All You Ever Wanted to Know About Emergency Funds (But Were Afraid to Ask)
Wednesday, 19th November 2008 (by J.D.)This article is about Basics, Planning
This is a guest post from Dylan Ross. Dylan is a long-time member of the Get Rich Slowly community: a frequent commenter and occasional guest author. He’s also a Certified Financial Planner. This article is an abridged version of a chapter Dylan contributed to Investing in an Uncertain Economy for Dummies, which was recently published by Wiley. See the end of this post for a chance to win a copy.
Even if you’ve never had to quickly come up with money for something you weren’t expecting, you always face the possibility of needing money in an emergency. Emergencies are unplanned expenses that require more money than you can cover with your paycheck, even if you cut some expenses until next payday. When you don’t have enough in savings, emergencies can put you in debt or deeper in debt. An emergency fund helps protect your finances.
Unexpected expenses may be one-time or recurring. Potential uses for emergency funds include car repairs, paying bills if you’re out of work, large medical costs, insurance deductibles, critical home repairs, legal defenses, travel to attend a funeral, natural disasters, and so on.
Figure how much to set aside
At an absolute minimum, set aside enough money in your emergency fund to pay for at least three to six months of basic living expenses (the regular and essential expenses you must pay to live). These expenses don’t include discretionary items like entertainment, dining out, or spa treatments. Keep at least six months of basic living expenses in your emergency fund if you’re single or living on one income, or if one income in your two-income household varies a lot from month to month or isn’t secure.
Your emergency fund does more than just cover expenses in case you lose your job, so resist the temptation to keep less in savings. If you anticipate more frequent or more severe emergencies than three to six months of basic living expenses can cover, increase the size of your emergency fund. For example, you may need a larger emergency fund if:
- Your job security is questionable.
- You’re about to have a baby or purchase a new home.
- You have numerous aging household appliances.
- You drive an older car.
- You live in an area prone to severe weather, earthquakes, or other disasters.
- You engage in activities that may require frequent trips to the emergency room, doctor’s office, or the first aid aisle of your pharmacy.
Your emergency fund is also handy when you need to make insurance co-payments or pay for charges not covered by a health, dental, or vision plan. Sometimes you may need cash until you’re reimbursed by an insurance company or flexible spending account. Consider any unreimbursed medical expenses from the past few years when deciding whether to increase your emergency fund.
If you’re feeling especially uncertain, add to the size of your emergency fund. You can always reduce it after you’re through a rough patch.
Handle your emergency fund with care
The tricky thing about financial emergencies is that you don’t know what they’ll be, when they’ll happen, or how much you’ll need in order to cope until you can recover. All these unknowns make your emergency fund an important part of your financial profile and one that you should treat with special attention and care.
Make your emergency fund a high priority. The harder you think it is to come up with money for an emergency fund, the more you need one. If coming up with money to start an emergency fund now will be a sacrifice, imagine how tough it will be when you have to pay the costs of an emergency situation.
If you’re trying to pay off credit cards or high-interest loans, start with an emergency fund that could cover one month of basic living expenses. After you save one month of expenses, put extra money toward your debt payments. When your debt is paid off, build your emergency fund as quickly as possible. Otherwise, a sudden emergency could send you right back into the red.
Keep your emergency fund in cash types of investments. This money should be quickly available with no risk of decreasing in value at any time. An emergency fund is self-insurance, not an investment. You want your money to be accessible, but you also want to earn some interest on it so that you offset inflation at least partially, if not completely.
Some places to keep your emergency fund savings include:
- High-yielding direct savings accounts. Online savings accounts often pay a higher than average interest rate. You can, and should, establish an electronic transfer link to your checking account.
- Savings and money market accounts. These are interest-bearing accounts at banks or credit unions. Being able to electronically transfer money to your checking account is best.
- Money market funds. Not to be confused with money market accounts, these are funds offered by mutual fund companies and brokerage firms. You redeem fund shares to get cash out. Some accounts allow you to write checks to access the cash.
- Interest-bearing checking accounts. These accounts pay less interest than savings accounts.
- Certificates of deposit (CDs). These banking deposits guarantee a specific interest rate if you hold them for a specified period of time. They aren’t an ideal place to keep your emergency fund money because you usually have to pay a penalty to get your money out early.
When deciding where to keep your emergency funds, make sure you know how and when you can access your cash. Can you get to your money after business hours? What about on weekends and holidays? Can you use checks, an ATM, or a debit or check card? Also, make sure you’re comfortable with whether or not the account is insured.
Don’t use available credit as an emergency fund! Credit cards and home equity lines of credit could serve as a backup to your emergency funds in the event of a catastrophe, but the whole idea of an emergency fund is to keep you form adding debt. Some emergencies could affect your ability to make minimum debt payments, and missed payments, late penalties, and finance charges can easily snowball out of control.
Use your fund wisely when the time comes
Sooner or later you’ll have a large, unexpected expense you can’t cover with your paycheck. First, decide whether it’s a real emergency. Do you need to spend the money right now? Can you make do until you can save up to meet the expense? Your answer may be influenced by other events. For example, if your dishwasher bites the dust, you may decide to save up for a new one while you hand-wash dishes because of layoff rumors at work.
When you face a real emergency, access only the minimum amount of money necessary to get you through the emergency. Cut any unnecessary expenses and direct any available income toward your emergency before accessing the emergency fund. When the emergency is over, rebuild your emergency fund as quickly as possible, before reinstating nonessential expenses.
Two book giveaways in one week! Strange, but true. This time I’m giving away two copies of Investing in an Uncertain Economy for Dummies. To qualify, you must leave a substantive comment discussing your approach to emergency funds. I’ll randomly select two five winners on Friday. Motorcrash image by Incase Designs.


November 19th, 2008 at 5:16 am
I just learned the hard way the need for an emergency fund. My significant other, an otherwise completely healthy 27 year-old, just had to have an apendectomy, while between jobs and between health insurance plans. When it rains, it pours!!
Thankfully, we do have a fairly well-padded emergency fund, and will probably be able to take this in stride!
November 19th, 2008 at 5:16 am
Great post! I think the tip about not using credit for an emergency fund is especially important. Too often we think of credit as “available cash” when it is really loan. While I have an emergency card for tight spots (especially when I’m away from home), I immediately pay it back with money from the emergency fund. Then start to build that fund back up.
November 19th, 2008 at 5:22 am
I think it’s best to pay off credit card debt first. I view having credit card debt as an emergency. Why save 3-4% when you can pay off debt that could equal ~20%. Calculate the interest rates of the debt and the guaranteed savings; and go from there. I like having a goal for my emergency fund. My emergency fund serves as a place to buy a new (or used) car. When I can afford to buy a car I want, then I have reached my threshold for the emergency fund. The remaining savings goes into lowest cost index funds. Then when you need a car, you buy it with cash; and start the process over again.
November 19th, 2008 at 5:25 am
If I have a maxxed out credit card shouldn’t I focus on removing that before building an emergency fund? That way I pay less interest and in desperate circumstances I can always use the credit card if need be
November 19th, 2008 at 5:27 am
You cannot over state the importance of an emergency fund. This is the pillow that protects you when you fall down.
There’s another interesting result of having a well funded e-fund, a lot of would be emergencies don’t seem that bad any more.
If you’re broke and the muffler falls out of your car, that’s a HUGE DEAL! If you had $10,000 in the bank, that gravitational muffler is reduced to an inconvenience.
Miranda makes a great comment above - credit cards are not the answer. Going into debt to pay for an emergency only compounds the problem. I would only suggest that she use high interest account with a debit card to replace her ‘emergency card’. Then you avoid the chance (however unlikely) that the bill doesn’t get paid, or is late, etc.
November 19th, 2008 at 5:37 am
In our emergency fund, we saved three months expenses because we knew a layoff from our company included at least a three month severence. Now we are getting to use it as my husband was laid off!
I will say it would have been better not to count on the severence for two reasons. First, it took about a month to receive it. Second, the taxes taken out reduced it by about 1/3.
A larger emergency fund would also have been better because we are in Michigan. In this economy, Michigan doesn’t have many businesses hiring, and other businesses are very competitive to get into. IE there’s a LOT of people applying, and they don’t need to pay as much or offer moving packages. A larger emergency fund gives you the freedom to move when you’ve lost equity in the house and need some towards a down payment for a house in a new location.
Fortunately for us, it looks like he’ll be accepting a new position in this area. So that severence payment will be added to our somewhat diminished emergency fund!
November 19th, 2008 at 5:41 am
I’ll go even further with the idea of an emergency fund. In conjuction with the emergency fund, there should be a plan of essentials and non-essentials expenses.
Depending on the type of crisis, the focus may not be on financials. If the crisis is taking an emotional toll on the family, adding the negotiations of essential versus nonessential expenses may result in no action or added stress.
November 19th, 2008 at 5:51 am
I’d like to add having some cash at home for emergencies i.e, locksmith; superintendent; groceries and prescriptions. backup prescriptions would be good too especially during travel.
November 19th, 2008 at 5:51 am
It’s important to separate your emergency fund from other savings you may have. In my case, I have separate accounts to save for for yearly/semi-yearly bills, home improvements, Christmas presents, etc. But all of those accounts are distinct from my emergency account.
I used to put all my savings in one slush account but it didn’t work out. It was too easy to spend the emergency money for vacations or new toys.
November 19th, 2008 at 5:52 am
I cannot stress one point enough from Dylan’s advice: having 27/7/365 access to the emergency funds is vital. Many online banks do not provide ATM access to the funds, thereby limiting their effectiveness as true emergency funds. I can say with 100% certainty that HSBC Direct does offer such a service (as I have an ATM card that is linked to my account).
@Ryan: If you have nothing saved for emergencies, then I would reccomend concentrate on doing both. While it is important to pay down debt, it is also just as important to build savings, particularly an emergency fund. There are no clear “rules” per se, just differing viewpoints. I am a believer, and tell my clients as well, that you should never have all of your money focused on any one specific goal. It is important to be well balanced, which means that not all of one’s monies should go exclusively to paying down debt, investing, saving, etc….it should be spread out with the emphasis on the most pressing issue. Depending on your specific situation you may want to figure what may be the best split for you (80% toward debt & 20% toward emergency fund for a loose example). Also please have a look at my blog post, Be wary of advice from forums and blogs regarding taking advice from blogs and forums at face value.
November 19th, 2008 at 5:52 am
There’s an additional disadvantage to using a credit card or HELOC as your emergency fund: you don’t have control over that money. Just ask the people who had their HELOC access cut off because they were laid off. So much for using the HELOC as a backup for unemployment!
Ryan: some credit card companies have begun “following down” as people pay off their cards. For example, say you have a $3000 credit limit and $2800 in debt. Pay off $400, and your debt is $2400… and they lower your credit limit to $2600. You still only have $200 in available credit, even though your balance is lower.
You can’t count on having that available credit after you’ve made a payment, because you can’t guarantee that your credit card company will keep your limit where it currently is.
November 19th, 2008 at 5:52 am
Mr. McLean, poster #3, NO! Build up that emergency fund first. That will help keep you from having desperate circumstances. A maxed out credit card is not an emergency, it’s usually buying too much crap or needing to work harder and earn more. Believe me, it’s a much better life when you live debt free. It’s not easy at first during the learning phase but it gets better as you persist.
November 19th, 2008 at 5:52 am
I keep two emergency funds–one for car repairs etc. which is in a money market fund and one for “unemployment insurance” which is in laddered 6-month Treasury bills (CDs would work as well). I have six bills in the same amount (which I’ve increased gradually) and automatically buy one every month (I keep money in my savings account so I have enough to buy the new one even if the old one hasn’t matured yet). All I have to do is cancel the buy order and I have a monthly income for six months (or cut it in half and have a low monthly income for a year). The interest rate isn’t great, but of course it beats the -30% or so my equities are earning right now.
November 19th, 2008 at 5:53 am
I take the paranoid route to emergency funds. I like to have what I call my “rainy day fund” with 6 months of expenses. I do everything possible to protect this fund. The only time I would ever deduct from this fund would be the result of a dire situation such as the loss of a job.
To protect my “rainy day fund” I have created additonal emergency funds that are more focused and smaller in value to protect me from the more likely problems I will encounter from day to day. I have a car fund, house fund, and HSA fund. These funds have < 5000 in each of them and will cover most repairs that may arise from problems with my house, cars, or health.
November 19th, 2008 at 5:54 am
CD Ladders are an excellent method to earn a decent amount of interest on your emergency fund. I would suggest building up a 6 month stash in a high-yield savings account (a la ING Direct) and then proceed to keep it in a rotation that allows for you to have 2 months worth of savings liquid while everything else is maturing.
@Ryan McLean: IMO, an emergency fund should be one of the first things you do before you try to tackle debt. While you should continue to make timely monthly payments, I would suggest that you save up at least $1000 to hedge against future emergencies. Using your credit card for emergencies is an assured way to discourage you on your trek towards eliminating debt–but having some backup savings will keep you on track and give you a better sense of security in your efforts.
Make your emergency savings + continued monthly payments first, then focus all your efforts on paying down your debt.
November 19th, 2008 at 6:00 am
My previous approach to an emergency fund had been to not have one. I thought I could use credit cards in case something came up.
But now with the shaky economy, and layoffs in the national media, it’s become a priority for me. I could sleep much better at night knowing I had 3-6 months of living expenses just in case something happened. I hate the thought that if I lost my job, I wouldn’t be able to pay bills (especially my mortgage) until I could find/start somewhere else.
November 19th, 2008 at 6:02 am
I agree completely with the need for an emergency fund.
Ours came in useful last year when my father-in-law fell ill.The only trans-atlantic flights available at short notice were business class. Having the fund meant we could go home without having to make the difficult choice of money vs. Family.
November 19th, 2008 at 6:04 am
I have a two-tiered “emergency fund”, and that system has really worked well for me so far. I keep $2,000 in a savings account with my primary “bricks and mortar” bank, and I can access that part of the fund with my ATM card, or transfer it (online) to my primary chcking. I can use that part of the fund to write checks for more immediate emergencies, like expensive repairs to my 8 year old truck or taking a trip to the Emergency Room (both of which happened this year).
The down-side to that easy accessibility is the low interest rate I get on my savings (a fraction of a percent per year). Since I now support a live-in fiancee (who is currently job hunting) and a mortgage, my “six months” number has increased. It would be nice if that money could make money, right? For that, I have an online, FDIC-insured “high yield savings account” that now pays 3% (though it has been as high as 5.75%, back when it was opened). It can take as long as 5 business days to transfer money to my primary checking, though in practice, it has never taken longer than 2, but at least I can put the larger chunk of my “emergency fund” to work. I also use this account for long-term and automatic savings, though I guess that’s a comment for another blog.
November 19th, 2008 at 6:07 am
An emergency fund is great. It helped us out several times. But the one comment is that every time I hear six months of expenses, I think it is impossible. People who do not have a fund should start with a smaller goal so they have a “more realistic goal”, like enough to pay a $500.00 car repari bill. Once that is saved up then think about the dollar value of a month’s worth of food added to the fund.
Here is why I say this. Back in 2005 I had an emergency fund of about 2 months living expenses. Then the shoes fell both at the same time. I was left go from my job. My wife was not working due to a health problem. Then two days after I lost my job, she found out she needed surgery. We had to keep her insurance under COBRA for the next 18 months. Yes very expensive. So out came the credit cards to pay for it.
Fast forward to 2008. My wife’s medical condition is still a problem. She is applying for social security disability. The company I now work for is up for sale. So in as little as six months I could be out of work again.
We were rebuilding an emergency fund but each time my wife needed a perscription or had another doctor’s bill it got wiped out. Our fund is now $600.00 but we have enough medical bills to wipe that out today.
The credit card debt we incurred in 2005 is about the same. We have been trying to pay it off but just when it starts to look better another medical bill is there.
Right now my wife is waiting for her appeal hearing for SS Disability. The wait could be a year or more we have been told by her attorney. She may have to go back to work to help pay off some bills but then she automatically loses her disability status. So she would have to apply again.
The future does not look brite but we keep trying to get an emergency fund. The $600 would pay for a car repair. Now we have to make that equal one months mortgage with escrow. It may take us a while but we will get there. In the meantime we just keep trying to Get Ahead in Life.
November 19th, 2008 at 6:19 am
This year is the first time I’ve ever saved for an emergency fund. Anything I’d ever saved before was for something specific, like a car, or Christmas, but just to keep from getting fees from my bank. Right now I have three months worth saved, but my sinking funds (I have an older car) need help right now. I’ve put everything savings-wise in ING. It’s made it a lot easier for me to maneuver and manage as I change my mind periodically on strategy (what kinds of funds I need). I’ve only been saving this way for six months. Fortunately, I haven’t needed to use it yet.
November 19th, 2008 at 6:21 am
I agree with the need to have 3-6 months of expenses in an emergency fund. My wife and I have been working on building our fund over the last two years in addition to paying the school & auto loans as well as the mortgage.
We have been using an ING savings account for our emergency fund. I like the idea of the laddered CD’s and will look into that. The other suggestion that we have started working on is the self-provided warranty account. This is a great idea to cover you when deciding if you should get the extended warranty.
We are about to find out if our emergency fund is enough to cover us. My wife had to stop work because we are pregnant with twins! Not only will we be missing the income, but we’ll soon have double the expense.
November 19th, 2008 at 6:23 am
Honestly, our approach so far has been not to have an emergency fund. We’ve had such high interest rate debts that we could not really justify having an emergency fund. I do not always think that it makes sense to have an emergency fund if you have debt with high interest rates. Any money you have in a savings account could be going towards the high interest debt. However, we are getting to the point where our high interest debts are almost paid off and will begin savings/emergency fund soon. Exciting!
Momma
Feature Blogger at Engineer A Debt Free Life (lots of money saving and frugal tips)
http://www.engineeradebtfreelife.com
November 19th, 2008 at 6:24 am
I recently had to extract my wisdom teeth and cost me hefty price for it even with my insurance covering. That’s when I start to realizing the value of emergency fund. I consider myself extremely healthy (never had any major surgery, no visit to ER) but I want to protect myself from unexpected event. So I set up an separate online account (ING) to deposit portion of my paycheck bi-weekly. I’ll learn to live without $100/paycheck and that money can come handy when (not if) my car breaks down. Thanks for the post.
November 19th, 2008 at 6:30 am
The article is really helpful. We have been working on an Emergency fund and have been considering a CD, but will probably stick to the Money Market account it is in.
Would it be recommended to have a totally separate account for the Emergency Fund or keep it with Short Term savings?
Also Donna makes a great point about having the essential and non-essential expenses planned out ahead of time, so when something would happen it does not add to the stress.
November 19th, 2008 at 6:31 am
Would a Roth IRA be a smart place to keep an emergency fund? I am 23,single with a student loan (~7% rate) and a car payment(0%). I have a pretty stable job and about 15k sitting in ING savings. So would it be smart to max out Roth for 2008 and 2009 and just have about 5k in online savings? or would it be wise to pay loans down sooner? Thanks
November 19th, 2008 at 6:32 am
I have had an emergency fund for nearly a year now. In fact, I now have three different emergency funds. Here’s how they work…
An “EMERGENCY FUND” for the serious emergencies. The AC/furnace breaks down, a cracked windshield needs to be replaced, a vehicular fender-bender, etc. These are mostly expenses that would be $250+. I started with $1,000 and $50 is added each month–all of which sits in a high-interest savings account. In the event that the EMERGENCY FUND needs to be tapped (not yet, knock on wood) the monthly budget will be adjusted to replace the tapped money.
Next, my “emergency fund” for those small month-to-month “pesky” expenses that are always there. The heating bill is $15 more than expected, the $25 wedding gift that was omitted from the budget, a car tire goes flat and needs to be replaced, etc. These are items under $250. This money is just “set aside” in my checking account and is always kept at $250. In my 8 months of using this method I have had as little as $23 and as much as $185 in one month to use–all of which was replaced the next month.
And finally my “stash” for the “old-fashioned” expenses. The road-side assistant, the small town diner, the taxi cab driver, etc. only takes cash. Generally small expenses that can be paid for by the $80-$100 I have “stashed” in my wallet because another payment method isn’t available (hence the “old-fashioned”).
There it is…a rather lengthy method to describe, but one that I have found to work for me.
November 19th, 2008 at 6:54 am
It is because of this blog that I have made personal finance a priority. Great post! Through this website, my fiance and I enrolled and survived (without strangling each other over our personal finance differences!!) Dave Ramsey’s “Financial Peace University” about two years ago. IT COULD NOT HAVE COME AT A BETTER TIME CONSIDERING EVERYTHING GOING ON IN THE ECONOMY.
If you are going to make the effort to have an emergency fund, you owe it to yourself to make a small investment in a quality personal finance education. That is your best emergency fund. With that, you make better decisions in the beginning to help cushion the effects of the unexpected.
Dave Ramsey mentions if you have debt, you need to first have at least $1000 cash for a beginning emergency fund. Then, you tackle that debt. Eventually you will need a 6 month emergency fund.
For the 6 month fund, I setup in INGDirect Orange Savings account (again, thanks Get Rich Slowly!) and into CD’s to protect against inflation. Since it is an emergency fund, you need to split it up so you have cash available when you need it without getting penalized for taking all of it out early. Invest in 1 year CD’s of $2000 each. Keep the first $2000 in cash in the Orange Savings Account so it is readily available. Believe it or not, the best part of the CD’s is that you will be punished for taking it out early, but not so mcuh if you need the money. That is a great deterrent to taking the money out to go by a nice new boat!!
November 19th, 2008 at 7:01 am
I’ve built up my emergency fund by depositing $x into another bank account that i don’t check very often every time my savings hits $y. this helps me for 2 reasons 1) i won’t spend the money because i don’t carry around the debti card for the other bank and 2) seeing my normal bank account with $y might make me feel a little flush and willing to spend while seeing $(y-x) makes me feel a little more like pinching pennies. but i still keep enough money in bank #1 to pay for normal expenses and the errant fee and i count some of that as part of my emergency fund.
I also think that not having a car means fewer emergencies to plan for.
November 19th, 2008 at 7:04 am
@Z:
A Roth IRA is not a good idea for an emergency fund at all. While it (or some other type of retirement vehicle) should be a part of your overall financial plan, that should be solely for retirement savings. An emergency fund should be liquid, and easily accessible at any time. As for the rest of your question, it would be very difficult to give an informed answer without having your specific financial information (ie: how much your monthly expenditures are vs. net income, revolving debt obligations, etc.).
I would also like to add that I have never believed in using a CD as an emergency fund. It is great for long-term savings, but the facts that it is not liquid, and you incur penalties for early withdrawal make it less than ideal. Even if you are laddering, there is only a 7 day window once the maturity day arrives, so your emergency will have to fall into that period, which as anyone who has ever had an emergency knows is never the case.
November 19th, 2008 at 7:07 am
One of the things I like about the Ramsay approach to debt repayment is that he pays attention to the emotional aspect of it all. Having an emergency fund allows you to pay for an unexpected situation without getting discouraged about your general plan. If you were to use credit for emergencies, you quickly forget why you spent the money, you just have to face that number at the end of each month and it can seem like you not getting ahead. An emergency fund keeps you feeling that you are still in control (as much as you can be) and that you are still moving forward.
November 19th, 2008 at 7:17 am
Personally, I’m not sure why a CD is the lesser option for an emergency fund. I think it should be one of the primary tools. First, it’s the only way you are going to get a good rate. Second, despite the title, very few people need instant access to their emergency funds. So there’s little reason why you couldn’t structure some sort of ladder and be able to work just fine with that. I’m not suggesting all funds should be tied up in CDs. I’m just saying that it is pretty dumb to not earn interest on a sizeable chunk of money that you know isn’t going to be touched unless it is an emergency. Plus, a CD makes it harder. I also have heard some mention the need for quick access. I realize there are some emergencies where you need the money instantly. But for the most part, every online account can transfer funds within 3-5 days. I can count on one hand the number of true emergencies where money is needed faster than that.
Personally, I use multiple emergency funds. A general one with a small amount that is just in a savings account, another one for my house that is in a money market and the main one (my income replacement fund) which ultimately will be in a CD ladder.
November 19th, 2008 at 7:18 am
Without ever calling it an emergency fund, I do actually have one. Being single, therefore having a 1-income household, I have more than 6 nett salaries on an internet account, which can be accessed within a day. A nett salary covers more than basic necessities, so I estimate I could live for 10 months to a year just on my savings. A credit card takes care of immediate payments, which I can refund two days later.
I guess my savings account officially is meant for saving up for big investments or traveling, but in reality I have all I need and I usually save up extra money before traveling. I use the savings account to store the money I don’t spend, basically. No purpose there. Even if I want to invest in a more expensive product, I take enough time to find out if I really need it and during that time save up extra money.
Also, I must explain I come from a country with very good social services: if I get fired or my contract expires, I can get unemployment funds. Everyone has basic health insurance and I have some extra dental work covered. I have insurance for legal assistance. The only thing I don’t have (yet?) is insurance for being disabled and as a result not fit to work. But then I can still fall back on national social security funds. Actually, I’m going to check this weekend what happens to my income should I become severely disabled and maybe reconsider the insurance thing.
This post also reminds me to invest some time in getting a good private pension fund, since I am now only in a collective fund and I am not sure if the social pension program will still be there when I retire. I just put it off because I am still under 30 and will switch from academia to business in 2 years.
So, all in all, I guess I have got short term emergencies covered! Let’s now invest in possible long term adversities.
November 19th, 2008 at 7:20 am
Thanks to you, and the commenters for the great tips. I just (finally) set up a budget where I save 20% of my salary. I’m working on saving 6 months worth of expenses, after which I’ll start saving for a down payment on a house, and car. I’m actually pretty excited about it, which is a little strange!
November 19th, 2008 at 7:21 am
I’ve got a question. . .
Most people suggest various amounts in an emergency fund- 6 months expenses seems to be a commonly suggested amount. What do you do when you hit that level?
My approach to saving for my emergency fund, retirement, and debt down-pay is to limit “fun” expenses to concentrate on these goals. I feel that if I had 6 months expenses saved, I would be pretty comfortable and could focus some of my EF savings towards retirement, or just my own personal fun.
At what point around here do people say, “my EF is well funded, time to use some of that extra cash for a vacation or new tv.”
November 19th, 2008 at 7:24 am
I have a couple of emergency funds. Firstly, my current (checking) account always has a “float”, which allows me to use my debit card for smallish emergencies. If I ever have to top up the float from savings, I make sure that money goes back as soon as possible, because my instant access savings is my main emergency fund. This currently holds about 1 year’s worth of living expenses, because I’m thinking about buying a house, so I’m not tying up funds in things like CDs at the moment. Usually it would be between 3 and 6 months. I don’t worry about having the whole 6 months, because I figure that 3 months would get me over any sudden hump, and if I needed more, I could pull it out of the less accessible savings. If I’m in that much trouble, I’d be prepared to take the interest hit for those withdrawals, but it’s a good way of making me think a few times about touching it.
I do consider my credit card as an emergency fund source. However, this is because I could use the card, and then the delay before I needed to pay it off (in full, obviously) would allow me to pull the money out of the more tied-up savings. So I’m not using the credit as free money, just as an advance on my savings.
November 19th, 2008 at 7:31 am
I’m having trouble deciding whether to bulk up my emergency savings or to fully fund my IRA this year. With the market as low as it is (and a long-term investment horizon), now seems like a great time to be putting money away for retirement. On the other hand, I don’t want to plunder my emergency savings too much.
November 19th, 2008 at 7:35 am
I am on the brink of reaching my emergency savings goal. It is mostly in an online savings account and partially in a checking account. The accounts are electronically linked, and I have transferred funds between them before. But this post makes me concerned - it seems that transfers between my accounts can take 3-5 days until the funds are available. Is this common? Perhaps I need to increase the amount I keep in my checking account (which pains me a little since it is essentially no interest).
November 19th, 2008 at 7:37 am
Several posters have pointed out the risk of using a line of credit as an emergency fund. There has to be a risk vs. reward calculation. Here is the Canadian example:
My mortgage rate is 5.15% fixed. Mortgage interest is not deductible, so the effect of pre-paying the mortgage is a 5.15% tax-free rate of return.
An ING savings account currently pays 3%. Interest in Canada is fully taxed as income at the taxpayer’s marginal rate (in my case around 40%), so the after-tax rate of return is only around 1.8%, and thus below the rate of inflation.
As a result, I have only kept a small emergency fund and pre-paid the mortgage whenever possible, as in doing so I am earning an additional 4% on those funds. Instead, I have a line of credit that I do not use for anything but that could act as an emergency fund if there is ever a job loss. In order to earn an additional 4% risk-free, it is worth to take the risk that one day I might have to borrow money at 7% for a few months.
November 19th, 2008 at 7:43 am
Hmmm, my emergency fund! Gee what does that mean to me???? Let me think!
Honestly, it means to me:
I can go about this would and live my life without having to worry where the money will come from when a TRUE disaster strikes me.
The toughest part is understanding the definition of disaster. That is the key.
November 19th, 2008 at 7:46 am
The key to building an emergency fund (and to savings in general) really comes down to the idea of “pay yourself first.” At the beginning of the month, with my first paycheck, I automatically deduct a set value and put it in the emergency fund (an online high yield savings account). Then, at the end of the month, once I’ve paid rent, utilities, and credit card, I can put the leftovers in the emergency fund too! Double your pleasure!
November 19th, 2008 at 7:48 am
Having an emergency fund is huge. I’ve learned that the hard way since “Murphy” keeps impacting my family. It’s going to rain so you need an umbrella. We have a mini emergency fund and it needs to be larger. It has bailed us out over the past year and anyone who says you don’t need it is crazy.
– Andy
http://www.examiner.com/x-1181-Philadelphia-76ers-Examiner
November 19th, 2008 at 7:48 am
I think once you have some emergency funds set aside, some thought ought to be given to layers of protection. We should all have some cash on hand in case the emergency involves some type of disaster that closes ATM’s, makes processing credit cards impossible, or leaves no time for a bank run. I like having extra canned food, water, and toiletries available and consider them a required layer to an emergency fund as well. For the next layer, consider stashing some cash in a local bricks and mortar account with ready access. Then it becomes time to build layers like CD’s, T-bills, internet accounts, etc., for the larger yield to help beat inflation. While a Roth or I bonds could be part of this, consider the fact they can’t be withdrawn for a period of time without penalty, and in the early deposit period, can’t be withdrawn at all.
Personally, we spent four years building our emergency fund. Currently it covers a year of living expenses, because not only do we both work for the same company, but we are self-employeed in the construction industry.
We keep some cash in a safe, have a MM account at the local credit union with a debit card and electronic transfer to a checking account, then the rest of the money lives in laddered CD’s. While safety is an illusion, I do sleep better at night. It is a tough goal, it took us a LONG time to reach it, but it does bring peace of mind.
November 19th, 2008 at 7:51 am
I agree that an emergency fund is much more important than paying down credit card debt. While I have a bit of credit card debt, I am currently focusing on putting together one month of living expenses. After that I will turn my focus to my credit card debt.
I needed to get a root canal recently, but because I had no emergency fund, I had to get the tooth pulled. Even getting the tooth pulled nearly sunk me, and I had to wait to get paid again before I could have it pulled. Spending one day with a throbbing toothache was enough to convince me of the importance of an emergency fund. I also have been keeping a decent supply of dry goods on hand, so that if I get into a pinch, I can skip grocery shopping for a few weeks.
November 19th, 2008 at 7:52 am
While I don’t have a lot of data, I would suggest that much of the current wave of foreclosures in America is due to a widespread lack of an emergency fund. Emergencies can have extended lengths, or even pile on top of each other, and an debt instrument would be wise to avoid except as a last resort. Not only do you simply trade one type of issue (your present emergency) for a more long term issue (repaying your credit card, line of credit, loan, etc.), it is actually more expensive over time if you have to pay interest. As the author mentioned, I would regard debt instruments as a method of last resort only, to be used when you deplete your cash reserves. Even if you think you can afford payments with interest tacked on, how will your long term investments, retirement goals, and so on, be affected by an increased expenditure over time that you could have otherwise avoided?
As far as how much to keep in an emergency fund, my opinion is that you can never have too much in your fund. Reached 6 months income? Great, now make it 12. Any figure you use is arbitrary, of course, and there is no amount that is more right than any other. However, expect that emergencies will be far more costly than otherwise anticipated. As they say in Boy Scouts, be prepared! I would much rather have more money that I think I would ever use, and not have to draw my fund down significantly in any emergency, than find myself having to turn to debt to finance my crises due to not having saved enough in the first place.
November 19th, 2008 at 7:53 am
@ Nissal:
I think the point of having a CD ladder is so that your money is working harder for you–though your point on the short maturation window is noted. I find it acceptable then to use a credit card in emergencies that fall outside of that particular window. This makes sense as one will be able to make the respective payment back to the card in that time frame without incurring unwanted interest. On the plus side, one can also accrue rewards/cash back if using the appropriate card for the emergency at hand.
November 19th, 2008 at 8:02 am
I am currently putting my entire emergency fund in a 3% MMA with Captial One. I really like Dylan’s tip about self-insuring things. I would self-insure my car if I could! Also, if I know that I’m underpaying for something, I’ll contribute money to my MMA. For example, my DSL hasn’t billed me in 3 months, but I know it will eventually catch up with me. I see this as an arbitrage opportunity to gain interest on my money while I wait for AT&T to figure out that I owe them money! I would love to have a more sophisticated financial structure to my savings, but I am not sure where to start past an MMA.
November 19th, 2008 at 8:04 am
I keep my emergency fund in a high-yield savings account that is a bit of a pain to get to. This discourages me from using it unless it is a real emergency.
I have direct-deposit through work, and have a set amount go directly to my emergency fund. I follow the pay-yourself-first method. It is easy to save an emergency fund if you don’t really notice you are doing it.
Since my emergency fund is a hassle to access, and also due to the fact that I pay off my credit card in full, I use the credit card to pay for any emergency expenses. I then transfer the exact amount on my receipt / bank statement from my emergency fund to the account I use to pay off my credit card.
On the rare occasions that credit is not acceptable, then I will write a check and be certain to move funds over that same day.
This method keeps my hands out of my emergency fund except when actually necessary, yet provides me with instant access to ‘funds’ to see me through the emergency.
November 19th, 2008 at 8:06 am
As a person who has “operated” for 28 years of marriage without a true emergency fund, I can attest to the fact that if you do not have an emergency fund, you will find yourself more in debt as a result of not preparing adequately for these financial “emergencies”. I made the choice and decision weeks ago to contribute a specific amount dedicated for the emergency fund. For me, this was a milestone in deciding to do something to help produce a more secure environment for our family and to give us peace of mind in knowing that we have some security in building our emergency fund on a consistent basis. It has actually made us look forward to making that deposit into our emergency fund account because we can see the growth! This has become a way of life for our family now.
November 19th, 2008 at 8:08 am
We, too, have done Dave Ramsey, and been very glad to have that emergency fund. We have rather more than the $1000 basic one and a lot less than 6 months of expenses, but are still paying off some car loans. The thing that has amazed me is how few the emergencies have been since we had a fund in place!Dave calls it “Murphy insurance” and it seems he’s right when he says that Murphy just doesn’t come around when you are prepared for him!
November 19th, 2008 at 8:15 am
As a fresh college graduate with only around $1,000/ month of expenses I keep at least $5000 in my bank plus $4000 in well diversified mutual funds. For moral reasons I don’t invest in anything paying interest. In these times that’s certainly more risky but my moral code comes first.
November 19th, 2008 at 8:21 am
I don’t have an emergency fund, and often turn to my credit card in times of emergency… so it’s definitely something that I am looking to start. I especially liked the comment: “The harder you think it is to come up with money for an emergency fund, the more you need one.” I’ve always put it off because I am so caught up paying off my student loans as priority #1, but imagine the set-backs I could face if a major disaster were to occur.
Thanks for the post, I have a good outline of how much to save now and with the new tax free savings accounts here in Canada it’s a great time to start!
November 19th, 2008 at 8:22 am
THANK YOU! I was hoping someone would address this issue in more detail.
And thank you too for suggesting what single people and people in other circumstances should do. I find too much of the financial advice out there is for families. (Which is great, but a little too early for me:)
November 19th, 2008 at 8:33 am
We are just now building our emergency fund, I cannot believe we have lived without one this long. We would just put emergencies, or any unexpected expense on our credit cards. No more. I have found having an emergency fund helps me sleep better at night. I can only imagine how it will feel once its totally funded.
November 19th, 2008 at 8:38 am
I am nineteen, and have been on my own for about 2 years. I am one of the only 19 year olds I know with a budget, and the only one with an emergency savings account. However, I have been struggling to rebuild that emergency account. I recently needed to relocate, which clearly takes a chunk of unexpected change out of one’s pocket. At the same time, I had unexpected car bills, that left me out of work for a few days, and with more bills. I think that paying off my debt (only $1500 left) is more of a priority than building my emergency savings account. But at the same time, the more “emergencies” that come up, only ends up pushing back or decreasing the amount of payments I can consistently make to pay off my debt.
Any suggestions? I am craving a larger emergency savings, but I just don’t see how to build it other than 10-30 bucks each month right now.
November 19th, 2008 at 8:44 am
This may sound really dumb but I set my emergency account up a little bit differently. A few years ago I found a bank that offered about 3.5% for a savings account. I went in, setup an account, and depisoted about $1000. When I got my password in the mail I threw it out. Yep, so that I have no access unless I call them myself to setup a new password.
They send me statements to my email every month and I see how much my emergency savings are growing. Thankfully I have not had to use the account yet. When I do need to access it I will just call them up and provide my information to set up a new password and pull the money out.
November 19th, 2008 at 8:47 am
My buddy Karin Wertheim turned me on to this blog. Now I just want to preach the gospel to everyone I know.
I recently had to talk a friend down who had suffered a big financial blow. She is a marginally employed student and single mother, so they live pretty close to the bone. She uprooted the family chasing the promise of free tuition, but the move had many unexpected costs — car broke down en route, depleted the fund they were using for move costs, then the moving company held their possessions for ransom.
Now it’s one year later and she is finally getting her worldly possessions delivered. She puts a child support check in to the bank, but it has not cleared, so the bank will not make out a cashier’s check, by delivery day. Now the moving company charges $500 for the day wait to deliver. At that point, should she have gone to a payday loan or something? I didn’t think of that option until later.
November 19th, 2008 at 8:54 am
Although some people disagree, CD’s are EXCELLENT for emergency funds, if you set it up properly. Have a certain amount of cash at hand as part of the emergency fund. That way you will not be penalized for dipping into part of the fund. Then split your emergency fund into $2000 blocks. The penalty for early withdrawal with ING for a 1 year CD is 3 months interest. Let’s say you dip into that $2000, you have the rest of the blocks of money making 4%. Also, don’t forget to disable the automatic renewal so you can change you finance strategy, if needed, on your own time.
Think of it this way, if you don’t invest your money into CD’s or something stable like that, you are losing 4% a year due to inflation!
November 19th, 2008 at 8:55 am
“Tip: When purchasing household appliances, decline the extended warrantees and add that money to your emergency fund instead. If you self-warranty several appliances, you spread out the risk of needing to repair any one of them. If you don’t need to make repairs, you get to keep the money!”
This tip is fantastic for most appliances, I will start using it immediately. I do find Apple Care to be worth the money though.
Stacey: When you think about it you will probably pay off your debt at the same time. If you have a $1500 and incur extra unexpected expenses of $1000, if you add to the debt, it hurts about the same as paying less toward the debt to not incur more debt.
Its great that you have a budget, but look at is as a plan, sometimes you have to deviate from that plan, but keep trying to stick to the plan.
November 19th, 2008 at 8:56 am
I keep $5,000 in my checking account and another $4,000 in a well-diversified mutual fund. I would invest in CDs but I have moral obligations precluding me from investing in anything giving interest. It may not seem very smart in this market, but my morals come first.
November 19th, 2008 at 9:06 am
When I met with a banker last year to go over my finances, I had a small emergency fund saved up (about 1K) and a LOC sitting at about 9K. He advised me to put the emergency money on the LOC and, in an emergency, count on the LOC to get me through. I did it, but now I regret it a little.
I also have a savings account for my dog (instead of pet insurance…I just put the equivalent of the premiums into an ING account) and now I view that as my emergency fund. It works for me because I would never touch that money except for a big vet bill, or something else that was truly catastrophic — anything else would feel like I was stealing from the dog.
November 19th, 2008 at 9:09 am
Like other posters I have a layered system. I have a cushion in my checking account that is enough to pay my mortgage. I further have a small linked saving account for emergencies that are just a bridge between an expense and the money to pay for it. For example if my renter is late with his rent I have enough to cover the mortgage on that property as well until I run him to ground (if he’s a deadbeat and I need a 2nd month that money comes from elsewhere).
By the time I actually get to the layer titled “emergency fund” ($2k) I’m already pretty well insulated. What some people consider emergencies to me are just irregular expenses. My emergency fund is kept at ING in a partitioned account (single balance that I split up in my own records). Other partitions include “medical expenses”, “vet bills”, “car expenses”, etc. The logic of this isn’t just for the security of having that money and not needing to draw on the EF but to track how much I actually spend on those things.
The second leg of the EF (for if one or both of us lost our jobs), is all cash available to us (six months). Vacations, purchases, or investments would be immediately put off. We are conscious of this money and know it serves double purpose so we will never tie it up without increasing other cash.
The third leg of our financial emergency plan is an emergency budget. In my budget spreadsheet next to my regular budget is what expenses would be immediately cut if needed. As a previous poster pointed out often emergencies are very emotionally stressful and it can be hard at that time to make decisions and take action. DH and I have discussed what we consider the bare essentials and which are creature comforts. Is it worth it to us to spend 50% more on internet in order to cancel our cable service? Would we cancel curbside trash service? The real emergency might mean different decisions, but we already understand many of the trade offs.
November 19th, 2008 at 9:15 am
I use my credit card for must-pay-now emergencies, and then transfer from my online account to pay it off immediately. This way I get cc rewards, as well as the higher interest available with the online account. I keep enough in there to pay for most car repairs, insurance deductibles, etc. We also have a cd ladder for more long-term needs. For example, if one of us lost a job, unemployment + savings could hold us till a cd matured.
November 19th, 2008 at 9:16 am
Here’s a new approach to emergency funds: If you are scripted in generating passive income, such as a website or real estate property, you could dedicate a portion of that income toward compounding an emergency fund account. Maybe even dedicating one particular deal fully toward building your emergency fund.
November 19th, 2008 at 9:19 am
My husband and I have 10% of our income automatically transferred into an online direct savings account from our brick & mortor bank for a greater return on out money. We have about 3 months saved right now and hope to have about 6 months saved within the next 12 months. We also put about $1,000 in a CD, so we have a little money we would really have to try to get to. We will eventually increase that to one month of income. If anyone is looking for a good online bank, we really like emigrantdirect.com.
November 19th, 2008 at 9:24 am
I keep my emergency fund in Series-I Savings Bonds. The bonds are guaranteed by the U.S. Treasury, which is generally seen as even more secure than even the FDIC. They also guarantee to keep pace with inflation, something that CDs and savings accounts do not promise, so the value of the emergency fund doesn’t degrade over time. (And in practice, over the past five years I’ve seen that the savings bonds have easily beaten the returns from ING Direct’s savings accounts.) Another advantage is that it’s a minor hassle to build the account back up after I use it, so there’s an incentive not to touch the account unless I have an actual emergency.
The only caveat is that once you buy a savings bond, it cannot be redeemed for one year. (After that point, it can be redeemed at absolutely any time.) Because of this, it’s best to build the fund up gradually. If you invest $100 per month in it, then there will never be more than $1200 locked up.
You can go to treasurydirect.gov to sign up for an account that lets you buy series I savings bonds online.
November 19th, 2008 at 9:28 am
Regarding the note in there about the Extended Warranty, I just found out that most major credit cards will actually double the manufacturer’s warranty on appliances and electronics (it was on http://www.iwillteachyoutoberich.com/blog/). Yet another reason to decline the warranty in store!
November 19th, 2008 at 9:37 am
My emergency fund could cover two years of expenses. That’s a bit excessive but now that’s tucked safely away, I know the rest of my capital is long term and I can take some investment risk.
November 19th, 2008 at 9:37 am
Great advice above. The emergency fund is a must have for everyone. I recommend the creation of a robust emergency fund to all of my clients.
November 19th, 2008 at 9:39 am
My Emergency Fund Set-UP:
1)Set certain amount for fund ($10,000)in high interest savings account
2) Take out 3% of each check until $15,000
3) Evaluate each year depending on changing circumstances, such as baby, economy, job security, etc.
November 19th, 2008 at 9:39 am
PAY YOURSELVES FIRST - WITH A SENSE OF SECURITY (now that’s priceless)!! When my SO and I moved in together, we put the equivalent of his monthly rent and utilities into an ING savings account. Between his being a union employee (contract comes up soon) and my being an independent contractor, it was critical that we put away at least six months’ worth of living expenses. Thankfully, SO gets paid weekly (vs. my monthly invoice), so we can move funds to the ING account every week. Noting the fund transfers in our checking account register gives us a HUGE sense of relief that we’re making an effort to plan for emergencies, and are in better control of where the rest of our money goes each month.
November 19th, 2008 at 9:43 am
While relying on a credit card as your emergency fund is a terribly part, it can be part of a good solution.
For example, ING’s high interest accounts are money market savings accounts. You have no direct access to the money, but must instead transfer it to a local bank. Transfering out of an account is limited to 6 times per month, and takes two to three days to be processed.
By combining a credit card with ING savings accounts, you have a) the immediate ability to pay for an emergency and b) 30 days to get the money from ING to your credit card company.
November 19th, 2008 at 9:47 am
I just completed one year working at a “real job” after graduating college last year. After initially blowing through each pay check in an excited “woohoo I finally have money!” fit, I’ve begun working towards contributing to my emergency fund. I have had a Bank of America checking and savings account for years, but discovered that Washington Mutual has a higher rate of return on their savings account. So I opened an online savings account with them and transfer money there for emergencies. Because it’s not my everyday account I can resist the temptation to spend that money, and I’m earning a lot more in interest!
November 19th, 2008 at 9:47 am
I have a layered emergency fund as well.
Layer 1 is enough cash on hand to buy a tank of gas for my car. Not much — I don’t feel safe keeping money in my house anyway — but it’s enough that I could get out of town in a natural disaster.
Layer 2 is a slush savings account at the bank where I have my checking account. It’s where I fund things like annual insurance premiums, car repairs, computers, expenses from being in a wedding, and so on from. If it can’t come out of monthly cash flow, it comes out of the slush account. I kick in every month on auto deposit, and I generally try to keep around a month’s salary in there. It doesn’t make much in interest, but it is available immediately.
Layer 3 is my long-term savings at ING. It’s the most recently established account, so there isn’t much in there right now, but my top savings priority is getting it up to six months of expenses. Once I get there, I’ll establish a six-month CD ladder.
November 19th, 2008 at 9:47 am
I don’t technically have a pot of money I call my emergency fund, I just have savings I could use in an emergency. I’m starting to think I should set up something along the lines of a separate unemployment fund in laddered CDs or similar. I think my employment is stable but loss of income is probably the biggest emergency I fear - I’m upside down on my house so I need a bigger cash cushion.
November 19th, 2008 at 9:48 am
I personally get a real sense of security out of an emergency fund. There is a real power to being able to do something as dramatic as leaving a job before having a new one lined up because you have the savings to do it.
It is also a personal backup for turning down overpriced (and often unusable) extended warranties and costly low deductible insurance. This adds up to literally hundreds in savings for me.
November 19th, 2008 at 9:58 am
For most of my adult life until fairly recently I have not had an Emergency Fund. In fact, worse still I was one of those people who just figured you use your almost maxed out credit card in an emergency. I was never conscious of this but I can see now that the psychological pressure I put myself under by doing this was enormous - it made the emergency much worse than it needed to be. The slightest problem could have tipped me over the edge. Conversely, today I am about half way to my target of a 6 month emergency fund and already I feel more certain, more in control and highly motivated by the growing nest egg. The best part is I now choose my attitude in response to an emergency. The so and so just broke unexpectedly - I either decide to live without it until I can save up for a new one and am comfortable with that or I decide a repair/replacement is needed immediately and happily dip into the fund. It’s a tremendous feeling of power. Finally, in my case I have parked the emergency fund in my mortgage which has a quick and easy, unlimited redraw facility. When I’m not touching the fund I am actually saving a significant amount of interest each month on our only debt now and paying off more principal instead. So it feels like a real win-win.
November 19th, 2008 at 10:01 am
I keep my emergency fund in a high yield savings about at ING Direct. My checking account is wired in and all that usual stuff.
The one thing I do that I don’t read a lot of other people doing is when I need to access my fund I keep track of how much I take it and then treat it as a short term loan.
I create a payment schedule assuming a one year term and an interest rate that is equal to what I would qualify for on a fixed rate mortgage. I enter into my GnuCash file as an outstanding liability and treat it just like a credit card - I pay it off as soon as possible.
The bonus to this approach is that I am paying myself interest on withdrawals (which discourages me from taping the fund for non-critical expenditures) on top of what ING Direct will pay me so my fund continues to grow without my having to contribute to it every month.
November 19th, 2008 at 10:05 am
Here’s my substantive comment:
I need to do this. I need to act. Starting today. Now.
And that book would sure help me.
November 19th, 2008 at 10:17 am
I am laying on my couch after blowing my knee out in an adult rec league soccer game and I am at the moment unemployed. Because my husband and I have been putting money aside and paid off so much debt while I was employed I am not having night terrors, but instead feel confident we will pull through.
November 19th, 2008 at 10:25 am
The better you’re doing financially, the less important an emergency fund actually becomes.
In the past, I’ve experienced several actual emergencies that have required a fair bit of money — I’ve needed car repairs, I’ve had my wife get sick while she was traveling, I’ve had a computer break (which is critical for my work). However, none of these things has ever cost more than about $1,000. That’s not to say no reasonable emergency will ever cost more than $1,000, but it seems to cover 90% of real-life emergencies. I actually keep a $5,000 emergency fund in case anything really significant happens.
The reason I say the better you’re doing, the less you need an emergency fund, is because I’ve realized, as my financial situation has become more secure, I really don’t worry about $1,000 anymore. I had $3,700 in my checking account this morning. I have $5,000 in a “travel” account, $1,500 in a “fun” account, and I still have $5,000 in my actual emergency fund. I could easily raid my “travel” or “fun” account in the event of an actual emergency, so the importance of a specific “emergency” account dwindles when I have more places to draw cash from, should I need it.
Now, what really seems a bit ridiculous to me is the idea that you need to provision six months of living expenses as a *minimum* emergency fund. That, for me, is probably about $20,000. Which is a ridiculous amount to just sit around on,
in cash, earning very little interest. I think people need to better consider what constitutes an “emergency”. I think it could probably be defined as any event that results in a reaction like, “Holy crap, how can I afford to pay for this!”
And certainly a loss of a job could qualify for that. That’s where the six month provision comes from, the fact that you could lose your job, and it may take you a while to find a new one. And while the initial job loss is certainly an emergency, the resulting long period of unemployment is not. You will need to be able to pay your upcoming rent in the next few weeks, so certainly you should have enough stashed away to cover the next month’s payment on on your bills, but this gives you a month to make new arrangements to account for your change in income level.
Maybe you want to sell investments, or maybe you can borrow against your retirement fund, or maybe you want to move in with your parents or in-laws, or maybe you can sell your car since you no longer need to drive it to work. You probably want to reduce your standard of living to a more bare-bones level.
These are all adjustments that can be made in that first month while you’re living off your emergency fund. As long as you know you have these options available to you, then you don’t need six months’ living expenses in cash, because you will have time to pull funds from elsewhere or re-organize your life in the actual “emergency” period.
If anyone tells me something like, “At a *bare minimum* you should always keep $20,000 in your checking account,” I’m going to take that with quite a large grain of salt, as I’d bet 90% of people in this country, have less than $10,000 available quickly in liquid assets. While shooting to be above the 90th percentile in financial security is certainly a very nice goal, it’s extremely aggressive as an, “absolute minimum”, which is what the post states.
November 19th, 2008 at 10:34 am
I have several different savings accounts.
1) Emergency Fund - this has 3-4 months of expenses in it. This is the money that allows me to sleep ok at night even though my husband works for Wachovia and we have no idea what is going to happen with his job once the Wells Fargo merger happens.
2) Special Projects - this is supposed to be the place that I save money for things like replacing the carpet on our stairs (which is threadbare in spots). What it has turned into though is our “smaller emergency” fund. This is where the money comes from for that $200 unexpected vet bill or to replace the dishwasher that is about to croak. I am constantly putting money in there but it never gets to a huge amount.
3) Car Savings - both of our cars are paid off. When the second car was paid off we continued just setting that money aside in our Car Savings. The main point is to save up enough money to pay cash for our next car (in 6 or 7 years hopefully). However, this fund could also pay for any major car repairs. Regular maintenance comes out of current income but this pool of money would be there to replace a clutch or something like that.
4) Vacation fund - We are actively saving for two fairly significant trips. Depending on what happens with the economy and my husbands job, those plans may not happen. In that case, this money becomes part of the emergency fund. But, until then, I have this money separated because it helps motivate me to put money in there.
5) House taxes - We don’t escrow our property taxes or insurance. Every month, money goes in here so that when the taxes are due it doesn’t need to come out of our emergency fund.
6) Christmas - We put a little aside every month for christmas. That way, the holidays aren’t a shock to our budget.
7) Taxes - Most of my work is contract (I teach swimming part time). In general, we don’t end up owing money at tax time. We just don’t get much back (if any). However, I put a little bit aside every paycheck to cover a tax bill in the event that we have not planned properly.
So, even though I have only one fund that I call our “emergency fund” I have a few others out there too in order to cover things that others would use their emergency fund for. I find it motiving to have various funds to put specific savings for. And, having that emergency fund sitting out there that really doesn’t get tapped much does help me sleep at night
November 19th, 2008 at 10:40 am
I’ve always struggled with the “long-term emergency fund” and the “kinda-sorta emergency fund.” As in, I know I need to set aside enough money to cover living expenses for a couple months (although ever since burning through the savings while on unpaid maternity leave, it has been a struggle to reestablish even a one-month cushion) but there are also those other expenses that you know are going to come up, and may be bigger than just the $250 Todd mentions. Like the deductible when our house was broken into or our car run into.
I very much appreciate the advice of “set up one month of funds, then pay down debt before beefing up the emergency accounts” because it is true that having even a little bit stashed makes a huge psychological difference. But where/how do folks recommend saving for the “little emergencies”–or is this simply a matter of figuring out what constitutes an emergency, before the unexpected happens, and then sticking to it?
November 19th, 2008 at 11:12 am
We are currently working to build up an emergency fund. It takes awhile for us. I would like to have our emergency fund at $5,000. I love this blog though. It has really gotten my husband and I thinking about money and personal finances and we did recently finally open him a ROTH IRA.
November 19th, 2008 at 11:18 am
We’re about a year in to our five year debt elimination plan, so right now we’re nurturing our baby emergency fund by putting in a small amount monthly. It’s nowhere near six months of expenses, but it’s at least enough to handle a surprise repair bill.
While I would prefer to have a ‘real’ emergency fund, until our debt is paid off, we can only put aside the tiny amount to keep on hand. Still, even being so small right now, it’s comforting to know it’s there. I didn’t panic when our ancient washer broke down, b/c I knew we could replace it if we had to. (Luckily, it turned out to be a $15 belt that the repairman had on hand–he told us our machine was built more solidly than most of the newer machines he works on!)
November 19th, 2008 at 11:21 am
Good tips. Right now I have a part emergency fund/vacation fund I am slowly growing and keep in a money market account. Do you recommend me leaving it there or place it somewhere else?
Craig
http://www.budgetpulse.com
November 19th, 2008 at 11:22 am
Great post, as always. I started reading GRS about two years ago, and while I’ve commented maybe once before, I pretty much follow the various pieces of advice I find here. The first few steps I took was take the money that was sitting idly in a checking account and open a ROTH IRA account as well as an emergency fund in the form of a high-yield savings account (complete with Debit Card!) From there, I decided my priority would be the emergency fund, so I set up a recurring monthly transfer from my checking acct to the emergency fund. Now I have 10 months rent saved up in there– and it’s always nice to see the interest compounding.
Now it’s time to set up the recurring transfer to my IRA account. Unfortunately, the index funds I’m seeing have some pretty high minimums– 10,000 to start and things like that. We’ll see.
November 19th, 2008 at 11:39 am
I don’t have emergency savings but am aware of the need for it. In fact, I was hit with a situation a year ago in which I could have used it: my grandfather died. He lived in Louisiana, I live in Ohio. ‘Nuff said. My little girl’s dad was kind enough to take us down there for the funeral but even he was scrounging because it was the week in between paydays. Yipe.
He’s doing a side job right now and I may be looking at a small windfall because he’s passing some of what he makes on to us. I have been going back and forth on what to do with it; paying off some small debts was my first thought. However, we can’t be stuck again with no emergency savings if something else comes up. So I may dump the entire amount into my savings account and pretend it no longer exists so it’ll be there when I need it. I may not get a great return on it but to me, that’s not what a savings account is for. Different financial vehicles and tools have different purposes–if you want investment income, make an investment. You know?
November 19th, 2008 at 11:41 am
My partner and I have a little over 10K in an online savings account just for emergencies, as well as 2k in cash on hand. I don’t know if this covers 6 months of essential expenses, but I suspect not (we live in an expensive East Coast city; she works and I’m a soon to be published novelist). One thing we have going for us is that the condo is paid off, and we could rent out a couple of rooms if we needed the cash.
November 19th, 2008 at 11:43 am
For me, an emergency fund was the first thing I did in my journey toward getting control over my financial life. This was the “first step” because it meant I was planning for the FUTURE as opposed to living for only the present/short term. And once I saved up the necessary funds, it gave me the psychological and financial cushion to pursue other personal finance goals, such as paying down my debt, beginning an investment portfolio, and buying a home. Building an emergency fund took away much of my worry about the unknown and allowed me to focus on the other financial goals I had in front of me.
I put my emergency fund in a hybrid ING orange account. 80% in pure savings and 20% in 6 month CDs. I think it reasonable to assume that I would not need the full 100% of the money immediately, so I try to get a little more interest earnings through CDs.
November 19th, 2008 at 11:47 am
Great tips, everyone.
I learned the hard way why it’s important to keep your emergency fund in an easily accessible, highly liquid form. My husband and I had saved up 6 months of emergency money before I left my full-time job to raise our first child. We stuck it in an index fund thinking it would continue to grow and we could get it out only if we needed it.
Because of current market conditions, our six month emergency fund is now (barely) enough for two months. If we pull it out now, we’ll never recover our investment. So we’re basically leaving it alone, calling it long-term savings, and starting over from scratch on an emergency fund.
Live and learn, I guess …
November 19th, 2008 at 11:49 am
While I agree that you generally shouldn’t use debt as an “emergency fund”, there are no hard and fast rules in finance. You have to take advantage of what is available to you.
I have a zero balance line of credit that has a prime MINUS rate. Right now that line of credit has a 1% interest rate. And it is my emergancy “fund”.
I moved all of my cash savings into fixed interest debt repayment 6 months ago, and have saved over $600 in interest so far.
When those debts are paid off (in the middle of next year) then I will replace the emergency fund in stacked GICs with two months worth of expenses “liquid” as the rest rotate in 6 month terms.
November 19th, 2008 at 11:53 am
“The reason I say the better you’re doing, the less you need an emergency fund, is because I’ve realized, as my financial situation has become more secure, I really don’t worry about $1,000 anymore. I had $3,700 in my checking account this morning. I have $5,000 in a “travel” account, $1,500 in a “fun” account, and I still have $5,000 in my actual emergency fund. I could easily raid my “travel” or “fun” account in the event of an actual emergency, so the importance of a specific “emergency” account dwindles when I have more places to draw cash from, should I need it.”
This is why I don’t separate my emergency fund from my other savings. I have a single savings account for emergencies, annual expenses and vacations/big purchases, a single mutual fund for mid-term savings like a new car and a downpayment on a house, and separate long-term savings.
I see no reason to seperate my emergency fund from my vacation or “fun” money. When I have a large expense in a month, whether it’s car insurance or an unexpected vet bill, the first thing I do is cut back my discretionary spending. If I lost my job, I would cancel any vacations I had planned. If I had a seperate fun account, I would probably take money out of it to replenish my emergency fund.
November 19th, 2008 at 12:10 pm
We are currently doing the Dave Ramsey program but instead of $1000 baby emergency fund, we have 1-month’s expenses - about $4500. We feel that this is a good compromise from paying off debt and having a decent EF. We opted for this due to:
1. My husband’s job is a contract position which can be eliminated anytime. However, unemployment compensation will be available if needed.
2. We have a rental property in which the tenant is on a month-to-month basis so he can also move out within a 30-day notice. Not to mention possible repairs.
3. Both our PAID OFF cars are about 10 years old.
4. We have a dog. One time, it cost us almost $200 for an ear infection.
On the other side:
1. Our home is newer (12 yrs old) with newer appliances (1-2 yrs old)
2. We have good health insurance
We hope to build up the full EF after we pay off all our debt.
-Charlotte
November 19th, 2008 at 12:10 pm
I disagree that CD’s are a bad idea for a emergency fund. If you setup 3 90 day cd’s every month for 3 months one would be accessible at almost all times, and of course they usually offer higher interest than a savings account. Plus if it’s harder to get to the money there is less temptation to get at it for something you don’t need.
November 19th, 2008 at 12:10 pm
We have a few tiers depending on the seriousness of the emergency. First both my wife and I keep a $1000 buffer in our checking accounts. This buffer prevents overdrafts and can handle minor emergencies. The next level is an ING savings account- we use this for mid-term savings but we would pull from it for a more serious emergency. Next would be a CD where we keep our longer term savings - not ideal given penalties but there are enough alternatives that it shouldn’t ideally come to this. If things are really dire there are investments outside of retirement accounts we can sell. Selling stocks is not a good thing when the market is beat down but a possibility in a reasonable market.
If things were horrible bad we would look at either pulling from retirement or home equity. We could pull contributions from our Roth IRAs without any taxes but the hit to compound growth would really hurt. I wouldn’t want to count on home equity, especially since a HELOC isn’t really guaranteed but that is a possibility. Finally there is the 401K account; we would lose ~40% of whatever we took out in taxes and penalties so that would be our last resort.
-Rick Francis
November 19th, 2008 at 12:15 pm
my wife and I use ING savings and checking accounts to fund our emergency funds. we use ING savings accounts which are earmarked for specific things that are a bit more emergency related — car repair, medical bills, home maintenance, etc. We then use an ING checking as our emergency fund so we can more easily access our money.
November 19th, 2008 at 12:19 pm
I have many tiers to my emergency padding.
First off, I will say that I use a cash back credit card to pay for just about everything, which I pay off at the end of each month.
Then, I try to keep an extra $500 in my checking, and an extra $500 in my regular savings which is linked as an overdraft account, so that’s the first line of emergency defense.
Next, I have about 6 months of bare necessities money (not net pay but enough to cover a frugal existence). Between freelance work and unemployment benefits, this would probably last me a year if I were laid off.
Then there’s my Roth IRA, which, in the most extremely dire of circumstances, I could tap for what I put in.
If I get through all that, I’ll sell my motorcycle
After that, I’m in trouble…
November 19th, 2008 at 12:26 pm
Thank you for sharing this timely information. In the current economic climate having an emergency fund available moves from being an abstract idea to a reality.
I believe it’s important to build up an emergency fund while also paying down any debt that you may already have. As the article mentions not having funds available can put you in debt or further into debt. Anything you can do to offset that is worth doing as soon as possible.
My own emergency fund is almost at the level I require and once completed I’ll focus on paying debt down more aggresively. Which will be great as I’m already ahead of schedule on my debt repayment!
November 19th, 2008 at 12:26 pm
I think Tyler (@80) had a couple really good points. When one is thinking about an emergency account one may take it from a perspective of the liklihood of it happening. I did the same exercise of “What are the most likely emergencies, and how much would they cost?” By the time I get above $1-2k I’m looking at a different sort of emergency. For example if something that major broke in my car I would be replacing the car and financing it since I don’t have the cash for it yet. If a tree fell on my house I would be calling my home insurance.
After that when we are talking about 3-6 months of expenses and having that in MMA vs CDs vs stocks so much depends on you personally. How secure is your job? How liquid are your investments? How volitile are your investments? People point out the penalty if you cash out a CD early and my response is: So what? In an emergency I am not going to argue over 3 months of interest, especially if I’ve received a better rate for the life of the invesetment.
DH and I make almost exactly the same salary and it isn’t likely that both of us would lose our jobs, so the probability of needing 6 full months of salary seems a bit over the top. And our company has NEVER had layoffs and I flatter myself to think I’m not likely to be fired, so that isn’t a looming concern. There is also unemployment and either of us would be aggressively looking for a new job. If I needed the money I couldn’t sell my rental property, but I could sell all my stock tomorrow if I had to. With all of this in mind: over the next 10 years how likely is it for me to see an emergency that needs 3-6 months of salary? Am I willing to take the risk of cashing out at a loss/penalty so that I can have my money working for me for that time? As long as I acknowledge the risk and have the plan for what to do in an emergency I don’t see any problem having all but a month of expenses tied up if it makes sense for my situation.
With that said I believe my emergency plan needs to be completely self contained, i.e. based on personal assets and not the prospect of borrowing. If I’m relying on debt then I’m relying on someone else’s decision to lend to me in a given situation and will they be willing to lend during the emergency (which is when a prudent business WON’T lend to me)? I have known more than one person who relied on credit and when the emergency hit they were cut off and left stranded. And if you prepay on your mortgage: good luck getting them to give it back when you need the cash to go to the grocery store.
November 19th, 2008 at 12:33 pm
@Ryan McLean: The math, and probabilities, says you’re right. However, having even just $500 or $1,000 in rainy day money creates a real sense of relief and safety. As has been said your goal should eventually be both. But having lived with one for a few years now, I will never, ever go without some kind of emergency fund available.
November 19th, 2008 at 12:35 pm
I’ve found that it’s best to have two “emergency” funds: a real emergency fund for “omigods” like a tree smashing your roof in, and a buffer zone for reoccuring, big, but infrequent, expenses like insurance bills.
The buffer zone idea, for me, came because I got tired of being caught blindsided by those big annual or semi-annual bills. I did three things about it.
First, I wrote down every one of these bills’ due dates and a mounts on my calendar. If it came before the 15th of the month, I put a note on the previous month to remind me it was coming up.
Second, I added up all my big bills: insurance, property taxes, you name it. I then divided them by 52, to get an idea of how much I needed to save every pay period. (Boy, was *that* every an eye-opener!) Now that I had a hard and fast number to shoot for, I only had to figure out the best (easiest, laziest, most temptation-proof) way to save.
Third, I took fullest advantage of my company’s stock purchase fund and used it to create my buffer zone. I was allowed to put up to 10% of my paycheck into this fund, which bought stock quarterly at 15% under the lowest price at the beginning or end of the term, whichever was lower. This not only ensured I saved enough money, but it generally ensured a 15% return each quarter. Once in a while I got “stung”, when the company made an announcement the night before that sent the stock tumbling the night after it was bought, but before I could sell the next morning. However, these were rare, and even when they did happen, I made a 5% or so profit, or at worst broke even.
As for the “omigod” fund, I used auto-deposit to keep things going. It worked out to about $115 every two weeks, pulled out before I saw it, so I couldn’t “forget” to fund it. At first I kept it in a long-term muni bond fund (one of Vanguard’s), but the taxes on it, and the fluctuations, really got annoying, so I’m now in a tax-free MM fund. (Should’ve done that in the first place….) I can get money out of it, either by electronic transfer or check, but since the electronic transfer takes a few days, and the checks are only good for $250 and up, I’m not tempted to dip into it on a moment’s notice.
Now I’m no longer with that company (*sniff sniff*), and the new place doesn’t do direct deposit yet, so I’m going to have to buckle down and make myself contribute to these two funds the old-fashioned way. I’ll treat them like bills and do an electronic transfer every month.
As an aside, I’ve had to dip into that emergency fund more than once over the past few months. I was in a motorcycle accident the last day of January 2008, which dislocated my knee and left me unable to leave the house for months. (Thank GOD for Aflac!) The dummy who hit me (of course) has minimal insurance, and Blue Cross wants all they can get their hands on, so I’ll be lucky to see $15K when all is said and done next year. Then I got laid off in July, and on top of it had to buy a new car (no more bikes for me) to use for job hunting. I only found a new place to work in the first week of November. Having that money there has made all the difference in the world for me.
November 19th, 2008 at 12:41 pm
I am so glad I realized the need for an emergency fund earlier this year, as I just had to use half of ours! Right now, our minimum goal is $1000, but we want to get it up to three months’ of expenses just in case. Rather than throwing extra $$ toward debt (because all of ours is really low) we’re just snowballing so we can put as much as possible into our emergency fund and other funds like car repair, next Christmas, and our “goodie fund”.
November 19th, 2008 at 12:55 pm
Wow. You guys have posted some amazing comments today. Between Dylan’s great post and your great feedback, this will become my new default post when I need a link for the phrase “emergency fund”.
Because there are so many responses, I’ll bump the number of books I’m giving away from two to five: two from Dylan and three from me.
Thanks, everyone!
November 19th, 2008 at 1:15 pm
We have 1 months expenses in an e-fund right now. We put the excess from our utility budget in there (about $100/month in the winter) and are slowly getting it up to 6 months expenses. We have a 12 year old car that our primary savings goal is saving for a replacement for it. So all other funds are being directed here. My husband considers our car fund the first thing we’d drain in an emergency as a dead car is our most likely emergency.
November 19th, 2008 at 1:18 pm
I’ve calculated three different versions of an emergency fund, and am aiming for the highest number possible (currently about half way there).
Calculating it this way gives me bench marks other than a number of months. Instead of thinking, “I have enough for 4 months for neither of us working,” I can think “I have enough for 6 months of me not working.” It seems silly, but it helps me to concretely visualize what the emergency savings is for.
1) I am still working, but my spouse is not contributing to the household.
2) My spouse is working, but I am not and we need to pay for COBRA for health insurance.
3) Neither of is working and we need to pay for COBRA for health insurance.
The calculation includes:
rent & energy & net access,
min. student loan payments,
groceries,
healthcare costs,
bus fare & bicycle maintenance,
a trip to visit my sister, and a trip to visit his family. (Depending on the nature of the emergency, family support would be a necessary expense!)
And typing this up, I just realized I left out our cell phones (we have no landline).
Back to Excel…
November 19th, 2008 at 1:26 pm
If you want to know how much setting aside an emergency fund versus not funding an emergency fund while paying off credit card debt, I suggest downloading a debt payoff spreadsheet. Plug numbers in. First one if you didn’t set aside a monthly amount to fund an emergency account. Second if you do set aside any money for an emergency account. It used to be you’d find the difference is only 1-3 months. However, that may be a little different now since credit card companies have been jacking their interest rates to 20%-30% and above. If this is happening to you, I suggest you find alternate ways to pay off the credit card quickly - like borrow from family, or barring that, transfer the balance to a social lending site like lendingclub.com or prosper.com.
November 19th, 2008 at 1:31 pm
An interesting article, I’m living off my emergency fund now (gone back to school). One thing I somewhat disagree with is to not use credit to pay for emergencies. I think if I had it to do over again, I’d have paid off a bit more of the mortgage earlier, and had my emergency fund backed up by a LOC (low interest of course!)
November 19th, 2008 at 1:34 pm
Excellent and timely advice! The comments and real-life stories from everyone are as valuable as the original post.
Here’s a tip: If you’re living paycheck-to-paycheck and absolutely cannot afford to sock money away for an emergency fund, SELL something (or a lot of somethings) to raise that money. A car you rarely drive, an extra refrigerator out in the garage, that old coin collection you inherited… if you don’t NEED it, sell it… because you NEED an emergency fund!
November 19th, 2008 at 1:56 pm
Great article–I’m sending the link to my five children. One of the things I didn’t see mentioned, however, was having more money in an emergency fund if you’re over 50. If you’re 50+ and out of a job, it will take you longer to find employment, and I don’t believe that companies are willing to pay the salaries that the over- 50 job seeker was paid at his or her previous job.
Because I am on disability and my 55+ year old husband works in the tech industry, we have enough in an emergency fund (online high yield savings and CD ladders) to last through over a year of unemployment, which would also include COBRA payments. My new mantra is, however, “please don’t lay him off until he’s 59 1/2.”
November 19th, 2008 at 1:57 pm
To me I don’t think it matters really whether the emergency fund is an extra couple thousand “cushion” in checking, in a low interest savings account, high interest savings account or in cds. The most important thing is to have the mindset of having additional money that is not spent in the day to day, month in month out spending activities. To me that change in thinking was the most important difference between either not saving and getting ahead financially. Once you get in the mindset of having more money than you spend, the rest of the goals (paying off debt, saving for retirement) become alot easier.
I do not have as large as an emergency fund as recommended but at the same time I’ve rarely needed to touch the e-fund because I have enough leeway in my regular checking account to account for small disasters. However I do want to remedy that, and do want to say that however it is done to move to where you are not paying bills month to month is more important than reaching a specific “magic number”.
November 19th, 2008 at 1:59 pm
One more thought on actual experience: even as a grad student, I was able to save enough to cover close to 6-months expenses. Three months before graduation, I was laid off from my job. I took this as a blessing, and dedicated myself to finishing my thesis full-time. Once I graduated, I started looking for work and drawing unemployment, and about 3 months after graduation, I started my current job.
I won’t lie, the last month before finding a job I started arguing with roommates over whose $1.39 can of juice was in the freezer, but it was a huge relief to not have to worry about looking for work while in grad school.
Also, at the time we had a CSA subscription so there was a pre-paid almost*-guaranteed minimum supply of vegetables and eggs. Even now we probably have a month’s worth of food in our pantry and freezer. That’s another form of savings.
And, yes, there is a certain minimum cash savings in our apartment for those true disasters. Most of it is in the online savings account where my paycheck is direct-deposited, though.
*Depending on how the farm does.
November 19th, 2008 at 2:12 pm
This is probably the one area where I find myself identifying with married folks with one spouse saying at home with the kids. As a single girl I don’t think I’ll be comfortable until I have a year of bare minimum expenses (rent, power, phone, student loan minimums, food, gas) tucked away. I guess I feel more insecure with just my income and no one to back me up. The extra benefit of an emergency fund, for me, is helping me sleep better at night, so I want to feel as secure as possible. Having even a small EF has been really empowering.
I have also started layering my EF as some other commenters have suggested. I am loathe to touch my actual EF so I started a “car” account. I think I may also start an “oops” account for little expenses I overlooked or forgot to plan for.
November 19th, 2008 at 2:17 pm
We use a layered approach to emergency funds too.
Layer 1 - I haven’t kept much cash on hand recently, but we used to each have $100 at the house and $20 in our wallets.
Layer 2 - The proscribed $1,000 basic emergency funds are left in our brick & mortar bank, earning a sad little .25%, but is purely liquid. With winter so dangerous here, it isn’t comfortable to wait 3-5 days for funds to transfer from an online-only account to our checking account. Last winter we had to buy a generator because an ice storm killed the power for 9-10 days (and the hotels were already full before the power went out).
Layer 3 - Anything above and beyond the basic funds gets transferred to our online savings account. We’re trying to pay off credit cards and back taxes, so we only transfer a token amount to this one each month. Windfalls and extra money leftover at the end of the month gets transferred too.
Once we hit a certain number in our online account, we’re going to start a CD ladder or T-Bill ladder. I’m not worried about that yet, though- it’s not necessary to do the research until we get closer to that crossroad.
November 19th, 2008 at 2:28 pm
I am not sure that the EF is a “one-size-fits-all” deal. I think the size of it also depends on your family circumstances. We have a 3-yr old and I am amazed at how many ‘emergencies’ crop up - from sudden requests from the daycare for activities, raffles etc to ER visits over the weekend. This month so far we have spent $100 or so for unplanned events connected to our son. When people talk about the cost of having children, I always think of all these expenses which articles/posts usually do not mention. Maybe I’ll write a guest post for JD about this
Another thing I wanted to bring up is that PLEASE take the time to inform all your family members where your EF is and how to access it. Some of it should definitely be in cash at home, even if it is $100.
Thanks for the great site JD. I enjoy your posts.
November 19th, 2008 at 2:31 pm
Based partly on becoming a GRS reader early in ‘08, I started an emergency fund. My method was to open an ING savings account, then start automatic withdrawals from my checking account, once a month. I also added money into the account when I had a little extra. I hit 25% of my goal (5 months expenses) last month, and I have not missed that money (much). Assuming my company will still hand out bonuses next month (we are profitable), I’ll be putting 50% of that into the emergency fund.
Automatic withdrawals are the key. Even if it’s just a trickle of money flowing into your emergency fund, it will build up. And as your circumstances improve, you can bump up those contributions.
Starting this emergency fund, and growing it, has been very significant for me. It is a tangible way to for me to take care of myself and take control of my money. I’ve never put aside this much money for anything that wasn’t “fun” (like a big trip). But this gives me a different kind of satisfaction — I realize that I now have my eyes open about money and personal responsibility.
November 19th, 2008 at 2:50 pm
I still don’t completely understand why to have an emergency fund, especially while paying off debt.
If you put the $1000 onto a credit card instead, you automatically start earning that interest rate. If you have an emergency you can put the $1000 back onto the credit card, and you are where you started. But if that emergency doesn’t come up (odds are probably pretty good but I’m just guessing) you are ahead of the game because you are earning a better return by not paying 20% on your credit card.
I can understand it after you pay off debt, though I’m not completely sold on the idea myself. Before your debt is paid off I think it is counterproductive.
-Nate
November 19th, 2008 at 2:51 pm
Ah, e-funds. They create such controversy sometimes… Those who crunch the numbers argue that the measly savings interest doesn’t come close to the finance charges the credit cards and loans earn, which is true, and whomever doesn’t just pay down debt first aught to have their head examined.
But, honestly? I was $50k in debt because of student loans (less than 8000 of that was non-student loans) 3 years ago. I have funneled as much as possible into those debts, but I also know that I will not be able to pay off those loans in a year, in 3 years, or even 5 years. I’d have to pay over $1000 a month to pay them off in 5 years after interest is applied. That is almost half my paycheck after taxes and benefits (no retirement set up yet), and while my rent isn’t a huge amount, and I could easily cut out things like cable and internet and maybe (gasp) change my phone to a pre-pay or something, I’m not going to for a while… I’m current and ahead on my bills, and I have an emergency fund that bare-bones covers 2 months of bills and part of a 3rd… I think I’ve now paid the debt down to less than $43000, but I promised myself I wasn’t going to check again and figure it out to the penny until after Christmas.
I’d like to think that in 5 years I’ll have a significant part of them paid off, but other than that? I’ll probably have to buy a new (at least to me) car, I will have to move at least once more (2 moves across state lines in 4 years, that’s where some of that non-student loan debt comes from), I might get married, I might have a kid, I would like to think I’ll be in a house with my husband and kid.
Yeah, I’m losing out on a few bucks of interest here and there, and as a math teacher I can figure out just how many. But I like knowing that, when I have to get a new car in a few years, I’ll have money to make a down payment and I can finance a fraction of the cost as opposed to the whole thing. If I didn’t have a down payment set aside, I might not be able to finance the full amount, whether I paid off debt or not, whether I bought used or new, so an emergency fund is more helpful.
Once I’m in a situation where I can feasibly pay off my debt in less than 2 years, then I will move mountains to do so and screw the emergency fund, I’ll take my chances, withdraw a portion and make a huge payment, and hope nothing happens (maybe keep $1k set aside). Until then, I’ll keep current or as far ahead as I can while setting money aside for that future house down payment and such, and enjoy my cable.
November 19th, 2008 at 3:01 pm
If you’ve got high interest debt (credit card), I don’t really see the point of an emergency fund. That should be paid off first, then any type of savings/emergency fund should be considered. There isn’t a disadvantage to paying down your debt (and in turn increasing your available credit in case of an emergency). Whereas if you put together some kind of fund, you’re losing out on the 20% in interest that your debt is costing you, waiting for a rainy day that probably will not come.
November 19th, 2008 at 3:13 pm
We started our emergency fund after attending a Dave Ramsey Total Money Makeover Event and feel much more secure now that it is in place. Ours began with $1000.00 and it is held in an ING savings account. $75.00 is directly deposited into the account biweekly from my husband’s paychecks, and I plan to increase the amount to $100.00 biweekly when our credit card debt is paid off in January. When we come into windfalls, like the most recent rebate from Uncle Sam, they go straight into the emergency fund. My goal is to have $10,000.00 in our fund by June of 2009 and I will feel that it is “fully funded” when we’ve accumulated at least $25,000.00. Luckily (and knock on wood) we have not had to use our fund since starting it several years ago. I believe the keys to good emergency fund management are 1. Automatic funding (e.g., direct deposit, auto transfers, etc.); 2. A high interest savings account; and 3. DISCIPLINE! Good job to all of you have an emergency fund and good luck to all of those who are beginning one.
November 19th, 2008 at 3:15 pm
I said it in my post but I admit I get long winded:
The reason to have an e-acct vs cc for an emergency is because the e-acct belongs to you. No one can change the rules and close that acct (assuming you aren’t doing anything that might lead to having your bank accounts frozen). The difference between the balance and limit on your credit card is only implied by the creditor and subject to change. And even if everything is fine what if the emergency doesn’t take credit? What if it means covering your rent because you lost your job last week and your last check won’t cover it? I don’t know about you but I can’t pay my mortgage on credit, nor (as a landlord) do I accept it as a payment for rent owed to me. You can take a cash advance, but those rates are higher and if you have a balance it is the last bit you will pay off (assuming you have your PIN and other info you need to ACCESS that cash advance).
WRT the larger e-acct if you rely on a line of credit or similar account, that can be a good tool but those are often based on your ability to repay. If you lose your job that means your access to that credit may be lost as well.
November 19th, 2008 at 3:30 pm
We put such a high percentage of our monthly income into an emergency fund that, now that I’ve been downsized, we don’t need to use it yet. We got so used to living on the smaller amount that my unemployment is keeping us afloat while I job hunt, even though I’ve heard so many people moan about how little money it is compared to their old salary.
So, the act of saving has been as much of a help as the actual money that results.
Once our emergency fund overflows the cap we decide on, then we set up an electronic “funnel” to send the extra into a home improvement fund, and then once that’s filled, we’d go on to a vacation fund. It’s like a series of waterfalls along a stream.
November 19th, 2008 at 3:33 pm
@118:
I’ll add to Shara’s comment to say that another way an Emergency Fund is improtant before paying down debt is this: If you are out of work for an extended period of time, you can still pay the monthly minimums on all your debts.
November 19th, 2008 at 3:36 pm
Like everyone else, I agree that having an e-fund is critical. I’m currently building up my e-fund in a money market acct. where I can quickly transfer money over to my checking account if I should ever need it. I put money in the e-fund each month.
Another way I like to save is by doing a match with my travel fund. I like to travel as often as I can, but I don’t want saving for travel to derail my emergency savings plan. So for every dollar I put into the travel fund, I match it by putting a dollar into my e-fund. It’s a great motivation for me to keep on saving.
November 19th, 2008 at 3:40 pm
We’ve done the CD Ladder for our emergency fund…just started last month, so we have 3 CDS - 6, 9 & 12 month, we’ll do the same the next few months and then do the rest in 6 month after that. When the non-annual CDs come due, we’ll convert them to 12 month CDs so that we’ll have a chunk of our emergency fund available every month. We’ll also keep one month’s expenses in a high-yield savings account.
November 19th, 2008 at 3:48 pm
After seeing friends and family members go through major emergancies it was clear that I needed to build cash reserves. I have seen people sell prized possessions at a fraction of their value and go with out necessities after job loss because they live payday-to-payay. I got a part time job(which I like)just to build my emergancy fund, after three years I have $10,000 in a high yield savings account.(I only make about 30,000 a year at my full time job) I still have the part time job and am using what I make there to fund My IRA. It is rough sometimes, but the feeling of security I get makes it worth while.
November 19th, 2008 at 4:19 pm
The jar method.
We have three jars on the counter and each one has a purpose. We feed these jars with the same amount of cash in each jar every day. The amount is based on budgeting.
The first jar is for savings. We are saving for an emergency fund, a car (which could turn into an emergency), and for a vacation. So this money periodically goes back into an interest or dividend bearing account. This money will be split 70% for an emergency fund, 20% for a car fund, and 10% for a vacation fund.
The second jar is our spending jar. This jar is used for gas, food, clothes etc. Once it is gone, nothing gets spent. However, basic bills like electricity are still paid by check. Again this is budgeted.
The third jar we call “tithing”. In addition to donating, we use this for medical treatment for our special son and gift giving.
This method has helped us several ways:
1) It helps us control our spending, no more plastic which is easy to use.
2) It helps us set priorities in what we do, how we save and how we spend.
3) It has forced us to think about cash flow, income. Try to feed these jars on a regular basis. It is not easy. Increase the amount as your income increases.
It works if you do not cheat!
I recommend that you to set up the jars in a way that works for your individual circumstance.
November 19th, 2008 at 4:31 pm
I first learned about this concept from Dave Ramsey about 4 years ago. I started by putting away small amounts say of like $20 a month. Then when I would get a bonus I would add that to my savings account. It ended up being perfect because I had to quit my job due to the stress and I was able to take off a year from working and was not in any debt! That was a true emergency for me…my mental health. I’ve since gotten a better job and have started to build one up again…slowly but surely.
November 19th, 2008 at 4:36 pm
We have a combination of CD ladders and internet savings account. We keep over 6 months of expenses due to my husband being self-employed, but the peace of mind is priceless. It was an absolute lifesaver when he was starting his business and I was looking for a better job. I talk to anyone and everyone about having e-funds whenever I can–they can’t be overrated!
November 19th, 2008 at 4:40 pm
While I think individuals or single-income families should have 6 months of expenses available as an emergency fund, I think dual-income couples can get by with a 3-month emergency fund. I think it’s very unlikely that both people will lose their jobs simultaneously, and thus a 3-month money supply would actually last 6 months, since it’s only covering half the bills (with the still-employed partner providing their usual half).
As for CD’s, I don’t really agree with the argument that they’re a bad idea on the grounds that you pay penalties for early withdrawal. For one thing, you can never lose more than you’ve put in (your principle), so at worst, you’ll only get a 0% rate of return. However, since it’s an EMERGENCY fund, you should very rarely need to touch it. So, for 10 3-month terms in a row, you didn’t need to touch it, and it grew at 3% APR (or whatever). Then, one day, you needed to crack into it early, and forfeited a couple months’ worth of interest. Still, isn’t that better than having it sit in a bank account earning pennies during the years you *didn’t* need it?
One last thing - I don’t see the problem with using credit for an emergency fund, as long as it’s for a short term. For example, if you store your emergency fund money in CDs, and suddenly need access to a large sum of money, is it really that bad to draw from a line of credit for 2 or 3 months until your CD matures and you can access your funds without penalty? I think you’ve got to weigh the long term interest gains of the CDs against the (hopefully!) rare time you actually need to access your emergency fund, and possibly pay a little interest on your money. Overall, you should come out ahead by relying on credit in the (very) short term, and locking your money away for medium-length terms (I’m talking a few months at most) for some bigger gains.
November 19th, 2008 at 5:09 pm
One way we pad our emergency fund is with those extra paychecks that we get on the months with 5 Fridays (weekly paycheck) or a 3rd pay week in one month (like this last October) — transfer those directly to savings!
November 19th, 2008 at 5:14 pm
This is a great article. I am very very bad at saving and it is difficult for me to have money in the bank and not spend it. But I am trying! Interestingly enough, I have no trouble saving for retirement.
I think that I need to open one of these ING or similar accounts, to keep my saved cash out of arm’s reach, so I only access it in a “real” emergency.
November 19th, 2008 at 5:28 pm
I have an emergency fund that I have had for years. I sometimes add to it, but I never allow it to fall below a certain amount. I am also now creating a “slush” fund for irregular expenses and future planned expenses such as co-pays, postage, car registration, greeting cards/gifts and a newer vehicle. My husband and I also have a “nest egg” that was given to us as a wedding gift. Right now, the entire amount is in a CD which will mature in January. Once that is available, we will be investing some of it for retirement and the rest will go into a CD ladder. My husband has a nice bit of savings, but it just sits. He is not proactive about making it grow faster.
November 19th, 2008 at 6:57 pm
Incredible response by everyone!
This post comes at a timely yet tremendously unfortunate time for a relative of mine whose house has just been severely damaged by the wildfires in southern California. Although she is in grief over the situation, she is glad to be safe and have an emergency fund that can support her until she can get further help. She told me that a lot of her neighbors aren’t as fortunate and have no where to turn to during this catastrophe. Emergency funds are often talked about in personal finance but I still feel like not enough people understand the importance of them. I hope this helps get the word out.
November 19th, 2008 at 7:34 pm
I’m doing the Ramsey baby steps, and I modified, albeit slightly, to accomodate my crappy grad-student income and suffocating debt.
Instead of starting with 1000 in savings, I started with 200 and dumped 25 a week.
Did I get flamed on a few blogs? I sure did. While tons of people are stellar at dishing advice, not too many are adept at sitting down and budgeting MY life. So I did it, took the heat and by the time I got up to 1,000, my credit card debt went from 3 grand to 500.
Without the MINI emergency fund in place, I’d probably have a lot more scalp to show for it.
November 19th, 2008 at 7:40 pm
I am so thankful my father stressed the importance of an emergency fund as I was growing up. When I was about 12 years old, he was laid off from his job and there was a few-month gap before he was able to get a comparable one. I know that our family carried high monthly expenses, so this period was difficult to get through. I’m glad he shared his wisdom from that life experience with me because I learned to be a saver and have always had a substantial emergency fund. Now I have a six-month fund growing (not as high as it used to be) interest in an ING Orange Savings account. Though I have not had to use it yet, the security and peace of mind it provides is priceless.
November 19th, 2008 at 7:52 pm
I guess I’m a little paranoid.
Even while I was in high-school, I’ve always felt comfortable only when I had enough money to survive roughly a year without a job. This isn’t luxury living, mind you — just the bare essentials.
I found it was easy to save money by simply taking all of my change and putting it in one safe place — and by “change” I include the $1 bills. This got the emergency savings up there in no time flat.
Don’t forget that it’s not just money that you’ll need in an emergency. I also like to keep water, food and ammo (no joke!) just in case. Worst case scenario? I’ll be a regular Davey Crockett.
November 19th, 2008 at 8:18 pm
I recently finished funding a 12-month efund. I live frugally and it covers all my monthly expenses so, if something were to happen to me, there would be no change in lifestyle. It did take many years to fund. I’ve sold items around the house to help fund it, added extra money from other sources and cancelled most monthly subscriptions (i.e. tivo, netflix and gym memberships). Now I’m considering adding Netflix back into my budget, but I don’t add any recurring monthly charge until I save 12-months of that expense in my efund. This helps me decide how important it is to have that particular expense and slows down/stops impulse spending. For instance, if Netflix is $20/month, I have to put $240 in my efund before subscribing to the service.
The amount a person should have in an efund is very personal. I’m single and there would be no one to help me if I found myself in an emergency situation. Several years ago, my mother became very ill and I left my job and travelled to the state she lived to take care of her. I was still paying rent, utilities, etc in my hometown since I didn’t know how long I would be away. All my expenses went on my cc, but as others have mentioned, a payment has to be made monthly on that cc. It got to the point were I could no longer charge additional expenses on the card because the payment became so high and eventually I couldn’t afford to pay for my basic needs.
Relying on a cc for an emergency for longer than a month is very scary. My life experience was a wake up call and caused me to do whatever was needed to save money in an efund. When in an emergency, a person would want to focus on that situation, not the situation and the stress of how to pay rent/mortgage or keep food in the fridge. In addition, even if a person has disability insurance, there may be a need to hire someone to help around the house, to run errands or help with doctor appointments.
As far as where to keep the money, I originally had it in 12 one-year cd’s earning about 5.5% interest. Each cd contained enough money to pay for one month’s expenses. But since the cd’s have recently matured and the interest rates have dropped, I put the money in my checking account earning 5% interest and keep a simple spreadsheet showing which part of the balance is the efund. However, I recently found out that I have access to a particular savings account through work and it earns almost the same amount of interest and there are no taxes on the interest until it is withdrawn. I may move most of my money to that account in the near future.
November 19th, 2008 at 8:57 pm
An important point that Dylan makes is accessing only what you need from your emergency fund and rebuilding it as soon as you can. I recently had to cover major dental work, and though I was tempted to round up to the nearest thousand (I like making transactions in round numbers!), I disciplined myself to round down.
I also received $700+ in insurance reimbursement. At first, I thought of it as found money, but then realized “No, this goes right back into the emergency fund.” And I rounded it up, and put back in $1000 right away.
So I’m $2000 ahead of where I would have been, had my first undisciplined instincts ruled the day….
November 19th, 2008 at 10:01 pm
I just started my emergency fund this year based on information from this website as well as The Simple Dollar. Thinking about it now, I can’t believe I went so many years without one. Since I’m single and would rather have more than necessary, I’d like to have a year’s worth of net income saved. Since I get paid every two weeks, there are two (very occasionally three!) extra paychecks a year. Since I’m now on a spending plan based on two checks a month, I should be able to save those extras. Those two checks plus my biweekly savings and tax return should have me able to get to this goal in about 24 months, God willing. At this point, I’m all hopped up on savings! I think my fellow employees are a little burned out on hearing about it, but it’s like suddenly seeing the light and wanting everyone to know what they could be doing for themselves. I was randomly selected to do a survey about my satisfaction with the Thrift Savings Plan (federal 401k, basically), and one section asked for suggestions as to how they could encourage participation. I suggested basic financial education about the benefits of starting as early as possible and how compound interest can do wonders. I wish I had known that years ago, but better now than later! I’m happy to be doing the smart thing now. As far as excess monies after the EF is fully funded, well I guess that’s when I’ll turn my attention to investing - but fairly conservatively at this point in my life. Thanks for all the great help here on GRS.
November 19th, 2008 at 10:48 pm
Announced in the 2008 budget, as of 2009, Canada has a new TFSA - tax-free savings account. This is a registered account, much like an RRSP (registered retirement savings plan), in which you can save up money without paying any taxes (obviously). The difference is that with an RRSP, once the money is invested, you are taxed on the money when you withdraw it. The TFSA, however, is something totally different.
ING Direct is already offering TFSAs - and since it doesn’t kick in until 2009, they are doubling interest rates to offset any taxes you might have to pay. So, it is now possible to save up to $5000 a year tax free. But here’s the great thing, which makes it far superior to an RRSP - you can withdraw that money at any time, use it, and put it back in (as long as you don’t go over that $5000 limit).
So, my Emergency Fund is now growing tax-free at ING. If something dire should arise, I can pull that money out, weather the storm, and start putting the money back in. The amount in that account still hasn’t reached the $5000 limit, but that will be my eventual goal.
I realise that many readers of this blog are in the States, but I count myself among one of the stalwart Canadians who subscribes to the Get Rich Slowly feed. Thanks for letting me share my two cents!
Click on the link at my name to an informative article about the TFSA.
November 19th, 2008 at 10:49 pm
I have a suggestion for those who are building their emergency fund and want to take advantage of the higher interest rates that CD’s can offer and at the same time, not tie up all your funds in CD’s that are not very liquid. Try scaffolding and diversifying your emergency fund monies. Diversify by putting some money in each of several different types of accounts and at different banking institutions and scaffold by investing some of those monies in CD’s that mature at different dates. For instance, you may put 1,000 in a savings, 1,000 in a money market account and divide another 2,000 into 2 or more Cds with different maturity dates. Eventually, you could have money in Cd’s that each expire one month after the next. You’ll have to decide how much goes into each account. Also, inquire at your bank for special rates for CD’s. My Credit Union has monthly rate changes and periodic “specials”.
November 19th, 2008 at 11:21 pm
@bjc
Thank you for the great link, being a Canadian myself it is difficult at times to find Canadian exclusive finance advice.
ING has ads everywhere for this new account, they are really emphasizing the importance of it in today’s economy.
November 19th, 2008 at 11:50 pm
I can’t agree with this post more. Even though I’m only 24, I tell everyone I run into about starting, getting, and keeping an emergency fund. However, I’ve noticed that most “20-somethings” make excuses why they can’t save. My emergency fund started with me just saving about $5-$10 per paycheck. To me that’s 2 trips to starbucks or a drink at a bar. Now, I save a lot more than that per paycheck.
That’s the key…a reasonable amount should be saved every paycheck. Having this has definitely helped me protect my credit.
Last comment on emergency funds…They are the best kind of insurance because they reward you three times over. There’s cash available for an emergency, and if you end up not needing it for some time it gains some interest, and then if you’re really good and know that you’re basis are covered…You can use a portion of it to treat yourself. I recently bought a macbook pro with a small portion of my emergency fund.
November 20th, 2008 at 2:51 am
The best thing about an emergency fund is that it turns financial emergencies into mere inconveniences. For example, my husband had a pay problem over the summer, where instead of getting paid $2000 a paycheck, he got paid $150 a paycheck! Not kidding! This went on for three months. Luckily, between my paycheck and our emergency fund, it was just annoying more than anything. If we had never put money into our savings accounts, we would have been forced to put almost $3000 on our credit cards. But instead we just had to wait it out and pull from our savings. Since then we paid ourselves back and bumped up our emergency fund to almost 6 months of expenses.
Right now our money is just sitting in a savings account earning about 2%. But once we get it up to cover 12 months of expenses, I’d like to start laddering CDs just like Cally (@141) suggested.
For any Soldiers who might be reading, there is a great program called the Savings Deposit Program. During a deployment, you can put up to $10,000 into the program and it will earn 10% interest while you are downrange. Now that’s a nice deal!
November 20th, 2008 at 4:42 am
I have about $15k in a Wamu savings account as an emergency fund.
I try to find the best possible rates for this fund. Therefore, from Chase (that has one of the lowest interest rates…) I moved to ING and then to Wamu. Unfortunately Chase bought Wamu and the first thing they did was to reduce all interest rates. Now I am moving to GMAC…
It sounds like a hassle but my $15k get me about $40/month. So looking for the best interest rate once every month (and spending time to setup a new account and transfer the money, 1-2 hours max) is a well paid job.
November 20th, 2008 at 6:39 am
Ironically, if the Big 3 would have built an emergency fund, they wouldn’t need to be begging the government to give them a bailout. Works for businesses and individuals. Great tool!
November 20th, 2008 at 9:01 am
For the Canadians on the blog: the new Tax Free Savings Account will be offered at all banks and investment houses, not just ING.
Shop around!
November 20th, 2008 at 9:21 am
I would just like to take this opportunity to urge people not only to avoid using credit cards as an emergency fund, but not to use “leftover” loan money as an emergency fund. I know numerous people who have gotten too much money from loans and just held onto it as an emergency fund. Imagine how much interest could have been saved by immediately returning the unneeded loan money and then working to save up the emergency fund? Or perhaps, saving up while paying back the loan money if you are worried to be without an emergency fund.
I simply saved up an emergency fund while continuing to make overpayments on loans, because I knew if I were in trouble before I had a large enough fund, that I could quickly get a few thousand in an interest free loan from my parents, though not all people have that luxury, it is something to think about if you are starting an emergency fund but also have debt.
November 20th, 2008 at 10:05 am
I started a savings account/emergency fund at a credit union seven years ago. I also unexpectedly had to buy a new car at that time, and I’d been getting mailers from the CU offering a terrific auto loan refinance rate. Later on I did refinance.
I made regular automatic deposits from my paycheck all those years. To avoid temptation, I didn’t get a debit card for the account. Nor did I immediately go for electronic transfers between the CU and my bank, when that first became available.
My first rainy day has come: my share of medical bills from recent surgery. It’s a great feeling having the cash to cover it.
My bank can process an electronic transfer overnight, and doesn’t charge for the service. But I make the transfer from the CU’s end because the bank’s process has one requirement I can’t meet, and another one I’m not thrilled about anyway.
The CU charges a $10 transaction fee, which is perfectly reasonable yet still enough to make one consider each transfer carefully. Even though I have the the process set up now, I won’t transfer funds again except in real need or emergency situations. I’ve always felt that the day I tap the CU account for anything less, I have a bigger problem than the immediate need or emergency.
November 20th, 2008 at 10:10 am
My family is on a modified “Dave Ramsey Plan”. We have $1,000.00 in savings, $300 in small bills in our safe at home, and a months supply of water and nonperishable food in case of emergency. We’ve been concentrating on paying down credit card debt. Luckily, the interest we are paying on our debt is 3.99% fixed. It could be far worse. I know I would feel much better if we had more in the emergency fund, since the $1,000 wouldn’t cover even one month of our mortgage payment if my husband lost his job.
Thank you for this blog and the comments. One day I will be debt free with a six month emergency fund again. For those of you who don’t see the need for an emergency fund, I hope you rethink that.
November 20th, 2008 at 10:42 am
I have to say that having an emergency fund was such a relief when my husband lost his job in August. My parents gave me $5000 when I graduated from college and so I put a portion of it in a high-yield savings account. If we did not have an emergency fund, I would have stressed and freaked out over his job loss. Instead we made lemonade with the lemons and my husband decided to go to school full time.
November 20th, 2008 at 11:07 am
I’m the kind of person who uses a credit card for most expenses, but I always pay it off in full every month. It gives me a little cash back, so I use it for everyday things. I have an emergency fund, so therefore I feel OK using a credit card in an emergency because I can just pay off the extra charges on the card with the emergency fund money.
November 20th, 2008 at 11:26 am
In our house, we never really agreed upon an emergency fund. For the past two years we have been aggressively paying down our credit cards, and my husband did not see the need for an emergency fund: he felt it would take away from our debt repayments. I felt it would prevent us from adding to our debt. I admit that I did a bad thing: I hid some money in an envelope. I did sort of tell him about it, and if something had happened to me, he definitely would have found it, because he knows where I hide things.
In the end, he agreed that it would be good for us to get in the habit of saving, because now that we are close to getting out of debt, we don’t want to ever be back in debt.
So we started an emergency fund, mostly by increasing the cushion in our accounts. It’s pretty good for peace of mind, and when his sister’s car needed a repair while we were borrowing it, we could pay for it.
November 20th, 2008 at 11:32 am
It’s important to have a $1000 emergency fund BEFORE starting to pay down debt. Otherwise, any emergency that comes up will be paid for once again with credit.
1. $1000 emergency fund
2. Pay down debt. Smallest debt first and once done, snowball this payment amount towards the next smallest, etc.
3. 3-6 months emergency fund
etc, etc, etc
We’ve followed Dave Ramsey’s Financial Peace program and swear by it.
November 20th, 2008 at 11:39 am
Your Emergency Fund should NOT be an investment. Park it in a “secure” savings account or money market and leave it alone. After it’s fully funded, then you can start investing your other money.
November 20th, 2008 at 11:42 am
My husband and I are young-barely 23-but we have $20,000 in emergency money. You never know, and it allows us to be able to relax. Anything additional goes towards additional student loan payments (consolidated for low rates) and saving for a house, which we are well on our way to achieving. We drive crappy cars, rarely eat out, but we have more in the bank than any of our friends and waaaay more peace of mind even in this economy. I’m a huge advocate of this system.
November 20th, 2008 at 12:43 pm
My wife and I handle our emergency fund a bit differently, and for the most part, it goes against many of the suggestions here, but I don’t personally see a downside. I would be interested to hear opinions.
Each month we make a payment on our home equity line of credit that is four times the interest charged that month. One quarter of that payment goes to the monthly interest, one quarter goes to paying off the principle, and the other half is our emergency fund. We keep track of how much of our payed off line of credit is actually the emergency fund so we know how much we have available.
The benefit in my eyes is that we have the emergency fund available, but if we don’t need it we have the advantage of not paying interest on that money.
November 20th, 2008 at 12:59 pm
REASON BEHIND THE PLAN: I was sick and couldn’t work for about a year and a half. During that time, a hurricane hit, flooding my condo and car. I think that determining if a 3-month/8-month, etc., emergency fund is right for you is an excellent starting point for most people. But now that we are more comfortable with our finances and now that we are (mostly) out of debt, having an 8-month emergency fund (or however many months you choose), is not enough for us.
BREAKDOWN: We now want 8 months living expenses (we call this our “lose job fund”), plus $6000 (which is the most we would pay per year no matter if we use his company’s medical insurance or mine) plus $2000 to $3000 (for things the medical insurance won’t pay for) in a medical emergency fund, $500 for car insurance deductible plus $3000 for car repairs (one car is 10 years old) in the car emergency fund, $500 for home insurance deductible plus $1000 for miscellaneous house emergencies (appliances going out, etc.) in the house emergency fund. Multiple things can go wrong at the same time as I learned the hard way.
THOUGHT PROCESS: FYI, the reason we have multiple emergency funds instead of “the” emergency fund is 1) to make sure we keep enough money in there (car deductible may raise $500 and $500 against $20k isn’t something to worry about; but against $3500, $500 seems like a lot) and 2) since we will have all the money in one high yield ING account, it’s tempting to look at that $20k or so lump sum figure and spend it on a new car, etc.. Breaking the money down and thinking of it the way we do makes the money less tempting to spend.
PLACEMENT: We aren’t there yet, since we want to finish the student loans before we start (everything but the mortgage and student loans is paid). But this is our plan. We plan on keeping at least a $1000 for each fund plus one month’s living expenses in the local bank. All the rest will be in ING savings.
REPLENISHING: Also, even though most of the money is in a high yield account, it will never keep up with inflation so each month we will contribute “X” amount of money to the funds. In the event we do have a true emergency, our budget isn’t so tight that it takes a few years to build the funds back up again. If 100% of all emergency funds are spent, then we plan on being able to replenish this entire amount in about a 12-month time (barring future emergencies). And during this replenishing period, we plan on having adequate spending money. We plan on buying less house than we can afford in order to be able to do this.
November 20th, 2008 at 1:00 pm
I am a big fan of starting small when overwhelmed by the prospect of accumulating a 6 month emergency fund. For my EF it has been a slow progression. Keeping a $20 in my car, maintaining a $1000 cushion in checking, automating a weekly $20 to our personal savings accounts were some of the small steps I took before becoming serious about having a true emergency cash fund.
Online banking and automating savings made it substantially easier for me to save more on a regular basis. Saving for a fun thing (trvel in my case) as I started to save for an EF motivated me.
Reading GRS made realize how lucky my husband and I have been. I feel like a dope after decades of depending on credit cards and more recently, our heloc for emergency funds. My sense of how much we need to have on hand has risen after reading the kinds of emergency situations have come up for GRS reader and also in recent events. Saving
has become more natural to me as I read about others struggling and doing the same.
November 20th, 2008 at 1:12 pm
I just started reading this blog and am really enjoying it. Thanks!
As for the emergency fund issue…my husband and I both have good-paying jobs and fairly low budget lifestyle. As a result, we accumulated quite a bit of extra money in our personal and joint accounts, some of which was designated as an “emergency fund” in a money market account.
Now we’re in the midst of a divorce, and I’m facing the reality that much of my emergency fund cushion will be gone. I’d like to keep the house and if I do, will have to forgo keeping most of the money in exchange.
I also will have to adjust to living with a single income and the fact that I won’t be able to rely on a spouse’s paycheck as a backup if I am laid off or become sick and disabled, even temporarily. I find this rather scary, quite frankly.
But, if many of you who are in much worse situations can do it, so can I. I will economize even more and build up the emergency fund as my first priority.
I’ve previously thought about the CD ladder concept as an investment strategy and think I’ll give it a try once the settlement is done.
November 20th, 2008 at 1:19 pm
I’ve just started our emergency fund, but I am not sure where I want to put it (yes, I have $1,000 in an envelope). I like the idea of added interest from an online bank, but I worry about access and I don’t know about how safe they are. How do you find out if a bank if a bank is reputable, ie not going under soon? (I know nothing, really!)
November 20th, 2008 at 1:48 pm
I am finding it hard to build an emergency fund, as well. I have been trying to put money aside, but it’s so tight lately. choose to cut my food budget back to $15/week to try to save, as it’s the only part of my budget that is flexible.
Been trying to put extra money into the bank account that auto-pays my bills, so that if something does happen, i don’t have to worry about those right away. The rest, i’m just trying to build in my local savings account, transfering to my ING when i feel i have enough local for quicker emergencies.
I am glad to see the author of this piece suggest people only save up a month’s worth of emergency fund, before tackling their debt. Compound intrest can help you, or hurt you, depening on which side of the coin you’re on.
November 20th, 2008 at 1:55 pm
TWoP Fan @154: Be sure to see if the online bank is federally insured. Even if it goes under, you will get your money back. When I’m looking to open an account, I go to bankrate.com, which does have a rating system. Is it accurate? I don’t know, but at least it provides some information. I linked my online account with my “brick and mortar” bank account so I can transfer money if needed. However, it can take several days to transfer. I have check writing privileges on my money market account so I keep $ in there, too, because of the access issues of the online savings. The interest rate on the MM is lower than the savings, but I like that it’s accessible.
November 20th, 2008 at 2:13 pm
My wife and I have made a regular practice of contributing to a buffer fund every paycheck.
When I got laid off the first time, we found that it wasn’t so much the cash in the account that helped, but rather the discipline of living below our means.
When we re-structured our spending after the layoff, the first thing to go were our savings contributions, an absolutely painless adjustment.
When I got another job two months later we turned the spigot back on and away we went.
November 20th, 2008 at 2:33 pm
so whats the differance between an emergency fund and an irregular expenses fund? are they the same thing or not?
November 20th, 2008 at 3:02 pm
Right now I have our emergency fund (about 8 months of pared down expenses) in a money market account. I will be using this money to start twelve, 12-month CDs each coming due at about the first of each month in order to capture slightly higher interest rates.
My husband’s job is fairly secure, but we do only have one income. I’d rather be more secure than less so, so we will keep a one-year fund.
November 20th, 2008 at 3:25 pm
@mb
An emergency fund and irregular expense fund are NOT the same thing.
An irregular expense fund is for items that you KNOW are coming, and probably WHEN. For example: car insurance (semi-annual), propane (I pay when it is filled, about 3 times per year), Xmas gifts, etc.
An emergency fund is for things that you DON’T know are coming: Your car needs non-routine work, you visit the E-room, you need a dental crown, your furnace quits, etc.
I have an irregular expense account that acts as a buffer to my emergency fund. Even though it isn’t scheduled I know I am going to need periodic work on my car, visit a doctor, see a vet, or replace something in my house. Some people consider these emergencies. I consider them inevitable.
So there is some grey area and how you bin these expenses is up to you, but the concept of an irregular expense fund vs an emergency fund are completely different.
November 20th, 2008 at 3:48 pm
(Sorry for the length! I realised after I posted it how long it got)
I have been trying to get a grip on my finances, and after seeing the “grand total” of my college loan amount ((shudder)) I realized that I had no idea how to go about finances, or how I was going to pay back more money than I had ever seen in my life. I was not surprised to learn about an emergency fund I mean it seems like a good idea, but to me the amount always seemed to be 500.00 to 1000.00. Then I learned it should be 3 months salary MINIMUM. So I did a little research, I also have been supplementing that knowledge and altering my finance plan.
Currently I have an automatic draw of 10% of my paycheck routed into my savings automatically. I realized if the money isn’t there in my checking for me to spend I can’t spend it. Part of the problem was when I had direct deposit I would just sit on that amount, before I got it routed automatically into the savings. I would sit on it for weeks, and then when I would turn around to deposit it over into savings, it would make the month tight or I wouldn’t have the full amount. I also discovered that if you calculate your finances WITHOUT the money there, you are less likely to see it as useable income. (Even for loans or rent or food)
I had to also take a few months to notice my spending habits and understand what tricks work for me. I have tried a few methods and currently the automatic draw works the best. But I have also set a goal amount for my savings, and I look forward because it’s exciting to see that money grow closer to that amount. I plan to then start putting the additional cash to work I will save through my checking account after that goal amount is reached.
I think the hardest lesson for me and an emergency account was learning do to it without breaking the bank. I got so caught up in the desire and need to have an emergency fund I didn’t realize I was also hurting myself financially. That isn’t the goal of finance, you need to help your self out as much as you can at a time but also learn the financing method that works for you, without causing you so much financial strain you cant eat well for a week. It’s all about finding the balance between you, your spending and your savings.
I need to pay myself first and then re-pay myself later. Work up to my goal amounts and celebrate the milestones. I have had to borrow money out of my savings, but my goal is to pay it back over time, partly because I’m more borrowing the money from myself currently. It isn’t mine in the sense that I can use it at will, I have a strict mental association on it of “This money is set aside for me for emergency situations. If you keep spending the money how can you use it for an emergency?”
I have learned that finance is something that grows with you and needs to. You need to re-evaluate it every few weeks to a couple of months to ensure you are on track, have spending under control and are adjusting. I hope to eventually be able to put 15% of my paycheck aside monthly. Interestingly enough I learned more about personal finances when trying to set up an emergency fund, than just reading a book about it.
November 20th, 2008 at 9:16 pm
Unfortunately I have learned this lesson the hard way. With no emergency fund of any substance, paying for a new heat pump, car repairs (timing belts, motor mounts, etc.) and coping with my wife’s reduced hours at work all at one time became a nightmare. My small emergency fund quickly vanished and was replaced with escalating credit card debt.
I make a good salary but the crunch felt from the credit cards could have been easily avoided with a better emergency cushion. I know that now and am on the way to digging out of the hole. Unfortunately, one of the pieces to pick up is a lost marriage as well. I am not suggesting an emergency fund can save a marriage but the absence of one can absolutely crush your personal finances in the event of an emergency we call life!
November 21st, 2008 at 6:00 am
This is a very timely post. I am recently remarried and while we both have secure jobs and a very nice household income, we are both sloppy when it comes to how we spend. What I mean is that money trickles away without us realizing where it’s gone. We’ve kept separate accounts but opened a joint account for the mortgage and home repair stuff. Well, we stocked up the joint savings account when we bought the house but since it’s been spent, we haven’t restocked it.
I am a CPA and knowledgable about money and savings but haven’t put that knowledge to good use. My new husband is much less knowledgable and also less disciplined.
I am going to show him this column in order to start the discussion I know we need to have. Luckily, there is only one piece of debt (we bought a pool last summer), no car payments, and no credit card debt. In this ecomomy it is truly foolish not to have a plan in place. Thank you!
November 21st, 2008 at 6:29 am
My husband and I began earnestly saving for our “future” a year before our wedding date - financial advice, etc. Our house purchase was planned for. Our son came earlier than we had expected. The medical complications leaving me unable to return to work full-time were unforseen. Eventually I left work all together to recover completely and did side jobs with my husband. I did find a better paying, full-time job in a different industry 7 months later. (Yay!) Needless to say, we burned through our fledgling savings, and my previous employer offered no maternity/illness benefits (to small), or IRA matches. Now we are trying to rebuild the savings, plus to pay the debt we incurred while I was “not holding my own”… And we have extensive maintenance issues that we put on the back burner for a while. I like the advice I’ve read here about “paying yourself first” and about various separate savings accounts. We’ve begun using Quicken to analyze how we spend our money and, hopefully, will be able to come up with appropriate percentages of paycheck deductions to accomplish each savings / repayment goal - esp. a renewed emergency fund. Our last big hurdle (hopefully s.t. you will discuss) is our Michigan mortgage. Yes - we were among those homebuyers who used the 0% option, since we had good incomes (that were going towards rent) but little savings. Now, our home is worth less than our purchase price, but we still can afford our payments - we just can’t afford to sell and move to a better job market.
November 21st, 2008 at 2:40 pm
I actually found this article to be very helpful. I have always struggled between saving for the emergency fund and paying off my debt. I liked Dave Ramsey’s baby steps, but I was slightly uncomfortable with only $1000 in an emergency plan — that’s really one emergency! I liked the suggestion in this artcile of saving for 1 month instead of the 6 months, and then moving back to it once debt is paid for. It was a “duh” moment for me, “why didn’t I think of that?” Thanks for the post.
November 22nd, 2008 at 10:44 am
This is the cut-off point for this article’s book giveaway. The numbers I’ve randomly generated are:
37, 69, 110, 128, 133
Which correspond to the comments here. I’ll e-mail the posters and arrange for shipment!
November 22nd, 2008 at 9:12 pm
If you are subsisting and have irreducible expenses, how do you build an emergency fund?
income: 908
rent (room in house with nine people): 650
medical exp: 110
student loan garnishment: 135
don’t see any way to reduce the expenses
November 23rd, 2008 at 6:34 am
@Poor Boomer
If you can’t reduce the expenses, maybe you should try to increase the income. Get a second part-time job, find a new job, do odds-and-ends jobs to create more money–By just doing a $25 task each week you can build up an emergency fund faster than you would think. You never know what those types of jobs would lead to either. For instance, my uncle took on mowing lawns after his 8am-5pm job and within 3 months the “word had spread” about his services. He now runs a successful landscaping business with 3 crews.
November 23rd, 2008 at 8:20 pm
Wife and I have been building our emergency fund since March of 2008, and started with $300 in a MM account. Our goal is to have $12,000 saved, however whenever we crack the $7000 mark, something comes up that depletes the fund. We cracked the $7000 mark again last Friday, only for my wife’s car to blow out two tires. Now we’ve been told we need to replace all four tires, which will set us back $600. I find it annoying, but my wife keeps reminding me that if we didn’t have the money saved up, I’d REALLY be annoyed right now.
November 24th, 2008 at 3:12 am
Oh wow. 100+ comments! This is going to take me some time to get through - I have a question and I hope someone can answer this for me. After being deeply in debt with just a few hundred dollars in the bank, I managed to dig myself out of the hole and now have about $20k of savings spread out in bonds, and investments.
I don’t really like CDs as the interest rates are so low, and currently, in my country, inflation is about 7% and interest rates for CDs are about 3.5% at most.
With bonds at least I can match the inflation rate.
My question is this: is it a good idea to place your emergency fund in bonds?
November 24th, 2008 at 3:16 am
Oh heck … I realise that bonds have been discussed extensively in this thread. Apologies … and also, I realise that bonds sure work differently in the US. In Malaysia we can withdraw the money with a 10-day wait, and without penalty.
November 24th, 2008 at 11:38 am
After going through a transmission replacement ($2,100) with only a $1,000 emergency fund, I am so excited about the ability to have a real emergency fund. To me, it seems like freedom. For my fiance and I, 6 months of expenses will be $18,000. $18K! Once we have that much money set aside, most emergencies will be no big deal at all.
Transmission? No problem. Last-minute plane ticket? No problem. Water heater explodes? No problem.
Amazing.
November 24th, 2008 at 2:46 pm
I have a mere five grand set aside as a pseudo-emergency fund. If I need more, I’m basically screwed at this point - compounded by the fact that I’m swimming in debt. I realize I need to build up my emergency fund first, so that’s where I’m putting my money right now - even though my debt-load is pretty large. I’m not sure I can ever get out from under this mountain of debt, but at least the wife and I are finally focusing on it and trying to take baby-steps.
November 25th, 2008 at 8:04 am
i leave my emergency fund in igobanking.com checking 3.80% APY for all banking needs except check writing and in bofi.com for check writing 3.40%APY
November 27th, 2008 at 5:26 am
My husband & I were always in sync financially. We both needed to put funds aside for an emergency. That emergency came when he became seriously ill and passed away after three years. Our emergency funds carried us though that. My biggest fear was becoming my sons responsibility. Because of what we put away in saving, IRA’s, ect, I should be able to maintain my independence and not live in fear. With a little planning (I’m learning) I should be able to continue to work my present job, retire in a few years and maybe even travel a little here and there. We enjoyed life but were frugal. We always thought and planned for a ‘what if’.
December 16th, 2008 at 9:07 am
I’d like to add having some cash at home for emergencies i.e, locksmith; superintendent; groceries and prescriptions. backup prescriptions would be good too especially during travel.