This is a guest post from Robert Brokamp of The Motley Fool. Robert is a Certified Financial Planner and the adviser for The Motley Fool’s Rule Your Retirement service. He contributes one new article to Get Rich Slowly every two weeks.
With all the hullabaloo over the release of the iPhone 4 this summer, and having just paid my monthly service bill for my own iPhone (an older version, thank you very much), I thought now would be a good time to think about how much all our modern conveniences cost us.
First off, buying the new iPhone might have cost you an additional $500 on top of the actual price of the phone, if you were the silly person who paid that much to take Jordan Richardson’s place in line on the day the iPhone 4 debuted, according to an Associated Press story. Richardson then paid someone farther back in line $200 for his/her spot, making a $300 profit — but he’s still out that two hundred bucks because he couldn’t wait! I bet Jordan and his patron — now that it’s six weeks later, and a new iPhone 4 can be bought anywhere — wish they had that money back.
But even if you were so un-hip as to not wait in 11-hour long lines or pay people to move up, you are still paying a lot for that iPhone — or just about any other cell phone, for that matter. And by “you,” I mean “me,” since I have just such a gadget myself. Let’s look at the numbers:
- My monthly bill came to $73. Multiply that by 12, and you get $876 a year. But that’s not all!
- That bill was paid with after-tax money. Assuming I have a combined state and federal tax rate of 30%, I had to earn $1,251 — that’s $876/(1 – 0.30), for those curious about the math — then hand over a chunk to Uncle Sam and Aunt Virginia (my state) to have enough after-tax dollars to pay the cell-phone bill.
I’m certainly not alone in spending that much; plenty people spend even more, and that’s not including the cost of the phone itself. Given that the median household income in America is approximately $50,000 a year, it’s safe to say that there are people who are spending 2% to 3% of their annual income for the privilege of checking their Facebook pages in the movie theater while I’m trying to figure out what the heck is going on during Inception. (OK, a cell phone does more than that. For example, it might also give you brain cancer.)
But wait — there’s more!
Summon your inner grumpy old man
Cell phones are just one of the modern conveniences that we have come to think of as necessities. As Wall Street Journal columnist Jason Zweig wrote in his thought-provoking book, Your Money and Your Brain, “In 1957, the average American earned about $10,000 (adjusted for inflation) and lived without a dishwasher, clothes dryer, television, or air conditioner” — and more people reported being “very happy” than do now. All these conveniences involve monthly fees, up-front purchases, regular repairs, accessories — or all the above.
Besides not having to live in a shoebox and lick the road clean every morning (text version for those who can’t watch video at work), kids today have all kinds of luxuries that weren’t around 50 years ago. Here’s some of the other Stuff that the past half-century has spawned to consume our money:
- Cable TV
- High-speed Internet
- Netflix
- Tiger Woods
- GPS devices
- Chocolate-covered ants
- The ShamWow!
- Computers, laptops, printers, monitors, keyboards, software, cables, mice, mice pads, speakers, and assorted USB-related doodads
- Mel Gibson
- Houses that are twice the average size of houses in the 1950s
- Satellite radio
- TVs the size of waterbeds (side note: let’s bring back the waterbed!)
- e-Book readers and the books you have to buy for them, instead of getting books free from the library (can someone explain the allure of these things, because I don’t get it)
- TiVo or other digital video recorders
- ATM fees
- Magazines profiting from the inability of Tiger Woods and Mel Gibson to control their anatomical apertures
- iPods or some other MP3 player
- Chocolate-covered scorpions
- Security and medical alert services
- Lobbyists
- Video game consoles and their $50 games
- Handheld video game devices and their $30 games
- The SlapChop!
- iRobot vacuum cleaners
- Summer camps galore (my kids and their friends attend more camps in a summer than I did during my entire childhood)
- Additional freezers and fridges in the garage (that dispense water and ice, to boot!)
- Little blue pills
- Chocolate-covered bacon [J.D.'s note: Darn-tootin', I'm trying this recipe!]
- Lottery tickets, which can be purchased online or through a recurring “subscription” (“Never miss a drawing! No waiting in line!”)
- Multiple digital cameras and video recorders
- Hats of meat
- TVs and DVD players in cars
- Smoothies, Frappuccinos, Bloomin’ Onions, Chia Pets (tastes sorta like parsley, or chicken)
- Child car seats and booster seats
- Prostitutes who bite your tongue (as hired by the guy who promotes the SlapChop and the ShamWow)!
- Books that explain what the heck was going on during Inception
- Gym memberships
- Children
- Chocolate-covered women
Not all these items are luxuries. Many enhance safety and productivity, and provide just the right combination of sweetness, crunchiness, and antennae-ness. Plus, since average household income has quintupled, we can afford more Stuff.
On the other hand, the list also demonstrates why some people might have trouble saving money. I often receive emails from readers who are in the second half of their working careers and yet have saved very little for retirement. A while back, I read a Washington Post article about a family that was struggling financially, including this description of their life: “The house is small, and the blare of Nickelodeon from the TV chokes the day.” Of course, Nickelodeon can only be accessed by paying for cable TV (a luxury we finally succumbed to last January).
My point, dear reader, is that there is a current and future cost to the modern lifestyle. For every dollar we earn, we could rightfully ask: “Do I want to spend a dollar today and work longer, or do I want to spend a few dollars in the future (assuming some compound gowth), when I no longer have to work?”
For some purchases, we’d undoubtedly still spend the money today. However, others may be providing less current satisfaction than what that money could provide in the future. Just something to think about. I know I’ll keep it in mind when my cell-phone service contract runs out this spring, and I evaluate whether the $1,251 I have to earn every year for it is worth the $102,609 I could have (assuming a 6% annual return and 3% inflation rate of the cost of cell service) 30 years from now.
GRS is committed to helping our readers save and achieve your financial goals.Savings interest rates may be low, but that’s all the more reason to shop for the best rate.Find the highest savings interest rate from Ally Bank, Capital One 360, Everbank, and more.
This article is about Choices, Consumerism, Planning
Disclaimer: This content is not provided or commissioned by American Express. Opinions expressed here are author's alone, not those of American Express, and have not been reviewed, approved or otherwise endorsed by American Express. This site may be compensated through American Express Affiliate Program.
Discover is a paid advertiser of this site. Reasonable efforts are made to maintain accurate information. See the Discover online credit card application for full terms and conditions on offers and rewards.
SEARCH FOR RECENT ARTICLES



Isn’t the point of frugality to spend less on something you dislike and more on something you enjoy?
So what if someone likes their iPhone?
Personally I enjoy hiking so I spend much more on a knife or boots than I would on a phone. Oh well.
loading....
J.D. -
Thanks for this article. But please consider taking out that throwaway comment about cell phones causing brain cancer. It simply isn’t true and by leaving it here you are giving this myth undeserved legitimacy.
loading....
man, looks like i was about 2 days ahead of this article. i just cancelled my blackberry and data plan.
my wife and i had a two-line plan with verizon and i had a data plan for my BB. i killed my phone and will use my work phone for rare personal calls, and we bumped up my wife’s minutes to cover my weekend chats with mom.
in total we will save over $900 per year (that is if i don’t get busted by my boss), and i get so sell my BB on eBay. i had to pay $125 to kill one of the two lines we had with our plan.
after the video post earlier this week about investing for your kids to have some money to start out, i decided to look into paring back (yet again), and found that i could initially fully fund my kids’ accounts just by killing my cell phone and data plan.
between cable, internet, the cell phones, we were paying about 6% of our take home for data/media content.
loading....
Get list! Notice how many are also needlessly consuming energy. You can save lots of money if you limit the number of such devices, not to mention any subscription which might go with them. I am starting to think victorian for replacing a lot of these useless things. Yes they had radio. You could do radio, but radio is not what it used to be. In this case, an mp3 player would still be very useful.
loading....
@ExpatEngineer:
“please consider taking out that throwaway comment about cell phones causing brain cancer. It simply isn’t true and by leaving it here you are giving this myth undeserved legitimacy.”
Funny. People said the exact same thing about cigarettes in the 50′s. Huh.
loading....
Lots of interesting comments.
I see some items are cherry picked, but what about others?
What about a car and having to buy gas for it. Or having to buy electricity instead of using candles.
Couldn’t these things back in the day be considered “high cost of modern living”?
The high cost of living is just the progression of an increased standard of living. While some mentioned are maybe lifestyle inflation, most of these items are not and are becoming standardized in our society (ie cell phones).
loading....
Just so I’m clear…the amounts listed are for 1 Smartphone in a family. If there are 4-5 in a family, are the costs 4-5x the above numbers? I imagine there are family plans, but any word on how much the cost per year for families with several iphones?
My husband has a Blackberry that his work pays for, as he travels a lot for his job. I just spent $300 for a year’s worth of minutes on our daughter’s and miy prepay cell phone. They are required to pay for any additional minutes after the paid for ones are used. They text when they need to.
Also, funny story…my husband was at a large airshow in Wisconsin last week, with about 350,000 attendees. He said he looked into the crowds at one point, and about 90% of the people were looking at their little screens, instead of some very impressive “being there” experiences. It’s also really interesteing to me how many do not look up when they are walking, biking, or driving, as whatever is on their little carry around screen is more interesting than what is happening around them, and the people they are with. Or their own safety, for that matter.
loading....
I agree with Coley in that it’s a matter of perspective and am cynical of the calculations made in the article regarding salary in 1957. I think my grandma told me they bought their first house in the late 40s for $20,000. My parents were married in 1976 and bought their first house for $40,000.
As wealth increases, it seems that the certain lifestyles become expensive as more and more people have access. In the 50s, fewer people went to college, but it was more affordable and likely that young people would pay for their own education. Now, a great number of students get loans or have had parents save for them, and the price of education has risen drastically. These are “necessities” that are also very expensive.
It does cost money to even aspire to a certain lifestyle in many cases.
loading....
102)ExpatEngineer
What evidence do you have that backs your theory?
It would be nice to shrug off cell phones causing brain cancer, etc. as a myth, but from what I’ve read there is no conclusive evidence either way. Part of the problem seems to be that alongwith independent studies, phone companies also fund many studies. According to some of the articles I have read and listed below, the studies done by the phone companies (who have a vested interest) show no danger while the independent studies show differently. In a really good piece on This American Life, one author quoted neuroscientist Leif Salford saying, “This is really the largest human biological experiment ever, because we don’t know what the long-term effects are going to be.” This rings true to me only because cell phones have not been around long enough for us to really see their effects.
http://www.pri.org/health/are-cell-phones-frying-our-brains2039.html
http://www.thisamericanlife.org/radio-archives/episode/406/true-urban-legends
loading....
I very much enjoyed the style and humor of this post.
However, Elizabeth Warren and her daughter Amelia Warren Tyagi debunked the the “everyone is squandering their money on luxuries” theory when researching their book “The Two-Income Trap”.
The book outlines the rise of the two-income family and highlights the consequences when one parent loses a job.
It is an excellent read with stellar research to back up their assertions. There are many illuminating cost-of-living adjusted for inflation calculations cited.
loading....
Re: video games
More like $100 after you calculate the price of all the downloadable content.
On rare occasions I will pre-order the special edition of a game, but most of the time I will just wait until the price of the game to drop.
It doesn’t usually take the price that long to drop down to $30. I usually wait until it is $20 which takes a little longer. With PC games, you can usually get all the DLC included for that $20 if you wait long enough.
And really, you only have to wait once, since once you do, there will always be ‘old’ games that have dropped in price that you can purchase while you wait for the next one.
loading....
Funnnnny!!!!!!!!!! And absolutely true~!
loading....
Great post– the numbers at the beginning actually made me go to my phone plan, calculate how much I was paying for unlimited texting v. how much I actually text, and change my plan accordingly. I reduced my bill by $15/month pre-tax. And I’m about to look into decreasing the Netflix account too. It’s amazing how much we (that is, I) can waste without really thinking about it.
Thanks for this blog– it’s helped me start my “debt snowball” rolling, and I hope to have good news to report soon!
loading....
Houses and vehicles are the biggest discretionary expenses.
Not iPhones or cable or high-speed internet.
People spend much more on the above than in the 1950s.
Who wants to live in a 1957 3 bedroom, 1 bath, 1000 sqft. Levittown house anymore?
Or share one used car per household when they can finance one new car per driver?
loading....
I loved the article-I am so sick of people pressuring me to buy an iPhone, esp as I have a blackberry from work and no cel reception at home. So I still have a landline. And these devices are not always the ideal solution. I organize a lot of high level meetings, often with speakers who go over time. At the last one I didnt have my blackberry and had to zok my VP on the arm to get the time off HIS cel phone. It was unspeakably indiscreet and vulgar. I bought a good quality wristwatch that weekend and have worn it every day since-so I cant forget it. I can check the time MUCH more discreetly that way. AND NO MONTHLY CONTRACT! Who needs a Scrabble app anyway? I am much too busy. As a victim of both burglary and mugging I DONT WANT my entire life on one machine. It is too risky. I try to be mindful when I spend money, but it can be challenging.
loading....
Thinking things over never hurt. If you don’t have much money, you should think about what to invest in. A fast internet connection is MUCH better than a slow one: you can actually get more things done, and the internet can be a rich source of cheap entertainment. Playing an online game is relatively cheap. Finally the whole family is enjoying it.
TiVo or satellite radio: over here in Europe we don’t have it, and I certainly don’t miss it! Smartphones: benefit is grossly exaggerated. You really DON’T need to be in touch any time. If they need you, they’ll call or text you.
loading....
This is probably to late for anyone to notice but it seems the iPod Touch has been overlooked. I was at the check out with the original iPhone when I found out you couldn’t use any of the features without the ATT data package. ATT has crap for coverage just about anywhere I go so this wasn’t even an option. A few months later I got the iPod Touch and have been loving it for the last 3 years (wow) I get all the functionality that I need and wi-fi accessibility. To top it off they cost less and there is not monthly upkeep. I use it for games and e-mail while traveling and books (so no kindle needed) and surprisingly enough it’s pretty handy having a dictionary to settle arguments. It’s also been great for my art career. My entire portfolio is a touch away and I can show interested parties anything of mine on the go, no waiting to get back to them.
After living without a TV for the past 5 years and not having internet at home for most of college I’m totally confident in my ability to get out of the house and find what I need, not pay for things to keep me in.
loading....
I totally agree! This came up in a conversation at work about the “cost of living” and how many people think it includes things like iphones and cable tv.
loading....