Online Banking: 13 Choices for Higher Interest Rates and Increased Security
Published on - June 16th, 2009 (Modified on - May 23rd, 2012) (by J.D. Roth) In its July 2009 issue, Consumer Reports Money Adviser published a brief overview of the best online banking options according to their research. “Online banking, despite a rocky start, is becoming the rule rather than the exception,” the article says, noting that online banking can net savers better interest rates and increased security.
I’d love to be able to point you to an online version of this article, but none exists. And I’m not about to reproduce large chunks of the text here. (Consumer Reports doesn’t like that.) But I can highlight their main points about online banking, as well as list the results of my own research into online banks.
Some of the article’s main points:
- Traditional banks that have moved into online banking (such as Bank of America and Wells Fargo) generally offer lower rates and impose higher fees than established online banks like ING Direct and HSBC Direct.
- If you’re worried about bank failures, remember that the FDIC currently insures deposits of up to $250,000. (This limit has been extended through the end of 2013.) You can research the financial safety of online banks (and traditional institutions) using BauerFinancial’s bank safety ratings.
- The biggest thing that holds people back from online banking is concern over security. Via Twitter yesterday, @thenonconsumer told me, “My husband is very skeptical about using an online bank like ING Direct for savings.” He’s not alone. But according to Consumer Reports Money Adviser, online banking can be safer than traditional methods because there’s less of a paper trail, and your transactions are digitally encrypted.
Here’s a table of current interest rates, updated daily. Below that is a list of online banking options I originally compiled in four hours of research but these have become out of date and I unfortunately don’t have the ability to update them regularly, so the table will let you see some of the most current rates. You can also see a full list of over 200 banks’ savings rates and an almost-as-long list of certificate of deposit returns by following the links.
I haven’t tried to be comprehensive here (a comprehensive list would be huge), but have based my research on my own interests and the requests of my Twitter followers. I’ve made no attempt to rank these banks. They are listed in alphabetical order. Rates are annual percentage yields. All accounts are FDIC insured.
| Savings | 12-month CD | Money market | Bill-pay |
|---|---|---|---|
| 0.84% | 1.04% | 0.84% | — |
| Notes: No fees, no minimums. Money-market account appears to act as a checking account and has no ATM fee. Ally Bank is the newly-renamed GMAC Bank. | |||
| Savings | 12-month CD | Money market | Bill-pay |
|---|---|---|---|
| 0.60% | 0.30% | 0.50% | Free |
| Notes: No fees. Savings rate is 0.10% for balances below $1,000. $5000 minimum balance for certificate of deposit. No minimum for money-market account, which includes an ATM card. Capital One does not charge for ATM withdrawals or balance inquiries, but the owner of the ATM may. | |||
| Savings | 12-month CD | Checking | Bill-pay |
|---|---|---|---|
| 0.50% | 0.10% | Free | |
| Notes: No fees, no minimums for checking. Charles Schwab is a discount broker, but also offers banking services. Checking has no ATM fees. | |||
| Savings | 12-month CD | Checking | Bill-pay |
|---|---|---|---|
| 0.05% | 0.25% | 0.01% | Free |
| Notes: $1,000 minimum deposit for certificate of deposit and $500 minimum deposit for checking. Day-to-Day Savings no fees, $100 minimum for savings. Checking is actually “Citigold” account and may require a second account. ATM access for checking. | |||
| Savings | 16-month CD | Checking | Bill-pay |
|---|---|---|---|
| 0.70% | — | — | — |
| Notes: No fees. $1000 minimum. No ATM. Sibling to Emigrant Direct. | |||
| Savings | 16-month CD | Checking | Bill-pay |
|---|---|---|---|
| 0.60% | 1.00% | — | — |
| Notes: No fees, no minimums. ($1000 minimum for certificate of deposit.) No ATM. Sibling to Dollar Savings Direct. | |||
| Savings | 12-month CD | Checking | Bill-pay |
|---|---|---|---|
| 0.05% | — | 0.05% to 0.15% | Free |
| Notes: No fees, no minimums on savings. Checking has minimum balance of $5,000, else rate tier is 0.05% to 0.15% based on account balance. No ATM fees (and ATM card appears to be available for savings as well as checking). | |||
| Money market | 12-month CD | Checking | Bill-pay |
|---|---|---|---|
| 0.76% | 0.75% | 0.61% | Free-ish |
| Notes: For first time account holders, new account bonus rate for Yield Pledge Money Market Account – 1.05% for the first six months, first year APY currently 0.91% and an ongoing APY currently at 0.76% for account balances up to $50K. $1500 minimum to open accounts. Low-balance fees may apply. For first time account holders, new account bonus rate for Yield Pledge Checking Account holders – 1.05% for the first six months, first year APY currently 0.83% and an ongoing APY currently at 0.61% for account balances of $25,000 – $49,999. Online Bill-Pay costs $8.95 per month if you do not maintain a $5,000 balance in checking. Checking has no ATM fees. | |||
| Savings | 12-month CD | Checking | Bill-pay |
|---|---|---|---|
| 0.65% | 0.40% | 0.65% | Free |
| Notes: No fees, no minimums. Checking is actually an “Online Billpay” account. ATM card available, though GRS readers report fees are vaguely defined. The FNBO site used to be more informative; I had trouble finding the data I needed for this article and, in fact, had to rely on reader comments to fill in gaps. | |||
| Savings | 12-month CD | Checking | Bill-pay |
|---|---|---|---|
| 0.80% | 0.20% | — | Free |
| Notes: No fees, no minimums. ($10 minimum for certificate of deposit.) No ATM fees for checking. ATM available for savings, but I can’t determine fee structure. | |||
| Savings | 12-month CD | Checking | Bill-pay |
|---|---|---|---|
| 0.80% | 0.50% | 0.20% to 0.90% | Free |
| Notes: Easy to set up multiple accounts. No fees, no minimums. Checking allows ATM access. | |||
| Savings | 12-month CD | Checking | Bill-pay |
|---|---|---|---|
| 0.40% | 0.90% | 0.25% to 0.65% | Free-ish |
| Notes: $1,000 minimum to open savings. No fees or minimums for savings account for children. $10,000 minimum for certificate of deposit. $500 minimum for checking. Free bill pay for 90 days. Free bill pay if you maintain an average $10,000 balance in checking. ATM card available on some accounts. | |||
| Savings | 12-month CD | Checking | Bill-pay |
|---|---|---|---|
| 0.60% | 0.35% | — | — |
| Notes: $100 minimum to open savings, $1000 minimum to obtain rate. $1000 minimum for certificate of deposit. “Nationwide network of surcharge-free ATMs”, which seems vague. | |||
To compile this list, I pulled information directly from bank websites on 23 May 2012. I also used the tools at Money Rates to fill in gaps. Note that many of the checking accounts above are simply online bill-pay accounts — you can’t use paper checks with them. Please let me know if you spot errors.
The Consumer Reports Money Adviser article about online banking included a handful of brick-and-mortar institutions. My list leaves most of them out. I visited every website that CR mentioned, but I have to say, a lot of traditional banks have terrible web presences. Bank of America? Wells Fargo? Chase? Good luck trying to figure out how online banking with any of them or what rates you’ll receive. They’re still marketing to the pre-Internet generation.
For more info, you may want to visit Money Rates or check out some previous GRS articles about online banking:
- Here’s the ever-popular Get Rich Slowly list of high-yield savings accounts.
- Don’t forget that certificates of deposit are a great way to put your savings on steroids. Here’s my list of current CD rates.
- Finally, be sure that you’re making the most of your checking account. In many places, a rewards checking account actually offers better interest rates than any other option.
One final note: The Money Adviser article emphasizes that rates are low right now. It might seem silly to worry about the difference between 1.50% and 1.65%, but eventually rates will rise and there will be more differentiation between online banks.
If you have thoughts about any of these online banks (or about online banking in general), please leave a comment.
This article is about Choices, Money Hacks, Savings, Tools
SEARCH FOR RECENT ARTICLES




![Capital One Direct Banking [Capital One Direct Banking]](http://www.foldedspace.org/GRS/capitalonelogo.jpg)
![Dollar Savings Direct [Dollar Savings Direct]](http://www.foldedspace.org/GRS/dsd_logo.gif)
![Emigrant Direct [Emigrant Direct]](http://www.foldedspace.org/GRS/emigrant_logo.gif)
![FNBO Direct [FNBO Direct]](http://www.foldedspace.org/GRS/fnbologo.gif)
![ING Direct [ING Direct]](http://www.foldedspace.org/GRS/ingdirect_logo.gif)
![VirtualBank [VirtualBank]](http://www.foldedspace.org/GRS/Virtual-Logo.gif)
@KC
Comment #28. I agree with KC that you should check your local credit union.
Buy local, where it benefits your community where you are at.
loading....
@Gholmes(#51)
Normally I’d agree, but where I live here in Florida, the local credit unions I’ve tried are AWFUL as far as customer service. Heaven help you if you need to do anything even remotely complicated.
I’ve heard bad things about Bank of America over the years (and, well, every other big bank), but they’ve been no end of help both with my accounts and with helping me handle my parents’ accounts now that they can’t deal with it themselves. Even their phone reps have always treated me with the attitude of “if I can’t help you, I’ll find someone who can.”
(I’ve also had good luck with my Citi credit card, but I think that’s only because I’ve had the account since 1990. They tend to bend over backwards to keep me happy.
)
loading....
@Cherie
Come to Oregon we have some great credit unions and supportive banks. They support our local high school sports, community college, hospital and other charities.
Branch mangagers are members of our chamber of commerce, rotary, lion club and local charity board members.
loading....
@Gholmes(#53)
I want to come to Oregon for a WHOLE lot of reasons. You just added one more.
I’m sick to death of the south. And especially sick to death of the mosquitoes and Huntsman spiders the size of my hand… *shudder*
There is one local credit union I admit I didn’t try (out of the three I know of), but as far as I know, they only have one branch and it wasn’t nearby. My parents were with BOA pretty much their whole lives (or however far back BOA goes) and after experiencing how INCREDIBLY nice they were to me helping me take over managing their finances, I switched to them for all my banking except for my ZionsBank emergency fund and that Citi card. I sincerely hope they never give me a reason to rethink that decision…
loading....
I second the Smarty Pig comment. While I’ve only had the account for a bit, the 3.05% is nice.
The one main item is that interest is only paid to the account every 3 months instead of monthly.
loading....
@Carla – USAA has expanded membership eligibility to include some retired and former personnel. The details are at usaa.com, just click on “who is eligible.”
loading....
@Linear Girl
Thanks, but still no (he got out in the 80′s, so they would have to back the date up quite a ways)
loading....
HSBC Direct also has the ability to easily open multiple savings accounts, although they don’t call them sub-accounts. You can rename them for viewing purposes so that you can remember what the different accounts are for.
loading....
One comment mentioned BankDeals in passing, but this site deserves a mention. It’s really amazing for researching online bank accounts.
http://bankdeals.blogspot.com/
In addition to the obligatory “list of highest yields”, there is an in-depth review of almost every online account available. The author takes the time to contact a live customer service rep for each bank and find out hidden details that people may not think to look for. One example that surprised me: some banks will perform a “hard pull” on your credit report – which means that query will be visible to lenders when they look at your credit report. Some do “soft pulls”, and some just look up your banking history, which is altogether separate. Just one interesting tidbit that I didn’t know before visiting BankDeals.
loading....
I am currently a college student and have recently turned 18. I am looking to open up a savings and checking account and an investment portfolio.
I was thinking E-Trade would be my best option because I can open them all at once. What are your opinions?
loading....
I have heard bad things about E-Trade. Granted that may just be coincidence.
For me personally (I am also a student), I find having a checking account within walking distance is nice. I use M&I Student Checking and am able to avoid any fees. I then just use an ING Direct Savings account to hold whatever I dont need to leave in my checking.
As for an investment account, I use Scottrade. I like them because I pay no maintenance or annual fees, just when I purchase stock. If I were you though, and you are looking at opening an IRA, I might look into Vanguard also. Scottrade also runs a promotion where if someone refers you, both the referer and referee get 3 free trades which is nice.
loading....
Anyone familiar with igobanking.com? APY 2.05 %. If so, what has been your experience?
loading....
@Jacob (#46) Your answer to the difference between Dollar and Emigrant is the minimum. Some people are starting with less than $1000.
Danna
loading....
I use FNBODirect for my emergency fund. I started using them when the savings rates were closer to 6%. Unfortunately, the lower rates are the way things are now, but it’s still higher than a brick and mortar bank.
For all my other banking I use my local Florida credit union, which is superb! The savings rates may be lower than online banks (though so is my credit card rate), but the customer service is first rate and they are available whenever I need face-to-face help. Good for short-term savings/checking use.
I like the idea of ING’s sub-accounts, but I do that myself with my checking account using a financial program on my computer. It’s all available in my checking when needed, but separated into categories by use on my computer.
loading....
FNBO Direct’s online savings account does have an ATM card. They aren’t really very clear about the fees associated with using it, but I certainly do have an ATM card.
loading....
As someone already pointed out, there are many local credit unions that are offering great rates even up to 4.50%, with direct deposit and other transactions requirements. But it may workout for some people.
loading....
“Online Payment Account” is the checking account from HSBC Direct allows up to 3 reimbursements for ATM fees per statement cycle, and the money is credited back to your account at a certain point during the month (I can’t remember if it’s at the beginning of the statement cycle or on the first of the month or what … but it’s not the very next day like some banks do). “Online Savings Account” from HSBC Direct does NOT offer the reimbursements so you’d have to use HSBC’s ATM to avoid incurring fees. ING Direct also does NOT offer ATM reimbursements but the ATM’s are free as long as you stay within the AllPoint Network. Fidelity’s mySmart account offers unlimited ATM reimbursements and the credit to your account is made the very next day.
Other notes regarding HSBC Direct… I did go into a branch once to ask about whether I could do a wire transfer, and I was told by the branch manager that they couldn’t service my account there. (So yes it is true that it is 100% online-only except for ATM but I knew that when I signed up so that was fine.) I was told that it might still be possible to do a wire transfer but I had to send some request by fax and it seemed like it was rather nonstandard so I didn’t want to chance it at the time and I used Fidelity for the wire transfer instead (which went relatively smoothly, by the way).
Note: Just for clarification, I am indeed referring to Fidelity brokerage and NOT the bank previously known as Fidelity Federal (now NationalCity/PNC).
loading....
I have used both ING Direct and HSBC Direct savings accounts for years. Both are easy to access and transfer funds to and from a US bank account. HSBC Direct gave me an ATM card which I can use at any ATM in the world with no fees from HSBC (you do have to pay the ATM’s bank fees depending on the bank). Both are FDIC insurred, however, both are considered US accounts, and I cannot wire money outside of the country with these accounts.
loading....
The HSBC Direct ATM card doesn’t charge any fees and in fact reimburses you for at least some “foreign” ATM fees, so that your access to your account via ATM is truly fee-free (no fee from them, no “surcharge” from the other bank’s ATM). Note that I haven’t read their policy, so I don’t know what kind of limitations there may be, but that’s been my experience with my very occasional cash withdrawals from my account.
…Okay, I just read the posts above saying there’s no reimbursement of foreign ATM surcharges for the Online Savings Account, but I went and looked at my own account history and I didn’t imagine it; there are clearly identified reimbursals for foreign ATM surcharges. Maybe they changed the policy and I’m grandfathered in? I don’t know. I have a decent balance, but nothing I’d think was so hefty as to put me into another tier of service.
loading....
Just a quick correction about the Citi Accounts listed above…the checking part of the “Ultimate Money” account you sign up for does NOT pay interest. The Ultimate Money account is actually two accounts that you sign up for together. It has a non-interest, regular checking account (they call it “EZ Checking”) and the other part is a money market account. “Ultimate Money” implies that you sign up for the two together and allows you to get a bit better interest rate than if you sign up for the “Ultimate Savings” account alone. When I signed up a couple years ago, that rate was 5%! Sigh…
loading....
I have opend an account with Ally, it worked out fine. I also have ING and love its setup. I filled out a feedback form on Ally and suggested they do some things like ING
Not only the sub accounts but the display of daily interest, YTD interest and last years interest on the account page.
Hope they take those in consideration.
loading....
I feel like chiming in as well. I use HSBCdirect and absolutely love their service through and through. Right now they have 1.55% but before this crisis they were one of the top tier online banks for rates. As well they offer you an Online Payment Account, which basically acts like a checking account with debit and that currently offers 1% (that’s higher than some savings!).
I have been abroad the last 9 months or so. Going to any HSBC bank for cash withdrawal never resulted in a fee. I was told before I left, I would get foreign fee’s at non-HSBC atm machines. Since I have a Capital One credit card with no foreign fee, I thought I would open up a Capital One money market which by the way, only offers ATM-card not debit. Capital One bank has no foreign fee’s either (just like the credit card). I told HSBCdirect I would be using my Capital One bank abroad, but still be transferring money to it from HSBC. Oh and for that matter, notifying HSBC and CapitalOne I would be abroad was way too simple.
In a pinch to give someone cash for a plane ticket they bought me to Amsterdam, without time to transfer the cash from HSBC to Capital One I withdrew from my HSBC account. And I did not receive any fee whatsoever. Not for withdrawing from ATM abroad as Sweden has no atm’s fee’s anywhere for any bank. I thought HSBC would hit me with a fee and perhaps even having to exchange the currency, but they did not. I have since used my HSBC debit 3 more times for cash or charge in a store without any fee’s (and I know cuz MINT would flag it). I emailed customer service to my applause I can use the debit card 6 times in a month with no fee’s while I am abroad. So I guess they listened to me.
I will give my hats off to anyone who read this long story and I hope it reinforces how great HSBCdirect and for that matter Capital One banking is.
//Zach
loading....
@Zach: I was really disappointed when HSBC dropped their rates to 1.55% but the no-ATM-fee abroad you mentioned sounds nice. I am still their customer but have moved most of my funds to Ally.
loading....
I’ve locked up all the cash portion of my money in a 5-yr CD (3 of them laddered) at 4.2%. Why anybody would lock up their cash savings at 2% or less for 1 yr is beyond me. There will be NO INFLATION for 2 years.
You carve up your netwealth, and the cash savings you have (which you never plan to spend until you retire) needs to get maximized. So lock it up at the longest duration and rate possible! I plan to retire in 10 yrs, so if there was a 10 yr CD giving me 6%, I’d date it!
RSC
loading....
@Jacob #61. Thanks for the input. I will definetely look into your suggestions.
loading....
which of the ebanks you mentioned accept international clients?
loading....
I love ING *so much*. However, they’ve recently changed their policy to actively block third-party aggregators (such as Wesabe and Mint.com). They state that it is a security risk, but I feel strongly that I should have control of my own financial data. (I haven’t seen anyone blog about this, though it’s been on the Wesabe forums.)
I recently opened an online checking account with Schwab (it went with the Schwab 2% cash back card I applied for), and so far I’m super impressed with them.
* You can mail checks to ING, but you have to pay the postage. Schwab provides postage-paid envelopes to mail in checks for deposit.
* With ING, you can use ATMs within a certain network without a fee. ING will never charge a fee on their end, but if you use ATMs outside of the network, the bank that owns the ATM will still charge you. Schwab, on the other hand, refunds those fees.
* ING does have the subaccounts, which Schwab doesn’t. And ING’s website is better organized. (Though they both display the interest earned so far in the month, which I like.)
I’ve gotten stellar customer service from both sites, so I wouldn’t hesitate to recommend either of them. But unless ING reverses the aggregation decision, I may be moving to Schwab, at least for my primary bank.
loading....
@ kat (#77)
I have an ING Savings Account and I use both Mint and Quicken Online. I have not noticed any change in that regard (it just posted my deposit made a day ago). When was this policy passed and/or when might it take effect?
loading....
@Jacob: I believe ING is still supporting MS Money and Quicken Online, but since both are being discontinued (I think?) that isn’t very useful. As for Mint, they seem to find ways to work around the limitation, but it has been very on-again off-again for me. I notice that now it says on Mint that ING is only available after business hours M-F. I have accounts on both Wesabe and Mint, but after many cycles of removing and re-adding my ING account (which would make it work for one or two updates), I haven’t been able to re-add it again. Maybe I need to try after 5pm or something.
I don’t know a ton about the situation (I haven’t gotten around to calling ING myself, though it’s on my list), but here’s one of the Wesabe forum threads about it (you don’t have to be a member to read): https://www.wesabe.com/groups/4-saving-up/discussions/4141-ing-alternatives . And the blog post referenced: http://www.thinkplansave.com/2009/06/14/what-is-ing-thinking/
loading....
I am surprised no one mentioned that Ally was forced to lower its rates recently.
http://www.bankaholic.com/finance/fdic-pressured-ally-bank-to-lower-cd-rates/
http://www.nytimes.com/2009/06/13/your-money/brokerage-and-bank-accounts/13money.html
Seems like other banks were pissed off that Ally was offering higher rates than they were!
loading....
I use Bank of America in MA. I specify MA bec am not sure accounts in other parts of the country are the same. It is the fourth bank for this account (formerly Bank of Boston, Fleet, BayBank…). I also use Citizens for my mother and Liberty Bay Credit Union. The Bank of America account is THE BEST of the bunch esp for bill pay. I can sched payments and edit later if nec. I love the feature of being able to go into checking account and update manual checks with detail. I pay nothing bec keep certain amount of money in several accounts including savings.
loading....
You should only buy a CD when you have paid off all your debt. Paying off a 6 percent mortgage is a much better deal than a 2 percent CD.
loading....
A few disappointments with ING:
1) If you have both personal and business accounts you cannot transfer money between those accounts. I could do this with my Wachovia accounts.
2) If you mail in a deposit you have to pay for postage. You also have to write your customer number and account number on each of your deposited checks – they do not provide deposit slips. If the name on your check doesn’t match EXACTLY the name on your account, they will return your check. This has been a headache for me since my business and personal accounts have similar names (my name) and my clients often make checks out to both my name and my DBA.
3) Twice I have encountered problems with ING’s website where I was unable to access my account. ING sent me a short apology e-mail but would not overnight a check for me that I was unable to have sent when their website was offline.
4) Something that perhaps people don’t realize until it’s too late: with ING and other online banking if you have to send a payment to a vendor, and that vendor requires a voucher, you’re out of luck. ING will not send you a check made out to a vendor which you could then forward to that vendor with their voucher.
For all their great rates, I am now looking elsewhere.
loading....
I’m not economically savvy at all, so maybe I don’t understand how it works, but 1.15% a year is the highest rate in the country? I just don’t get, it almost sound like it’s not worth it, with all the bank crises going on over there in the last couple of years.
loading....
ABOFA (American Banco of Asia) interest rates are 1.27% monthly! That is over 15,30% per year. And this is if you only have a balance of $1000. Some higher deposit amounts have higher interest rates and additional options.
For me, the BEST is American Banco of Asia. I started using ABOFA savings accounts last year. They pay interest rates on time(I selected the quarterly payment option). They have quick online support to answer my questions. I fully recommend ABOFA.
loading....