This is a guest post by Lori Blatzheim, a writer living in Chanhassen, Minnesota. For more information about National Thrift Week, visit NewThrift.org.
If there was a coat of arms for my family, it would display a golden lion standing on his back legs on a field of dark olive green. He would be clutching bags of gold coins in his front paws and, emblazoned across his chest would be three words: God, Family, and Thrift.
Thrift? Yes, that much maligned and oft misunderstood value.
A forthcoming study by the John Templeton Center for Thrift and Generosity at the Institute for American Values shows that many Americans associate thrift with penny-pinching and money-hoarding. In the nationally representative sample, 54% of respondents believe that being generous is the opposite of being thrifty, and 48% of respondents think that if Americans became more thrifty, it would either hurt the economy or wouldn’t make much difference.
Try telling that to my family.
Thrift as a Family Value
My grandfather Thor came to America amidst a background of gray sky and gray sea, in a ship tossed by waves with swells of white and blown by the wind. With limited funds, he took a train to Wisconsin to meet a distant uncle before saving enough to get to St. Paul, Minnesota, where he married Inga, the nurse he fell in love with in Norway and followed to the United States. Together they worked hard planting and harvesting, making rag rugs on the loom that Thor built, and saving much of the money they earned.
Children kept arriving and eventually numbered nine. After learning English, Thor went to work for a major newspaper in St. Paul. He worked hard to improve sales of the paper and he eventually became Circulation Manager. Meanwhile, Inga was at home, cleaning and combing wool before spinning it into yarn, which was used to make sweaters and mittens in traditional Norwegian design. Older children were taught to help out, and all the children learned to earn, save, and spend wisely. Because of Thor and Inga’s thrift, during the Depression they were able to take in relatives in trouble and foster children with no support.
Far from hurting their economic well-being, thrift is the value that enabled my grandparents to enter the American middle class. And now, after nearly fifty years of neglect, Americans are once again celebrating thrift.
National Thrift Week
A once-vibrant social movement from 1916-1966, National Thrift Week is back, starting in Philadelphia and poised to go viral across America with its message that “thrift is the friend of sustainable prosperity, broad economic opportunity, beautiful neighborhoods, and a healthy planet.”
Last month, Philadelphia Mayor Michael Nutter officially proclaimed Thrift Week, and 80 representatives from community organizations, businesses, churches, schools, and banks came together at the “Philadelphia Thrift Leaders Roundtable.” A Philadelphia credit union and charter school are renewing an old Thrift Week tradition by inviting students to open school savings accounts.
The mayor of Philadelphia kicks off Thrift Week.
As the organizer of the only “Thrift Club” in the country, I find that many Americans aren’t even familiar with the word “thrift.” When I extend an invitation to a Thrift Club meeting at the Chanhassen Public Library, I’m met with a politely blank stare and the question, “What’s a Thrift Club?” My daughter, a librarian, suggested that I change the name to the “Simple Living Club,” which is a chic idea nowadays, and could describe the variety of topics our club discusses — from home gardening and food preservation to achieving “greener” homes to having low-cost, meaningful weddings to financial planning and volunteerism.
But the word “thrift” can’t be replaced. For one thing, the root of the word “thrift” is “thrive,” and “to thrive” perfectly captures what the thrift ethic is about. While many people erroneously associate thrift with being miserly, cheap, or stingy, look up “thrift” in the dictionary and you’ll see that it is more accurately described as prosperity, thriving, healthy and vigorous growth, careful management (especially of money), and gainful employment. Thrift is not simply a money saving strategy — it’s a broad term that encompasses the wise use of all resources: health, time, money, and environment included. Thrift is a way of life, an ethic, a philosophy that enables ordinary people like Thor and Inga to be generous and to live the good life.
The Apostle of Thrift
Ben Franklin’s life is the perfect example. Known as the “Apostle of Thrift,” Franklin penned numerous proverbs about “industry and frugality.” However, because he wasted no time or money in his early life, he retired early, donated his money to create libraries and fire departments, and attended plays and ate fine French food while acting as a public servant in France.
John Adams, who also served in France, accused Franklin of hypocrisy, but as social historian Barbara Dafoe Whitehead points out in Franklin’s Thrift: the Lost History of an American Virtue, Franklin was just enjoying the fruits of his thrift.
Rather than inhibiting people, thrift can help contemporary Americans achieve the prosperity that their ancestors came to find. As our leaders seek answers on how to build a more sustainable economy, they would do well to be guided by that venerable word “thrift” — an idea both old and new.
GRS is committed to helping our readers save and achieve your financial goals.Savings interest rates may be low, but that’s all the more reason to shop for the best rate.Find the highest savings interest rate from Ally Bank, Capital One 360, Everbank, and more.
This article is about Frugality, News
Disclaimer: This content is not provided or commissioned by American Express. Opinions expressed here are author's alone, not those of American Express, and have not been reviewed, approved or otherwise endorsed by American Express. This site may be compensated through American Express Affiliate Program.
Discover is a paid advertiser of this site. Reasonable efforts are made to maintain accurate information. See the Discover online credit card application for full terms and conditions on offers and rewards.
SEARCH FOR RECENT ARTICLES



This mades me think of my wonderfully frugal Scottish grandmother who was so generous in her ways but ultimately thrifty. I remember once when my grandparents car broke down my parents worried about what they would do as they were living only on pensions by then. My grandmother bought a car outright with cash. Everyone was stunned. They had no idea she had any money. Yet her generousity was amazing. When her sister died she left my grandmother a small inheritance which she promtly gave to her children and grandchildren saying ‘she had no need for that much money anymore’ and that she would enjoy giving it away more than spending it.
What a lady.
loading....
Cute post! Yay middle class!
loading....
Was it thrift or something else? My parents came to the US around the same time. They started businesses and became successful. I also owed it to determination. Maybe it is a lot of things!
loading....
I haven’t always been thrifty. And I’m regretting that today. Our 24-year-old friend called my husband today: “I’m not trying to brag or anything, but since you’re such a good friend, I wanted to share that we just made our last house payment today.” I am blown away – 24 and no house payment? His wife called me last night to ask for a recipe. In the course of the conversation, she asked if she could substitute generic steak sauce for A-1 steak sauce, because “it’s so expensive. Not worth it to me.”
loading....
Sorry, you lost me at God and “Family Values”. For a non secular blog, this post got too close to the line for me.
loading....
To Russ #5, you’ll notice that she said HER family, not yours. Stop whining.
loading....
@Russ – Way to totally miss the point.
And, I think you mean “secular blog” rather than “non secular blog”.
loading....
ah, a comment that made me laugh out loud.
thanks des!
loading....
Makes me think of the saying, “Use it up, wear it out, make due or do without.”
loading....
@ #5 Russ
Ah ha ha, yes!– and the Templeton Foundation is anything but secular. It’s a proselytizing organization that funds pseudo-science that supports religion. In other words, it doesn’t fund science, it funds theology.
–
About thrift, etc.- sure, why not. We’re all into that here, aren’t we? If the point is that thrift does not equal being miserly, good point.
loading....
I would love to see a revival of thrift and frugality. I get such odd looks from my friends and peers if I even allude to having a budget or planing my grocery list around sales. Of course, I was brought up that way which makes it a lot easier to practice. To them, many things I was taught (like rewiring a lamp, cooking from scratch, repairing clothing), are incredibly complicated and too difficult. I am so thankful my parents equipped with these skills because they remove so much financial stress from my life.
loading....
Great article. It’s a shame that thrift has become so unfashionable. Maybe what puts people off is the idea of saving money that could be spent making them and their families healthier, happier and more comfortable. As El Nerdo #9 says, there’s a difference between being miserly and thrifty. For example, I know people who, despite the admittedly rising costs, could easily afford to heat their homes properly, yet live in an uncomfortable, unhealthy chill (and inflict these conditions on their children) just to save money. Money spent on heating isn’t “wasted” – you spend money, you get a nice warm home. The same can apply to anything, really. I despair of people who sit sweating and baking in boiling rooms in summer with the aircon unit switched off just to save a few pennies – you wouldn’t dehydrate yourself or stop washing just to save water, would you? And anyway, the money you’d save on not using airconditioning could easily be wasted in an impulse on something truly inessential. I believe true thrift is living well but finding ingenious ways of achieving this on a limited budget – I love cooking a week’s healthy and delicious meals based around what the supermarket has on special offer, for example, or re-lighting my living room with energy saving bulbs to create a cosy atmosphere using much less electricity.
loading....
How could I be spending hours every week writing about thrift without finding newthrift.org? Can’t wait to explore it!
I lure citizens to the “dark side” of thrift with the benefits. I find valuable treasures in yard sales, dumpsters, and curb sides. My home features quality supplies, books, furniture, and electronics; most of it free, some of it dirt-cheap.
I save hundreds with creativity and staying true to my “Buy Nothing New” pledge for 2011. Thrift isn’t just a lifestyle, it’s as fun as a video game once embrace the challenge of beating your “high score” by saving more every week.
loading....
@Russ
Oh just go crawl back into your primordial soup and discuss thrift with the relatives.
———–
Wonderful post! I think that “Simplification” or “Living a Simple life” is synonomous with “Thrift.”
If everyone lived well below their means, we wouldn’t be in this economic mess.
loading....
I think thrift has become a lost art. As a culture, I feel like we have gotten accustomed to having everything right away, and being OK with leveraging our futures in the form of debt to get what we want right now. Hopefully thrift will make a comeback, not only on a personal family level, but also on a macro-economic, government policy level.
Pat
http://compoundingreturns.blogspot.com
loading....
I read a great book on the history of Economy/Thrift in America; it’s called “in Cheap We Trust”. It chronicles the history of saving, thrift, and “cheapness” in America. It’s a good read if your interested in this type of history (I know I’m a nerd for enjoying it). My family is very thrifty and takes every opportunity to save a re-purpose things. I’m glad for their influence (although I got the only spender gene but I do try to be thrifty
loading....
I wish this post had been published three weeks ago – we missed Thrift Week! (was Jan. 17 – 23)
loading....
@Annelise
Absolutely wonderfully made point!!!
Thrift does not mean denying one’s self the necessities of life, rather many of the UNnecessities of life.
Thanks!
loading....
Institute for American Values? Hmmmmm. Look up David Blankenhorn, their founder. Or Maggie Gallagher, one of their affiliate scholars.
I think we can all promote thrift without somehow claiming it to be an “American Value” and then attaching to it all sorts of other politicized positions. Thrift is not just an American value, actually; in fact one of the reasons this blog exists is precisely because so many Americans have lost the gist of thrift.
I enjoy GRS a lot, but am a little troubled by finding this here.
loading....
The make do and mend mentality is hard to follow nowadays though, and it’s not always the individual’s fault. For example, it’s often not worth getting small appliances repaired because the cost of the repair is equal to the price of a new one. Similarly, it’s often not worth fixing busted clothes because the fabric quality it so crap.
However, I feel we need to throw some thrift at the public sector. That would be good for the economy- if governmental bodies became more efficient, wasted less money, made the most of what they already had, they wouldn’t have to lay off public employees to save cash.
loading....
gracious, people, it’s a guest post, not a manifesto of J.D.’s new direction! keep calm!
loading....
Thrift is in right now because the economy is so bad. Once the economy improves, jobs will be plentiful, and milk and honey will flow again. Then it will time to $pend $pend $pend.
I think it’s all in the upbringing. If you learned to be thrifty early in life, it will always stick with you. It’s a lot harder to learn when you are an adult.
loading....
First, I think this is a great article – it really puts a fine point on thrift and its benefits.
I do agree with Michael in Missouri – thrift is a great value, one of my own for sure, but to hear about its virtues on the platform of a political and religious “think tank” makes me uncomfortable.
Also, to consider it an American Value feels like truthspeak from 1984. Sure, it is one of the boy scout values, but in practice America is probably the least thrifty country I have been to or lived in. What retirebyforty is saying rings very true – what I think the majority of Americans are practicing now is not truly thrift but “gaming” the system to look for deals, and squeezing the maximum material goods out of the minimum outlay – not reflecting on what is really needed.
loading....
I’m a huge Franklin fan and love the concept. But the timing of this blog post is a little curious…seems like it should have been posted a month ago.
loading....
How exactly do you promote thrift? What are people supposed to do, or not do?
I suppose my grandparents could be called thrifty, at least from the stories my mother’s told me about her childhood. She had many siblings so they couldn’t afford to waste anything. I doubt they called it “thrift”–they were poor and just trying to survive. Mom’s hardworking parents were uneducated sharecroppers so despite their thrifty lifestyle, they remained poor until they died–quite young. It’s an unfortunate legacy passed down that I, my siblings and cousins still struggle to break free of today. Not knocking thrift, just pointing out that thrift alone is not an automatic path to prosperity, at least in my experience.
loading....
What on earth is with all the grumpy, off-the-mark responses to this post? Some families would include God on their family coat-of-arms; some wouldn’t. Mentioning a deity in passing ought to be allowable given that the author is discussing her own family roots. I read it as a literary device emphasizing how important thrift was to her family – that is, as important as faith and family, and imporant enough to be included on a hypothetical coat-of-arms. And I don’t know anything about the Templeton Foundation; maybe they are a bunch of wackos – but for crying out loud, she quoted a poll! I usually look forward to comments here; tonight I’m disappointed!
While many Americans don’t practice thrift today, it does seem to be to be one of the LOST American values… something that we used to have, when we lived life closer to the bone, and that we now pay lip service to when it’s convenient. I think it’s instructive to think about the practices of our grandparents in this way.
loading....
This post is kind of preaching to the choir, isn’t it? (not to pun on a touchy subject, heh) Not sure I learned anything new….
loading....
@Russ-5
It is even worse, at the end of the message, also Thor is mentioned. Indeed, secularity all the way
loading....
I think where thrift lost it’s way in American life is the reason to work hard.
It used to be that you worked hard so that you get get ahead financially and make a better life for your family than the life you had. Now, I think Americans work just as hard, but they feel they deserve to reward themselves for their hard work in the form of spending.
A lot of people have not experienced true hardship in their lives until recently so the idea of saving for a rainy day was completely dumb. Hopefully some good will come out of this downturn and that’ll be preparedness for the next one.
loading....
Hi all,
As a reader of GRS from Norway, I found this a quite interesting post.
Norwegians are known for being thrifty, so I can assure you this is an accurate claim.
Many years ago when Norwegians moved to the US, Norway was one of the poorest countries in Europe. So people moved to the US looking for opportunities.
Today Norway is one of the wealthiest nations in the world. This is mainly due to oil though – not the virtue of thrift alone
http://www.voxeu.org/index.php?q=node/1199
http://seattletimes.nwsource.com/html/nationworld/2004024446_norway20.html
loading....
I just wanted to comment on Bon’s comment (#19) about “gaming the system” rather than real thrift. I had never thought about this before, but I really agree with it. For example, last spring/summer I had a coupon for free McDonald’s coffee. Free is good and thrifty, right? But at the same time, I know it’s a marketing promotion designed to get me to buy more McDonalds. For many reasons (politcal and healthwise) I do not buy McDonald’s. So if I go and only get the free coffee and never buy anything from them again being thrifty or gaming the system? It’s a very interesting point to think about, and I’m glad that you mentioned it.
loading....
Thanks for the post! I love the idea of a thrift club. My girlfriends and I just started a savings club to discuss thrift, investing and continue to educate ourselves about financial issues. http://www.WomensSavingClub.com
loading....
Great post! I love being thrifty! It is what allows me to save way more money than others who make a similar salary.
loading....
Two comments here.
1) @Sara, #26. The coffee is not really “free,” it’s just that McDonald’s is trading their coffee for a bit of your attention. Really, they just want to get you into the restaurant (and I use that term loosely). What you do once you are there is up to you: buy a muffin, another coffee, or never come back.
2) In general, regarding thrift as an “American Value.” How can any one forget Pres. Bush’s exhortation after the September 11th, 2001, attacks that the patriotic thing to do was to keep spending? The economy was in danger of falling due to consumer fears and Bush practically drove the American people to the mall and said, “Don’t come back without an armful of stuff.” So it’s no surprise to me that when the equation spending = loving your country is made that thrift goes out the window.
loading....
Wow…what a great article about the practice and benefits of frugality. It`s such a shame that this article was taken out of context by some readers.
loading....
I don’t think the article was “taken out of context”. Most of us appreciate the story of the thrifty grandparents, and the clarification of the meaning of thrift. That’s very valuable information for GRS readers.
However, some of us also do apply a little skepticism when looking at the sources of this information or certain ideological currents within the piece, i.e. linking thrift with religion or advancing the political agenda of the very creepy (to me anyway) John Templeton (whose foundation gets a double mention here, and he gets several links from this article, as he is prominently featured in the new thrift dot org site and and his book is sold in the National Thrift Week website).
I’m all for tasting the bait (it’s good bait, thrift is good), but I’ll skip the Templeton line, hook and sinker. There is no shame in exercising critical thinking.
loading....
If there were no access to credit or debt, people would be a lot better at saving and being thrifty in order to survive. One of the reasons so many GRS readers are good at being thrifty is that they do not regard debt as an acceptable option.
Delayed gratification is usually a product of practice or perceived necessity. As far as frugality goes, most Americans are out of practice and may not realize that it is in some ways a necessity (due to limited resources).
loading....
I’ve become a huge “Good Will” shopper and buy most of my clothes and other house essentials there. The thought of buying these things ‘new’ makes no sense for me when there is perfectly good, quality things piled up for almost free! With the money I save, I can enjoy a nice dinner out or buy some artwork for my collection. I cringe when I hear that American consumption is “up” as if is was a good thing – perhaps short-term for the economy but certainly not long-term. If people were more thrifty there would be more money to go around for more important things, like allowing us the freedom to start a new business or travel or do others things you enjoy or helping others.
loading....
Great short article. I’ll admit that I was preparing to sign off when Lori mentioned God, but I persevered and found a well balanced piece that wouldn’t offend anyone!
Speaking as a Scot, thrift is definitely a virtue to be admired. But seriously Lori – you’re surprised that many Americans haven’t heard of the word?
According to UN statistics from a few short years ago, the USA consumes roughly 25% of all energy produced on the planet, despite the CIA factbook saying it has less than 5% of the global population?
I’m not bashing America, but the thrift movement has a hell of a long way to go if it wants to make meaningful change in a country this imbalanced!
loading....
I’M AGHAST!!
Being thrifty and watching what you spend is completely un-American. By being thrifty, you cost the world jobs because less is sold, which means less is made. You keep the US government from getting bigger and bigger in its attempt of becoming a complete nanny state. If you can take care of yourself, what is there for the government to do?
loading....
Chanhassen? I believe you mean Chanhappening! I recently moved here from out of state, was pleased to see an article written by a fellow Minnesotan (even though I’m originally from WI).
What is this Thrift Club you reference? Is this something local I can get involved in!?!? Info would be appreciated, dmdiller@gmail.com
loading....
Just another guest blogger rehashing old financial advice. Get Rich Slowly is slowly becoming redundant because of hack guest posters.
loading....