Notes on Self-Study from a Killjoy Perfectionist
Published on - January 14th, 2010 (Modified on - June 30th, 2010) (by April Dykman) This post is from GRS staff writer April Dykman.
I have a friend who just doesn’t see himself. He has declared bankruptcy twice and alcohol abuse landed him in jail for the past year. Despite losing almost everything, when he was released he was talking about how much money it would cost to get his iPhone back in service. To make the situation more frustrating, he largely blames others for his circumstances.
We all know someone that makes us shake our heads and wonder why he or she continues to repeat the same self-destructive behavior. But how often do we consider the likelihood that we, too, are not seeing ourselves clearly?
Self-study is a tricky process, but it’s the only way to create lasting, positive change, whether it’s a change in how you handle your finances, your relationships, your weight, or any other life area with which you struggle.
Revealing the positive
Self-study doesn’t require sitting in front of a mirror or retreating to a cave. In fact, usually it’s activities to which we’re naturally drawn that uncover our strengths and teach us about ourselves. Writing, sports, travel, music, dance, photography, woodworking–any activity can be an act of self-study if there’s an intention to learn about yourself and a commitment to stick with it. The sticktoitiveness part is key, since it’s usually when something becomes difficult that we learn the most about ourselves.
As a personal example, one of my favorite activities is kayaking. I took lessons in college, and during our last lesson, we were to circle a small island near the dam. The river was usually calm, but recent thunderstorms made the water choppy, and we had to fight a current to circle the island.
A few students couldn’t make it and were swept back, deciding to meet us on the other side. I pushed through and made it around the island. I felt a surge of pride, and our teacher was greatly impressed that students with only four lessons could paddle against the current. My sheer determination to accomplish a goal was something positive I learned about myself.
Facing the negative
The downside to self-study is that you start to learn things about yourself that might be unpleasant. Self-study can reveal weaknesses, shortcomings, obsessions, bad habits, and less-than-attractive behavior of which you either weren’t aware or have been ignoring for years.
When my boyfriend (now husband) and I went kayaking together for the first time, I was psyched to share my love of paddling with him. We rented a tandem kayak and set out into the water. I explained the basics, and we started to paddle toward a spring. Only he wasn’t in unison with me, so we were having to work too hard. And sometimes he wasn’t holding his paddle at a 45-degree angle. And where was that push-pull technique I showed him? After helpfully pointing out these things, thinking only of perfecting his paddling skills, he smiled and said, “I thought this was supposed to be fun.”
(Can you see why I married the guy? He’s the only one that can kindly point out that I was being a killjoy perfectionist without using those words AND make me laugh about it at the same time.)
Here I was ruining a lovely day on the lake, not enjoying the scenery or the company, because I was concerned with kayaking technique.
Acknowledge and accept
If you’ve read some of my other articles at GRS, you know I stress going easy on yourself. This is because my first inclination has always been to berate myself for every shortcoming and every failure, real or perceived. But it never got me far, so I started to ease up on myself. I emphasize cutting yourself some slack both for your benefit and to remind myself of the same thing! Rather than berating yourself for being an insensitive egomaniac (or a killjoy perfectionist), acknowledge and accept the behavior.
This does not mean that you continue to be a first class jerk because you are who you are, it means that you recognize that you do it. You accept that this is the way you act sometimes. By accepting what you discover about yourself, you can get closer to the source of the behavior. You can’t think constructively about what causes you to react a certain way and learn to handle or redirect the habit if you’re busy hating yourself.
“Self” doesn’t mean “solo”
Self-study is not easy. It can be difficult to separate our perceptions from the truth because we usually see things the way that we’ve been taught to see them from the time we were children, and sometimes the way we’ve been taught to see things is distorted.
In many ways self-study is a solo task, but if our perceptions are distorted, it can be impossible to see ourselves. For this reason, you need a mentor. Mentors can be teachers, close friends, family members, or anyone who you trust to see your weak spots. I wouldn’t have noticed what I was doing that day on the lake if my husband hadn’t called my attention to it.
Once you have a person in mind, find some quiet time and mention that you’ve noticed that you are a bit of a killjoy perfectionist (obviously substitute the weakness for your own, but feel free to use mine if applicable). Ask your person if he or she has noticed it. Talk about possible causes of the feelings or behaviors, and ways to redirect them. Tell your person that you want to work on improving yourself, and ask for help when he or she notices the negative actions.
Self-study is hard work, but it’s worth it.
Have you ever discovered something negative about yourself that you’ve intentionally worked to overcome? Was it hard to own up to it? How did you redirect the feelings or behavior?
GRS is committed to helping our readers save and achieve your financial goals.Savings interest rates may be low, but that’s all the more reason to shop for the best rate.Find the highest savings interest rate from Ally Bank, Capital One 360, Everbank, and more.
This article is about Psychology, Self-Improvement
Disclaimer: This content is not provided or commissioned by American Express. Opinions expressed here are author's alone, not those of American Express, and have not been reviewed, approved or otherwise endorsed by American Express. This site may be compensated through American Express Affiliate Program.
Discover is a paid advertiser of this site. Reasonable efforts are made to maintain accurate information. See the Discover online credit card application for full terms and conditions on offers and rewards.
SEARCH FOR RECENT ARTICLES



Wow! You are indeed lucky to have such a wonderful husband who can point out what you were doing in a positive way. But you should also take some credit for recognising what he was saying and taking it to heart (and not tipping him out of the kayak…)
Until I deal with the underlying self-esteem issue I guess.
One of the problems I have is that some of the things I’m aware of are linked with low self-esteem. And so most of the times they have been pointed out have been in very negative and derogatory ways, by which I mean rude, bordering on actual bullying. It’s sometimes hard not to be defensive about them in that situation, and if I ask people I trust “am I like this”, they say “not that I’ve really noticed”, because when I’m around them, I’m confident, and so it’s less of an issue…
Vicious circles
loading....
This is a really interesting approach to discovering more about yourself. I’ve always been a fan of writing (both public and private) as a means of self-discovery, but largely because that’s one of my big strengths.
What I had not considered is some of the other activities you mention…of course, we need an additional “layer” during this self-study time–that of self-awareness to actually know that we’re self-studying.
I think this has many personal finance applications, both in the same spirit as you discuss (finding out your characteristics, strengths, and weaknesses) and in a direct application (like taking the time to review your expenses in detail to see what you prioritize).
loading....
Yes, every day I strive to work on my short comings in my professional and personal life. I tend to be controlling and a perfectionist and that can be a positive and a negative in both arenas of my life.
One of the reasons that I set goals and not resolutions is that goals are things I’m working on and some days I do better than others. Resolutions = things that I resolve to do or not to do and for me its pretty easy to fail at resolutions because its an absolute.
Almost every day I review my goals, and I work away at them and I check the box for those goals on which I’ve made progress and I review the ones for which no progress has been made and I keep working away at them each and every day.
loading....
Sometimes it helps to make life changes to accommodate your personality. I was a manager for the first 12+ years of my career. That profession, however, doesn’t really mesh well with a trait that I have to take on tasks for myself and just do them. I’m not a great delegator.
I also tend to avoid confrontation, which can be a problem when addressing others’ performance. I switched careers to IT network admin. Now I don’t have anyone reporting to me and I’m in more of a customer service type role. I’m much happier 5 days per week. It’s a much better fit!
loading....
I like the way you write and the topics you pick, April!
I have found that it takes a lot of self-confidence to really look at myself and see my shortcomings and work on them effectively. Only now, at 42, do I have enough confidence to ask a voice teacher pointed questions until I understand what he is trying to teach, to record and evaluate my own singing, or to look in the mirror to see what I’m doing wrong.
I’ve also found that the main issue I have to work around to effectively address my shortcomings is shame. Probably because my parents felt this way themselves, I tend to feel intense shame when dealing with my mistakes and flaws. Fortunately, 15 years in the land of serial reinvention (California) plus a year of therapy was very helpful in dealing with this. I can usually put my flaws and mistakes in perspective, and move beyond the shame to dealing with the issues, but it’s still a struggle.
As a parent, I want my kids to be more effective at self-improvement, without the elements of shame I picked up. By pursuing interests and situations where I’m learning all the time, I hope I can provide a helpful model for self-awareness and self-study. We’ll see . . .
loading....
For self-study and self-improvement, I highly recommend co-counseling, which is a peer process involving two people who share time in a session to heal past and present hurts, to celebrate growth, and make intentional change. I have found it invaluable for identifying and changing negative patterns, and for self validation. More information can be found at http://www.cci-usa.org.
loading....
I’ve worked on a lot of different things, and overcome some of them (including a doozy — social anxiety). What I’ve discovered along the way is twofold: one, we’re often way harder on ourselves than anyone else ever would be, and two, sometimes it pays to observe/listen to others in order to see our real issues.
By that I mean that if there is something that really annoys is about others, chances are it’s really a problem with ourself. Likewise, if we keep experiencing the same issues over and over again with different people, it’s likely that the common denominator is us.
loading....
“Writing, sports, travel, music, dance, photography, woodworking–any activity can be an act of self-study if there’s an intention to learn about yourself and a commitment to stick with it. ”
I’m glad you make the point that self discovery can occur in conjunction with activities we enjoy. I think if I set myself the task of “evaluate myself” or “consider areas for improvement” that task would never get done. Or else it would get done and I’d be depressed. If the evaluation is a happy benefit of doing something I otherwise enjoy, well then, it’s closer to the top of my list.
loading....
I’m certainly a perfectionist, but I tend to force it out of myself rather than the people around me. I’ve been getting slightly better, at least with some things — I no longer demand nothing but A’s in my classes, for one. I had to admit that I wouldn’t be good at every class I ever take, so there will be B’s. I’m finally a senior, and am glad to say I’ve only gotten one C so far.
Other than that, I’ve always suffered from low self-esteem and a lack of confidence. Since finding cars I’ve been better with that — racing has given so much more to me than I ever thought it would, other than something to just do and love. I’m a more confident person because I know some of my strengths, and all I care about weaknesses is identifying them and mending them enough to get by. I really like the idea of working on emphasizing strengths and not weaknesses, it just makes sense to me. (And promotes social interaction, something I tend to struggle with as well.)
loading....
I go to Crossfit regularly, which is a gym that favors short, intense, and VERY challenging workouts. It’s at the gym that I often see most clearly what is holding me back in other areas of my life, whether it’s an inability to concentrate, a lack of confidence (I talk myself out of being able to lift more weight, for example), or my anxieties about competition (which usually translates to self-sabotage).
The ways these things manifest themselves are often quite subtle, but it’s amazing how often something will happen at the gym that turns a light bulb on in my head — I realize it’s something I do at work, in my relationships, etc.
I also think that regularly learning new skills is a great way to “see yourself in action,” so to speak. Taking a risk and trying something you aren’t comfortable with activates lots of emotional triggers. Do you avoid trying something new? Turn into the class clown to mask anxiety (or get out of doing the task altogether)? Switch into competitive mode, having to be the best? It’s eye-opening.
loading....
One of my weaknesses is lack of confidence. It’s not really apparent at work because I can cover it up in other ways, but it really shows up when I am rock climbing. Whenever I have the thought of not being able to make a certain move while climbing, my mind takes over my body and completely cramps up. I waste my energy cramping up and then I get to tired to finish the climb smoothly.
What I have learned from all of this is to mentally move the negative thoughts out of my head and believe in myself (both in sports and at work). By visualizing that I will succeed, my body will follow and it will be easier to concentrate on the difficult task at hand rather than worry about the what-ifs. This technique is applicable to so many things in life. For example, it makes me be less fearful of asking for something, because with a more focused yet relaxed mind, your body language will reflect confidence rather than fear.
loading....
It’d be nice if J.D. updated with a post about the importance of giving and humanitarian relief efforts in Haiti. I know it’s everywhere else as well, but the perspective is important on a blog like this.
loading....
April, I was just thinking about this topic, but from a different perspective.
It is important to know yourself and your weaknesses not just to work to make them better. But since they can hold you back, and continue to do so before you overcome them, it can really help to know how to work around them.
I don’t fold clothes. I don’t mind doing it, but it always seems so unimportant that I procrastinate until my clothes are a wrinkled heap. So my husband and I have worked out a system that hangs important clothes, and I can just dump everything else in a drawer. My husband really wants me to organize my sock drawer, but why should I? I have given up on perfection. It is a work around I have accepted.
It’s also helpful to know the difference between discomfort and fear. I don’t like public speaking, but I worked on it until it was a skill I was proficient at and didn’t fear. But it still makes me uncomfortable, so once the fear was gone I gave myself permission to avoid it if I can.
loading....
I disagree with many statements above because they presume that the self is not fluid, but a fixed state. People are not “perfectionists,” but they choose to be. Anyone can find someone that they admire and mirror similar actions and reactions and began to develop in a way that the admired person did. What is required, however, is active reflection and construction, both of which are unpopular these days since TV is “more interesting.” However, the few people that understand reflection (like the above), rarely realize that construction allows you to alter your being because it’s not fixed, solid state.
So essentially there is no “true self” of a person, though because construction is an arduous labor, many people will assert that they can’t change due to their innate nature, which really means change requires too much work.
loading....
I’m a scatter-brained perfectionist. How’s that for oxymoron? Lately, I’ve managed to make myself dizzy by trying to focus on too many things at once in an effort to get everything right. The consequence is that I’m getting nothing done. I know this is a repeated pattern for me, but I feel like a bug flying toward the light. I know I’m going to get zapped, but I head there anyway!
This unproductive habit definitely affects how I manage our finances. I am sometimes trying to juggle budgeting, retirement planning, tax planning and everyday purchases at the same time. I end up spinning my wheels and accomplishing very little. I’m working on focus.
loading....
My weakness is that I am too easy on myself. When I want to eat another chocolate chip cookie, I can in seconds come up with a great rationalization for doing so even though 10 minutes earlier I had been swearing off the things. I am sincere when I am swearing off them. And I am sincere in the rationalizations. Human feelings trump logical consistency in my world view.
My wife is the opposite. Her view is that you say what you mean and you mean what you say and that’s that. My weakness is inconstancy. Hers is a lack of understanding of why people mess up.
I believe that God put us together so that I could remind her of why people are so weak and so that she could remind me of the need for me to toughen up. And, also, because He has a good sense of humor.
Rob
loading....
Too many to list! Hoarding, procrastinating, over-spending, over-eating, being judgmental…..and many more!
I found for myself that a therapist provided the best help for self-study. Others I know got it from AA.
loading....
I am a perfectionist too. It is silly sometimes. I’m working on that.
loading....
Truly one of your most moving and inspiring articles at GRS, April.
I believe self-study and observation to be at the core of improving our financial lives as well as our personal — as you cannot “fix what is not broken.”
We each have to delve deeply into ourselves with respect to personal finances and ask ourselves “I want to be debt-free because…” “I want to retire because…” “I spend /spent money because…”
By learning the roots of our behaviour, only then can we accept what is good, alter what is bad, and truly get to know ourseleves and enjoy our lives to their fullest extent.
loading....
Absolutely. I did a program with Landmark Education, and this is what they are all about.
I realized what a precious little spoiled brat I’d been being (at age 40) about my mom and cleaned up my relationship with her, fully acknowledging the awesome job she did after my dad died (for which I’d been blaming her). Moreover, I came to realize how I’d been carrying a need for ‘someone else’ to fix everything in my life into my relationship – imagine how that was going.
It’s like being a fish – you don’t have much concept of water until someone takes you out of it. Then you get a whole different opinion on the subject!
So, I very strongly recommend Landmark Education – I now have a great relationship with my mom, I’m married to a fantastic girl and we work on our relationship together continuously, and I’ve achieved financial Independence – all as a result of doing these programs.
loading....
When I think of weaknesses that I have made great improvements on, the kinds that are obvious (easy to realize) are the ones that come to mind:
* I stopped sucking my thumb (finger, actually).
* I stopped biting my nails.
* I learned how to talk to strangers.
But then I remembered a few other things I learned:
* I tend to err in the direction of being too macho rather than too wimpy – I learned this while recovering from a sprained ankle and while recovering from the flu. Now I know that when in doubt about whether I should keep resting, the answer is probably “yes.”
* I tend to give up too soon – I learned this when I read that most people get 10 – 15 interviews before they get an acceptable job offer. I had just given up on finding a new job after 9 interviews. So I started the job search again, and got a job offer after interview #11 and an acceptable job offer after interview #12. Now if I’m wondering whether I should face facts already and just give up, I know the answer is probably “no.”
Similarly, while playing ultimate frisbee, if I knew there was do way I was going to get to the disk, but there was no one else there to try for it, I should try anyway (just in case). This strategy transferred instantly to playing volleyball, improving my game. And just yesterday I used this strategy and started running when I saw my bus coming even though I knew there was no way I’d make it. I did make it–it turns out there were a lot of people at that stop and one of them was having trouble getting her bus card out.
* I can learn lots more. In grad school I met someone who was much better than me at everything (except embroidery). One day he came folk dancing with me and messed up more than I did. He did learn more quickly than I had learned, but it wasn’t some sort of magical talent thing–he had to practice just like anybody else. Since that time, I have gotten a lot better at several things, including some things I have no talent at that were very slow going but very fun.
@namesarehardtopick, there may be no true self, but there are definitely recurring patterns in behavior! It’s a lot better if these aren’t always a big surprise.
loading....
Great article! It gave me a lot to think about. I loved the picture, it made me laugh out loud! Nicely done.
loading....
April, Congrats on a fanstastic and insightful post. JD – I commend you for acknowledging and honoring the reality that personal finance is not just about the numbers.
Human beings have a tendency to mask psychological turmoil with addictions, destructive habits, etc. I think money is often used in this way. We also tend to mindlessly mimic money habits our families of origin taught us.
I think if people grew up poor, they tend to buy more stuff, chasing the ever elusive sense of security. They want to feel empowered, strong, and confident. Hoarders may also feel that there will never be enough. If people feel inadequate – new clothes, gadgets may validate them – what’s disturbing and sad is that this validation is not authentic nor lasting, so the quest continues and their finances go down the drain.
For me, I distinctly remember my mother sitting at the dining room table trying to figure out how to pay all of the bills – I recall knowing not to disturb her because she was quite tense and stressed, there never seemed to be enough, she paid her bills consistently and on time, but there was not much left over in terms of an emergency fund, retirement, investing. Most working and middle class people have been taught that your job is your source of income, that you are hopelessly dependent on that job to take care of your family. We have to re-wire our minds and challenge what we’ve been taught, what we’ve witnessed – we can live authentically empowered lives, money does not have to be a source of stress -it is merely a tool, handling your finances is a skill, and like any skill it can be learned
loading....
It must be seasonal:-) Just this morning I read an article in Harvard Business Review with a great exercise that helps to change behaviour. It goes like this:
Complete the sentence: “When I get better at…” over and over again. Listen closely as you recite potential benefits. You will be amazed at how quickly you can determine whether this change is worth it for you.
I’ve tried it with my goal of changing my spending habits and there is a good chance it will work
loading....
@Rob (#16) “I believe that God put us together so that I could remind her of why people are so weak and so that she could remind me of the need for me to toughen up. And, also, because He has a good sense of humor.”
My husband and I complement each other in a similar way and I find that it works well as a relationship dynamic. He is very easy-going and I am a bit more uptight than I’d like to be. He helps me recognize when I am stressing over meaningless, unimportant things, and I help him to be more responsible and task-oriented in the areas where it matters.
Very funny
I’ve also found that self-study has become easier as Ive gotten older. Through my teens and 20s I was more concerned about how others’ perceived me, and therefore tried to hide or cover up any potential weaknesses. But as a 30-something, I find myself analyzing my own strengths more, and taking ownership of my weaknesses. It’s a powerful and freeing feeling to be able to publicly admit to something you don’t like about yourself, and not fear what others’ will think of you. Most of my “admissions” have been met with reaffirmations of my decency as a person from the people whom I care about, as well as a few admissions of their own. This type of honesty has added a new dimension to even long-time friendships.
loading....
Perfectionists aren’t always high achievers. In fact, they are often the worst procrastinators.
They are scared to get anything done because their self image is on the line if they don’t achieve perfection.
“If you will settle for nothing other than perfection, that is often what you will get — nothing”
Working on unconditional self acceptance (easier said than done ) is the way to shut that cycle down.
loading....
Really liked this one. I’ve been doing self-study as part of my yoga practice for the past six years. It was enormously helpful in a) deciding to take action in creating an exit plan from a miserable job; b) choosing a new path; c) divorcing my ego from said miserable job and its mind-numbingly dull successor; d) enjoying the transitions and being open-hearted about new opportunities.
I am a relentless improver, and the biggest difficulty for me in life has been my impulse to improve everything around me. It’s not my responsibility to fix other people, other people’s businesses, other people’s relationships, or anything else but myself and my immediate environment. It’s been a challenge, but one well worth pursuing, to learn to let things be.
loading....
great write-up.
loading....
There’s a reason they call a tandem kayak the “divorce” kayak! Almost 30 years of marriage, and we still won’t get in one.
loading....
There are friends who will always commiserate with me about your shortcomings, and I’m to have them in my life. But when I’m ready to make progress, it’s the friends who will look me in the eye, and tell it like it is, that really seem to matter the most to me.
loading....
I don’t know, man. I’ve followed this blog over the past year while I killed off more than $20K in debt and put $8K in my savings. A true success story if there ever was one. Anyway, here’s my critical observation: With the addition and more frequent use of your staff writers the quality of Get Rich Slowly is going down. I like your style, your views, your talent with words. These posts lately come across as “well, duh” pieces that anybody who’s willing to invest a few hours Googling can come up with. At least with your posts, I felt a deeper commitment on your part to understand the motivations and the implications of whatever topics you discussed. Just my 2 cents…
loading....
I think I can learn any subject on my own.
John DeFlumeri Jr
loading....
Awareness is truly hard to develop. I have tackled this task many times myself. The hardest thing to do is to catch yourself in the act of a destructive action.
At those moments it seems that the mind just goes blank and that you cannot remember exactly why it happened.
Journaling helps a ton with this as well as watching others and recognizing yourself in those actions.
One other major tool that we can use to build awareness is to look at our parents and see how they act and then ask ourselves if we have been guilty of similar actions.
Why does studying your parents work? Because they raised and that’s where you picked up most of your good and bad habits. It can be an eye opener; at least it was for me.
Best,
Tomas
loading....
Yes, I have. The best lesson that I learned is that you must take responisibility for your own actions and realize that only you can bring about your own happiness–no one else and nothing else can do it for you
loading....
April, I love the kayak story with your husband! I know a number of people who have gone kayaking with a significant other and found it a real test of how well they can communicate, coordinate and do something difficult together. On a vacation with a boyfriend, we tried kayaking and ended up in such an argument about who it was that was steering us in circles that he wouldn’t speak to me for the next three days!! Needless to say, he isn’t my boyfriend any more (and I maintain that it was his fault as he was paddling with all his strength, but was twice my size). Sheila (#29) obviously knows of this phenomena too!
loading....