Three Things the Amish Taught Me About Money
Published on - May 6th, 2010 (Modified on - May 14th, 2010) (by J.D. Roth) Yesterday, a couple of readers pointed me to a CNN Money article about why Amish businesses don’t fail. Good timing, because today’s guest post is from the author profiled in that piece. This is a guest post from Erik Wesner, who researched the Amish for his new book Success Made Simple: An Inside Look at Why Amish Businesses Thrive. He blogs about Amish culture at Amish America.
Most people associate the Amish with certain things: simplicity, rumspringa, funny hats. I’ve been fortunate enough to spend a lot of time with Amish over the past few years. And I’ve found there’s both truth and myth behind many of the perceptions.
But one thing that is accurate is the idea that Amish use money and resources wisely. I’d like to share a few observations from my time in Amish America — simple ideas for amping up your savings accounts, cutting waste, and maximizing what you get out of what you already have.
Lower tech, lower costs
Contrary to common belief, the Amish do actually accept a good degree of technology. During a recent stay at my Amish friend Abe’s home, his three-year-old woke up one evening with a nasty bark. I first thought it to be whooping cough (sounds pretty Dickensian, I know) but turned out to be the “croup”, something less menacing.
The next morning, Abe asked me to pick up a medicinal vaporizer from Wal-Mart. The kind with a plug that goes in the wall. Abe’s home, of course, lacks the outlets needed for that type of thing.
You may be wondering how they expected to operate it. Well, the Amish do have a way of using plug-in devices. Diesel-powered generators coupled with an inverter (a device that creates 110-volt current) can produce enough juice to operate small appliances. It’s how they run their 1950s-era wringer-style washing machines and a variety of other implements.
Before you start to think that the Amish have sold out somewhere along the line: It’s inconvenient and loud having a diesel engine blasting in your backyard, so it’s not something you’re apt to overuse. And running one round-the-clock isn’t cheap.
And that’s the point: Amish allow certain technology, but the way they use it is costly and inconvenient, so they’re compelled to limit its usage.
Amish choose to restrict ownership of technology for a couple of reasons:
- First, owning cars and having new gadgets around the house both invite the world in and take them far from home, potentially threatening their way of life, affecting family and community.
- Secondly, accumulating all the latest gizmos (as many of us know firsthand) can get pretty expensive.
The takeaway? We’re not talking about trading in the Chevy sedan for a Yoder buggy. But it makes one wonder: How much cash does overuse of technology (or for some, an outright addiction to it) suck out of our pockets?
It could be anything from the new set of wheels every third year to the seemingly cheap iPhone apps to the value of the time burnt browsing the net for hours. Hang onto your laptop. But it’s worth thinking about how we use technology — not just in terms of the benefits it brings, but the costs it imposes.
Debt is a tool — and a bit of it is healthy
Along the same lines, some Amish do use credit cards. It’s nothing near a majority, but those who use credit do so for convenience’s sake. Habit and a mentality that says you always pay back your debts means that Amish rarely carry a balance. They use credit cards as one ought to — as a tool that makes life easier, not as a way to spend beyond one’s means.
Much more common among Amish would be taking advantage of bank credit for a home mortgage or to fund a business. Not only does this help one reach life and business goals, but when used properly, it can even be a motivator. Having something to pay back gets you out of bed and gets you moving, as an Amishman once explained to me. So the right type of debt, Amish realize, can be healthy.
Lose the high-interest consumer type as quickly as you can by following the debt snowball method or the other great ideas detailed here on Get Rich Slowly. But do take advantage of the right kind of debt as a tool to build a future.
“Little things make a big difference at the end of the year.”
This advice came from an Amish business owner who is also a bishop, so when I remember it, it comes with an extra dose of gravitas. (Amish bishops come with the gravitas built-in!)
Along those lines, another Amish entrepreneur brought up the impact of longer breaks. He figured 10 extra minutes a day added up to a week of work lost on an annualized basis. Writing this makes me wonder how many weeks of work I burn checking emails (like I did just now) in the middle of tasks where I’m meant to concentrate (there I go again) until completion.
Abe, an organic produce farmer who is also something of a coffee fanatic, brought a battered travel mug along on a recent road trip. “I guess I should probably wait a while before getting a new one,” he explained. This was just one of many little day-to-day costs that Abe was avoiding. Though it looked a bit beat-up, and maybe didn’t insulate as it once did, it still kept the coffee off my floorboards and in the mug. The bottom line is that if it still works, it still has value.
This extends to the things we might normally toss. The coffee grounds from that morning brew end up on Abe’s flowerbed to fertilize the plants. The eggshells from our 6 a.m. breakfast go back out to the chicken house, where the birds like to peck at them for calcium. Once picked, Abe’s produce is housed in an old semi-trailer converted into a cooling unit. Nothing gets wasted and new uses are found for seemingly tired and spent items.
Even Abe has his weak spots, though, and he lets himself off the hook with a small treat from time to time. For this health-conscious Amishman, that means those fresh-squeezed store-bought juices that cost triple the regular price. He’ll splurge occasionally. It makes him happy.
The point: Little savings matter. But even the Amish don’t take things to extreme extremes. If you’re consciously living a frugal lifestyle, treat yourself from time to time, so you don’t end up resenting it and regressing to old habits.
Not reinventing the buggy wheel
This isn’t revolutionary stuff. But it doesn’t take revolutionary ideas to amp up your savings and slash waste from your life. Simple ideas work — one reason Amish businesses have shown a 5-year survival rate of over 90%, roughly twice the US average.
Applying these ideas, whether in business or in life, doesn’t take an MBA or even a GED, as 8th-grade educated Amish prove. Rather, it takes a choice, or rather a series of repeated choices, in the way we think about things like debt, spending, and what we throw away.
GRS is committed to helping our readers save and achieve your financial goals.Savings interest rates may be low, but that’s all the more reason to shop for the best rate.Find the highest savings interest rate from Ally Bank, Capital One 360, Everbank, and more.
This article is about Basics
Disclaimer: This content is not provided or commissioned by American Express. Opinions expressed here are author's alone, not those of American Express, and have not been reviewed, approved or otherwise endorsed by American Express. This site may be compensated through American Express Affiliate Program.
Discover is a paid advertiser of this site. Reasonable efforts are made to maintain accurate information. See the Discover online credit card application for full terms and conditions on offers and rewards.
SEARCH FOR RECENT ARTICLES



Debt is indeed a tool, if used wisely as used poorly it is very dangerous. It can make you both rich and poor depending on how you use it and your level of financial intelligence.
Go the Amish
loading....
http://www.wired.com/wired/archive/7.01/amish_pr.html
may also be of interest to people reading this post.
loading....
I live near Amish in Eastern Indiana. I do know of at least one Amish family that filed bankruptcy and had his farm and land auctioned off. (I went to that auction) They got into too much debt. Another Amish family has had so many business failures that they may too have to file bankruptcy. So it does happen. In Eastern Indiana, Amish befriend their modern neighbors and pay them for modern conveniences , such as driving them in their vehicles to Aldi’s or having an electric freezer in the neighbors basement or garage. They cover up their modern phones by having them in outhouses, and actually do have modern plumbing, run by a generator, in their homes. The Amish around here can have a lot of the “modern” things, just not on their own property where the “outside” world can see.
loading....
You people have no clue. I lived among the Amish for 8 years. I drove them everywhere they needed to go. They are nothing but a glorified government sanctioned cult. Did you know at their speciality shops the have two prices for their goods? A much higher price for YANKEES and a lower price for their own kind. They laugh at the stupid Yankees and told me if I want to sell my crafts put Amish made on it…thats what sells. They put their children to work at 14, when they complete school at 14 with their certificate of completion they are handed a work permit. Until they reach the age of 20 and a half they HAVE to give their parents their paychecks. That is one of the biggest reasons the have so much money, thet spit
loading....
The Amish are exempted from paying Social Security. They may not collect but they don’t have to pay either. I am self employed and I have to pay Social Security for myself and from the employer’s side too. I’m not exempted. There was an article in Wall Street Journal about intermarriage among Amish communities and this has created genetic defects in their children. Many Amish don’t believe in carrying insurance and these genetic defects are carrying a high medical cost that many Amish are having difficulty paying for with cash (even when the community pools it’s resources) and they are applying for charity care with hospitals that treat them even though they have businesses and own farm property that is valuable. According to the article, they don’t feel that they should have full liability for their medical costs even though they chose not to carry insurance.
loading....
my computer is 500mhz
loading....
I am in UK we are a multicultural society with all sorts and nationalities and that is all good, but thank goodness we don’t have to put up with Amish and their cruelty to animals. I don’t think we would tolerate it.
loading....