This American Life: Something for Nothing
Sunday, 31st August 2008 (by J.D.)This article is about Funny Money, Odds and Ends, Real-Life
Kris called me down to the kitchen this morning to listen to This American Life. While she baked a molasses cake and canned applesauce, I sat at the table and took notes on the show, which featured four stories about people trying to get something for nothing.
Hands on a hard body
The first story was about a “free” truck. Each year, a car dealership in Longview, Texas gives away a vehicle in a one-of-a-kind contest. Twenty-four people stand around a pickup truck, touching it with at least one hand. They continue to touch the truck for a very long time. For days. The last person left touching the truck gets to drive it home. Sounds easy, huh? It’s not.
“What happens is you go slowly insane,” says contestant Benny Perkins, a past winner. “When you deprive your brain of rest, you start going slowly crazy.” He talks about hallucinations, about exhilaration, about the strain placed on the mind.
This contest, which is no longer run, was the subject of the documentary film, Hands on a Hard Body.
Guinea pig zero
I recently wrote about my experience earning $120 for an hour of medical research. I suggested this might be a way for people to pick up extra cash. Apparently there are people who do this regularly.
Host Ira Glass interviews Bob Helms, the editor of Guinea Pig Zero, “an occupational jobzine for people who are used as medical or pharmaceutical research subjects.” Glass and Helms talk about people who “sell” their bodies and minds to science for medical research.
“Do you feel this is easy money?” Glass asks.
“Yes,” says Helms. “Ideally, that’s all it is: it’s easy money…But you need to realize you’re taking a risk.” Sometimes you’re doing something very painful and getting little in return. You might get $100 to allow a spinal tap, for example.
“You’re not going to get rich,” Helms notes. “You could do it for a living if your expenses are very low, [or] if you have another income.”
Tao of the dumpster
In the show’s third part, writer Dirk Jamison describes how his father discovered the joy of dumpster-diving during the mid-1970s. After (more-or-less intentionally) losing his job, Jamison’s father decided trash-hunting was a way to get something for nothing: a way to feed his family without money.
Jamison’s father has a philosophy that I’ll bet many GRS readers will identify with, though his approach to it is different from what most of us would choose. And it’s definitely different from his wife’s — his dumpster-diving becomes indicative of deeper problems in his marriage and other relationships. Ultimately, this is a cautionary tale about taking anything to an extreme.
(This story reminds me of modern-day freegans, who mostly live normal lives, but scavenge for discarded food.)
Another success story
Ira Glass says that the classic story about something for nothing is actually about the price that you pay once you’ve obtained success. The show’s final story is about Roger, a man who travels from New York to Hollywood to find his fortune.
When he stumbles upon a high-paying job, he transforms himself from a down-on-his-luck bohemian to a Walt Disney imagineer. He’s living a dream-life. But then his luck turns. After five years of success, he loses his job, and he returns to the life he had before. And he’s happier for it.
Something for nothing
Ultimately, each of these stories demonstrates that there’s no thing as something for nothing — everything comes with a price. This episode was originally broadcast in May 1997, but the stories are just as interesting now. This stuff never gets old.


August 31st, 2008 at 10:18 pm
Your article is making me think … I am working towards building my Internet Entrepreneurship so I don’t have to do traditional 9 - 5 anymore. When I reach that, there must be something I will be missing (of 9-5 job). What that will be? Perhaps daily hustle and bustle, or meeting my friends at work. Because everything comes with a price.
A Dawn Journal
http://www.adawnjournal.com
August 31st, 2008 at 10:57 pm
A. Dawn, your comment rings very true to me. Since quitting my day job to blog full time, I’ve come to realize that while this makes me happy, it’s not without a price. Don’t get me wrong — I love writing this site — but it’s not the same as when it was just something I did in my spare time.
September 1st, 2008 at 12:21 am
Yuk,
I would never let anyone spinal tap me for $100
Screw that, Ide rather keep my body intact and not become the result of some science experiment gone wrong. I’ll stick to blogging thank you very much
September 1st, 2008 at 1:21 am
Good grief. The truck thing was also in “The Safety of Objects” by AM Homes.
September 1st, 2008 at 1:30 am
I had a spinal tap as a kid to be tested for meningitis (on my birthday, no less.) I still remember that it was one of the most excruciatingly painful experiences I have ever been through. I have to think that those who agree to have one for $100 are either hopelessly ignorant or insane and desperate. I wouldn’t wish it on anyone.
-Erica
September 1st, 2008 at 2:12 am
There is no such thing as free, they are giving you money, a prize or your paycheck because you are giving away something, a service, your expertise, your time or personal information. Whatever you give is of more value than the item given for free.
My favorite “free” is the 15% off I get if I open a store credit card that charges 30% or more interest on my purchases. We all know we promise to pay off the credit card before the end of the month so as not to incur the charges but who does?
Whenever I come across a free offer I look more than twice before I accept.
Thanks for a great post.
-Tabs
September 1st, 2008 at 3:23 am
I have a good friend that regularly volunteers for medical tests to make some extra cash. He once described to me an experiment that you was going to participate in that would require him to lie still for several hours with a spinal tap and a catheter. For this he would be paid a few hundred dollars. Not worth it in my book.
What I found even more interesting was that he said that he regularly saw the same volunteers over and over at different medical tests. To the best of his knowledge, there were no studies showing whether or not using the same human guinea pigs over and over would eventually cause problems with the data.
RDS
http://financialvalues.blogspot.com/
September 1st, 2008 at 5:35 am
I used to do drug studies. I loved it, although it was a time consuming side gig for money. It was perfect for those summers in between college, as my hours at work were scarce and I had plenty of time on my hands.
I never did anything so crazy as getting a spinal tap, and i never had a catheter. I did one on Birth Control, Cholesterol Meds, and there was one other I don’t remember.
But, overall I made close to $4000 from 3 different studies I participated in, and 2 or 3 more that I tested for but didn’t qualify. Since this was through a pharmaceutical company, they kept very close contact with us for side effects and such. It was a good experience, and if I could, I’d do it again.
September 1st, 2008 at 7:19 am
This article is exactly why I don’t watch TV anymore.
September 1st, 2008 at 7:23 am
As someone alive only because of modern medicine, I’m very grateful to those who volunteer for medical tests and to those who get paid to do so. Certainly, this is better than when prisoners were coerced into becoming test subjects.
There have also been questions raised about how some western companies go to third-world countries and pay very small amounts to test out medications, which also seems like an ill-use of the idea of market-based, for profit, research. I’ll stop now before becoming completely political about this.
September 1st, 2008 at 8:38 am
It is amazing how much of a bad name “work” has gotten. People will do everything to avoid work. We need to change that perception and understand that work is a good thing. You are able to give, contribute, and be, because you work. Your work is what makes you who you are. That doesn’t mean you need to have a job, especially a job you don’t like; you can be an entrepreneur and work from home like many on this blog. You will still work. You will still give, contribute and make a difference because of what you do. Life is not about free, it is about meaningful contribution through what you do (your work)!
The Success Professor
http://www.successprofessor.ca
September 1st, 2008 at 8:47 am
I did volunteer to take a med while they monitored my bone density. It lasted for several months (being tested once per week). I was paid very well and never knew if I got the placebo or the real thing. It was a very well conducted study and I received $3,000 for my part.
September 1st, 2008 at 10:08 am
A MUCH safer and easier way of making money doing a similar thing is to participate in focus groups. I did this several times a few years ago when money was even tighter than it is now. I generally received $50-100 to sit in a room with several other people and give my opinion about fast food advertising, trade colleges, etc. You can usually find these listed under the “etc” or “gigs” sections of your local Craigslist.
September 1st, 2008 at 10:45 am
That documentary is terrific. My husband and I still quote a line to each other: “If you can’t play with the big dogs, you’d better get back up on the porch. With the puppehs.”
I did psychology research for money during college. The most lucrative was a series of tests of voice-imitation computers. They were so awful, you could barely understand anything. I think of that research all the time, when computers call us on the phone.
And I still miss my beautiful suede jacket I found in a dumpster - mint condition, just needed cleaning. I wore it out over 10 years.
September 1st, 2008 at 3:45 pm
I do appreciate people who participate in medical research. It’s too risky for my taste though, but I do appreciate people taking risk.
Drug studies seem safe, but there was a really bad experience in England not that long ago when volunteers died. I googled for spinal tap risks and saw meningitis, injury to a disk in your spine, damage to the spinal cord, etc. All rare, but it’s one thing if you are sick and really need the test and quite another if you are healthy. Not for me. Do admire people who do it, though.
September 1st, 2008 at 4:54 pm
Another great episode of “This American Life” is the one where they interview Edward Ugel who offered up-front cash to lottery winners in lieu of annual payments. Some would say the lottery is almost like getting something for nothing.
September 1st, 2008 at 5:48 pm
@ Success Professor:
For the record, i did drug studies, worked at a cheapo motel, worked at a bookstore, and took classes, simultaneously. I was not using drug studies as a way to avoid work, I used drug studies as a way to afford college.
Many of the people I knew participating weren’t doing it instead of work, but in addition to. They did this to pay for home additions/renovations/down payments, family vacations, debt, and so forth. I don’t think I could have lived off of $1000 for every 3 months, but it did allow me to afford a class or two that wasn’t funded by student loans.
September 2nd, 2008 at 5:01 am
The truck stunt was featured on an episode of That 70’s Show. I believe it came down to Kelso and another guy, who had a *ahem* pee-bottle taped to his leg so that he would not have to leave to use the bathroom.
Also, I think that a similar stunt was done on the Drew Carey show, but contestants were forced to sit in the vehicle the whole time. Sounds easy, right? Maybe, until you think about how sore most people are after sitting in an office chair for just 8 hours. Think about 16-24 hours of that!
Stupidity, all around.
September 3rd, 2008 at 11:49 pm
My husband participated in some medical studies in college so he could afford to eat more than ramen (he had a regular job in a biochemistry lab, but it didn’t pay well enough to cover “real” food when he started there). I think the only part he didn’t think was worth the money was the prostate biopsy.
September 4th, 2008 at 5:03 pm
Get a 2nd job or income. I got a 2nd job 17 years ago, working about 10 hours per week extra. It is a consulting job averaging about $40.00 per hour. My hours are very flexible. I usually work a couple of hours a night on weekdays only.It has given me about $19k of extra cash every year. I have made over $300k in extra money in the last 17 years. I have never spent this extra money. I have tracked every dime I have made. I have invested it in stocks that raise dividends every year. My cash flow is great now. What did I give up? Well, I have watched no stupid sitcom TV shows in 17 years. I have never seen American Idol or Dancing with the Has Beens. I am not familiar with any of those shows. I hear people talking about those shows during the workday at my day job. I basically gave up nothing and set myself up with financial independence.