Five Tips for Effective Consumer Complaints Print
Tuesday, 20th May 2008 (by J.D.)This article is about Odds and Ends, Shopping
I hate big corporations — they’re bureaucratic nightmares.
Three years ago, Verizon claimed that our family business had signed up for a $37.20 monthly listing in their telephone directory. We had not. I spent nearly six months battling their customer service department to get the charges removed. I made phone calls and sent registered letters, but still they insisted we’d signed up for service we’d never requested.
Eventually, through internet sleuthing, I found the e-mail address for a Verizon bigwig. One polite (but forceful) e-mail to her was enough to get the matter resolved. But it shouldn’t have taken so much effort.
When the consumer makes an error, big corporations are unforgiving. But when the company screws up, the customer has little recourse. (I’m reminded of Sallie Mae’s recent computer glitch that could cost borrowers tons of money.)
That’s why I’m such a fan of The Consumerist, the blog that explores consumer experiences with big business. Now editor Ben Popken has contributed a story to Reader’s Digest that distills hundreds of blog posts into a single focused article about how to get what you paid for with effective consumer complaints. He writes:
Companies have the right to make a profit. As consumers, we have the right to receive the goods and services we purchased at the price and quality advertised. We also have the right to seek redress if those expectations are not met.
But the Federal Trade Commission and other regulatory bodies that are supposed to protect us from reckless profiteers can’t possibly address every complaint. So now it’s up to you to protect your consumer rights.
Popken details five core techniques for obtaining satisfaction:
- Dictate the options. On an index card, write a sentence or two describing what it is you want the company to do for you. Refer to this index card when you phone or e-mail — it’ll keep you focused. Tell them what the problem is and how they can make it right.
- Threaten to cancel. Let the company know that you’re ready to move to a competitor (but be prepared to follow through on the threat). Popken suggests using the phrase, “Give me a reason to stick around.”
- Shoot for the top. If you cannot obtain a reasonable solution through the normal customer service channels, get resourceful. Find a way to connect with the CEO or some other high-profile executive. That was the only way I could get my problem with Verizon resolved.
- Use the power of e-mail. Popken suggests finding (or guessing at) e-mail addresses for all the top executives. Armed with this info, launch an “e-mail carpet bomb”.
- Broadcast your complaint. If all else fails, exercise your First Amendment right to tell others about your experience. No company wants bad publicity. As long as your message is reasonable and true, you’re entitled to warn others away.
Popken’s article features other tips and suggestions, along with real-life stories of consumers who have used these techniques to resolve complaints with big corporations. He’s careful to warn, however, that these methods should only be used for valid grievances:
Before you open your mouth to complain about poor customer service, you need to ask yourself two questions: Do I have a valid complaint? Am I expecting a reasonable solution? If the answer to both questions is yes, you can use the strategies here to get satisfaction for almost any transaction.
I don’t run into situations like these often, but they do occur. I’ve bookmarked Popken’s guide for the next time I need to deal with corporate bureaucracy.
[Reader's Digest: The guerilla guide to getting what you paid for (without getting arrested)]

RSS Feeds
Facebook
Twitter

May 20th, 2008 at 5:45 am
Actually, companies don’t have a right to make a profit. They have a right to -attempt- to make a profit — within the limits posed by law.
Which ain’t the same thing at all.
May 20th, 2008 at 5:48 am
Great article.
One of the problems of dealing with a big company and the customer service department is the fact that even the most determined consumer has to work 8 hours, have a family and other aspects of life to take care of, but for the company, deflection is all that they do, so that can sit back and hope that people get discouraged and leave.
Knowing the key points of contact and other avenues is important so that you don’t spend a ton of time talking to people that are simply going to quote company policy.
May 20th, 2008 at 5:50 am
I’ve worked in customer service (IT helpdesk) and also dealt with some tricky situations where a company was not living up to their responsibilities.
If you tangle with a business, especially a utility or insurance company, that is violating its own terms of service (for instance, repeatedly returning a claim for health care service that is covered by the insurance), try contacting your State Attorney General. The State Attorney General will send a letter, and that may be all it takes to get the right people on the case.
But… NEVER START OFF CONFRONTATIONAL. Many of the people I dealt with didn’t understand that as a front-line service person, I wasn’t impressed by their high-pressure attitude; in fact, it made me unwilling to help them more than I had to. It’s ok to admit that a situation is really upsetting you or even making you angry; just make a clear effort not to take it out on the front-line service person and they’ll probably go the extra mile for you. If you get stonewalled, ask to speak to a manager; the rep probably can’t fix the problem anyway if they are stonewalling you.
May 20th, 2008 at 6:08 am
JD-great post, I’m going to have to check out his blog. I like how he recommends you make sure your complaint is valid. This is something that is often forgotten in the heat of the moment.
@Jenne-great point. Remember, the guy or gal on the phone is just doing their job. If you are pleasant, it makes them want to help you.
Big companies are saddled with the bureaucracy needed to keep a massive organization functional. They end up hiring less than enthusiastic people and plug them into a system that focuses on the company needs, not the customer.
I know this because I work for one of the largest in the world. I spend more time making it easier on my customer and fighting the bureaucracy for them.
Small companies can be even worse. At lease with a corporate behemoth you can a bigwig to help. With a small company the owner is often the problem-and your last resort!
My usual response-if I can’t get an answer-is to call the credit card company and dispute the charges. This always resolves the problem. Note: this only works if you have gotten you finances under control and can trust yourself with a credit card. Don’t get a credit card just so you can dispute charges!
May 20th, 2008 at 6:41 am
Airlines have recently been my thorn in the flesh. You either have to follow their policies, or get kicked off the plane. They can change the rules on each flight, and trying to reason with them is not an option because they can just call you “unruly” and kick you off the plane.
The issue at stake? Making families with small children wait to board until the first 60 passengers have boarded. The result of such policy? Those 60 people who board first - even when the plane is full - sit one person in the aisle seat in one row, one person in the window seat of the next row…all the way to the back of the plane, where you’re lucky to find a row where you can sit together.
If I paid extra money to get to board first (which is the underlying policy causing the problem), I would want to know where the families with small children were seated so I could sit away from them.
As it stands, the families either have to hike to the back (everyone else would just have to walk one or two rows further if the families boarded first) or the “important passengers” who got to board first and sit in front have the privilege of being kicked by a small child if the families choose not to hike to the back even if it means not sitting together.
But voice a complaint and they will respond to your complaint in such a way that they make you REALLY mad, and being REALLY mad means they can refuse to let you board because you’re a “threat.”
There’s a reason why airlines are always declaring bankruptcy…
May 20th, 2008 at 7:28 am
I’m all for sticking up for the little guy but too often Consumerist crosses a line and it’s just venting about corporations that people feel wronged them. I kind of wish the Consumerist would stick to major stories where it’s obvious there was an unfair problem that can be solved by the notoriety, but all too often they cover minor gaffes that turn into pile-ons about how much everyone hates the X company.
This list of tips on how to complain sounds ok at first, but an email carpet bomb to top execs? That sounds like a really annoying mess, especially if everyone reading Readers Digest follows through on the advice.
I’m reminded of a complaint I read yesterday where someone insisted that a web application wasn’t working because they picked the same username and password as their DSL login — they were totally convinced the site was slow because the site was contacting their DSL company every time they loaded a web page. The complaint is clearly ridiculous but I ran across their boycott of the website as they were complaining on other people’s sites about it.
May 20th, 2008 at 7:51 am
I agree wholeheartedly with Matt. Large corporations are generally not the easiest to deal with, but The Consumerist often annoys me by treating corporations as a borg-like single entity, rather than something made up of lots of people like me, who want to do right and be done right just like everyone else.
May 20th, 2008 at 9:14 am
I suspect if the people at the Consumerist were to go thru training for my job (the equivalent of a semester of college), and start taking calls, they would not last more than a week. Some probably would not make it until first break.
JD, I know what you are going thru. Half my job is fixing other agent’s mistakes. Trust me, fixing things is about ten times harder than breaking them.
May 20th, 2008 at 9:50 am
Great post! I just used these tips to get my itinerary changed at no charge when Delta canceled one of my flights and then put me on something ridiculously unreasonable. I suspect, though, that customer service specialists at Delta are allowed to offer such a service to inconvenienced customers…
May 20th, 2008 at 10:04 am
I’ve found that sending snailmail can get good results.
A rule of thumb: If you’re having a problem getting your complaint read, use a medium other than the one they usually get complaints through. If they use a call center, send a letter (on paper.) If they have mail-in comment cards, phone.
May 20th, 2008 at 10:08 am
While I’ll agree with some of the above posters that the Consumerist can be occasionally overzealous, the truth is that it works.
My coworker had a warranty dispute with a company, and she was unable to get her problem resolved using any of the above remedies. She tried calling, email carpet bombing, writing letters to the legal dept, being polite to the CSRs, being impolite, escalating her calls, but nothing worked.
And yet, 2 days after her story ran on Consumerist, the company contacted her and resolved her problem the same day, overnighting her a replacement for the product they had refused to return to her for 4 months.
So while Consumerist may seem irritating and repetitive to the casual reader, for many of those people who write in, they’re really the option of last resort.
May 20th, 2008 at 10:33 am
I don’t have the energy for all of this. They just lose my business right away, then I move on to step five. Treat me right the first time, jerks.
May 20th, 2008 at 10:41 am
Of course, sometimes you get cooperation at step 1. Kinda like Sunday’s Baby Blues cartoon - Mom asks the oldest to watch the baby, and shocked to get cooperation instead of nagging.
And speaking as a former frontline tech support person, I totally agree with Jenne in #3.
In particular:
Do not call the service reps names. The call will probably be terminated and you may even get blacklisted. I’ve been called everything from “b*tch” to “c*nt” before I even had my morning coffee, and it NEVER resulted in anything except me following the “Service techs do not have to take abusive language and can hang up on the caller with impunity” policy.
Yes, I am a woman. This does not mean I can’t do the job.
Of course you can complain that something made by another company broke. Just don’t expect my company to replace it!
May 20th, 2008 at 11:31 am
I agree with what you’ve laid out, but it doesn’t work when it’s a utility - namely water. We don’t have options on water provider and our utility is providing us water without chlorine that has tested positive for bacteria. Six months of complaining, contacting the health department and the water district and we still have unsafe water. Any suggestions?
May 20th, 2008 at 12:15 pm
I just had to “confront” the USPS employee who sold me the wrong stamps, and unfortunately they don’t care about customers because there are few alternatives to the postal service. But yes, like a commenter said above, definitely don’t start off confrontational. I started off okay but once she got rude, I let it get to me and pointed out her mistake, and she was defensive (and therefore not helpful) after that. I still wrote a letter to the USPS for all it’s worth, just to let them know how one customer feels.
May 20th, 2008 at 12:23 pm
For water quality complaints, try asking the EPA (http://www.epa.gov/safewater/), and also contacting your State.
The EPA has an informational hotline at:
Safe Drinking Water Hotline 1-800-426-4791
Never underestimate, when you’re dealing with an issue of government, the power of getting in the big guns… such as contacting your state representative or your federal congresspeople’s office to ask for help.
Oh, and also try contacting a library in your area for more suggestions.
May 20th, 2008 at 1:04 pm
Thanks for this post–Consumerist is an inspiration, and has personally helped with with erroneous WaMu charges and resulting Citibank issues.
May 20th, 2008 at 1:54 pm
You are right these things don’t happen often but when they do they are often a nightmare. This is useful information to have around.
May 20th, 2008 at 7:43 pm
The company should never let their customers get to a stage where they look up ways to get their voices heard. Its a pitty that it happens
May 20th, 2008 at 8:02 pm
Just a note to Jeanne that worked the IT desk.. I worked for a large insurance company for 21 years… I dealt with many irate people and never did I ever feel, as you worded it “in fact, it made me unwilling to help them more than I had to.” Many times I had to battle the company to get what people were entitled to, often without their knowing it and most times without thanks. I viewed my job as making sure that each insured that I dealt with received everything they were entitled to , irrespective of their attitude. That is the correct attitude and that is the implied promise that any business makes.
Thx jegan
May 20th, 2008 at 10:26 pm
Big companies really have a hard time solving customer service issues. The main reason is, they have this customer service agents whom you can address and then these people will be the ones who’ll try to solve your problem. But the disadvantage here is, some customer concerns are beyond the customer service agent’s knowledge. And so the very best thing they could do is to leave you words of promises and hope that they will try to look at the reason behind your query and will just call you if they have this solved already. That’s quite annoying on the part of the customers. We can’t really blame them though. Some customer concerns should be solved by another area of the company. And if the customer service representative finds out its beyond their capacity, then what they’ll do is to tell you that they’ll address your concern to the right department and will just give you a ring after they’ve done solving the issue.
The list above of ways to voice out effective customer complaints is helpful. Like what you said, it would help customers to be more focused in relaying their complaints as well as to be sure that their concerns will be heard.
May 21st, 2008 at 3:36 am
I am going through this right now with a small business. They sent me a defective product and now refuse to refund me based on their policies but I have complained UP, followed the appropriate channels and may have some small claims court action on the horizon depending on the results of my bank’s investigation. I hate to do this to a small business during rough times but piss poor customer service gets you no where.
This post reminded me that going through my bank and possibly small claims court may not be unfair after all. I am out $300 because of their inept order processing and customer service.
May 21st, 2008 at 10:41 am
One thing that helps a lot: a speaker phone. When they try to deflect you with the punch-a-button phone maze and the endless wait on hold, just switch to the squawk box. Then you can go on about your business and not have the company’s advertising and ungodly Muzak pumped into your ear, so you feel a lot less cranky when the hapless customer service rep finally does get on the phone.
Next strategy: Remember that the customer service rep IS hapless. Ugh. How would YOU like to have that job? By the time you get to her or him, you’re mad as a hornet because you’ve been through endless annoyance on the phone and likely been given a runaround. Try to keep your ire under control and be nice to the poor wretch who finally does answer the phone: you catch more flies with honey than you do with vinegar.
To minimize phone aggravation, check gethuman.com for clues to how to break through the kudzu.
Also, it’s true that snail-mail sometimes is more effective than talking to underlings whose job is to deflect you. Big companies, however, now hide the addresses of their corporate headquarters. To find them, google the company’s investor relations or investor services department. Sometimes Hoovers.com is useful.
And finally, keep a list of phone numbers and addresses of various regulators on the state and federal level. If you think you’ve been defrauded or cheated, a state attorney general’s office can be amazingly helpful. Companies really do NOT want to take time to respond to an inquiry from the AG, or to pay a lawyer to do so. Banks, credit card issuers, and credit unions are regulated by the federal banking commission. Insurance companies are usually regulated by state agencies. Check out and make a list of all the resources you can think of before anything happens to make you upset and angry, since rage tends to obscure your thinking.
May 21st, 2008 at 11:52 am
I have had good luck and bad luck dealing with companies. But one thing I have not seen mentioned here is filing a complaint with the Better Business Bureau.
I started getting text messages from aolAlerts, like 30 a day, for all kinds of “news”. Entertainment headlines, Football scores (which I don’t even keep up with), and just the silliest stuff. I missed all kinds of text messages that I did actually want, because I took to ignoring them.
AOL does not make it very easy for non customers to file complaints and after literally hours scouring the net for some way of turning of these incessant text messages, even signing up for them so I could cancel everything and impersonating my Dad who is a customer, I filed a complaint with the BBB.
A very nice AOL representative called me the next day and straightened it out. Early. I hope they fixed it so that people who have acquired new numbers can turn off these alerts, but I had to bring out the big guns.
May 21st, 2008 at 2:17 pm
I’m not surprised that Verizon behaved that way. I was forced to use their local service when I lived in New Jersey and they were awful. It took almost a month just to set up service, in no small part thanks to workers not showing up many times, and many of those employees simply showed no interest in doing their jobs or doing their jobs well. I always blame that kind of attitude on the company. Either that attitude is passed from the top down or the managers just don’t care enough to weed out lazy or incompetent employees.
June 18th, 2008 at 8:23 pm
Thanks to your post I was able to contact the CEO of a very large warehouse company and resolve an issue with their gas that caused engine problems in my vehicle. Unfortunately it took several attempts and it had to escalate a bit, but finally the VP of the company called me and offered to reimburse me for the repairs. I’m extremely pleased with this outcome.
Now I’m using the same techniques to battle my wireless provider for overcharging me $1800 in one week. Thanks for the post…you definitely saved me some money!