This post from staff writer Sierra Black is in honor of Earth Day.
As soon as you start thinking about how to live more lightly on the earth, your eyes start opening to the myriad ways you can do that. You can eat only organic food. You can bike to work instead of driving. You can insist on high-efficiency appliances. You can line dry your clothes.
Some of these lifestyle shifts will save you money. Others are expensive. Often, I hear cost used as a reason not to “go green”. In fact, environmentally damaging products and lifestyle choices are only affordable because we’re not paying the full cost of them. While you enjoy your cheap plastic toys, people in the developing world are paying the price in terms of pollution, exploitative labor, and natural resource consumption.
Most of us want to do right by the environment. We’d love to have pesticide-free homes and diets. We want our spending to support small farms, local businesses, and fair wages for workers in the developing world. That doesn’t mean we necessarily have the available cash to do what our values dictate.
A lot of green lifestyle changes also have a time cost, associated with them. A few weeks ago, I wrote about how easy it is to slip into Time Debt by thoughtlessly taking on new commitments. Biking to work sounds great, but if it adds an hour to your commute time each day, you’re losing an hour at work or at home.
With every green step you take, you need to consider whether or not you can truly afford it.
Here are some inexpensive steps you can take that will “green up” your bank account and the planet:
- Stop buying Stuff. You all knew I was going to say that, right? When you buy consumer goods, you create demand for resources to make, transport and sell those goods. That can be good for the economy, but it’s bad for the planet — and your wallet. When you do need to buy something, always investigate your options for getting it used rather than new. Used goods are cheaper and greener.
- Cut back on utilities. You can save about $150 a year worth of electricity by line drying your clothes instead of drying them in a machine. Another $150 can be trimmed just by washing them on cold cycles instead of hot. Using high-efficiency light bulbs, insulating your home, and using recycled rainwater to quench your garden are all small changes that can save you big money. They also leave a smaller ecological footprint.
- Park your car. Biking to work might not be practical every day, but maybe you can do it one day a week. Try expanding your radius for walking and biking, and explore public transit options in your area. My family of four drives less than 500 miles a month these days; much less than that in the warmer months. How low can you go? Make it a game. The prize: more money in your pocket, and fewer emissions into the atmosphere.
Once you’ve explored your free or cheap options, you may want to take a close look at some of those spendier choices. Should you be buying organic strawberries? What about “green” disposable diapers? How do you know what the best use of your limited resources is?
Making a decision about a green lifestyle change or product is like making a decision about any other expense. You just need to add the impact on the planet into your set of priorities.
It helps to do your homework. I can’t afford to buy only organic foods, so I use this handy table to help me understand which foods absorb the highest amount of pesticides. I prioritize getting organic apples and strawberries because they’re high on the list, and worry less about sweet potatoes, since they’re very low.
It’s also useful to consider how the added cost of an eco-friendly item will affect your ability to do other things you value. For example, I cloth-diapered both my children. We used second-hand diapers and washed them in a high-efficiency washer. If you’re going to use diapers at all, this is about as low-impact as you can get.
When my daughter’s daycare refused to use the cloth diapers, I assumed I’d put her in the “eco-friendly” disposables you can buy at Whole Foods. Those diapers, made in part from recycled paper, can cost as much as ten times what a box of generic disposables costs at Costco. I bought the generics, and used part of my savings to pay for a membership in the Union of Concerned Scientists.
Ultimately, being an earth-conscious shopper is a bit like being a frugal shopper. It’s important, but it isn’t the whole answer. The simplest, best thing we can do as consumers is to just consume less. That’s good for our bank accounts, our environment, and our bodies.
When we do consume, we’d do well to weigh the environmental impact of our purchases and look for used or eco-friendly options. We also need to hold corporations and governments accountable for large-scale change.
Don’t buy into the idea that every purchase you make needs to be local, organic, hand-made, or recycled. What matters most is that we bring our lives into balance, value the simplicity of buying less, and work for change on a global scale — as well as in our own backyards.
GRS is committed to helping our readers save and achieve your financial goals.Savings interest rates may be low, but that’s all the more reason to shop for the best rate.Find the highest savings interest rate from Ally Bank, Capital One 360, Everbank, and more.
This article is about Choices, Consumerism
Disclaimer: This content is not provided or commissioned by American Express. Opinions expressed here are author's alone, not those of American Express, and have not been reviewed, approved or otherwise endorsed by American Express. This site may be compensated through American Express Affiliate Program.
Discover is a paid advertiser of this site. Reasonable efforts are made to maintain accurate information. See the Discover online credit card application for full terms and conditions on offers and rewards.
SEARCH FOR RECENT ARTICLES



Some of the biggest things that affect one’s “footprint” is transportation (fuel) and heating/cooling costs for house. We purposely picked a place to live where both my husband and I could bike or walk to work if needed (we don’t do it every day) so we can be a 1 car family and maybe spend $80 a month on gas. Regarding heating/cooling, it is worth it to spend some money on insulation, and have a smaller size home sq foot-wise. This makes the biggest difference, and why ironically most city dwellers have smaller footprints than suburban dwellers. But- the way most cities and towns are designed (or NOT designed) the majority of housing is spread out, and there is poor public transportion. Given the choice of a larger, newer house for less money than a smaller older house close to the center, I can see why not everyone does this. That’s why we can personally do what we want to improve the situation, but there needs to be better planning to make the most impact (compare European versus American cities).
loading....
Want to make a green impact? Vote!
Public policy changes and laws are the things that will ultimately make a difference. You flushing the toilet a few less times won’t.
loading....
Here’s how I “go green”:
- I don’t buy or eat processed food. I also don’t drink soda so no aluminum cans to try to recycle!
- I don’t eat meat more than a couple times a week.
- I only have 2 kids instead of more.
- I work full time so I don’t have to heat my house, use the bathroom, or turn on the lights during the day.
- I live and work in a small town so I don’t drive much even though I do drive to work.
loading....
When I read this article and the comments that follow I can’t help but thinking that it must be tiresome to live up to all the rules and expectations of green fundamentalism. I suppose humans have an installed need to believe in something and that must make it worth it.
loading....
Excellent post Sierra! I must admit I found some of the responses absolutley hilarious. Does anyone really decide to have fewer children solely becasue it’s good for the environment? Come on – these are complex decisions based on a miriad of factors, economics, personal preference, and yes, sociatal impact should have some say. But it is true that green living has become so fashionable that people will think up all sorts of reasons to put themselves in the ‘good’ camp. The bottom line is that it’s all about making concious decisions. Mindless, rampant consumerism isn’t good for anyone (expect maybe Sam Walton’s children). But neither is getting on your high horse and pointing out how much better you are than your neighbors because you didn’t have children. I guess if humans became extinct that might be a good thing for ‘mother earth’ – but isn’t the point of keeping the earth green so that it remains habitable for us?
loading....
@49 GolfingGirl
The point is, don’t do the things that are super hard or expensive, and focus on what’s easy to do.
I used to bike 12 miles each way to/from work on the interstate, but I’m into biking. I wouldn’t expect others to do it. But what’s the point of a snarky, bitter post about how it’s too hard to be environmentally friendly? What was your point?
loading....
If it does take you round trip an hour to ride your bike to work, why would that be a bad thing?
You have to exercise anyway, so that saves you an hour in the gym. And money on multiple levels.
loading....
Regarding line drying, you can still do this if you live somewhere without a garden (e.g. a flat). I haven’t used a tumble dryer in years; instead, I have something that looks like this:
http://www.shop-com.co.uk/cc.class/cc?main=p&act=211491882&ccsyn=261
That takes about two loads of washing, and I can fold down some of the segments if I want to dry something like trousers, i.e. have them hanging from the top rail, past where the middle rail would be. When I’m not using it, it just folds up flat, so it’s not in the way. I can’t remember how much mine cost, but it wasn’t much, and I’ve had it for 13 years (surviving 3 moves).
I fold T-shirts in half and hang them over the rails to dry. For work shirts, I put them on hangers and then hook them over my shower rail. That also has the fringe benefit that I don’t have to iron them afterwards. (I don’t even own an iron!)
loading....
Uh, maybe some think this is gross but we don’t flush every time we pee. We drink a lot of coffee in the morning, live in Seattle where water isn’t cheap, and saved $60 on our last water bill by simply only flushing when really necessary. Lots of water saved as well as money. No judging others who flush every time but just a thought to those who are open to the idea.
loading....
FYI–The bit about having fewer children was actually a joke…..
I agree that sometimes people sound a bit sanctimonious over their “green” choices, which are usually just what they choose to do anyway green or not.
loading....
My resposne would be “How Can You Not?”
Start off with green steps that will SAVE you money, then use this savings to afford the green steps that cost a little.
loading....
Sierra,
TERRIFIC POST!
My favorite part: “…environmentally damaging products and lifestyle choices are only affordable because we’re not paying the full cost of them. While you enjoy your cheap plastic toys, people in the developing world are paying the price in terms of pollution, exploitative labor, and natural resource consumption.”
Thank you.
loading....
I think a point that has not been discussed enough is that in *most* cases, the green choice is also the frugal choice. People tend to focus too much on the few counterexamples. For instance, they think of “green” clothing as pricey organic cotton, bamboo, Tencel, and so on. But secondhand clothes are even greener, because they use *no* new materials and reduce waste at the same time, and they’re also a lot cheaper than equivalent items purchased new. Similarly, buying organic produce may cost more, but planting a garden, if you have room, will save you money on food and give you fresh, local, organic produce at the same time. (Yes, there is a time investment, but it doesn’t have to be a huge one, especially with container gardening.) Line-drying clothes, biking to work, switching to CFLs, using your local library–all of these are good for the planet *and* your wallet. (True, as Sierra Black points out, you have to consider the cost in time as well as money, but in many cases the time cost is quite low compared with the financial payoff.) I’d like to see a greater awareness of “ecofrugality”–the concept of “waste not, want not”–as a single ideal, not two separate and conflicting ones.
loading....
Being environmentally friendly is not just a bandwagon you can hop on and spend money. What people don’t realize is that the frugal choice, the practical choice, the choice that avoids waste, is also the green choice. Environmental degradation is the natural outcome of wasteful, extravagant lifestyles. Therefore, if you avoid waste and extravagance, you are “green” whether you like it or not.
loading....
I look at green strategies in categories.
1. the changes that cost me little or nothing in time or money. Switching to reusable bags at the grocery andother stores is one of these. It doesn’t really cost me more money as I already had cloth bags around the house and it doesn’t cost me more time. I just have to change my habits. No brainer on these things.
2. Changes that cost money. Yeah, it costs more to buy free range chickens or no hormone beef but I can balance that extra cost by simply eating less meat. Sometimes it does cost too much more and I have to balance what I can and can’t afford.
3. Changes that cost time. Hanging my clothes on the line, riding my bicycle to work… Again, I have to balance what time I can afford and if it gives me pleasure otherwise. Maybe I really enjoy that bike ride. That’s worht something.
Nice post. Thanks.
loading....
Why is having kids not green? That sounds horrible.
loading....
Why would having kids be green? Having more kids is going to use more resources than having less kids. I am a firm believer that we need to start instituting a population control program soon .
loading....
Wow, great post and comments. I have a few thoughts…
- 4 R’s: Refuse, reduce, re-use, recycle – love it! Should always be done and in that order.
- to Crosby: “It’s namby pamby, followed up by the pseudo science of global warming.” Pseudo science? Are you living on another planet?
- Giving up meat is something more of us need to do. Methane produced in raising cattle is 13 times more damaging to the environment than CO2. It’s also responsible for a lot of the cancers in America. Don’t eat red meat more than twice a week and try to eat more fish. Your colon and your planet will thank you.
Going green is more than a movement. It is quickly replacing religion in America. It’s hard to believe in a church that lets priests harm our children. It’s easy to believe in doing something with scientific evidence that supports its “goodness.” Green living is becoming something more of us can believe in.
The synergy of going green and saving money is a sometimes on, sometimes off thing. But in the end, even if you spend a little more to practice green living, you end up with fewer health problems and save money that way.
By the way, there’s another synergy here: mindfulness. When we pay attention to our choices and really think about our actions before we buy, we are doing more for our souls too! It also helps combat greenwashing. You can’t just buy things because of a green label. You have to think about the claims and look them up.
Has anyone seen the Good Guide? It’s an iPhone app that lets you look up the “goodness” of a product environmentally and socially. See something touted as “green?” Look it up in the good guide first. If enough people make purchase decisions based on its affect to society and the environment, manufacturers will naturally make more environmentally and socially responsible products.
loading....
It doesn’t work if you are going green but nobody else is going green. Here, you can’t ride your bike to work unless you want to be killed or sweaty and smelly like a pig at your desk.
If you have ever visited a third-world immigrants here in the States, going green is not a big deal at all. They eat out much less, conserve water, conserve everything. So if you want to go green, the only way is to have your brain washed by living in a third-world country and recalibrate your mind about how to live. Otherwise, it’s like a weight-loss program: you go fasting for a while, then you go back to eat like a pig and the cycle repeats.
loading....
I think a better question is, “can we afford NOT to go green?” So doing things in a green way may take a little or a lot of initial investment. However can we afford to not reduce our dependency on oil and other fossil fuels. Can we afford to not reduce our emissions.
So many things we can do as individuals are fairly easy. It a more plant based diet. Go vegetarian one or two days a week. Or go vegetarian all the time this can really make a huge difference. Air dry your clothes on a clothes drying rack or a laundry line. This will save 6-10% of the domestic energy use in the USA. Not to mention saving you money and your clothes will last longer as well.
loading....