Ask the Readers: Which Credit Cards Do You Use — and Why?
Published on - July 16th, 2010 (Modified on - January 18th, 2012) (by J.D. Roth) I’m always reluctant to cover credit cards here at Get Rich Slowly. There are other sites that do it better. Besides, I’m still not wholly convinced they’re a good idea. Plus, my wife — who is always right — told me the other day, “I don’t like it when you write about credit cards. Credit cards are boring.”
Still, in today’s world, effective use of rewards credit card is an important part of personal finance. If you don’t use them correctly, you can end up deep in debt. (I’ve experienced this first-hand.) But if you do use them properly, they can actually help your financial situation. (Note: See How to Choose a Credit Card).
Joining the Dark Side
When I started Get Rich Slowly, I was staunch supporter of the anti-credit card camp. I’d been stupid with credit cards when I was younger, and they were a big reason I found myself with over $35,000 in consumer debt. I’d been burned, and like Dave Ramsey, I couldn’t see any benefit to using them.
As my financial habits improved, however, I came to understand that credit cards aren’t necessarily evil. My wife, for example, has had a credit card for as long as I’ve known her (over 20 years!), and has never carried a balance. She loves using her Discover card, which gives her up to 5% cash back. (“To be honest,” she told me tonight, “I only get about 40 cents per month from using the thing, which is about half a percent cash back.”)
Still, I was wary. But three years ago — as we were preparing to travel to England, Ireland, and New York — I decided to take a risk. Based on the urging of GRS readers, I signed up for a credit card. I chose the Capital One No-Hassle Cash Back card because it offered some perks for travelers, and because I liked the idea of getting a one percent cash discount on everything I buy with it.
When I signed up for a credit card, I made some rules for myself. I vowed to:
- Pay off the entire balance every month.
- Never buy anything on credit unless I already had the cash in the bank to pay the bill.
- Make my decision about what to buy and then decide how to pay. (Instead of saying, “Oh, I have a credit card, so I can buy this.”
- Never use my credit card for impulse purchases.
If I violated any of these rules ever, I promised myself I’d cut up the card. Three years later, I still have that credit card.
The Chainsaw of Personal Finance
While I’m not about to sing the praises of credit cards, I do think they’re a useful tool in the responsible person’s financial toolbox. To quote myself from Your Money: The Missing Manual:
Credit cards aren’t evil, but they can be dangerous. Just as you’d treat a chainsaw with respect, you need to be careful with credit to avoid hurting yourself. And if you use them wisely, credit cards can actually give you a financial edge.
I don’t write about credit cards very often at Get Rich Slowly. If there’s something that needs to be said about credit, I usually let a guest poster do that. (Get Rich Slowly has good relationships with both Index Credit Cards and Card Ratings, and fellow blogger Five Cent Nickel keeps an updated list of balance transfer credit cards; they all know a lot more about this stuff than I do.)
But I’ve been wondering lately just how GRS readers use credit cards. I suspect that many (most?) of you are like me: You use credit cards wisely, and they’re tools that helps you achieve your goals.
So, I have some questions today. As I mentioned, I’m using the Capital One No-Hassle Cash Back card (man, what a dumb name!). What about you? Which credit card(s) do you use? Why do you use it? How, when, and where do you use it? Do you have personal rules for credit card use? Have you ever been in credit card debt? How do you steer clear of that now? I plan to collect your answers for a future post, one that I hope will help others learn to use credit cards responsibly.
This article is about Ask the Readers, Credit Cards
SEARCH FOR RECENT ARTICLES




Orchard offers a great pre-paid credit card option for those who have bad credit, but want to start rebuilding it. I had done this about 5 years ago with a $100 down payment on the card which gave me $100 in credit. I would use it occasionally and always pay off the entire balance each month. After about a year I got a regular credit card and used the same practices I learned with my pre-paid card and have improved my credit score significantly.
Having a low line of credit forces you to be frugal and watch your money. It also keeps you from spending more than you can pay off at the end of each month.
loading....
I keep two credit cards active. They are both VISA’s, but from two different credit unions. Neither card offers any incentives, but both have reasonable interest rates (11.5% and 9.9%).
I’ve had the first card (11.5%)for almost 20 years and it’s been the same interest rate for the entire time. Try getting that with a big bank card! It has a deliberately-low credit line, is used exclusively for online purchases, and is paid in full each month.
I’ve had the second card (9.9%) for about 2 years. (I obtained it after closing my WaMu/Chase Mastercard after they tripled my interest rate for no good reason.) It has a higher credit line, and is used mostly for travel, and unexpected vehicle repairs or veterinary bills. I sometimes carry a balance but usually only for a month or two. Total interest paid on it last year was $65.
loading....
My wife and I have an Alaska Airlines credit card from Bank of America. It’s connected to our Alaska Airlines Mileage Plan and we earn miles for all of our purchases. We have always been surprised by how quickly we accumulate miles. The card offers yearly buddy passes and 25k miles when signing up.
loading....
I’m confused about the posters who wrote about their Chase Freedom cards. One said there was a $30 fee; the other said there were triple points on the top 3 categories. I have this card. There is no annual fee for me. They used to give triple points on the top 3 categories; then they changed it to the top 5 categories; now there are no triple points. I get 1.1% + 10 cents per purchase on everything…new policy as of early July (2010). The new policy (no triple points) will cost me about $90 per year. Grr. But I wonder why we have different versions of the “Chase Freedom” card? I have another Chase card which gives me 1% on everything except 3% on gas purchases. Like many of your posters, I pay in full each month and choose cards with no annual fee.
loading....
Help. I am attepting to work toward having good credit again. I sold my house (went up a few point) I make my car payment on time. But I have been told I need a credit card (revolving credit??) Any suggestions, I would love a card that I could earn perks for travel. Help!
loading....
What’s your current FICO score Tammy?
You should have at least one credit card that you use sparingly and pay in full each month to help rebuild your credit. Of course, the best card for you will depend on where your current credit score stands.
loading....
I have 5, but I only use 2. The Cap One for travel and Discover for almost everything else. I use the Discover Rewards for Amazon mp3s, which is awesome b/c you get a little extra to spend, and I’m buying music legitimately and supporting the artists, and I’m not getting more clutter from cds. I really really love it, so I buy everything on credit cards. Plus it’s easy to keep track of everything I spent.
loading....
I am currently in credit card debt, and despite the frustration it causes me while I am in the process of paying them down, I can still see the good in them.
I have one card in particular that I’m fond of. It’s a Chase Freedom card, and it only has a $500 limit. There isn’t a whole lot of trouble that I can get into with this card as long as the rest are paid off before using it.
The card is currently running a promotion that generates 5% cash back on all purchases that fall into the category of gas, hotels, airfare, and one other travel related expense. This runs through September. All other purchases are 1%. It’s a small amount, and it used to be higher, but I’m happy to have it anyway.
I haven’t put the plan in place yet, but I have already designated this card as a tool to actually help me control my spending. I am starting a full time job in September, one where my salary will allow me enough money to quickly pay off my credit cards and school loans, while still leaving money left over for spending and saving.
Since the limit is only $500 on this card, that will be my budget. Without touching the money coming in to my checking account, I can be sure that the cash will be there at the end of the month to pay my card. If I max out my card, then I sure better not have any more expenses for the month. I may even have my boyfriend completely lock me out of my actual cash accounts altogether, just to ensure that I stick to my budget.
This plan is going to take a lot of practice, because of the increase in spending that usually comes along with my increase in pay. I’m confident though that if my card is automatically paid at the end of every month, this will be an effective way for me to budget, and also earn a few extra dollars for things that I would be buying already.
loading....
Hi JD,
I had never heard about the implications of swipe fees until I read this article: http://blog.oregonlive.com/finance/2010/07/paying_cash_to_reward_our_cred.html Maybe you’ve written about them before.
loading....
People are so anti-credit it makes me laugh
But I guess so many have been burned that they automatically come to despise credit.
Me…I love using it. I get lots of perks and money back while making sure I don’t pay for anything or carry a balance. It’s great for me and I hope GRS would talk more about it. Teaching others how to use credit responsibly is much better and effective than ignoring the whole concept all together, don’t you think?
loading....
@Eric – I agree with you 100 percent!
Rather than ignore credit, it’s much better to learn how to manage it responsibly and use it to your advantage. Unfortunately, lots of anti-credit folks truly believe that using a credit card to make a purchase automatically means you’re carrying debt.
loading....
We have three cards – personal credits for me and my husband and a third for common expenses. Third rarely gets used, and my personal card has not been paid fully only once, for one month, during the 8 years I’ve had it.
All our credit cards are also debit which we normally use – in Europe it is the most normal way of paying. Why use credit when you can pay directly from your account? I would neve give up the credit card thouhg – large purchases, such as airline tickets, are safer that way. A large purchase that does not cary similar risk – such as a bike – can easily be bought on debit though. It only takes a month if I don’t have the cash now. Obviously, credit allows to grab a great offer, and sometimes I use the chance, but mostly the offers are hardly that great.
loading....
Citi Forward for 5% off all Amazon purchases
Discover More for 5-10% off other popular online retailers
AmEx SimplyCash for 5% off phone bill, office supplies, and gas (grandfathered rewards program)
Schwab Visa for straight 2% cashback on all purchases (no longer available to the public)
loading....
I’ve been credit card free since 08 and I like it that way.
loading....
I have a lot of credit cards that I use for different purposes. 1 of my favorites is the Charles Schwab Visa that gives 2% flat cash back with no earned minimums and deposits monthly.
I use my Discover credit card when 5% categories are in effect such as gas or restaurants.
I pay my balances off in full and pay no interest.
loading....
I’ve used Fidelity Investment Rewards (AmEx) for several years now. It is 2% back on all purchases, and I make all purchases on the card because of its high credit limit (paid in full every month).
Another commenter mentioned they prefer Vanguard–so do I. You can redeem the Fidelity rewards into your free Fidelity cash account, and immediately transfer it out to your linked checking/savings account.
loading....
I have two credit cards I use. I have an Amex Blue that I use for points and is my main card. I pay off the balance in full every month and use it pretty much as stated in your post (don’t overspend, but as a sub for cash actually in the bank). I also have a Barclays Visa I use for bills that don’t take Amex and earn NFL points (that I use on experiences like a draft party). I may switch the Amex to a cash back card as they have recently lowered what the points can get you in terms of airline tix (my favorite use of points)
I don’t mind credit cards, but would only advise them for the financially savvy…they are actually not good for MOST people.
loading....