Embracing the Thrift-Store Ethic: 18 Top Tips for Buying Used Clothes
Published on - December 14th, 2008 (by J.D. Roth) If the national media is any indication, more people are embracing the notion of buying used clothing from thrift stores and consignment shops. Last week, USA Today ran a story describing how secondhand stores are reaping the benefits of recession:
As Americans look for ways to cut spending, they are scooping up bargain clothes, accessories, toys and furniture once owned by someone else.
“We’re sorry about the economic situation, … but it is a good time for our industry,” says Adele Meyer, executive director of the National Association of Resale & Thrift Shops. Three-fourths of resale stores said they had higher sales in September and October, compared with the same period last year, according to the trade group. The average sales increase was about 35%.
According to the article, 70% of adults surveyed last summer say that buying used is now more socially acceptable than it was a decade ago. Buying used has always been socially acceptable to me. I got in the habit of shopping at thrift stores during high school. It was the only way I could afford to add to my wardrobe. For the past 20 years, buying used has been a natural part of my shopping routine.
Kris and I are fortunate that Portlanders generally embrace the thrift-store ethic, and that we live near a highway lined with used clothing shops. (It’s actually more convenient for us to buy our clothes from thrift stores than any other source!) Here are some of our best tips for buying second-hand clothes:
- Set a budget. This is difficult at first — you don’t know how much things cost. But eventually you’ll be able to tell yourself, “I’m going spend $20 today”. It becomes a game to see how much you can buy for $20.
- Discard your prejudices. Some people consider thrift stores and used clothing shops nasty dirty places. Some are. Most aren’t. Explore your neighborhood. Find a shop or two that you like, and you’ll be hooked.
- Go with a friend. It’s good to have a second opinion. Your friend may have an eye for what looks good on you — and vice versa.
- Try things on. Sizes vary widely between manufacturers and even by eras. (Today’s clothes have looser fits.) But go in knowing your general size and measurements. Note that some places don’t have dressing rooms, so it’s smart to wear a modest thin layer in case you need to strip down in the aisle.
- Examine each item thoroughly. It sucks to get home to find your new shirt has a hole in the pocket. Or that the slacks you thought were a steal actually have a broken zipper.
- Check washing instructions. You don’t want to pay $3 for a silk blouse if you’ll never dry-clean it.
- Use the tags as a guide to find quality brands you like, but don’t limit yourself. Sometimes a brand you’ve never heard of can yield a favorite piece of clothing.
- Think layers. Maybe that shirt with a stain on the sleeve has a great collar for wearing under a sweater. For $3, you can afford to buy a single-purpose shirt.
- Use thrift stores as a way to diversify your wardrobe. Buy colors and styles on which you normally wouldn’t spend much. Wear the new clothes a few times to see how you like them, and to gauge the reaction of others.
- Used clothing stores are great for certain accessories. Why pay $30 for a new belt in a department store when you can get a better belt in your size for just $2? I like to shop at second-hand stores for hats. (Nice hats.)
- Look for clothes new with tags. Sometimes unsold department store inventory finds its way to used clothing stores and thrift shops. You’ll generally pay more for these items, but not much.
- If you won’t wear it, don’t buy it. You don’t save money buying a $3 shirt if it just sits in your closet for two years.
- Wash clothes when you get them home.
- Watch for sales. Used clothing stores (and thrift stores) run periodic specials. Our favorite local store just ran a half-off sale. The local thrift stores often have specials on certain items.
- If you go to the same store often, ask when they rotate stock. Stores get new shipments regularly. Most also have extra stock in storage. If you become familiar with the owners, you might even ask them to keep an eye out for particular items.
- Take your time. At normal clothing shops, everything is neatly organized. Not so at most thrift stores. When thrifting, it’s more important to be patient, to browse the racks methodically.
- If buying used clothes becomes a habit, institute a “one in-one out policy”. Every time you bring home something new, get rid of something old. (Give it away, take it to a thrift store, or save it for a garage sale.)
- Have fun! Buying used clothing can save you money. It’s also a fun way to kill a Saturday afternoon. At $3 an item, you can afford to be adventurous sometimes.
Another great thing about buying used is that you’re free to experiment a little bit more. It doesn’t hurt much to purchase a $5 cardigan sweater and then discover you’re not the sort for cardigans. On a recent shopping trip, for example, Kris picked up this garish pair of pants:

Kris thinks the pants are pretty hilarious. I do, too, but not in the same way. But what’s really surprising is the price tags. Check this out: these pants were originally priced at $288, but she picked them up for $8.99.

For many people, thrift stores offer an easy way to delve into frugal fashion. But most shops carry more than just clothes. If your budget is pinched, they’re an excellent place to find furniture, to pick up kitchenware, and even to find inexpensive entertainment. A large part of my personal finance library has been purchased from the local Goodwill (for about $3 per book).
SEARCH FOR RECENT ARTICLES




message #100 must be an employee or owner of Ross Stores. Yes, they have good selection of cheap, cheap clothes that do not hold up. I would rather buy a designer suit from a thrift store that was expensively crafted than a new cheapie that looks like a rag after 5 washings. No one should buy an item with rips or stains, nor do they have do, the
selection is so good at the thrift stores, no need to.
loading....
another great place to buy used kids items is kids consignment sales. use google to see if there is one in your area. the sellers set the prices. it is worth volunteering (if they have them) to shop first to get the best bargains. incredible deals!
loading....
Thrifting is awesome! Today at local thrift shops I got a pair of Notify Capri Cropped Jeans (Retail $320) for $6. Also a pair of Joe’s Jeans (Retail $150) for $8. And if that weren’t enough I got a Seven (for all Mankind) Denim Skirt (Retail $175) for $2. All in new condition and they all fit perfectly!
loading....
the economy being what it is today and with high unemployment. People still like to shop, you may only $20 alotted to buy clothes, it can take you far in a thrift shop and have fun shopping. in a retail store $20 will buy very little. thank goodness for thrift stores.
Supply and demand has come into play, Goodwill has raised all their prices which is sad. They always had 1 color tag 50% off and 1 color tag 25% off, they stopped the 25% off sales. But still a great deal for shoppers.
loading....
Another great thrifting day! A brand new pair of short black UGG boots! (Retail $159) I got for $20! How awesome is that? You never know what you’ll find next!
loading....
Shopping at thrift stores, yard sales and Goodwill has helped me expand my personal sense of style. I look at great item and if it’s not something I’d normally wear I might buy it anyway and see how it “fits” stylistically speaking for me. Also, because the items are often such a deal I can have several things that are very limited in the way they can be used with my wardrobe but are great when I need them.
My latest find: a pair of $90 Tsubo urban street shoes for $9.99 at Goodwill. And a $200 French made jacket (not available in the US) for $7.00. Both fit perfectly and look sharp.
loading....
My two teenage daughters love to shop thrift. Just last night my youngest was telling her dad, how much she paid for her jeans $3, brand new black heels $10. It’s fun you never know what you’ll find.
loading....
My reflections: My first hard and fast rule is to think of your goals and stay focused. Then…
*You will look your best if you can pull together an entire outfit – shirts, pants, accessories.
*If you need $ and don’t give away clothes, sell a set of clothes on craigslist for a reasonable price.
*Inventory is always revolving at these stores, so don’t get discouraged and make repeat visits.
*Garage sales are often cheaper, but if you can not try clothes on and look at yourself, it is harder to make wise selections.
loading....
If the item you’re buying costs less than dry cleaning you could wear it until it’s dirty than toss it. So you’re getting your money’s worth right?
One time I bought a bunch of suede jackets and waited a year to finally dry clean them so I can use them again haha. All that dry cleaning was the price of a single jacket if I bought it full retail!
loading....
Love this article. I have most of my clothes from thrift store. My best find a red beaded suit for 10.00. Someone would not beleive I didn’t spend hundreds of dollars. The other thing I love while pregnant for my second and last child. There was 7 years between them I did’t save any from the first. I got all my maternity clothes from a thrift shop. It is crazy to spend a lot of money on clothes I’ll never need again. I spent less than 20.00 and got a workable wardrobe for the few months I needed them. The only caution is my baby dr told me never to buy childrens shoes used. They need to fit properly for your child. I also stay away from sneakers. I have gotten many items with tag still on them.
loading....
Having been a thrift store junkie for years – I still see some misconceptions here. My ‘Favorite Thrift Store’ is in a horrible part of town. The new Ralph Lauren Polo shirts, with tags are only 2.50. The new quilted ski jacket with fur collar for my friend was only 9. The new Nordstrom heels (gold and silver kitten heels) were half off 8. The sterling silver candlesticks were 5 dollars for a pair.
My second favorite thrift store is the Junior League Thrift store. I used to be a member, and we were required to donate 150 dollars worth of clothing every year. I got my teen son his very own tuxedo jacket for 10 dollars. He got a beautiful vintage tuxedo vest for 5 dollars (my husband says it’s better quality than his!). I got my husband some new Ermengildo Zegna shirts for 10 each. And a silk wedding dress for 20. They know me well enough to pull me to the back to show me when they have St Johns knit come in.
My friends think I’m rich. I’ve invited them, but they think it means stained, ripped and dirty clothes. Their loss!!
loading....
I LOVE the pants! Go Kris!
loading....
Sorry this advice does not work for me. I have to look well dressed, well put together, and high-end at work. It is too much trouble to do this by thrift store shopping-most clothes you buy new need alterations to fit properly, let alone stuff from thrifts/Goodwill. I think this is fine in certain circumstances, but I dont think it would work for me. Personally, I find thrifting is a bore-it takes too long and yields very little of any use in my life-I simply hate sorting through all the junk.
loading....
I love thrift shopping! I am very well-dressed, and like Maharina, I have to look put-together and high end at work. I have a huge collection of gorgeous cashmere sweaters in every colour of the rainbow. I have beautiful flannel wool pants, silk skirts, and linen blouses. All top quality.
Recently, I found two brand new Hermes scarves at a local church thrift shop for $2.00 each. And yes, they were genuine!
It’s all about having the time and inclination to shop, knowing quality brands and fabrics, and being interested in investing the effort to get what you want at very low prices.
loading....
That is just my point: I dont have the time. My job is too busy and pressured, and I dislike clothes shopping in the US as it is so disorganized and random- it is just another stressor. Don’t get me wrong-I love my job, but I need to schedule time as productively as possible when I buy clothes, and thrifting is too slow if you are looking for specific items in a tight timeframe, as i usually am. With the best will in the world I cannot budget that far ahead of when I will need something. Its hard enough being Indian-most business clothes are the wrong styles, colors, and fit for my body type. Tailoring fixes the last problem, but not the first two. I have a personal shopper/dressmaker, shop twice a year very intensely with her, and have other things custom made. Thrift and saving $$ are great, but not in all situations. For me, this is one where it is just simpler to pay full price-I can cut costs in other areas-and frankly I shop as little as possible. My upfront costs for clothing are greater, but I am happier with my clothes. The pants in the picture are detestable and a waste of money at any price. They do not encourage me to thrift-if anything they are are a put off. Pressing or dry cleaning might have helped before taking the photo, but I wouldnt wear them for a Halloween costume. Poor quality, extremely cheap looking, machine embroidery (the fabric is all rucked up around the edges-it should lie flat) and the wrong shoes-strappy evening shoes would have been more appropriate: if you dont have the right accessories, it is a waste of money buying the item! This is the first rule of clothes shopping!
loading....
I guess the family with the $150/year clothing budget must be buying all their underwear at thrift stores too.
loading....
I go to thrift stores for several things, but the most useful is for jeans because it’s the only place where I can find a rack of 40 different brands all right beside each other in my size. I sift through the sizes right above and below me too, because they all fit differently. While walking by other sizes (i.e. four feet away) I scan them to see if something is misplaced and might fit me.
If I shop for jeans in a regular store, I have to sift through several racks all over the place for my size, and then go to the dressing room to try on five pairs of jeans only to discover the one or two brands doesn’t fit right… and then I have to drive to another store to do the whole process again.
At least with the thrift store I can find many different shapes and brands, some of which are likely to fit me.
Not as much of an issue for guys, I know.
With short-sleeved shirts, I have to try several different brands because my arms are very muscular. The only place to do that with any hope is in a thrift store. More brands to choose from, sorted by my size, and I don’t have to run around 1600 sq ft of space trying to do it.
loading....
I am such a thrift store shopper that I have favorite stores and my friends laughed at me when we were talking about thrift shopping and someone pointed out how close I live to one, and I stated, “Oh I don’t shop there; they price their stuff too high!” So I guess I comparison shop thrift stores!
loading....
those are the ugliest pants i have ever seen.
loading....
A good friend of mine introduced me to thrift shopping. I was quite hesitant at first but eventually loved it.. due to the variety and cheapness of the clothes. Nowadays I don’t have to cut down on my eating just to save for a new top or pair of jeans. So my friend and I now schedule our shopping together because as you’ve said it’s good to have a second opinion. I do this now because when I shop alone, I indulge in too many impulsive buys, especially at the thrift stores. And sometimes the trendy clothes don’t look good on me. So when my friend is there, she can easily talk me out of buying unnecessary clothing. And I really do enjoy it because we often have a good laugh when trying on ridiculous looking clothes we know we’d never buy and all the while I know im saving some serious money.
loading....
In the past decade over 95% of the clothes I have bought have been from thrift stores, or ‘op shops’ as we call them in Australia.
I did capitulate when I got my first job out of uni and bought some new clothes, but recently decided to go back to 100% opshopped clothes and havent bought any new clothes in over 12 months.
The reason I started was economic: I had just finished high school and was facing the prospect of going from wearing a school uniform 5 days a week to needing enough regular clothes for 7 days a week and starting uni I simply couldnt afford it. I was amazed at the clothes you could buy in op shops and ended up only allowing myself to buy my clothes from opshops for the next four years.
In the past decade I have paid as much as $20 for a pair of designer jeans to as little as 5c for clothes in a fill a bag sale from opshops. My favourite opshop has a huge one dollar section which I frequent often. When I can get clothes for one dollar I am less inclined to want to buy a pair of 5 dollar shorts at another opshop. At the beginning of the year they even had a fill a bag sale, so each item worked out to be 6c!!
I love thrifted clothes, everyone I meet is always amazed at the gorgeous finds I have bought from opshops!! One of my lovely older coworkers was worried I was spending all of my pay on clothes as each day I would turn up in a different outfit: I was so pleased to be able to reassure her that the silk skirt & knit top I was wearing cost a huge 80c each!!!
loading....
I’m looking at the date in the Goodwill tag pictured in this artical. I have not seen Goodwill prices or Salvation Army prices like that in quite some time. These types of stores have got completely out of hand. I use to support these shops two or three times a week and within the last year and a half I go maybe once a month. I picked up an old and dented and dirty muffin pan and the price was $8.00. Are they out of their minds !
loading....
Working at a Thrift Store is best.
We’d joke as ‘the regulars’ would come in & ask, ‘Where is all the good stuff’? We’d think to ourself’s, ‘In the employs trunks’
Now I have to much ‘stuff’, its being boxed up & donated back. I enjoyed it for a few yrs, time for someone else too.
loading....
I shop Thrift all the time, mostly for clothing, but now for decorating items. What fun! My hubby is into it and got a pair of cashmere slacks (never hemmed, tags on). Tag was on them for $150. but he paid $6.99!!! WOW!
All of my decor accessories are gorgeous white vases, pottery – very modern, also some notable glassware, an evening sequin purse, picture frames, art work, mirrors, –there is no end to what you can find if you are a sharp shopper…
Why pay more for this stuff? I consider it like RENT and if I tire of it, it goes back to the store …. Best time to shop is year end, as donations are heavier due to getting that tax donation slip for IRS.
loading....
i am 54 and have been thrift store shopping since i was a teen. and i have recently seen some problems. that bad economy you were talking about is making thrift stores greedy. i live in springfield missouri and only one of several local thrift stores truly have what i consider “real” thrift store prices. the others have decided that they can over charge because they have become more popular. it’s reached the point with our goodwill and the DAV (disabled american veteran’s) where you could actually do better at walmart and have something new.
loading....
I’ve been shopping at expensive high end stores all my life. I ventured into the Value Village stores here in Edmonton, Alberta a couple of months ago to find old sheets to make rag rugs out of. I never ever intended on buying clothing there, but guess what? I was passing buy the jeans rack and low and behold I saw the exact pair of jeans my daughter bought a couple of months ago and paid over 100 bucks for priced at 10.99. I tried them on, they fit perfect and I’ve been hooked ever since. I decided I would try and find some clothing for dancing as my BF and I take dancing lessons and everyone in the dance studio wears expensive clothing all the time and I just can’t keep uo!! Well, you should see me now, I have loads of nice clothing that I found gently used or only used once, some things never washed. I go for high end brand names only. The things that I just won’t spend the money on. People donate great stuff!! I know I’ve donated great stuff in the past too! I am hooked!! My sister’s and children think I have gone mad because I’m one of those people that is so fussy about my clothes. Trust me, you just have to have a little patience and you can find great clothes in thrift stores. I found a brand new Banana Republic jacket for 16, and I had just paid 175 for a jacket on sale in the same store a few months ago. I love them equally, but appreciate my 16 dollar one more!! I said I would never buy shoes there, yuk, but guess what? I found a brand new pair of boots, exactly my style and I was in desperate need of new ones for only 20 dollars!! It’s crazy and fun. I find it’s better to go myself, then I don’t feel bad about spending 3 hours going through the racks. I used to spend 4 or 5 hours shopping at West Edmonton Mall and buying less clothing for A LOT more money. I’m happy with my change and my wardrobe is plenty and lovely. You would never guess that much of it is bought at Value Village!!
loading....
My friend takes old sweaters, felts them and then uses crochet techniques to turn them into bags. You can get much better quality vintage clothes, leather, wool, silk that will last you a good 10 years (it’s already been around for 20 -30. If you can sew, you can do amazing things with a few hems, pleats, etc. Usually you find these things in the stinkier, dustier shops in rural areas. I don’t love American Eagle so I put in the work to find my favourites.
loading....