This is a guest post from Tim Clark, who writes about money and meaning at Soul Shelter.
Have you ever wondered whether you’re an entrepreneurial “type” of person?
It would seem easy enough to find out: The internet is rife with quizzes promising to assess your “entrepreneur-ability” in terms of personality, skills, experience, and background.
But watch out! Many such tests are nonsense. They’re based on folk wisdom, and lack any basis in rigorous research.
So here’s a reliable true/false quiz to test whether you match the typical profile of an entrepreneur. I adapted these questions from a comprehensive new study of entrepreneurship completed earlier this year by Professor Scott A. Shane (on which more later). In this quiz, the word “entrepreneur” is defined as someone starting a new business of any kind, and includes the solo self-employed.
The Entrepreneurial “Type” Quiz
Answer each question TRUE or FALSE.
- People who become entrepreneurs generally share similar psychological profiles such as being leaders, risk-takers, or adventurous.
- Most entrepreneurs are under 40 years of age.
- Among entrepreneurs, people with strong networking skills outnumber “lone wolfs”.
- College-educated people are less likely to become entrepreneurs.
- The desire to make money is the most common reason why people become entrepreneurs.
- Working for someone else decreases the chances that a person will become an entrepreneur.
- Immigrants are more likely than non-immigrants to become entrepreneurs.
- Most entrepreneurs work in technology, software, and other high growth sectors rather than in mature industries.
Ready for the answers? Easy enough — all of the statements are FALSE. Here are details:
- People who become entrepreneurs generally share similar psychological profiles such as being leaders, risk-takers, or adventurous. FALSE: As a group, entrepreneurs show no consistent or characteristic psychological profiles. For every study concluding that entrepreneurs are adventurous risk-takers, another finds they are timid risk-avoiders.
- Most entrepreneurs are under 40 years of age. FALSE: More than 60% of business owners and more than 54% of self-employed workers in the U.S. are 45 years old or older.
- Among entrepreneurs, people with strong networking skills outnumber “lone wolfs”. FALSE: Compared to salaried employees, entrepreneurs have fewer mentors and get less help from other people.
- College-educated people are less likely to become entrepreneurs. FALSE: College education (though not necessarily graduation) is more common among entrepreneurs.
- The desire to make money is the most common reason why people become entrepreneurs. FALSE: The most common reason for becoming an entrepreneur is the wish to avoid working for others. In fact, most entrepreneurs earn less than they would in comparable salaried jobs.
- Working for someone else decreases the chances that a person will become an entrepreneur. FALSE: Experience as a salaried employee increases the probability that someone will become an entrepreneur.
- Immigrants are more likely than non-immigrants to become entrepreneurs. FALSE: Immigrants are no more likely than their non-immigrant compatriots to start their own businesses.
- Most entrepreneurs work in technology, software, and other high growth sectors rather than in mature industries. FALSE: Worldwide, the overwhelming majority of entrepreneurs work in mature, mundane industries such as food service and insurance. Relatively few entrepreneurs work in innovative or high-growth sectors.
Here’s the bottom line: If you’re an over-40, married, college-educated white male with ten years experience in a mature industry, you most closely match the profile of the typical entrepreneur in the United States today.
Pretty uninspiring, huh? The reality behind received wisdom often is.
The good news is that these facts say nothing about the vast individual differences between people, or your particular aptitude or appetite for entrepreneurship.
Remember, this is all based on plain, boring demographics that happen to add up to a counter-intuitive profile of entrepreneurs (again, where “entrepreneur” is defined as including all self-employed people). I compiled this quiz from an extremely readable book by Professor Scott A. Shane entitled The Illusions of Entrepreneurship: The Costly Myths That Entrepreneurs, Investors, and Policy Makers Live By.
Here’s my takeaway: Forget the web quizzes. Read my entrepreneurship primer, sit down with a double espresso, and start planning your own entrepreneurial venture — regardless of your “type”.
This article is about Entrepreneurship Sunday, 26th October 2008 (by J.D. Roth)


RSS Feeds
Facebook
GRS Twitter







October 26th, 2008 at 8:24 am
“If you’re an over-40, married, college-educated white male with ten years experience in a mature industry”
White ?? I thought “Immigrants are no more likely than their non-immigrant compatriots to start their own businesses.” Which means the color of one’s skin does not matter ?
October 26th, 2008 at 8:27 am
Mr Chiot’s and I are entrepreneurs. We started our own business 4 years ago when we were 26 (and before that we had several small side businesses). We are both college educated (bachelor’s degrees). Our business is a small productions company, we make corporate videos, commercials, film weddings, and build and maintain websites. I guess we don’t fit the typical entrepreneurial type.
My parents always instilled the entrepreneurial spirit in me. I started my first business when I was in grade school. I had a very successful popsicle & chocolate business. My parents gave me seed money, but after that all expenses came out of earnings and I had to donate at least 10% to charity and save 25%, the rest I could spend on toys of whatever I wanted (or more supplies to grow my business). I had such a successful business that a lady on my street tried to start a similar business as a work from home job (I beat here out, my popsicles were better). I eventually had such a large business I had to have my own freezer in the garage. I made great money and saved most of it. I’m thankful for all the lessons they taught me, they have been more valuable than any other education I have received.
October 26th, 2008 at 9:01 am
Great post. Shows some common myths about entrepreneurs are wrong such as number 1, 2, and number 3. I would like to mention one article I wrote about Internet entrepreneurship - Do Not Quit Your Job Right After Reading This Article - http://adawnjournal.com/2008/05/25/do-not-quit-your-job-right-after-reading-this-article/
Cheers,
A Dawn Journal
http://www.adawnjournal.com
October 26th, 2008 at 9:15 am
Great observations. After 15 years of working with entrepreneurs, I agree that there’s no real “profile” that equates to self employment. I’ve seen all sorts of people start and run businesses.
I’m intrigued by the statement that entrepreneurs are less likely to have mentors. My understanding is that successful business owners are more likely than other business owners to have great mentors, support networks, advisors and so on. In fact, I just read a research report on this.
October 26th, 2008 at 9:24 am
There is no greater time to be an entrepreneur than now. The job market is on the decline and major corporations have been reducing their employees to cut company cost. By being an entrepreneur allows you the ability to make as much money as you want.
October 26th, 2008 at 10:02 am
Totally agree with Donny. Entrepreneurs, specially Internet entrepreneurs are recession proof. Darren had a nice piece on this - 13 Tips to Recession Proof Your Blog http://www.problogger.net/archives/2008/10/16/13-tips-to-recession-proof-your-blog/ Darren is the one who pioneered money making in blogging. Follow the link I mentioned under comment 3 to know more about this.
Cheers,
A Dawn Journal
http://www.adawnjournal.com
October 26th, 2008 at 4:20 pm
The stat that most entrepreneurs are over 40 seems a bit misleading — presumably many of them have been entrepreneurs since they were a lot younger. I’d be more interested to hear the average age people are when they START their entrepreneurial careers!
October 26th, 2008 at 6:34 pm
This post illustrates some things I’ve felt about business ownership for quite some time. In my case, I got off to a decent start as an employee and was frequently complimented for being a hard worker, but then I got out into the civilian world and the corporate world–my first experiences had been in a mom ‘n’ pop business and then the military–and I discovered I had a major aversion to workplace drama, customer drama (i.e., customers inventing problems where there had been none previously–trust me, a vocal minority do this), power trips, and other assorted fun stuff. This led to me creating a rather checkered, bounce-around job history for myself. I’m not proud of it, it is what it is.
But the end result is that between that and taking four years and counting away from the workforce, and now being a single mom to boot, the employment deck is seriously stacked against me. Again, it is what it is. So, for me, figuring out what to do for self-employment is as much about not being *able* to find a job as it is about not *wanting* to work for someone else.
Now, I’m not going to go as far as some of the other commenters here and claim that you can make “as much money as you want” in self-employment. You can sure WORK as much as you want, but in the end you have no ultimate control over whether someone purchases your product or service. Still, there is something to be said for knowing you’d hire yourself even if nobody else wants to. In fact this is probably one explanation for why there are so many independent businesses in minority neighborhoods.
October 26th, 2008 at 7:36 pm
Only recently did I realize that I’m an entrepreneur of sorts. I never really framed it that way, but besides some part-time work I do for other people I really do run my own tiny company. It makes up more than half of my income.
And you’re right, it’s not for the money. Nor am I a risk-taker or adventurous person in most areas of my life. In fact, I think eventually I’ll have a salaried job (once I get into the field I want)…but I’ll still work on the side a few hours a month because I get a real kick out of what I do and I love the freedom of it all.
October 26th, 2008 at 9:52 pm
I love it that the cover image of the book you cite at the end of the post is a scan from what’s obviously a library book - a great reminder to borrow rather than buy from Amazon, my source for most book images.
January 26th, 2009 at 8:03 am
I got such a kick out of this quiz!!! I answered all the questions one way, thinking, “I’ll never make it, I’m such a loser.” Then I find out I’m right! {{{{JOY}}}} I love non-cultural-stereotype people and approaches. Maybe I’ve been waiting and needing to open my own business all along. I especially like the “team player/lone wolf comparison”, as I am the Goddess of Lone Wolves (personally, I prefer the term “strongly independent person” to “lone wolf.” )
Teams make me vomit, in all honesty, except in the sports world,where they belong. Teams keep the individual, strong-minded person down, while worshipping the mediocre, average accomplishment as the alpha-achievement. Some people do well with them, but many are sacrificed so that “the team” will suceed, usually with one shining star (NOT very TEAM, if you ask me). Anyway, I feel much better—I feel VINDICATED. Networking gives me hives, and it is so hypocritical and full of crap. Look for the BEST PRODUCT and the BEST PERSON for the job, not a friend of so-and-so’s that you met at a mommy and me brunch or in the locker room. Look for referrals from fellow business people and those in your field of expertise and then make up your own mind on what would be the BEST for YOU and your PRODUCT. Anyway, that’s not what I see out in the world today. Happy to know there is still hope for me out there in mediocre-ville. Viva la Small Business! It’s what the Repubs should be working on instead of all this whiny social crap.
“The business of America is Business” (Calvin Coolidge, US President, 1920s). What will save America and save our economy is the small businessperson. So why aren’t the Repubs getting off their butts and doing something about this instead of whining about social issues. This party (BTW, in true “Lone-wolf” fashion, I am non-party affiliated) has a PRIME opportunity to make sound economic growth the cornorstone of its policies for the next 100 years, and all it does is whine about social “issues”, which are nobody’s bloody business to begin with. If you need to pull this, JD, as I know you are non-committal about politics, I will understand, but Geesh! I look at this country’s “economic downturn” and I see OPPORTUNITY. You’d think some political party would get it, wouldn’t you??