a guest post from JerichoHill.
Last week I introduced the first of a three-part series on my experiences with building a major home addition. It dealt with defining your objectives and determining if the necessary resources were available and where they were located.
To Recap: Because my fiancée, Julie, bought before housing prices rapidly appreciated, we had a large amount of equity to fund our addition, so we wanted to use a home equity loan product. We leveraged our strength towards its best use. Your financial picture will be different, but the key tenet is to utilize your unique strengths.
I next had to navigate the mine-ridden battlefield of loan applications. What was the best deal? How do I find it? And how would I know when I did find it?
We checked with our respective banks, thinking that our existing relationships with these behemoths (Julie and I had separate accounts in separate banks) would mean better terms. These two big banks had similar offers carrying a fixed rate of 8%. Not knowing if these were good or bad, it was time to utilize the magic of the internet.
I wanted lots of offers to compare to, and I wanted them quickly. Two popular websites for mortgage loan offers are BankRate and LendingTree. I filled out their forms and directed the offers to my spam email address, though regrettably, the phone number we used was Julie’s actual home phone number. In between the hundreds of highly annoying automated phone calls seemingly from LendingTree companies, we received about 10 different estimates on rates and funding in our email inbox.
Our national banks were dead last.

I believe my grandfather once told me to buy local and finance local. Hesitant to deal with lenders over the internet, and disappointed in our national banks, I turned to the local banks. Small local banks, the theory goes, know the area they are lending in. Local banks tend to only write loans in their geographic area. They may have more favorable terms since they lack the resources to compete on location and convenience against bigger banks. In my case, this adage turned out to be correct. After doing due diligence by stopping by various bank branches and getting rate quotes, I was up to 15 different offers.
It did not take long to wean through the offers, and after a few days, I applied for a Home Equity Loan with Cardinal Bank . With the small banks I talked to, I received better answers to my questions and more personal service than I had with the larger institutions. Since home-buying involves a large sum of money and a lot of trust, I placed a good deal of value on customer service. The smaller banks tend to be more willing to hold your hand and respond to your questions more than the bigger outfits, at least in my experience. Check out your local bank to see if this idea works for you.
Prior to signing the loan documents, Julie and I sat down to look at our financial picture with the new mortgage payment. Our new combined payment was essentially double what Julie had been paying previously on her first position mortgage. I wanted to sit down and look at finances because I had been used to living with roommates and paying very little in rent. I knew that my spending patterns were about to change. I was used to a college lifestyle (cheap rent, eats, entertainment) and was about to “grow up.”
We talked about how much our combined emergency fund should be (we felt comfortable with one year’s worth of living expenses). The new mortgage payment would be 36% of our take-home pay, which was quite roomy. There’s even money left over in our budget to prepay, and that’s a good feeling.
Good planning on your addition may mean you can find a way that it can finance itself: we turned the basement into a one bedroom suite. Eventually, this space will either house visiting relatives or children, but for awhile, we’ll be able to rent it out, and we plan on using the proceeds for one purpose: prepay the home equity loan.
If everything works out, we will pay down the whole home equity loan within 6 years. But what are we doing with the addition, and how can our experiences in the building process help you save money have to wait until next week.
You can follow the whole home addition process, including pictures and summaries, in this GRS forum thread
This article is about House and Home, Real-Life Saturday, 28th July 2007 (by J.D. Roth)


RSS Feeds
Facebook
GRS Twitter







July 28th, 2007 at 7:49 am
A bit of semantics here, but you didn’t fund your addition with your home equity — you funded it with your future income. Banks and real estate agents have managed to turn the word “equity” into something that sounds liquid, which it isn’t.
But still, I have to say congratulations — sounds like you’ve done a good job of planning and shopping around. I’m sure you’ll love your new addition.
July 28th, 2007 at 9:31 am
Jeff,
Of course you’re correct. I suppose the purpose of saying “home equity” is to indicate that the loan was secured by the difference between the appraised value of the home and the outstanding liens
July 28th, 2007 at 9:44 am
I’m impressed with your planning and thinking - you’ve done a lot more than most “experienced” people.
We did a gut reno of our new house - did a lot of the work ourselves and contracted out quite a bit. We had no idea what things cost and how much work it was and it was a bit of a financial disaster to say the least. The house turned out quite well and we haven’t sold it so I guess it worked out (sort of) in the end.
I’m new to this site but I’ll be checking out your full story in the forums since I’m sure it’s quite interesting.
Mike
July 28th, 2007 at 1:03 pm
It’s good to see a first-hand account of someone who used the internet to get a better rate. A lot of people think that local companies can always give them better prices and service, but with the internet, almost everything is local now. I’m glad that you guys were able to get a good deal and start your addition. Congratulations!
July 28th, 2007 at 1:23 pm
Don’t use your monthly budget surplus to prepay the mortgage unless you have already maxed out your retirement contributions first.
July 28th, 2007 at 3:27 pm
Jim,
We’ve already maxed em out =)
July 28th, 2007 at 3:30 pm
fwiw, there will be a 4th part of this series, detailing how to do a few big projects by yourself.
So far, we’ve
1) Built a fence
2) Installed Radiant Floor Heat
July 29th, 2007 at 12:54 pm
Then there are those who don’t understand housing math.
The story of an MBA student who thinks it’s smart to buy a 1-bedroom condo for $715,000:
http://wcvarones.blogspot.com/2007/07/poor-reflection-on-usf-mba-program.html
July 30th, 2007 at 9:55 am
A mortgage payment of 36% of take-home pay is considered roomy???
Yikes!
July 30th, 2007 at 1:10 pm
Telly,
In the DC market, 36% of our take-home pay is considered roomy (this number includes insurance and taxes). Of course, take-home pay is affected by your pretax savings rate, which is quite large for us. Had we kept a standard pretax savings rate, it would have been around 25%.
Additionally, percentages can mean different things depending on what your overall income level is.
July 31st, 2007 at 9:22 am
I didn’t realize you were including pre-tax savings. That definitely makes the mortgage much ‘roomier’.
Thankfully we live in an area where homes are pretty inexpensive, so we’re at around 12%.
July 31st, 2007 at 2:52 pm
[...] Blow-by-Blow Account of a Housing Addition, part two: Capitalization - For those considering adding on to their house, this is the second part in a series examining the real-life experiences of one couple. [...]
August 2nd, 2007 at 9:50 am
In some cities there, including Cleveland, where I live, there are special home equity loan programs available at substantially discounted interest rates. When I borrowed under one of these programs to do major home renovations, the rate was 2% with no income limits. Before you just start calling around to banks, it may be worthwhile to investigate whether these discounted loans may be an option where you live.