Today I am reviewing a new book written by a colleague. As you read this review, please remember that I am friends with author. For comparison, you can see my reviews of two other books by friends here and here.
I’m often asked to recommend personal-finance books for young adults. I’ve read a few (and have more in my to-read stack), but there are only two that I promote in my presentations to students:
- Debt is Slavery by Michael Mihalik, a short book packed with great advice. This is a fantastic overview, but it’s light on tactical tips.
- Suze Orman’s The Money Book for the Young, Fabulous, and broke has the opposite problem. It’s too long. Again, the advice is solid, but there’s too much of it.
Now, however, my friend and colleague Ramit Sethi has written a money book aimed squarely at those in their twenties. And he’s done a marvelous job. I can only hope that my own (theoretical) book turns out this well.
Would you rather be sexy or rich?
I Will Teach You to Be Rich is not simply a blog-to-book dump. Ramit has gone to great lengths to produce a volume that is packed with useful tips. It’s true that he’s incorporated some of the best bits from his blog, but he also spent two years crafting new material.
Here’s an excerpt from the end of the introduction, in which Ramit describes his goals:
After reading this book, you’ll be better prepared to manage your finances than 99 percent of other people in their twenties and early thirties. You’ll know what accounts to open up, ways not to pay your bank extra fees, how to invest, how to think about money, and how to see through a lot of the hype that you seen on TV an in magazines every day.
There aren’t any secrets to getting rich — it just takes small steps and some discipline, and you can do it with just a little bit of work. Now let’s get started.
Aside from that last bit (I think getting rich takes a lot of work and/or a lot of patience), this sounds like it could have been written by me. In fact, I wish I’d written many of the things in this book.
In my conversations with Ramit, he’s stressed that I Will Teach You to Be Rich is “highly tactical”, and he’s right. He doesn’t just encourage readers to find the best savings accounts, he walks them through the process. He provides scripts for requesting rate reductions from credit cards and banks. He demonstrates his method of automating his financial life. He describes how to come out ahead in salary negotiations.
Six weeks of action steps
Ramit has built his book around a six-week program of action steps. Each week highlights one aspect of personal finance:
- Week one focuses on optimizing credit cards and improving your credit history.
- Week two explains how to find great bank accounts, and how to negotiate away fees.
- During week three, Ramit helps readers to open a 401(k) and/or a Roth IRA.
- In week four, Ramit leads readers through he process of drafting a “spending plan” so that they can make conscious choices about where their money goes.
- Week five is all about connecting your new financial infrastructure, and automating it so that it hums along without intervention from you.
- And the final week is an introduction to investing — how to use diversification and asset allocation to meet your investment goals.
Each chapter includes a “guest” article from a prominent blogger, including Gina Trapani from Lifehacker (and now Smarterware), Trent Hamm from The Simple Dollar, Flexo from Consumerism Commentary, and yours truly.
I think my favorite part of I Will Teach You to Be Rich is that Ramit cites his sources. You’ll recall that in my review of The Power of Less, I complained that my friend Leo resorted to broad statements with no research to support his claims. I was disappointed. Ramit doesn’t fall into that trap. When he recommends index funds or talks about asset allocation, he backs up his advice with quotes and data. If only every personal-finance book did this…
The bottom line
Ramit’s book is great, but it’s not for everyone. First of all, it’s targeted almost exclusively at young adults. If you’re under 25 and single, and if you make a decent living, this book is perfect. But if you’re 45 and married with two children, and if you struggle to make ends meet, this book is less useful.
Second, as most of you know, Ramit has a strong authorial voice. He’s bold, sarcastic, and even a little sassy. Not everyone likes this. If you’re turned off by his blog (or by his guest posts at Get Rich Slowly), you’ll be turned off by his tone in this book.
These caveats aside, I Will Teach You to Be Rich is an outstanding personal finance book. It’s packed with solid advice, cites its sources, and provides scores of tactical tips for managing money. I stand by my blurb used on the cover of the book:
Smart, bold, and practical. I Will Teach You to Be Rich is packed with tips that actually work. This is a great guide to money management for twentysomethings — and everybody else.
Having just finished the book for a second time, I stand by that statement. I’d still recommend Debt is Slavery for young adults who are struggling with their finances (i.e., people like the 21-year-old J.D.). But for everyone else, I Will Teach You to Be Rich is an excellent choice. (Trent at The Simple Dollar reviewed the book yesterday, and came to a similar conclusion.)
This may not be the best personal-finance book for Get Rich Slowly readers, but it could be perfect for the newlywed or college graduate in your life.
Get an audio recording of Ramit and me answering YOUR money questions and talking about our own financial development! If you buy the book in the next seven days and forward your receipt to getrichslowly@iwillteachyoutoberich.com, you will receive an hour-long recording of Ramit and me answering GRS reader questions about saving, investing, and the mistakes people make when managing their money. (The recording also includes my wife in the background, working on the GRS garden project.)
SEARCH FOR RECENT ARTICLES




So, say you’re that 45 year old struggling to make ends meet with 2 kids…any good books for us?
loading....
I wish reviewers would acknowledge the fact that their audience isn’t just American. As an “outsider”, it would refreshing to have someone say “even if you’re not an American, this book is still worth a look because…” or “if you’re not American, this book probably isn’t for you because…”
I’m guessing I’m not the only one who reads American money blogs. There’s lots of useful information that applies to everyone, and I just skip the stuff that doesn’t apply to me. (No big deal).
Ramit’s book looks interesting, but I can’t tell if there’s enough useful content to make it worth ordering it. Ramit at least admitted to readers that his Scrooge Strategy was geared to Americans, but all his book hype seems to ignore the fact that there are people in other countries who might be interested as well.
loading....
I am sure there is much value to be had in your friend’s book; however, the path to being rich is not found by monetary means. Also, I must say that I am a bit tired of seeing a book title claiming it will make someone rich, especially if contentment is not part of the book’s teaching. Isn’t the idea of “getting rich” at the core of our financial crisis?
“If thou wilt make a man happy, add not unto his riches but take away from his desires.” ~ Epicurus
loading....
@Kent
I cannot agree more.
@JD
I disagree with you about Suze Orman’s YF&B. Her book is long, but isn’t intended to be read cover to cover (at least I didn’t think it was). Instead, it’s designed to be referenced when making financial decisions.
I think her book is a great resource because as I grew financially the book still applied. I used it as a reference when buying insurance and plan on using it as a reference when I buy my first home.
On a separate note, do you have any financial TV shows you’d recommend? I really like the Suzie Orman Show. Her “Can I afford it” segments help me keep myself in check.
loading....
Let me say, I really enjoy this site.
The title turns me off. There is no way he can teach anyone to be rich in a book. He can teach a better financial life, but I’m sure he’s relying on things out of his control (market returns for example) for people to get rich. I’m sure at the end of a 6 week plan, people could be in better shape, but with a 0% guarantee that they’ll be rich. I know… I know… catchy marketing, just seems more slimey snake oil salesman to me.
J.D., do you have a conflict of interest when you recommend this book? Why would you not recommend it if you have a section in it right? Aside from the possibility that you might earn something on sales. Always helpful to me if you acknowledge the conflict to maintain the trust you have with your readers. Sorry, but I have to question your possible motivations for recommending this.
loading....
Man people are reading way too deeply into the name of the book. I think everyone realizes there’s more to life and “riches” than just money. But he’s not going to change the name of the book when he built his reputation on that name for his blog.
@james M,
JD clearly stated at the top of the review his conflict of interest here. Settle down.
loading....
“So, say you’re that 45 year old struggling to make ends meet with 2 kids…any good books for us?
”
Lori, try “The Complete Tightwad Gazette” by Amy Dacyczyn. I’m 30 years old with two kids and it’s been quite helpful for us.
loading....
I did my part to stimulate the economy today. I purchased a new watch and Ramit’s book from Amazon.
loading....
From Ramit’s website for those who want to buy the book:
“TODAY ONLY: I’m giving away 1 Kindle per hour from 8am – 4pm Pacific and FIVE $1,000 checks to kickstart your savings account. Buy the book (Amazon, B&N) and forward your receipt to iboughtthebook@iwillteachyoutoberich.com
Winners announced every hour at the very bottom of this page and on twitter.com/ramit
I’m also live on video for most of the day to answer any questions (starting at 8am Pacific)”
loading....
The title comes straight from Ramit’s in your face website address. Nothing more sinister than that.
Ramit’s advice isn’t for everyone. I won’t be purchasing Ramit’s book even though I am in his target age bracket (29). However, if I was 5 years younger, I would tell my younger self to buy it. I enjoy reading Ramit’s website but I involved myself on this website rather than his, because GRS more fits MY profile. What’s that mantra “Do what works for you?”
And James, there is a clear disclaimer at the top of this post. If you’re read GRS for a long enough time, you would know that JD is very careful about what he signs off on.
Ramit, i did enjoy the free book preview chapter you put up on your site thought!
loading....
Thanks for the review, JD. I’m going to pick up a copy for some just-out-of-college family members. This is a concise review. “I Will Teach You To Be Rich” is a eye catching title, which may be an unfortunate choice given the financial times, but I think Ramit is a good guy and it sounds like he’s put together a practical work. While you can’t get rich in six weeks, I think there are a lot of things people can do in that amount of time that will lay the groundwork to finiancial success, and sounds like Ramit has offered people a tool to do just that.
loading....
@Beth- As a UK-based reader, I agree with you 100%. But sadly many American-based sites on the internet tend to fall into the same trap. But just from scanning this review, I’d be surprised if there was much in Sethi’s book for someone living outside of the US…it seems to be really specific, which is great for people who need that kind of info but the nature of providing specifics means that the usefulness of the book will likely be tied to one particular financial location, in this case the States.
@JamesM- agreed, I’m also not fond of the title of the book (and the blog.)
loading....
If “Debt is slavery” and a good saving-plan will let us get rich (slowly), who in the world should go in debt to give us the interest we expect for our savings? Could we talk about humanity if we want to get rich at the expense of those who haven´t learnt the lesson this blog teaches?
I think it is okay to get rich slowly, but we only will get rich by work …. and love.
(From germany)
loading....
@James M (#5)
Great question! No, I don’t feel like I have any conflict of interest in recommending this book. I’m receiving no financial compensation (nor any compensation of any kind) for doing so, even though I do have a two-page article here. I really do think this is an excellent book for its target audience. I’ve been completely honest about what I think about the book. Ramit has done a fine job.
I do think that the two problems people will have with this are:
1. Ramit’s tone/voice/attitude. I already know that many GRS readers find it grating, and I’m not about to suggest that these folks should read the book.
2. The title *does* seem scammy. But so does Get Rich Slowly. I’m constantly frustrated by the people who think that I’m running some sort of scam site. Ramit isn’t doing this, either…
Anyhow, I think your question is perfectly valid. But trust me: this is a good book.
loading....
Thank you for the reply J.D. This is why your site rocks! This is just a hot point for me.
If you feel good about it, great. Brand recognition, name recognition, etc. are there for you to gain from this book being successful. But just a difference of opinion.
I guess my real point w/ the title and all is for people just to realize that financial self help gurus get rich from the advice they give, not from following it. If enough people believe the book will make them rich, the people who will be rich are Ramit and his partners, not from setting up a 401k, but from working hard and selling books.
I bet there is good advice in there, debt reduction saving and investing can be good advice, but won’t make people “rich” just hopefully allow them to retire at a decent age. There is no such thing as “easy money”
loading....
wasn’t he just on the Dave Ramsey radio show as a guest?
loading....
A couple of asides:
1) J.D. do you think that recent college graduates and newlyweds aren’t in your “core demographic” (so to speak)? I seem to see tons of commenters on your site mention being in their 20s.
2) “Would you rather be sexy or rich?” Is a really strange title for a section of a personal finance book review.
3) Does anyone else find it difficult to take someone seriously who refers to himself by the name of a fictional cartoon robot (flexo)?
And a couple of on-topic notes:
I think having a personal finance book targeted specifically towards young adults with college educations is great. Having books like this with a targeted audience means that, as long as you’re in that audience, you’ll get more applicable advice than you would in a general book targeted at everyone. More books should do this, and target specific groups of people, as long as they make it clear who that audience is on the cover.
I probably wont be buying this book, but not because I doubt it’s a good book, more because a, “highly tactical six-week program” doesn’t sound interesting to me, and because I find that most books by bloggers don’t offer a lot that you can’t learn on their websites. I know you say he has new material, but does it offer any new lessons not in his online material?
loading....
For older people with kids, I’d recommend Andrew Tobias’s “The Only Investment Guide You’ll Ever Need.” Actually, I’d recommend that to anyone! The Tightwad Gazette books are more than just frugal tips; there’s a lot of “philosophy” there too.
loading....
Ramit has been sending me preview chapters of his book via e-mail during the past few weeks. As a single twenty something in his target audience, the book really stuck a cord with me. I found his humor and writing style perfect for our age group. From what I read, I would definitely recommend this book to a peer.
loading....
J.D., Just curious: does this post contain Amazon affiliate links? Thx.
loading....
I won’t be buying this book, but I will be checking it out (for free) at my local library!
Thanks for all the great book suggestions JD!
loading....
@Kevin (#21)
Yes, of course. Any time I mention a book, I use Amazon affiliate links. (Which I guess does mean that I am receiving some sort of compensation, which is probably your point. What I meant to say is that I’m not receiving any abnormal compensation, such as payment from Ramit or the publisher.)
loading....
>>He’s bold, sarcastic, and even a little sassy. Not everyone likes this. If you’re turned off by his blog (or by his guest posts at Get Rich Slowly), you’ll be turned off by his tone in this book.
Let me add that from my point of view, his tone and attitude are not tolerable for most of us humans. His writing betrays his authoritarian attitude, which is so over the top as to be bordering on condescending.
It seems like he is about to scream at you: “YOU’RE A DAMN FOOL FOR GETTING YOURSELF INTO THIS MESS, IDIOT!”
So who wants to read that in a PF help book/blog?
I think I’ll go lie down now. Whew!
loading....
I have noticed, and found myself at times, sniping at suggestions that are brought up on this site by way of guest posts, reviews or just comments by J.D. It seems we take a contradiction to our own habits as a threat at times. Maybe this is one of the things that helps this site to be more compelling as people passionately express their view points in contrast to others. I do think that it should be kept in mind that this site has become a great resource for the sharing of ideas (both good and bad) related to topics in personal finance and all along the fringe, so there has to be a very broad audience and the postings should reflect that.
loading....
Sounds like a book I need to buy. Being 23 and single and working a lower paying job, need some good advice I can actually use in my situation.
loading....
I read the pre-release of this book. It is excellent for the target audience. Ramit points out some skills for the 20 somethings that a lot of them are missing. If his target audience buys this book, then start using their heads to think about this, we will all be a lot better off.
loading....
Congrats to Ramit. He’s managed to make it to the #1 spot on the Amazon best-seller list, knocking off the Twilight books. I’m in awe. That’s impressive stuff.
loading....
Tyler: Your third point is interesting. Did you read the article I contributed? I find that most of my readers take my writing seriously (when I intend it to be taken as such) regardless of the pseudo-anonymous name chosen to protect my identity.
loading....
Wow, any idea how many books you have to sell to get a #1 ranking on Amazon?
loading....
Ramit’s writing is agressive, or maybe just passionate. I think that his style probably meshes well with many 20-somethings and I bought this book with my youngest son (26) in mind. I’m hoping he gets a push into 401(k) and investment (now, not later) territory. I think it may be too late for his 30-something brother, though.
loading....
@flexo: I’m sure most of your readers do take your writing seriously, but that means about as much as saying, “most baseball fans like baseball.” They wouldn’t read your site if they didn’t feel they could take it seriously.
Here are the writers mentioned in this post: Leo Babauta, Trent Hamm, Michael Mihalik, Suze Orman, Ramit Sethi, Gina Trapan, Flexo, and J.D. Roth. Which one of these names stands out as most looking like a joke? Note that *none* of these other authors feel the need to hide behind anonymity.
And no, I haven’t read the article. It may be very good. I personally don’t have a lot of interest in reading an article who’s author won’t even take credit for it. That doesn’t project much confidence in its content to me. You are free to take issue with my viewpoint here, and obviously you disagree, but at least you know who you’re disagreeing with.
I don’t want to derail J.D.’s comments section any further. If you’re still interested in discussing this, my name at the top of this comment will take you to my site, where you can contact me.
loading....
@Tyler (#31)
Flexo hides behind anonymity for good reasons. He’s not anonymous to those he knows and trusts. I know his real name. I’ve met him and think he’s a great down-to-earth guy.
Flexo is anonymous because he shares more about his life than most other pfbloggers do. I don’t share my income or net worth because everything else is public. Flexo can share that stuff because he’s anonymous.
Also, at least one of the others in your list (not me, not Ramit) is semi-anonymous — but hasn’t taken the name of a cartoon robot!
loading....
I’m not trying to imply that he’s not a great guy, or that he’s not a good writer, just that the name “flexo” doesn’t inspire confidence. It’s sort of like having “skaterguy420@aol.com” as the email address at the top of your resume. It doesn’t make you any worse a job candidate, but it makes interviewers think, “hmm, really, he can’t be any more professional than that?”
That’s all, didn’t mean to take over the comments section with this.
loading....
@Lori:
For your situation, I’d look at either David Bach’s “Smart Couples Finish Rich” or “Smart Women Finish Rich”.
I don’t like some of Bach’s newer books, but “Smart Women Finish Rich” really hit the right spot with me a few years back.
Somebody else mentioned the Tobias book but I didn’t care for it — I thought the book itself seemed aged. I think he wrote it in the early 90s?
Re Ramit Sethi’s book, I’m also Not-A-Fan of the title or tone of his work. Can’t stand the blog, so doubt I’ll peek at the book.
But my basic thought on this is — how many personal finance books do we really need? I look at the dizzying selection in the book store. So many of them say the same darn things.
loading....
I haven’t checked out Ramit’s blog, but based on J.D.’s review I’ll be checking out the book (from the library, like Denise #21). This sounds like the type of advice that made me want to start blogging: seeing younger people who could benefit so much by getting started sooner than I did. However, almost everybody has the same problem. They think the theoretical advice is great, but they still don’t know how to turn it into practice. Thanks for the review, J.D.
loading....
As another Brit (hiding behind a pseudonym based on a comedy show, so clearly not a real person) I’ll chime in with Andrea and Beth to ask whether or not this book is very US-specific. I kind of fit into the core demographic, and I can do some translation (from say Roth IRAs to Stocks and Shares ISAs), but if it’s more specific than that, it’s probably not worth it for me.
loading....
I will not be getting the book. Ramit’s always come across as very “late night informercial” to me – handing out overly simplistic tips for free and promising the real stuff is available as soon as you start handing your cash to him. My advice? Stick with the wealth of free information that’s available out there. If you need to get the book, get it at the library.
loading....
I agree with ddavidson07 (above).
I also want to applaud your honesty. You are the first PF blogger that has admitted, up front, that there is a friendly relationship between you and the book’s author. No one else seems to want to admit it in spite of fawning reviews.
You’re da man!
loading....
This is the first i’ve briefly stumbled upon your site, and I’m commenting without reading much because i have to do other fun things. While I probably would agree with much of what you say, you were discredited early with your closed opinion of reading books and ideas on financing. Only two recommendations? Why not read everything you can. Orman, a very smart, seems to assume her readers can only gain knowledge by joining her ways. Case in point: Term Insurance. She hates all Whole Life. Right? Term has it’s uses, but it is foolish to assume that everyone can be treated the same and get 20x term insurance, or that their isn’t a need to do something different for an individuals needs. Everyone needs different things tailored to them to be successful for their plans and dreams. Insurance and Investments can be used for many things. They can compliment each other to help you be more successful. Read a lot more detailed topics on finances instead of getting the Ramsey / Orman approaches. I’m not recommending a book. I’m recommending you open your mind. There’s a lot of rich people out there who disagree with your recommendations. I don’t think I’ll be back at this site… Not purposefully anyway. I may stumble here on occassion as I use Google to supplement (not replace) solid research.
loading....
I know this is an old post… but, I just feel the need to say that the only people who are offended by Ramit’s personality and tone are older people who don’t get the sarcasm or 20-somethings who think they are “mature” and “sophisticated.” The great thing about Ramit’s humor is that it is outrageous but deadpan at the same time — you’re reading along, nothing to see, and then out of nowhere comes some hilarious insult or self-flattering remark. Totally outrageous and definitely endearing.
So there. Suckas. (Or at least that’s what I think Ramit would end with
)
loading....