My Paperless Personal Finance System: A Work in Progress
Published on - May 20th, 2008 (by J.D. Roth)
Last summer, as a part of my quest to get rid of clutter, I began to move toward paperless personal finance. I had planned to share my system only once I’d perfected it, but yesterday Daniel e-mailed to ask for a glimpse of its current state.
To go paperless, you might need a scanner (or some other way to convert your documents to digital files). I also recommend using a shredder to dispose of paperwork. (A shredder is one of the best defenses against identity theft.) Here’s how my current paperless personal finance system works after nine months of trial-and-error.
Handling income
Having your employer electronically deposit your paycheck for you is the first step in going paperless. This wasn’t an option for me at the box factory. Now, however, I have each of my sources of blog income automatically deposited to my business checking account. This reduces the risk of mail and identity theft, and saves me the hassle of running to the bank.
This business account adds a layer of complexity to my finances, but because I’ve automated everything, it’s not too bothersome. Most of my income sits in business checking for months on end. I make quarterly estimated tax payments from this account (a process that is not automated), and retain some of the rest for other business expenses (read: more taxes at the end of the year). Once per month, I transfer a “paycheck” to my personal checking account at the local credit union. This amount is roughly equal to my former income at the box factory.
Juggling accounts
Most of my “paycheck” remains in checking, from which it is automatically transferred to various monthly bills. (The only bill I still pay by check is the mortgage. The mortgage company wants $11 for an electronic transfer. I’d rather pay 42 cents for a stamp.) The rest of my money is divided among three savings accounts:
- My ING Direct emergency fund
- My Mini Cooper account (at the credit union)
- My vacation fund (at the credit union)
I don’t like having my accounts spread around, if only among two banks. Based on suggestions from GRS readers, I plan to move all my savings to subaccounts at ING Direct, but keep my checking account at the credit union. (I will document this process for an upcoming entry.) Besides, ING Direct pays 3.00% interest; my credit union is currently paying 0.35%!
Paying bills
Except for the mortgage, I’ve set up electronic statements and payments for all my bills. Every month, I receive an e-mail notice from each company that my statement is ready. I verify that the bill is correct. If I were to find an error (none so far), I would cancel the scheduled electronic payment and contact the company to correct the problem.
Most of my bills are set to be paid automatically. I’m wary of my credit card company, however, so I process that by hand every month. I simply log in to the bank’s web site, verify the totals, and then initiate a payment.
Processing paperwork
Using this system means I deal with a lot less paper than I used to, but I still receive certain bills and statements by mail because the companies don’t offer any other option. Plus I accumulate the normal receipts through day-to-day living.
I keep most receipts only until I’m sure the bank or credit card has processed the transaction correctly. (Others — for an appliance, for example — I keep on file.)
When I receive any other paper item, such as a bank statement, I immediately scan it and convert it to PDF. Based on reader recommendation, I use the Fujitsu ScanSnap S510M document scanner (Windows version). This is not a frugal option, but it’s damn efficient. The ScanSnap looks and feels like an inkjet printer, but it scans paper quickly and accurately, automatically converting the documents to PDF. (You may be better off using your existing scanner, if you have one.)

After scanning, I shred the original document. I name the PDF something sensible (“200805 – Mortgage.pdf”, for example), and then save it to a pre-set folder. This part of the system is key, actually. Without care, a digital filing system can become just as cluttered as a paper system. It took me several months, but I’ve created a naming convention that works for me.
My hard drive is backed up daily, so I’m not worried about data loss due to computer failure. I would like to create off-site backups, however, so I intend to look at Shoeboxed, a free online tool for receipt storage.
Reconciling statements
Every weekend, I reconcile my accounts. I use Quicken to download data from my banks and my credit card company. I verify that the information is correct, and then think about upcoming expenses. If I believe I can afford to, I transfer money from my personal checking account to one or more of my savings accounts. (I hope to move another big chunk to my emergency fund in the next week!)
I still suspect that one day I will move to a web-based tool like Wesabe or Mint or Quicken Online, but for now I’m happy with Quicken.
My impressions
Looking at this system, it’s clear that I’ve come a long way in the past year. I’m moving closer to the paperless personal finance system I described in August. Instead of retaining a shoebox full of paper every six weeks, I’m now filing just a few pages. After using these techniques for the past few months, I’m very happy with them. They’ve helped me to reduce clutter and save time.
My system isn’t perfect, though. I need to move all my savings accounts to ING Direct. Since registering a couple of business names last winter, the junk mail has picked up again — I need to put a stop to that. And I need to find out if there’s a way to pay my mortgage electronically without paying $11 per month.
Have you moved to a paperless personal finance system? Have you taken steps to automate your finances? How do you keep things organized? How do you manage all of the files and PDFs? Are you worried about data loss?
This article is about Hints and Tips, Money Hacks, Real-Life, Tools
SEARCH FOR RECENT ARTICLES




Just out of curiosity, why are you saving things like mortgage statements in the first place? When was the last time that you needed to reference it?
All the information should be available online (assuming that your loan is with a major lender and not Bailey’s Bank). All you really need is the one statement every year that shows your interest payments for tax purposes. Hell, my mortgage payment is drafted automatically, and I don’t even remember the last time I opened the statement.
(This also circles back to Juan’s comment above: Everything is handled electronically now for anybody who’s charging you for anything. I think to a certain extent, you have to trust in the reliability of their systems. I used to scour every paper statement that came into my house, matching up charges and payments. Life’s too short to worry whether someone overcharged me $10 somewhere.)
Also, any respectable financial institution should provide free online bill paying these days.
loading....
Scanning documents is definitely the way ahead.
loading....
How does the ScanSnap & other scanners handle multiple pages with text on both sides of a page? I have an old-school scanner and I’m looking to upgrade to something w/ a document feeder on it so I can set it and forget it. Anybody? Thanks. ~Jason
loading....
Here is how I wrangle up my paper statements. I probably should think about throwing these things away because I never use them 2 years out. At any rate, I can understand how maddening organizing finances can be so I’ve tried to go paperless from the start. The lady at the post office can’t believe I don’t pay any of my bills by check. Why would I?
loading....
I’ve also been using shoeboxed.com for a while and I really like it so far. I used neat receipts once upon a time but just could never keep up with it … now i can be laxy and just mail those suckers in.
loading....
Reply to Que: Even if you go paperless, don’t neglect to review your bills when they come. I work for a major wireless provider, and have at least 1 phone call per week from someone who has auto pay, and never looks at the bill, then months later, wants to know why they are being charged a certain charge that was billed to them months ago, or for several months, before they realized it.
Mistakes can happen – check your bills – then file ‘em, “shoebox” ‘em, whatever…but LOOK at them!
loading....
Agree with Que! I would never keep monthly statements. What’s the point? Review and trash. Since most businesses, esp. financial, have electronic records, you’re not going benefit by keeping your own copy.
Educational and legal, gotta have the originals. Same with investment PURCHASES and raw tax data. Sounds like warrantees, so forth, might also demand original receipts, though larger businesses have electronic records of purchases, especially if you pay with a card. BTW, I like the idea of spiking receipts you only need for a short time.
So, for us, electronic filing boils down to personal data you don’t need the originals for (all the medical record keeping stuff, DMV, insurance, manuals, small time original contract info such as CC offers, communications and letters you might need, etc.) and home improvement and auto repairs/maintenance receipts (in case we decide to sell either). We are narrowing down what we personally have to save by directing ALL billers to send invoices, notices, all paperwork, to our Paytrust account. Paytrust scans, retains, contacts us as needed, and provides annual discs of all events.
I’m also exploring the option of having service receipts and the like either faxed or emailed to us.
loading....
I used to be paperless back in the early days of scanners (3 pass for color), when one cost $1000.00 and visions of the ‘paperless society’ were bright and clear. I used a product called Papermaster which allowed you to scan and store documents in filing cabinets complete with folders. It was an awesome product, but the biggest drawback was that the images were some proprietary type that you could not view without Papermaster. It may have been in the pre-PDF days.
I suffered the indignity of having a major HD failure and could not retrieve my info. Of course, as fate would have it, the backup I was relying on did not do so properly (early days of CD writers), and lots of records were lost forever. Since then, I have not gone paperless.
loading....
I recently bought a ScanSnap document scanner as I was fed up of spending so much time searching for paper documents. Time is money, so I calculated it would pay for itself in not much time at all.
Anyone doing this should definitely ensure they have a good backup system in place though, otherwise they’ll get truly and utterly screwed when their hardware throws a wobbly.
loading....
Another vote for Mozy. I’ve also used Jungle Disk, but Mozy is easier and cheaper.
loading....
I have a scansnap and love it. I got my 510 for $125 from a company liquidating. For those who’ve mentioned the issues with backing up your docs, I can recommend Mozy as well. It’s an online service, free to 2 GB. You basically set it to auto place your docs online. Unlimited storage is only $5 a month. I back up all my critical documents, email PST, and some settings. All my music/pics/other stuff is on a RAID and/or NAS.
loading....
When I scan documents, I do it at work (with permission). My department’s high-end scanner/printer accepts hands-free stacks, and does duplexing, in no time.
As long as I do it on my own time (lunch, staying late, etc.) they don’t mind, since I’m not actually consuming any goods.
loading....
When you say review & trash your monthly statements, I hope you mean review & Shred them. You don’t want to make it easier for ID thieves.
loading....
i would also recommend yodlee moneycenter. (moneycenter.yodlee.com). they aggregate all your accounts in one place, show you balances, and even transactions for some accounts, always up to date. it is a nice way to get a true picture of your finances at any given point. hopefully they will eventually create an interface that is good enough to reconcile transactions and do all quicken-like tracking online.
loading....
I use Shoeboxed and I’ve been really happy with it. I’ve had some probelms with receipts in the past and they’re pretty friendly over there. You can just call them (888 369 4269) and they’re pretty nice. bunch of guys that are up a pretty much all hours of the night too.
loading....
Great article.
One site that I always see mentioned for online money management is Mint, but not too many people talk about Yodlee. I was a user of mint over a year ago and I know it has now grown a lot more, but Yodlee is extremely powerful, a lot more than Mint, but I will say, it is not as pretty. I would look into it before making a decision.
moneycenter.yodlee.com
loading....
What about protection on your PC?
I also receive electronic statements and scan in others but I store them in an encrypted folder on my hard drive.
I also use a program to securely move items and securely “shred” items on my machine.
My view is that it does little good to compile a giant depository of your data in electronic format if you don’t protect it well.
For starters, you may want to hit a web search and check out the Windows programs Cryptainer and Eraser.
Just food for thought.
Thanks for the great blog!
loading....
I already use the steps you mentioned.
Sometime back I came across Yodlee’s website. I use Yodlee (http://moneycenter.yodlee.com) instead of my Personal Money Software (Microsoft Money) for reconciliation.
Nice blog.
loading....
I strongly urge investing in the ScanSnap scanner. The problem with every scanner before it is that they are slow and likely require a prescan – which means you WON’T DO IT. The ScanSnap is very fast, and about as slow as I could stand to run a paperless system, but I love it. Just get it and don’t look back.
loading....
A new and interesting book “Paperless Joy” that addresses paperlessness from a fresh perspective has appeared. Is this the future?
http://www.paperlessjoy.com/
loading....
Would highly recommend Shoeboxed.com.
They auto-categorize receipts now as reported on LifeHacker
loading....
Paperless here!
I have a local bank (Regions) for my normal checking and ING Direct with multiple savings accounts. All transactions are done through their Web sites.
My paychecks are direct deposited. I use a virtual envelope-style spreadsheet using Google Docs, so I can access it at home or at work.
Early in the morning each payday, I see was direct deposited. I “give every dollar a name” using my spreadsheet. I pay the bills that are due the following week. “Extra” money is transferred to ING Direct.
“Doing” my finances (and well) takes me 10 minutes a week.
I pay my bills through their respective Web sites, except for my water, which would charge a $1.50 fee. I resent that, so I use my online billpay to send them a check at no extra cost to me.
Reconciling is no sweat. I make sure my spreadsheet shows same amount as the bank’s Web site. That is easy, because I take cash out of ATM each payday for food, fuel, and fun — using envelopes (thanks, Dave Ramsey). So I have no need to write paper checks (which are costly) or swipe my debit card. I therefore have no need to wait for pending transactions to clear.
None of my bank accounts charge me a fee of any kind, so I’m well organized and am saving money.
loading....
Please check out our solution at http://www.pixily.com. Send us your paper documents and upload your electronic documents as well. Then, you can search ALL of your documents from your secure online account. All text in your documents is searchable and you can also apply multiple labels to them.
loading....
Any updates since this post was written?
loading....
Have you updated your system at all? Are you still pleased with how it is working?
loading....
I absolutely love being paperless! My filing cabinet is down to one half of one drawer for the entire year and that is only for all the one-off payments I have to make. The end of the year process is much smoother now that everything is on my computer. I just have to make sure I back up every week!
loading....
It looks like some of the issues you are encountering when you file could be solved by using software to keep track of your files. You can try The Paper Tiger Filing System to help you better keep track of your files. Give it a try! We are a BBB A-Rated business and are always looking for ways to help people file!
loading....
Good article. Interesting that I also scan all my documents. In fact I’ve all my cheques and bank statements dated back to 1986. Yes, it took me a while to scan everything.
My actual bank statements and cheque images are available to me at my RBC Internet banking site in PDF format, so I just have to download them to my ccomputer every month.
Now you may also want to protect all these files on your computer and for that I would recommend TrueCrypt, which is an open source app, which can encrypt your whole HD or create TrueCrypt drives.
But don’t forget your password or you data will be lost forever.
http://www.truecrypt.org/
cheers..
loading....