Social Capital: More Valuable Than Money?
Published on - May 27th, 2010 (Modified on - June 1st, 2010) (by J.D. Roth) I’m back! After ten days boating through southeast Alaska (and two days of recovery), I’m ready to think about personal finance once again. Actually, it’ll probably come as no surprise that I never stopped thinking about personal finance. Even while we were skirting among ice floes, pulling up prawns, and admiring whales, my mind never strayed far from the topic of money. (I’m not saying this is a good thing, but it’s the truth.)
It’d be all too easy for me to share another sermon about the perils of Stuff — when you spend ten days on a 38-foot boat, living out of a single carry-on bag, you come to realize how little you actually need in life — but I feel like I’ve beaten that topic into the ground over the past few months. I’m working to cut down my dependence on things, and I know that many of you are, too; let’s save further discussion for another day.
Today, I want to talk about the value of social capital.
Though I don’t mention it often around GRS, the idea of social capital is constantly lurking behind the scenes. It’s a notion that can be hard to define. In fact, rather than try to do so from scratch, I’m going to quote myself. The next section is an excerpt from my book, Your Money: The Missing Manual.
What is social capital?
You create social capital — mutual goodwill — when you volunteer at a soup kitchen, help your neighbor move a piano, have your Sunday School class over for a barbeque, or join a softball league. Any time you participate in your community, you’re generating social capital, both for yourself and for the other people involved. People with lots of social capital can find help when they need it; those with little social capital can spend a lot of time frustrated and alone.
The classic Christmas film It’s a Wonderful Life is a great illustration of social capital. Jimmy Stewart plays George Bailey, a man who repeatedly forgoes his own interests to help his friends and neighbors. It costs him — financially and mentally. When disaster strikes, Bailey decides he’s worth more dead than alive, and plans to commit suicide so that the proceeds from his life-insurance policy can set things right.
In the end, Bailey is saved when all the folks he’s made sacrifices for over the years come to his aid. Sure, it’s a schmaltzy, feel-good moment, but it’s a fine example of social capital in action. When Bailey’s brother declares that George is “the richest man in town”, he’s not joking: Bailey may no have much financial capital, but he’s flush with social capital.

You don’t have to sacrifice your own interests to create social capital. You can often create win-win situations where everyone profits. But the best way to build social capital is to help others without expecting anything in return.
There’s more to wealth than just money. Social capital is just as real as financial capital — and often more valuable.
The extraordinary power of compound kindness
Social capital comes from building a broad network of relationships, a network that you can draw upon to help yourself and help others. This isn’t networking in the smarmy, slimy sense, but in the authentic “I’m your neighbor and your friend” sense. A complex network of people will have thousands (millions!) of connections, creating a powerful web of support. (You can see great examples of this in Ben Franklin’s autobiography and in Keith Ferrazzi’s Never Eat Alone.)
These networks are usually built through everyday kindnesses. These actions compound (just like compound interest) to yield larger returns in the future. From my trip to Alaska, here are some examples of the sorts of small actions that help create community and help build social capital:
- Southeast Alaska is peppered with small villages separated by large expanses of water. Boaters (and not just my skipper John) stop to check on each other, and on the people they know in out-of-the-way spots.
- Another way to cope with this isolation is book exchanges. Many of the small airports and harbors contain bookshelves where folks can discard the books they’ve finished and pick up new ones. This is a brilliant idea!
- We had miserable luck crabbing and fishing during the first part of our trip. One night, a small charter boat invited us over to share in the halibut they’d caught earlier in the day. Later, after we finally caught and filleted our first salmon, we handed off some of the meat to a passing boat.
- Some of the summer boaters actually live in southeast Alaska. These folks have vehicles in their home towns, and they share them with other boaters they know well. When we docked in Sitka, for example, we were able to borrow a truck from Sailboat Bob so that we could run our errands and drive to dinner.
- Every morning at 6:30, John gets on his ham radio to check in with the Great Northern Boaters Net, where dozens of different boats check in throughout the week, giving updates on their progress. This allows folks to keep tabs on each other, to ask for and receive advice.
These are just a few of the ways I saw social capital in action during my trip; there were many other examples, both large and small. Taken together, the community spirit I saw was amazing.
Social capital in real life
Social capital plays an active role in your life, too. The broader your circle of friends, the bigger your family, the better you know your neighbors, and the more involved you are in your community, the more social capital you have. (And the more social capital you contribute to others — it’s a reciprocal thing!)
Here are some everyday examples of how you and I generate social capital:
- When I loan my rototiller to a friend, that builds social capital. When I then crash my bike and have to ride to his house for first aid (yes, this really happened), that generates social capital.
- When your community comes together to clean up a run-down park, that generates social capital.
- You create social capital when you join a bowling league, a knitting circle, or a book group. You create social capital when you go to church or join a social club.
- When you stop to help a stranded motorist, you’re creating social capital.
- Social capital grows when you share the surplus from your vegetable garden with your neighbors and co-workers.
As you can see, social capital is most often generated by doing things that help other individuals — or your community. It exists everywhere, but some places have more of it than others.
I’m not sure why I was so struck by the community ties I saw in Alaska. Are these ties really stronger than elsewhere? Were they just more obvious because they took different forms than I’m used to? How can I learn to see (and contribute) to the social capital here in Oak Grove, Oregon?
I don’t have the answers to these questions, but I’ll certainly be thinking about them a great deal during the coming weeks. As I say, social capital is always lurking in the background here at Get Rich Slowly. There’s more to being rich than just having a lot of money; there’s real wealth in having a large network of friends, too.
Also don’t forget to follow Get Rich Slowly on Facebook and Twitter.
This article is about Giving, Psychology, Relationships, Self-Improvement
SEARCH FOR RECENT ARTICLES




Maybe not more valuable than money, but darn close, and it never hurts to have a lot of it.
loading....
My mom is the embodiment of social capital.
If I explained all of the ways this was so, this would be a very long comment. Let me just say, she is the only person I know who considers her exterminator one of her best friends. And she truly never expects anything in return – just the good feelings she gets from helping others.
She recently came down with cancer, and her social capital has paid back in full with all of the people who have come along side us through this.
I grew up with a rich community of people around me through my mom and all of her friendships. I can only hope I can build the same environment for my kids to grow up in, but I have big shoes to fill.
loading....
You are absolutely right! In my hometown I have/had a rich social network, but in my new town in a neighbouring country, I have hardly any social network. There are a few people here that help each other out, for instance we babysit each other’s child for a few hours when necessary, but I would not feel comfortable to ask for or offer a whole day of babysitting. I really miss parents nearby for that kind of thing!
When I was still firmly in the middle of my hometown social network, I received lots of things from other people. They knew I was living thriftily to finish my University education, and sent stuff they were tired off or cleaning out my way. It became embarassing to me, because it started to feel it was a one-way flow. There was not much I could do in return, so I would offer babysitting, painting, etc., which was not often accepted. I still have the feeling of being indebted to them.
loading....
“Social capital” is great idea ! I think the society with people rich on “social capital” could be named socialism. There was an good example in the history of such society: USSR… No bad society, but …
loading....
This was a great article. I actualyl sent it on to someone in China, who I’ve known for a little while. He recently wrote in his personal blog about the attacks on the Chinese school children, and blamed in part, a lack of community, and how everyone needed to make a greater effort in that area, to band together.
I know for myself, I’ve gotten where I don’t interact with people much, I guess I get too nervous about crime, or being taken advtage of, or, just not having time, but I need to remember, doesn’t take but a minute to say hello, or to do something nice for someone, and make your day, as well as their better. The ripple effect they call it.
Great article!! Though I never mind the ones about STUFF, I like those a lot since I’m trying to get rid of mine!
loading....
re Bannan @ 25
” But… You can’t enter social capital into a spreadsheet…”
Sure you can, or at least track some of it (just to gauge affect, not to “keep track”) with an astrick * in regularly used columns like gardening (JD’s garden experiment) or bartering items on want list i.e.:
Grocery: (-@6.99 for 2lbs organic green beans from Mrs. Cobb in exchange for hour emergency kid watching)
Wants completed: 10-speed bike* (stopped to chat with Mike while he was cleaning garage)
etc. etc. etc.
loading....
@Erika #42
In my life, I have discovered that some extremely generous and helpful people take so much pride (within them) in their generosity that when they need help they fail to ask for it or reject offers from others just because they imagine that after all, they are supposed to be the helpers, givers etc. Trust me, I used to be one of them and I see it in two close family members. Quite intriguing.
loading....
Just wanted to say thanks to all the folk who took the time to offer suggestions.
You’re all collectively right – I’m aware that I’ll need to take the first step and ‘put myself out there’ a bit more, change my routine and at least give myself the chance to meet new folk!
Comments were much appreciated – there you go – some more social capital for you (even if I’m too far away to mow your lawn!)
loading....
When it comes to “social capital”, I think a good way to approach the whole thing is to help others and be generous without expecting anything back.
Sure, you probably WILL get something back, and the power of compounding may apply here too. Intersting concept.
That said, giving and helping without direct strings attached is a great thing. Not that we all have the ability to do so every minute of the day, as we have our own responsibilities, but it’s good to help when you can.
loading....
I’ve been thinking about Social Capital a lot recently because I’ve been doing a bunch of volunteer work since I was laid off from my work in March.
I responded to this article in my blog.
http://realme42.blogspot.com/2010/05/social-capital-with-little-help-from-my.html
loading....
I just finished a book called In the Neighborhood where, in the wake of a neighborhood murder-suicide, the author decides to get to know his neighbors by asking to sleep over at their houses. Interesting read, full of personal stories with touches of research about social capital.
loading....
This is a gorgeous post. So very gorgeous! Thank you for sharing your thoughts!
I am of two (or more) minds about this. On the one hand, I’m somewhat like Luke and other introverts. I had a very painful childhood, not because of my family, but because of how I was treated by people outside of my family. I was bullied all through junior high school. Severely. I grew into a depressed teen and, though less so, a depressed adult. I struggle with depression every day. I have also been hurt as an adult. It is hard to reach out, and also too much contact with other people wears me out. I totally get the urge not to reach out, too cocoon. My boyfriend, though for different reasons, is the same way. We both simply prefer to minimize our interactions with people outside of our own inner circle (us, some family members, few enough friends to count on one hand.)
That said, I actually do a lot to invest in my own social capital. We both regularly donate food to our local food shelter. We have both helped out various neighbors with different things here and there. I regularly help my parents and his family out with things. I even sometimes smile and make small talk with a random person. I’m involved with animal rescue, and I regularly speak up when someone asks for advice or needs comforting.
None of these things are easy for me, and some don’t feel good (so I only do them once and never again,) but I have always recognized that our world will only get better if we are kind to one another. Americans, in general, are not kind people (I’m an American, so I can say that.) I find a lot of people shallow and self-centered. I don’t want to be like that. It takes a great deal of effort for me to reach out, but I do.
If nothing else is said of me when I die, I’d like for people to be able to say, “Yes. I remember her. She was a very kind person.”
My last comment is to say that I also agree with the folks who say to be careful in whom you invest. There are plenty of psychic vampires and “just plain takers” out there. It is healthy to become aware of these folks and to protect our own health and resources. It’s not something you know right away. You learn after a few interactions with these folks who they are.
One of your best posts ever, JD!
loading....
To the degree that you circulate positive energy is to the degree and measure that you will invite wealth to you.
The idea of social capital falls into the same theory of social reciprocity. Responding to a positive action with another positive action, and responding to a negative action with another negative one. It is basically a bank where you put a deposit or take one out.
There is nothing wrong with this. People respond to postive actions towards them and when you need it, you have people to draw from to help you in times or need or opportunity…
loading....