Last month, I asked for GRS readers to help me by taking a quick survey about their goals, interests, and preferences. As my financial skills mature, I’m wanting to write different types of articles here; I wanted to be sure you were on board with this.
Fortunately, what you want and what I want seem to be fairly well aligned. I don’t have the space or the inclination to share the complete survey results, but many of you have asked for some sort of summary. I’ve tabulated some of the information below.
Only the 1135 complete surveys were used for calculating results; incomplete surveys were discarded. At the end of this summary, I ponder the implications of the results.
Why do you read Get Rich Slowly?
Multiple answers were allowed to this question, and people could write in their own responses (which 111 of you did!). Here’s why folks come here:
- 84.3% of you read GRS to improve your personal finance skills.
- 72.6% come here for tips on how to save and how to be more frugal. This surprised me, to be honest. I’ve been moving away from frugality, but there’s obvious a lot of interest in the topic. So noted.
- 56.7% read the site because you like my writing style. (Thank you.)
- 51.3% appreciate the community and/or like to see how others handle their finances. This is good to know, too. I can share more stories about how other people handle money in the Real World.
- 23.5% are looking for help getting out of debt. This is a lower figure than I expected, but still significant.
- 14.9% like to hear about specials and offers that might help them with their finances.
In the free-form section, you also noted that you like the gardening project (though to be fair, some of you don’t like it), you appreciate the links to outside resources, and you come here for motivation and inspiration.
What is your primary financial goal?
You were only allowed one answer here, though you could offer a write-in response (which nearly a quarter of you did). Here are the primary goals of GRS readers:
- 29.8% are saving for retirement.
- 21.5% are getting out of debt.
- 13.0% are saving for a down-payment on a house. (Surprising! I should write more about this.)
- 8.7% are saving their emergency fund.
- 5.7% want to protect their retirement savings.
- Only a small percentage say that saving for a car or for their children’s education is their top priority.
Many of you noted that your primary financial goal is Financial Independence or early retirement. (I consider these roughly equivalent.) I’m not sure how I forgot to include that on the list since that is now my primary financial goal.
Which personal finance topics interest you?
With this question, you could specify the degree to which the specified topics interested you. You could also list other topics you’d like to see covered. I’m not going to provide the full data, but I can give you some rough info:
- Frugality and DIY were by far the most popular topic: 89.8% of you have some degree of interest in this subject (with 61.4% being very interested). Again, I wasn’t expecting this.
- Budgeting (87.1%) and investing (85.9%) were two more topics in which there was a lot of interest. Savings accounts, etc. had strong support at 77.5%
- Topics with moderate interest include: home improvements (64.4%), gardening (56.8%), getting out of debt (54.1%), credit cards (47.2%, which surprised me), and health insurance (43.1%).
- Few of you are interested in credit repair. Only 18.2% expressed interest, while 54.7% have no interest at all. There wasn’t much interest in auto, life, and health insurance either.
Again, there were a lot of write-ins saying that people like to read about others’ experiences and successes. You enjoy stories like that of my neighbor, the real millionaire next door. (He’s in Alaska now, by the way, on the summer portion of his adventures. Just the other day he mailed me a newspaper clipping that mentioned Get Rich Slowly.)
Basically, it sounds like GRS readers are interested in learning about the things they can do to control their own financial destinies. That’s great. That’s what I’m interested in, too.
Questions about saving and investing
The survey contained a number of questions about your habits with saving and investing. The results here aren’t that interesting, but they help me know what kind of info to provide as I do bank reviews.
For example, only 11.7% of you are rate chasers. Most of you prefer to find a bank you can trust, and are willing to give up a little bit of interest rate to do this. Low fees and online features are very important to you.
Probably the most surprising result in this survey came from the question about debt. I expected many GRS readers to have trouble with debt. And it’s true there is a significant minority for which this is an issue — but it’s a minority. Only 13.2% of you say you need help dealing with debt. (And student loans are by far the biggest problem!) Most GRS readers (52.9%) don’t have a debt problem, and 33.9% of you have debt, but are trying to manage it on your own.
How could Get Rich Slowly be made more useful?
This was a difficult question to construct. It’s hard to know what I can actually offer and what you want. Those who took the survey were able to rate features on a scale from one to five. They were also able to write in additional features they’d like to see. Here are some highlights from this question:
- The feature that sparked the most interest was somehow integrating the best posts from the forums into the blog: 71.9% of you marked this as a four or a five. I’ll confess that I spend very little time in the forums myself, so I can see the value of this feature, too.
- 65.8% of you expressed interest in personal finance calculators. Again, I think this is a great idea. In fact, back when I first started this site, during the summer of 2006, I purchased a license for a set of personal finance calculators — but I never implemented them. It’s time to fast-track this feature.
- There was also strong interest for a “fine-print translator”, a personal finance glossary in plain English, and more guest posts from financial experts (as opposed to other financial bloggers).
- What didn’t you want? You’re not interested in a weekly newsletter, in lists of the best credit card deals (oops — already have a guest post on the way about this), lists of insurance deals, or videos from financial experts.
I’m actually willing to bet that many of you would find it useful to have a section of the site devoted to insurance and credit card deals, much as I have a section devoted to bank deals. It’s not something I’d need to write about all the time, but that info would be there for when you chose to do research.
Other information
There were a lot of other themes that came out in the written comments you provided. Here are some highlights:
- Many of you are interested in increasing your income, especially through hobbies and side jobs.
- You’re also interested in the psychology of personal finance (which is great because that’s one of my favorite topics).
- You’d like more book reviews.
- Most of you seem to love the anecdotes and the personal stories, even if they’re not from me. (That is, you like reading how other people succeed — and fail — with money.)
- There were mixed results regarding the garden posts: There’s a hard-core following, but some of you actively dislike them. I think we’ll maintain the status quo with these.
- Get Rich Slowly has a large international readership, and they’d like info that’s less region-specific. I knew this but had forgotten it. (At one time, I had a huge readership in Australia!)
- Many of you don’t like guest posts, especially from non-experts. Guest posts serve a useful purpose (they give me a break, they provide other viewpoints), but this is good feedback. I actually hope to address this in a creative way by taking on a “staff writer” in the near future. (For more info, see the end of this article.)
To be honest, there were 43 pages of feedback — and that’s with a 9-point font and narrow margins! That’s a lot for me to digest. It also makes it impossible to summarize the many viewpoints.
Demographics
The median Get Rich Slowly reader — or the average person who took the survey, anyhow — is a 31-year-old woman with a bachelor’s degree and a household income of about $73,000. You work full-time and own your own home (though this was a pretty even split — many of you rent!). You’re married (or in a relationship — sorry about the limited choices to this question).
How do you read the site? 13.2% read the e-mail newsletter, 35.4% read by RSS, and 51.4% come to the site directly. Most of you visit the site almost daily — except e-mail subscribers, who hardly visit at all!
Implications
More than anything, this survey confirmed that I’m mostly on the right course. Mostly. You’re interested in saving and investing, you’re interested in retirement and Financial Independence. That’s great. I intend to cover these topics more in the months ahead.
But it was surprising to learn that you really like the frugality and DIY stuff. Not everyone likes this — and there are other sites that do a better job with it than GRS does — but enough of you like it that I intend to write more about it. I’d been avoiding the subject because I thought there was no interest. I was wrong. I’m not going to cover extreme frugality much (I don’t make my own laundry detergent, for example), but I’ll try to do a better job describing the frugal choices Kris and I make in our own lives.
It’s also interesting to note that based on survey feedback — and recent reader e-mail — many of you actively dislike guest posts from non-experts. You’ve asked me to exercise a stronger “quality filter”, and I think that’s a fair request. But it’s also a challenge.
Over the next few months, I’ll begin to work on a book. Based on my conversations with others, it’s clear that this project is going to take a lot of my time. I’m not going to be able to maintain the same publishing schedule (10.2 articles per week) as I have over the past three years. In fact, my goal is to do about half that. (One post per weekday?)
How then to continue providing great content? One option is to feature more guest posts, but that’s likely to leave many of you unhappy. As a result, I’m going to try an alternative.
I’m in the process of auditioning candidates for a “staff writer” position at Get Rich Slowly. This would basically be a second author — a regular guest poster, if you will. I’ll need your help in selecting this person, as you’ll see in the weeks ahead: Candidates are producing their audition pieces right now. (I have all the candidates I need, thanks.) It’s my hope that a regular contributor will be more palatable to you than a never-ending parade of guest authors.
I enjoyed sifting through the survey responses. It’s always fun to hear what other people like about Get Rich Slowly, and how they think the site could improve. (My favorite part of GRS? As always, it’s interacting with the readers!)
This article is about Administration Sunday, 12th July 2009 (by J.D. Roth)


RSS Feeds
Facebook
GRS Twitter







July 12th, 2009 at 4:21 pm
Hi J.D.,
“The feature that sparked the most interest was somehow integrating the best posts from the forums into the blog…”
This is a prime candidate for outsourcing to a smart, talented VA. You’ve been saying for a while now you wanted to find the right person — hiring someone for that task would be a good way to build a relationship with a VA.
-Erica
July 12th, 2009 at 5:00 pm
J.D.,
13% said their goal is to save money for a down payment on a house, ranking pretty high among the other choices. Even though the mortgage and real estate markets are going through a major realignment people are still dreaming about homeownership. This is encouraging, as housing is such a major player in our entire economy and it needs to recover and become a growth engine again.
July 12th, 2009 at 5:34 pm
There is no median of gender!!
But… don’t fall into the trap of worrying *too* much about what your readers *want*. You are followed because you offer creative, different things. Yeah, I have a hard time following the gardening bit because I’m currently trying urban gardening in my nigh-sunless, space-free urban apartment and having… well, limited luck… so I find it hard to imagine that I could really pull off a serious urban gardening effort. But that doesn’t mean I don’t want to hear about it. Like the Dalai Lama once said to a follower, even if you do not have the experience to understand my lesson today, listen anyway; one day you will have the experience to understand what I have said.
July 12th, 2009 at 6:21 pm
interesting survey results. I was wondering - with your recent blog redesign - if there’s an opportunity in the side-bar to feature recent discussions in the forum. Perhaps show the top ten most-discussed forum topics for the past 24 hours.
I read your blog daily (it’s one of the default tab opens when I open a Firefox browser session) but I never visit the discussions. It would be a good incentive to dip my toe in the discussions without being overwhelmed by the volume.
July 12th, 2009 at 6:47 pm
JD,
To echo the above comment “Don’t worry too much about what your readers want,” you mentioned the readers preferred experts for guest posts, but I have seen some CFPs torn up on this site spouting the same thing they use in sales with clients. An example is last week you had a CFP guest post talking about how he met with teachers and advised them to a 403b, instead of a Roth, even though a 403b is an inferior product laden with fees that serve more of an interest for the broker than the client and are seldom portable to another retirement plan such as a Roth without incurring more fees. http://moneycentral.msn.com/content/P134940.asp
In my opinion “Experts” who write on GRS often push the company lines that help them sell products which creates even more mistrust in the financial industry. It may be more effective to have someone in a role similar to what Kiplinger does, writing anonymously giving good advice, but also warning consumers of bad products and practices in the areas they are familiar with.
The other problem with experts is they have the “curse of knowledge.” When some of them write they forget what is like not to know. As they write they become more concerned with sounding intelligent, rather than communicating effectively.
People remember and identify with stories, and experiences, not facts (unless they help illustrate the story). So as you do select people to write I hope you still maintain a healthy mix of your readers stories, struggles, and successes, or at least encourage your experts to include the stories of clients and illustrate how the advice they are sharing with your readers helped the clients they have worked with.
July 12th, 2009 at 7:26 pm
Guest posts are actually the reason I stopped actively (read: everyday) checking GRS.
It’s honestly like coming to a concert to see your favorite band play and you find out the band was tired. So instead you get some other band you never heard of. They could be great players, but it doesn’t matter at the time. You’re in a tiff because you came to expect one thing and got another.
July 12th, 2009 at 8:08 pm
@JerseyMic (#6)
I love your analogy, and it makes sense. To extend it a little though for my own purposes: This band has been touring day after day for a long time and it’s beginning to take a toll. Also, the members would like to record an album. In order to do that, they either have to play less often, or supplement the performances with other groups. It seems like the other groups aren’t always appealing and may actually be turning away the fans. So what the band is trying to find another group that might appeal to listeners and bring this new group in to play on a regular basis.
Ha.
I love that extended metaphor.
Truly, though, I understand the frustration with guest posts. When I think about it, I often skip guest posts at the sites I read regularly. However, I don’t *always* skip them. I’ll read if I think they’re interesting. And if certain authors are regulars, I find that I usually come to appreciate their writing too.
This is why I’m hoping to find a Staff Writer. It seems like a win-win-win situation.
Fingers crossed!
July 12th, 2009 at 8:25 pm
Good luck with the new staff writer–that sounds like a winner. I’m not a fan of the guest posts, but I’d love a regular alternate opinion on the site–it would be a fun contrast. Even better if they come at things from a different angle.
“More than anything, this survey confirmed that I’m mostly on the right course.” Just a note that this survey has an inherent selection bias–the responders have confirmed your instincts because the people who like your stuff (your readers) were the ones answering the survey. To extend the band metaphor one more time, you got up in front of the crowd who paid to get in the concert and asked if they like your songs. If you want to get a bigger crowd (which you might not want), you might have to change your act. Which you are–you’re getting the new guy.
Good luck!
July 12th, 2009 at 9:00 pm
I, for one, would not mind a reduced posting schedule if it meant consistently high quality.
I think the staff writer is a good idea. People resonate with you because they have to come to know you, in a way. So its not that guest posts are inherently bad (although sometimes they are), but that it’s a strange voice to the readers. A staff writer would allow us to get to know someone else. You then just have to be sure to pick a writer with a voice.
July 12th, 2009 at 9:05 pm
Okay, I’m re-reading all of the detailed comments tonight and I came across one that made me laugh. For the survey question about “what would you change?”, one reader said: “Lasers. I would add lasers.” I think that’s hilarious. I think a personal finance blog with lasers would be dangerous.
July 12th, 2009 at 9:22 pm
It seems to me there may be another good compromise here. Consider getting a really sharp VA to help manage the blog, moderate comments and transcribe your book from voice recordings. If you dropped from 10.2 to an even 7 posts a week, that would free up some time for your book and transcription from recordings should save you some time from the keyboard. This solution would also allow you to multi-task creating a written and audio version of your book. It should also eliminate the need for a staff writer. Just a thought, we trust your judgement or we wouldn’t be regulars here.
July 12th, 2009 at 10:07 pm
Better yet a through back to the 90’s, add images of sharks with lasers swimming around the header of your page. Then maybe you could make $1,000,000 (echo evil laugh)
July 12th, 2009 at 10:13 pm
Good idea getting feedback from readers. Guest posts are more often than not shunned by regular readers.
July 13th, 2009 at 3:50 am
One interesting thing would be to see how many of your readers are outside the US, I don’t think this was an option on the survey but from other comments I think there are quite a few of us. Although not all the content here is directly related to my circumstances this is still my favourite blog. Having an international flavour might be an idea?
July 13th, 2009 at 5:30 am
I laugh at lists of best credit card deals because how often do you need that? If you do credit cards right you should never really need a new one once you’ve got what you’re looking for.
As for guest posts, I like being exposed to other writing styles, but a lot of what is published here isn’t very good. No offense to the writers, it’s just not fantastic. It should be.
July 13th, 2009 at 6:20 am
I really like the idea about highlighting most discussed forums. It would give you a break from creating posts and keep readers interested (I haven’t checked out any of the forums yet, but if some were highlighted it would definitely give me something to read and think about). I think a staff writer could also be very helpful. One other thing you might want to consider is posting more reader questions - maybe with less commentary from you (which would reduce your workload) and give other readers the chance to offer advice/thoughts. One of the things I love about this sight is the great comments a lot of your readers provide.
July 13th, 2009 at 7:17 am
JD,
Thanks for taking the time and effort to see what we like and why we keep coming back. That to me, is a big reason why I visit your site so regularly. There are a lot of blogs out there that seem to be written just because the writer needs something to do or something to complain about. Your blog is truly helpful as are your readers. I enjoy reading the comments almost as much as the blogs sometimes. Keep up the good work!
July 13th, 2009 at 7:40 am
About the only guest posts by “Financial Experts” I regularly read all the way through are those by Neal Frankle, although I did read the one by the JARS guy and found it interesting. As someone else mentioned, the rest read more like ads for the guest poster’s paid website/services.
July 13th, 2009 at 8:10 am
One of my favorite political blogs, the one at the washington monthly, has a regular blogger and a secondary voice — who is very different but just as interesting! I hope you will find someone (maybe a woman from england or australia!) who has a very different but complementary approach to you, and I would encourage Kris to continue her occasional posts, too. Also, I’m with those who would appreciate main page links to specific forum content.
And finally, I love the comments on posts and almost always read through them if I’m reading the post — even when they get into the 100s! The commentary here is really good — unusually civil and appropriate almost allthe time.
July 13th, 2009 at 8:45 am
I keep forgetting that there ARE forums on this site. So yeah, maybe a hot topic link on the front page or something like that would be cool.
I look forward to testing out your potential staff writers!
July 13th, 2009 at 9:11 am
I laughed when you mentioned not going to the lengths of “extreme frugality” and not doing articles on making your own laundry detergent, because I remembered an article on another website on how to make your own tampons! EWWWW!
July 13th, 2009 at 9:53 am
I’m one of those who tends to skip over most guest posts… though I will say a few have grabbed my interest and a feed subscription. The staff writer idea is a really good one.
Also, it seems like you’ve been downplaying it a bit, but you’re WRITING A BOOK! That’s cool!
July 13th, 2009 at 10:02 am
I’ve never set foot (eye?) in the forums here at GRS. That being said, I’d be a lot more interested in linking to interesting discussion there than hearing a guest writer rehash some topic you can read a hundred other places. (Sorry JD, I realize you want the traffic, but I’m being honest.)
Bottom line is JD’s writing style and message is why people come back, even if the survey says just over 50%. The comments are also consistently good here, which is another reason I keep reading.
July 13th, 2009 at 1:17 pm
I think the staff writer is a great idea. You’ll choose someone who really understands this site and its readers.
Other popular PF blogs seem too paranoid about losing their cult of personality to get help. You’re not afraid to let someone else make a name for themselves here and I respect that. Keep up the good work.
July 13th, 2009 at 3:45 pm
Just checking in after a long hiatus. So glad to see how well you’re doing, J.D. I will definitely be checking in more, I could use some reinvigoration in the PF department. Congrats on the book and the ongoing success of the site. You have earned and deserve it.
M (from M’s Blog)
July 13th, 2009 at 5:03 pm
Interesting to note that 50% of us care about retirement and getting out of debt. My #1 goal is on a comfortable retirement.
What would be interesting to know are the demographics of the readership ie age, income, medianmean salary etc.
I will be highlighting your post on my blog JD. Thnx!
July 13th, 2009 at 7:04 pm
JD - Is it ok to add my blog website in the Website box? Sorry, I’m a novice at this.
RB
July 14th, 2009 at 12:05 am
I was a tad surprised to read that GRS readers don’t like guest posts. I hope people understand that you have to rely on them or you would go crazy. How else do you take a vacation or work on another project?
I actually like them. They send me to other sites. I find other good material. If I see a guest poster that I don’t like, I just skip over the material. That’s no different from skipping over a post of yours on a topic that doesn’t interest me.
July 14th, 2009 at 12:28 am
I’m all for guest posts. Need new perspectives. Just like one should read three separate newspapers a day as to not get jaded by one leaning view point.
Rgds
RB
July 14th, 2009 at 8:00 am
Yeah, late to the party here, but like a couple of the others above I don’t mind the guest posts either. I don’t read all of them but some are very good and after all I don’t read all of your posts either.
July 14th, 2009 at 3:49 pm
I’m glad that you’ll be writing more about financial independence/retirement. I’m older than your average reader and would like to retire early - mostly because my husband is 8 years older than me and we’ll want to do some of the active things that we enjoy before our bodies limit our options.
But I have a lot of concerns about retiring early - mostly making our money last and dealing with health insurance before I reach Medicare age… I’ll be real interested in your posts on this subject.
July 23rd, 2009 at 11:51 am
I’d love it if you wrote more about saving for a downpayment. I’m in that boat right now.