This is a guest post from Louisa Rogers, a consultant who provides leadership, management, and communication coaching and training to businesses. Previously, Louisa told us what it’s like to have even better than enough, described how she’s getting a fresh start on the path to prosperity, and wrote about living on less in Mexico.
As a middle-aged fitness junkie, I’m always interested in what motivates people to get in shape. Typically, folks say they want to lose weight, tone their bodies, and slow the aging process. But there’s another major reason to get fit that I rarely hear discussed — saving money. Fitness alone doesn’t guarantee reduced health care costs, of course, but it sure increases the odds. In my case, although I grew up overweight and out-of-shape, around the age of twenty I started becoming active, and now, at sixty, I’m finding that years of accumulated fitness are — literally — money in the bank.
Over the last few years I’ve started to see more and more of my peers spending money — lots of money — fixing their health. They are not necessarily in terrible shape, but few of them are as active as I am. They suffer from knee problems. Back problems. Shoulder problems. Digestive problems. Prostrate problems. Osteoporosis. Insomnia. Arthritis. Diabetes. Memory loss. Cancer.
Looking for help, they invest in prescription drugs, medications, hormones, supplements, complicated tests, scans, chiropractor visits, podiatrist visits, procedures, body replacements, surgeries, chemo and radiation. Not to mention expensive health care insurance.
My own story is different. I’ve had one cold in the last ten years and never get the flu. I don’t take medication. I sailed through menopause — no hot flashes, mood swings, insomnia, or estrogen. I started practicing preventive health care forty years ago, and now it seems I’m reaping the rewards. I do have catastrophic health insurance, and the reason I’m willing to take the risk of paying only for skimpy health care coverage is that I have such a strong health record.
Am I just lucky or is my good health the result of years of taking care of myself? I really don’t know. But surely my fitness record didn’t hurt and may have helped.
Genetically, I’m a mixed bag: my dad is my model — a healthy, active 90-year old who climbs up and down the stairs of his home several times a day. But my mother died young, at 53, and my older sister died at 60. I have two other sisters: one very healthy, the other besieged by multiple health conditions.
I’m convinced that, on balance, taking care of myself has led to good health, with lower health costs. Here’s what has worked for me:
- I move everyday. How I move, in my opinion, is less important than that I move. Just like I brush my teeth everyday, I’m physically active everyday. Period. I know common wisdom says that rest is recommended once a week or so. But even on a “rest” day, I still stroll around the neighborhood or ride my bicycle to the library.
- Left foot, right foot. I used to think walking was wussy. Running was my “real” exercise. Because it’s so simple, I underestimated walking. It’s now my default activity; if I do nothing else, I’ll always walk. And it requires no gym, Spandex, Lycra, or technical skill.
- I’m on a car diet. Like sugar, I limit my driving. By cutting my driving intake by about 90%, I automatically move more, using my natural locomotion to get around. I first experienced the freedom of being car-free in 1997, when I went on a car “fast.” After I dropped my husband off at the airport, I decided I wouldn’t drive again until I picked him up a week later. Every evening, I’d pore through regional maps figuring out how I’d get to my next day’s client meeting. All week long, as I used my feet, my bicycle, my inline skates, the commuter train, and the bus, I felt light-footed and lighthearted.
- Bicycles rule. I’ve owned a bicycle since I was in college. For years I rode three-speeds that I’d buy secondhand for less than $100. On my first bicycle tour, I rode 350 miles down the Oregon Coast on a Sears Huffy, a behemoth of a bike. My current bicycles are a $400 mountain bike I bought in 1996 that I keep at our home in Mexico, and a $500 Dahon folding bike that I use for getting around in California, as well as when my husband and I bike-tour in Europe.
- There is life after running. I love running, and I kept it up even after a traumatic parachuting accident in my 20s, when what was left of my right ankle was cobbled back together with stainless steel pins and plates. Around age 55, my ankle began to feel increasingly wobbly, and I remembered my orthopedic surgeon warning me that one day I could be a candidate for early arthritis. So, I gave it up and took up swimming. It annoyed me, though, to drive six miles to the nearest pool. Or, if I rode my bike to the pool, by the time I reached the pool, I wasn’t motivated to swim, knowing I still had six miles to ride back. One day, I thought, “Why don’t I try open-water swimming in the bay?” (a block from my home). Now I swim happily in the bay, accompanied by seals and herons, three or four times a week, several months out of the year. I would never have discovered this joyous activity if I kept running. My lesson? I have to be willing to adapt. I can’t let my fitness become captive to one form of exercise.
- I’m opportunistic. When I have an appointment or a meeting, I’ll take a pair of comfortable shoes to explore the area afterwards. I stalk hills and stairs like a predator. At airports, I avoid escalators and moving sidewalks. If I pass a playground, I’ll throw my stuff down, join the toddlers and swing for several minutes. Once, while walking near our home in Mexico, I passed several kids kicking a ball around. I turned around and kicked it back towards them, as hard as I could. They shrieked. I’ll bet they weren’t expecting that from a gringa, especially not a señora.
- No time? No problem. You’ve probably read, like I have, that you need to break a sweat for at least 20, 30 or 60 minutes for it to “count.” This may be physiologically true, but to me it sounds discouraging. My philosophy is, every bit of movement counts! None of it is wasted. I don’t avoid exercise just because I only have a few minutes. Five minutes here, ten minutes there — it all adds up.
- Variety makes my day. I feast on a potluck of activities. On my favorite days, I’ll walk, ride my bike, play with kettlebells, swim or kayak, do bodyweight exercises or yoga. I’m fortunate in that I work for myself and can set my own hours. But my sister, who has a full-time job, rows in the morning, walks her dog after work, and does yoga at home a few times a week. It can be done.
- I invest in the right equipment. The current trend in fitness is towards light, portable and often low-cost tools, so you can work out easily without expensive, bulky machines or the cost of joining a gym. I own a stability ball ($15), hiking boots ($60), inline skates ($100), a yoga mat ($15), 2 hoops (one weighted) ($60, combined), a Pedometer ($20, but it was a gift), a bicycle ($500), bicycle pannier bags ($50), a kayak ($300), a backpack ($100), a “shorty” Neoprene wetsuit ($55), a kettlebell ($55) and several dumbbells ($50 combined, also gifts).
These are the practices that have helped me stay out of the hospital…so far. No guarantees. Fitness does not promise a life free of illness or pain. I’m just hedging my bets, hoping that, like my dad, I’ll still be financially and physically fit, climbing up and down steps in my 90s.
Speaking of which…it’s 1:15. I have an appointment at 2:00 on the fifth floor of an office building. If I head out now, I still have time to do a few circuits up and down the stairs before the meeting. See ya!
GRS is committed to helping our readers save and achieve your financial goals.Savings interest rates may be low, but that’s all the more reason to shop for the best rate.Find the highest savings interest rate from Ally Bank, Capital One 360, Everbank, and more.
This article is about Health & Fitness
Disclaimer: This content is not provided or commissioned by American Express. Opinions expressed here are author's alone, not those of American Express, and have not been reviewed, approved or otherwise endorsed by American Express. This site may be compensated through American Express Affiliate Program.
Discover is a paid advertiser of this site. Reasonable efforts are made to maintain accurate information. See the Discover online credit card application for full terms and conditions on offers and rewards.
SEARCH FOR RECENT ARTICLES



All excellent tips, and good for Louisa for making health a priority. I agree that taking better care of ourselves is a worthwhile investment. A good lifestyle lowers our risk for any number of serious diseases.
However, speaking as someone who isn’t as genetically lucky as Louisa, I also think we have to be very careful how we judge others’ health. Both from my personal experience and that of people I know, it’s all to easy to say “if only they’d done this…” or “they shouldn’t have done that.”
One thing I’ve learned is that it’s really easy to “blame the victim” for doing or not doing something — but just because someone develops a health issue, doesn’t necessarily mean it’s their fault. I think we like to believe we’re more in control of our health than we actually are. Louisa hit it lucky, and she has some good advice, but the judgement in this post really hit me the wrong way.
loading....
I’m so glad this was the first comment. I totally agree that good health is largely a matter of genetics. My husband’s aunt lived to 98 years old and smoked a pack a day until she was 93 and had to give it up because she could no longer afford it.
It’s great to live a healthy lifestyle and good habits certainly reduce your risks of many illnesses. But knee problems, memory loss, and cancer happen to vegan aerobics instructors too.
loading....
I can add that, as a nurse, I was also put-off by the tone of this article. It is VERY true that caring for our health makes everything in life better. Far more life enhancing to not NEED medications for blood pressure or Type II diabetes due to weight management and regular exercise. Many people in the First World are digging themselves an early grave with their fork, while not moving off of the couch.
However, not all illnesses are what we think of as “lifestyle” illnesses, and injuries can occur to anyone at anytime. I had a patient who an “Ironman” type trialthetle….and loose gravel under his bike tires causes a fall that paralyzed him from the shoulders down. Cancers tend to have a strong genetic component (small cell lung cancer tends to occur in non-smokers) as are many, many other diseases, including polycystic kidney disease (fatal without dialyis) bleeding disorders, and rheumatoid arthrits.
And, despite sanitation and vaccinations, our war with germs is hardly over..bacteria are becoming resistant to antibiotics due to overuse, and viruses are still mainly a mystery (Get seated next to the wrong person on a bus and get SARS or TB)
Self-care is wonderful, but not when it evolves into a sense of self-congratulatory invulnerabilty…or blaming others for accidents of birth, location, or genetics. And that “emergency insurance” can reach its limits in less than a day or a weekin the hospital.
loading....
Magical thinking remains magical thinking. I wonder if it ever occurred to Louisa that if she felt in the morning as if she had just started sleeping she would want to be swimming in the bay, running, etc.
And bike riding, with or without a helmet, can be a seriously life-limiting activity.
loading....
Hi,
I just wanted to say thank you so much for referring to Type II diabetes by name instead of just ‘diabetes’…As a type 1 diabetic, my auto-immune disorder (which comes from a strong genetic component and an unknown environmental trigger) is expensive (would cost $12k per yr w/o insurance) and not-preventable or curable regardless of diet, weight, or exercise.
Cheers,
type1gal
loading....
I had this reaction initially too, but on re-reading I think most of it was unintentional. However, the end of the second paragraph still irks me. A lot of those things might be alleviated/prevented by healthy living, but some are just plain bad luck, and others can be caused by exercise (bad joints particularly!).
I’m not advocating not living healthily – I cycle everywhere despite my asthma unless I’m particularly unwell, and eat healthily, both of which reduce my bills and keep my exacerbations down. But living healthily is not a “magic pill”…
loading....
I’m not trying to pick on poor Louisa
I think it’s an attitude our society has in general. We’ve become increasingly focussed on prevention — which is a good thing — but I think we also have to understand that we can do everything right and still get sick. We like cause and effect. “So-and-so had skin cancer because they never wore sunscreen. I wear sunscreen, therefore it can’t happen to me.” It doesn’t always work like that.
The other side of this story is that people who make an effort to exercise, eat well, get lots of sleep, etc. are judged too. Sometimes people aren’t happy unless others are making the same choices they are.
loading....
As someone who places a very high priority on healthy eating and exercise yet still suffers from an immune disorder that causes illness, I am very thankful for these comments. The majority of Americans do need to start eating better and moving. There is no question that doing so lowers our health costs. But even a lifelong vegetarian who cooks from scratch daily with fresh ingredients, walks 20 minutes a day, drinks copious amounts of water, flosses and takes her vitamins can be hit with unfortunate health costs.
loading....
This was my reaction as well. Don’t get me wrong, I think staying active is important for everyone regardless of their age. However, we tend to grossly under-estimate the part genetics plays in our health.
My great-grandmother is still alive at 99, her daughter (my grandma) is in her eighties and has been obese (occasionally morbidly) her whole life. She deep fries her bacon (no joke). My husband, OTOH, has no living grandparents, and his father is in failing health in his 50s. You can see the difference even now in our 20s. DH has decent (but borderline) cholesterol and blood pressure. My blood pressure is low and the nurse said she had literally never seen cholesterol numbers as good as mine. Yet we eat the same food at every meal, and exercise together the same amount of time doing the same activities. The difference is in our genes.
I think the “blame the victim” mantra is an unfortunate side-effect of a more positive attitude: that we are masters of our own fate, that we have control over our destiny. It is a lovely sentiment, but it is only partially true. That shouldn’t discourage us from doing the best we can, though.
loading....
Well said…all we can do is change what we can change (as the old serenity prayer states)and learn to live with the things that cannot be changed. Be as healthy as you can and understand that blaming others (or yourself) for health problems BEYOND YOUR CONTROL is silly and non-prodective.
So..eat well, move every day, keep stress down, and remember that no one gets out of here alive.
loading....
I have these arguments with my father – he says he can’t be healthy becasue of his genetics so why try. I say – for any set of genetics – maintaining a healthy lifestyle will greatly improve your chances of a longer more enjoyable life. Yea, vegan aerobic instructors get cancer, but when they do, they probably are able to manage much better than someone who is morbidly obese and in poor cardiac fitness.
loading....
@ Bella — I have the same arguments with the men in my family too
I see health sort of the way I do wealth. We’re all born with a certain amount of it, but it’s up to us to make the most of it. I didn’t hit the jackpot, but I’m grateful for what I have — and for the access to information, strategies and tools to be better.
loading....
thank you for making that point so I didn’t have to.
It’s a lot easier for a physician or surgeon to do procedures on someone with a well-exercised heart who isn’t 50+ pounds overweight – and safer for the patient, as well.
loading....
Here in Ontario, I’ve heard cases where doctors won’t accept new patients who refuse to look after themselves. When resources are tight — need I say doctor shortage? — some physicians want to focus their efforts on people who will actually take their advice.
loading....
For the record, Louisa had caught the problem with tone and forwarded a revised version of the post to me last night, but I didn’t catch it in time to make changes.
loading....
I’ve read recently that the first 50 years are free, the next 50 are earned.
And this wisdom can be seen by someone such as yourself. As one gets older one can see the impact that by making small decisions to invest in health, can change not only on our future lives, but on our lives right now.
loading....
“I’ve read recently that the first 50 years are free, the next 50 are earned.”
I love that and, boy, is it ever true! I’m putting that on my PC as a screensaver to remind me LOL
loading....
Personally, I didn’t pick up on a judgmental tone. The benefits of exercise and practicing a healthful lifestyle are well documented. I do agree with the genetics spin, however. I can really see the effect of ‘good’ genes in my father’s side of the family. My father is in his mid 70s but he frequently gets mistaken for someone 20 years younger. He still works, is highly active both mentally and physically and I have no doubt that he will become a centenarian like most of his mother’s family.
loading....
I suspect some of us who are used to being “judged” (rightly or wrongly) are extra-sensitive about this. Nice to know from JD that any judgement was unintentional. Intention does make a difference IMO.
loading....
I agree. For the record, I certainly don’t think Louisa intended to offend anyone. Sometimes beliefs that we have as individuals and as a society come through in what we write. I’m challenging the idea, not Louisa herself. I think she did a great job offering tips, and there’s always a risk when you “put yourself out there” in writing.
loading....
TRUE TRUE TRUE TRUE!
We aren’t as in control as we like to think we are. And we really don’t discover this until an illness hits us, that we can’t “fix.”
loading....
I’m more a swimmer (plus walk to work). It has the advantage that the basic equipment is very cheap (swimsuit, sandals, towel, googles and hat) and long lasting if you buy it Chlorine resistant and keep it well. The disadvantage is that you pay everytime you practice it (in my case €37 for ten sessions). I’d like to get a bike, but I don’t have any space at the moment.
loading....
I miss swimming
These days I find it easier to get in a brisk walk because it’s more convenient than driving across town to the pool. (Not to mention dealing with my hair after swimming!)
loading....
That’s one of the reasons I like my very short hair
loading....
There are ways to store bikes that don’t take up floor space. Hang them from the ceiling! See: http://www.performancebike.com/bikes/Product_10052_10551_1023851_-1___
loading....
Thanks a lot Claire, but even for that my current room is too small (I live in a big city) and I don’t want to use common space of my shared flat. We’re moving soon to another place, so hopefully I’ll have more space in a few months.
loading....
Can’t agree more, even 5 mins of exercise every hour or two adds up. Improving finance and health are two thing everyone knows about, but the difficulty is in implementing the ideas.
I read an article last week which mentioned that, showing how you’d look in yours 60′s or 70′s motivates people to save money and improve health.
loading....
I love the empowering effect of walking, especially when you live in a city- you’re not a slave to the bus, to traffic or to the tube. I used to live in Southwark and walk all the way to Marble Arch and back for shopping trips (about 6 miles). Every day I went into uni was a 5 mile walk. The city is never boring to walk in.
Now I live with my parents outside of London and walk to the train station every day (2 miles) and I hate it. It’s so boring and my town is so ugly. I wish my bicycle hadn’t been stolen.
I hated team sports as a kid, but now I’m on the cheerleading squad at university, and it’s the best thing ever! The sense of camaraderie and friendship is amazing, plus you get very strong from lifting up other people and learning gymnastics. I feel so much healthier and happier on weeks when I have cheer.
loading....
Try taking a course in botany and entomology. If you learn more about the smaller things you see in the country, you’ll make the walking more enjoyable in both locations. Things move at a slower pace, but they can be just as enjoyable.
loading....
Thank you for your suggestion, but I don’t live in the countryside, I live in an industrial town! I could develop an interest in cars I guess and be able to name all the vehicles on the dual carriageway I walk along every morning
2 miles a day in the country would be invigorating. 2 miles a day in Slough is life sucking. Aah, the things I do to avoid paying £2.50 for a bus that’s never on time…
loading....
Industrial areas surely have their own interesting things! And just as soon as I can think of some, I’ll be sure to let you know….
loading....
When I was in school in a very very small town, an mp3 player was a lifesaver. A podcast can keep you entertained for a while. Also, it can help you study.
loading....
This is some great advice for everyone who is looking at their current health care needs and fearing in the future that the insurance will go up, or the bills will go up, or both.
I really encourage the movement every day, but some of us aren’t as lucky as Louisa and able to move around before important meetings – we sweat a lot. If I took “a few circuits up and down the stairs”, I would be shunned out of my office because of the overriding stench and sweat stains on my clothing. I wish it wasn’t the case, but sometimes people have to segregate their work and exercise. A lot of these tips seem to be in the same vein of “get your exercise in when you can”.
loading....
I think another relevant issue that the author didn’t mention is that when you are physically active, you are often not spending money. After the initial equipment investments (which don’t have to be expensive), most activities don’t cost much at all. It’s hard to spend money when you are riding a bike or jogging, especially if you are not riding a stationary exercise bike or running a track in a gym.
I play capoeira, which I recommend to anyone looking for a cheap way to get really fit. Most schools are very focused on being economically accessible and you will not find any other exercise that marries strength-training, flexibility, and endurance so smoothly.
loading....
Very good points in this article, and in the comments. Health does require some investment, and unfortunately, it’s probably the easiest thing to take for granted if you’ve never had a major issue. Several years ago I developed a chronic illness, and I had two choices. The care my insurance would pay for would be the cheap way to go, but it wasn’t going to address the underlying issue, and I’d be dependent on drugs indefinitely. My doctor suspected acupuncture would be more helpful, but insurance didn’t cover it. I chose the acupuncture anyway and paid out of pocket. It tooks some time and patience, but 2 years later I was symptom and drug free. Excellent investment.
loading....
What a great post!! I don’t think she means to criticize those that have worse health, I think she’s just thankful that she fit in exercise where she could. This post is a good reminder to the under 40 crowd to get moving!
loading....
I agree. I didn’t pick up any judgmental vibes, I think she’s an optomist and truly loves to exercise.
I do want to echo however, those who have mentioned genes. Sometimes you can be the picture of health and suffer from a catastrophic underlying condition that is just part of your body’s makeup; just look at James Fixx, for example.
My Dad was relatively healthy, with just some hypertension making up his negative health history, up until 3 years ago when his aorta dissected and he was diagnosed with a rare form of skin cancer (not sun induced) within 3 months of each occurring. Some things just aren’t preventable.
If she can afford it, I would encourage the author to add regular health insurance on top of her catastrophic policy; a health emergency could potentially leave one with a chronic condition that requires ongoing care.
loading....
Here’s what I’ve read and learned from my doctors – exercise and diet will take you to 80, but genes take you beyond that. But we can’t choose our genes (or luck – if a semi hits you, a semi hits you), we have much more control over our diet and exercise.
I’m not a “natural” exercise lover, so what works for me is that I found an activity that I truly enjoy on its own, (Argentine tango) that is also helping me with a little bit of cardio, movement, and a lot of coordination – which studies have shown also helps with the brain. I’ll take whatever I can get!
loading....
I started taking the stairs at work when I realized that I wasn’t getting enough exercise. We had a fire drill and we had to walk down 18 flights of stairs. I was in heels but I was huffing and puffing. That made me want to get in better shape.
loading....
“On my first bicycle tour, I rode 350 miles down the Oregon Coast on a Sears Huffy, a behemoth of a bike.”
All I can say is “Holy Cow.” That is, indeed, a behemoth of a bike.
loading....
This is the exact message I am trying to get across: taking care of your health is the greatest investment you’ll ever make.
I tend to focus on nutrition, but fitness is definitely huge as well.
loading....
Since the focus here is on benefits as you get older – it’s very important to engage in “load bearing” exercise from age 40 on. Starting in our mid-30s we start to lose bone and muscle tissue – and aerobic exercise does not really address that.
Weightlifting and other heavy-load exercise stimulates muscle growth and bone density. You should incorporate HEAVY weights – not just small dumbells – in your fitness plan. Eventually you should work up to hefting your own bodyweight – which sounds like a lot, but basically insures you can pull *yourself* out of a hole.
loading....
I like this visual. I don’t think that I can currently lift myself out of a hole – might dislocate a shoulder – this is a great goal to work towards – bonus – the lighter you are the easier it is to accomplish
loading....
Anyone should be able to eventually get to where they can lift their own weight. Someone may be 300 pounds when they start lifting, but the combination of getting stronger and losing weight from the exercise will bring you closer to lifting your own weight.
loading....
I agree, but if you do load-bearing exercises for this reason, be SURE to get enough calcium & vitamin D. My mom has been weightlifting ever since I can remember, but has found out that she has the beginning stages of osteoperosis. I highly suspect the reason is that she avoids excess sunlight (a major source of vitamin D) like the plague. Without enough vitamin D, your body can’t absorb calcium.
loading....
I like the “being opportunistic” tip. I do similar things at work. When I’m waiting out in the hall for a meeting room to clear out, I’ll some wall squats. I’ll take the stairs instead of the elevator. I’ll take the long way around the building when I need to get somewhere. If I’m waiting TV I’ll do a few pushups and situps while I’m at it. There are some many little ways to keep moving.
loading....
I agree. I ‘m not an uber exerciser, I have to work it into my regular routine or it’s just not going to happen.
loading....
GREAT post. I loved the enthusiasm the author shares. My husband & I have FINALLY made exercising a habit, but my only exercise is 30 mins at the gym 4x/week. I love the section about “be opportunistic”. The author has inspired me to get a pair of walking shoes for my work desk so that I can take a walk when I can every day (my work shoes are not comfortable enough to take walks like that). I’ve tried walking around the inside of my building, but it’s only so big.
loading....
I used to run 5 miles a day using a building with 24 laps to the mile. I learned to use my fingers to track laps without thinking about it.
loading....
I also agree on the “tone” it can sound a little braggy. I’m in my mid forties and besides exercise videos a couple times a week and putting on music and dancing with my kids, the main thing is I do is walk. I think the word on walking is getting out. When people asked me how I keep in shape, I’d say “I walk” and I’d get, no really, how do you get in shape? Now when I say that people nod their heads.
loading....
Wow Louisa, that is such an inspirational post! Health is on my mind a lot lately. I believe that you are making some well researched points regarding the correlation between health and fitness. I haven’t been as diligent as you, though I find myself wishing I had been. All I can do moving forward, however, is to do the best I can now. I stay out of restaurants, cook and eat at home and exercise daily. When I don’t eat well or exercise, I definitely feel worse for it. You’re so fortunate to have made the connection between wellness and lifestyle so early in life
loading....
I found this to be an interesting post, but fairly condescending (looks like a revised post may be coming?) I agree that taking good care of yourself can pay off, but Louisa almost seems to imply you can avoid cancer, etc if you just eat and live right, which is frankly BS!
loading....
This is a question I really struggle with– to what extent do we exert any influence at all over cancer? I’ve lost two members of my family to cancer (at young ages–in their 50s and 60), and a third member now has cancer, so I think about this a lot. None of the three family members who got cancer did much exercise, ate healthily, or managed stress well. The three other family members (including me), who, so far, have not contracted cancer, do make better lifestyle choices. I am not a physician or a medical researcher; I’m only going on circumstantial evidence. But to me the jury is out as to whether cancer is preventable. Maybe my mother would have died young even if she had jogged everyday. I have no way of knowing. But like I said, I’m just trying to hedge my bets.
loading....
I’m not a doctor or other medical professional, so please take this comment with a large grain of salt (or sodium substitute). The answer to whether cancer can be prevented is, “It depends.” It depends on genetics as well as on environment. Case in point: everyone on my father’s side of the family who smoked died of cancer in their 50′s. My m-i-l (no blood relation) smoked like a chimney until age 70 with no ill effect, then quit and lived on for 13 more years. So on my father’s side of the family, they very likely could have prevented their cancer if they’d been able to quit a very addictive habit (and at a time when the danger of cigarettes wasn’t well known). For my m-i-l, it obviously didn’t matter. Why the difference? Genetics.
I agree that it’s smart to eat right and exercise. But it’s the same as good personal finance: just as you spend less than you earn, you eat less than you burn – but the rest of it is about mindset, attitude, conditioning, and the incredible power of the subconscious to help or hinder you in your goal. It’s helpful to know the right thing to do, but conscious knowing alone can’t do it.
loading....
This is motivating! I’m a 23 year old who has been relatively active my whole life. In the past couple of years I’ve become less so, and thus in an effort to keep fit, I’m picking up healthier eating and exercise once again. I’m striving to make a habit of it! I like how integrated “moving” is into your life! I need to start thinking of it that way. Instead of sitting at my desk and sending an email to a co-worker, I’ll walk over and talk. Instead of just eating lunch at my desk, I’ll take a walk, then eat my lunch in less time. I would love to be physically and financially fit when I am older as well! Thanks for the inspiration!
http://munchtalk.blogspot.com/
loading....
Recent recommendations in the fitness profession are that unless you are doing heavy weightlifting or distance running/biking four or more days a week, no “rest” day is needed. Most people simply don’t work out hard enough to need a day off.
Exercise is like good sleep habits, anyway. Staying up late and sleeping in seem like indulgences but they can start a cycle. So can skipping a day of exercise. People who are serious about fitness do some exercise every day. They just don’t necessarily do the SAME exercise every day.
I think Louisa’ primary point was that staying fit has a *likelihood* of producing lower health-care costs over a lifetime. And that is a well-substantiated point; many studies support that conclusion. Simply put, you are more likely to live a healthy life (i.e. not requiring expensive medical interventions or longterm medication regimes) if you are fit and active.
“More likely” doesn’t equal “guaranteed,” but why fight the conclusion just because it isn’t guaranteed? Putting $10 a week in a savings account isn’t guaranteed to get you financially healthy, but it sure is more likely to do so than spending $10 a week on lottery tickets.
loading....
I don’t think people here are fighting the conclusion. I’m sure we can all agree an active lifestyle is healthier than a sedentary one. I think many of us resented the tone and implication that the author’s friends earned their Alzheimer’s, cancer, back troubles, autoimmune diseases and knee replacements because they haven’t led as healthy a lifestyle as she.
loading....
Perhaps if those folks have been sedentary, lacking any kind of regular exercise, then they have in effect earned their problems.
I personally have crap genes and other bits that have helped me to failing joints. I still keep moving. Keep doing whatever exercise I can.
Poor choices lead to poor outcomes. It is not pointing fingers or assigning blame. Simply a statement in fact.
loading....
What if you have type 1 diabetes? pulmonary hypertension? cystic fibrosis? GENES determine your potential, whether it’s living to 30, 60 or 90. What you do during that time–diet, exercise, avoiding the aforementioned truck–determines whether you reach your potential.
loading....
What an inspiring post! Thanks Louisa for giving us all the nudge we need in such a positive way. Great tips! I also want to add that even if we’d predisposed to ‘bad’ genetics we can turn 90% of that around with a healthy plant-based diet. (I’ve been very inspired by the book, “The China Study” which goes into this exact issue of overcoming genetics by a vegan diet.)
Laurie
loading....
I agree Laura.If people would just “lean into” the idea of a plant-based diet, they’d be surprised at the relative ease of the change. Not only is it healthier, plant-based diets are more compassionate and is environmentally green.
I would highly recommend reading Kathy Freston’s book “Veganist”. It is NOT preachy and is loaded with information about animal products we eat and how it impacts us as humans.
loading....
There is nothing healthy about completely cutting meat from your diet. No one needs a 36-ounce ribeye, but you do need certain proteins that come from lean meats.
loading....
Actually, a balanced vegetarian diet is a very healthy diet, healthier than including any lean meat.
See here http://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S0899900704001674, here http://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/014067369091656U, here http://ukpmc.ac.uk/abstract/MED/707372/reload=0;jsessionid=C7922C32F9442B5B8000C6931E5FD69B, here http://journals.cambridge.org/download.php?file=%2FBJN%2FBJN72_04%2FS0007114594001601a.pdf&code=9a274db6db733bff91f4e05f6aebbcf2, and here http://www.ajcn.org/content/70/3/525S.short.
loading....
No, you’d don’t. I’m a qualified nutritionist and to say that animal protein is necessary is completely wrong.
loading....
Humans are omnivores, and require the amino acids only found in complete proteins. Some dedicated adults can manage to combine incomplete proteins (beans and rice, peanut butter and whole grain bread) to make up a healthy diet, but this is DANGEROUS FOR CHILDREN.
loading....
@Patti, a well-balanced vegetarian diet is healthy for children. Please read the research. But as any diet, it must be well-balanced.
The idea of complete protein was tossed years ago in studies of societies, religions and other areas where vegetarianism is practiced either exclusively due to religious dietary restrictions (Hindus, 7th Day Adventists, others) or culturally.
While the research may change or tweak certain aspects, I hope that more people will become familiar with peer-reviewed, first source data rather than what is printed by the media.
loading....
This could be a great post and an inspiration but the writer loses credibility because of the numerous leaps in logic. Statements regarding that the author is the most active person she knows and she never has colds or illness or cancer is linked to her friends who are not as in shape and are now spending money to fix health issues. How is it that these practices have helped to keep her out of a hospital? The theory is I haven’t been in the hospital; here are things I do that are unique; thus, the two must be linked. Under that logic, anything can be linked. One can be a “expert” on relationships simply because she isn’t divorced . . . until it happens. The problem with this is that the underlying validity of the proposition is resting on an individual’s personal situation.
The article would be so much stronger by simply relying on statistics for health in general instead of the look-my-situation-and-trust-my-perceptions. Then the author could provide her specific examples as to what she does.
As for the question regarding colds and illnesses, in my perspective, some people simply have better genes. I get sick easily, and have since I was an infant. (Or perhaps I was simply not active enough in the womb). My husband never gets sick. I have one child who is sick often and it lacks for weeks and the other who rarely gets sick or is over it in one week. And interestingly enough, my sicker child is the one who is ALWAYS active, running, biking, swimming, climbing.
loading....
I have a friend like that; she went to National Jewish in Denver and got herself tested, and her three kids, and they have immune system deficiencies. That would certainly be worth knowing if it is the case with you.
loading....
Since hitting age 50, I’ve come to the realization that once you hit middle age the only thing you have going for you is diet and exercise. One of the few things in life you can still control is what goes into your body and what level of activity you choose to do. I’m an advocate of strength training and yoga, and regularly alternate BodyPump workouts with Ashtanga Yoga. While I feel the joints creak at this time of year, I still manage to do what I can when I can. Of course I can’t life what I could when I was 30, but I don’t huff an puff after hauling in groceries or climbing the flights of stairs to my office. Both my parents had arthritis and heart problems, yet lived well into their 90s. If heredity does indeed play a part, I plan to follow their lead and age as gracefully as possible.
loading....
I finally made my weight a priority this year and I can say that Weight Watchers Online was my best ever investment. I am down about 20 pounds overall for this year (156 from 176) and will hit it hard again in 2012 to get down the total 36 pounds I am aiming for (maintain around 140), but the biggest difference to me is that I don’t feel tired all of the time. My face isn’t lost in puffiness anymore. I am happier on a daily basis. Yay for being healthier!
loading....
Reading many of these replies, I am curious if we read the same post. The criticisms of not blaming genetics,”vegan aerobics instructors get cancer too” seem misguided.
The article I read seemed to say, “I decided to take charge of my health and I have felt much better and am happier for it.” I read no blame.
I often see overweight people. They are often the first to blame everything and everyone else; take zero responsibility for their health and related costs. They frequently have the more difficulty physically as well as financially.
It seems when we attempt to educate folks on the benefits of changing their behavior, lifestyle, etc. to something more conducive to better health they hear nothing. Or my favorite: become hostile or like a petulant child.
I rather enjoyed this article. Simply written, w/a simple message. Thank you, Louisa.
loading....
I agree with you — some people don’t want to be told how to live their lives, whether it’s health, relationships or spending habits! I think there’s a happy medium between taking responsibility for our lives and thinking we can control everything.
Some illnesses like type 2 diabetes have been proven to have a strong lifestyle component. However, experts still don’t understand what causes a whole host of diseases from autoimmune disorders to cancer.
We can’t control risks like our age, gender, environment, family history, ethnicity, etc, but we can control our lifestyle habits. I don’t think anyone is arguing that good lifestyle habits aren’t worthwhile. They’re just one piece in a bigger puzzle. It’s a piece I can control, so I for one am going to try!
loading....
Science, researchers and medicine do not fully understand many diseases and disorders. We do know that folks can weight the odds in their favor by making healthy choices.
Between genetics and previous damage, I have failing joints. I still move, work out, try to make healthier choices. Many things in our lives are nature vs. nurture. I will try my best to nurture better choices.
It just seemed that so many read criticism in this article that did not seem to be there. I wonder if those folks are more accustomed to criticism in daily life. Or perhaps they are the folks who make less healthy choices and feel called out. I do not know. Just ideas.
I figure I have things I can control and things I cannot. I will concern myself primarily w/ those things I can control. Seems more effective. If I want change I begin w/ my own thoughts and behavior patterns.
loading....
I love, love your post and this definitely motivate me to exercise. I am forty and not in good shape but after I read your post… I have to do something to live a long, long healthy life. Thanks for sharing. You inspire me.
loading....
I am a very healthy 65 year old! I exercise, stretch, lift weights and bicycle. I think one’s health drifts into everything they do. I feel more confident and assured because I feel and look good.
loading....
nice tips. walking and being mobile can truly burn more calories than you can imagine. A sedantary job or any office job does not provide the opportunities one would want to have a significant calorie burning experience. you would need to supplement it with exercise. ofcourse the walking is a bonus.
loading....
I get post-exertional crashes when I exercise, so exercise actually makes me sick now that I have autoimmune problems and smoldering myeloma. I used to exercise several days a week in the gym but the effect of exercise on me was always ‘different’ than I noticed on others. For one, I stopped being able to exercise in any way in the mornings without it destroying my day, and this in my twenties. Yet I have an aunt who is in her 80s and she jumps to exercise 6 am at a health gym 5 days a week, and in the afternoon does aerobics. She started her exercise in her fifties, no early stuff like me. And I used to eat vegetarian until it landed me in the hospital because my stomach cannot handle raw foods; I was told by the doctors to stop eating raw foods, as well as I am allergic to whole wheat, as my brother is.
My aunt has a different set of genetics that I do, yet her sister, my late aunt, died from the same myeloma that is smoldering in my body. At the time they blamed it on her smoking; but I don’t smoke, and never have, and I don’t even drink, but I have fatty liver from steroids taken 20 years ago for allergic asthma. I am adding my 2-cents here because, for some, even exercise does no good at all when you are stricken with certain diseases, and I am in my early fifties.
loading....
It is, in fact, counter productive. I’m sorry you got such a lousy genetic inheritance, but you are doing well.
Look up online “spoon theory fatigue” and you’ll get a great way to explain your fatigue to others!
loading....
Yes! The spoon theory! My daughter nearly died from a rare neurological disease at age 19. One of the residual effects is unpredictable, serious fatigue. Trying to explain to others why some days she manages OK and other days she needs two naps just to function is very challenging. The spoon theory is a good way of doing it.
The author says “the reason I’m willing to take the risk of paying only for skimpy health care coverage is that I have such a strong health record.” I hope her winning streak continues. But s–t happens. My daughter never expected to be struck down. Shortly before her illness she walked eight miles on a whim, after a full day of classes. A week later she was on life support. Health is a blessing, and it can disappear without warning.
loading....
I thought people in this community would be interested in today’s XKCD. It’s a diagram of all the money in the us economy showing how much things cost, who makes what, and where it all goes.
http://xkcd.com/980/huge/#x=-6432&y=-5552&z=2
loading....
I totally agree with the advice to stay as active as possible; it’s good for the whole body, including the brain.
But I also agree with those who said not to be judgmental about others’ physical condition. People might have disabilities or pain that make exercise very difficult, or they have bad luck and develop medical conditions at a young-ish age. I can’t run, for instance. Even walking can be painful, but I do it, as well as hiking (slowly) and other physical stuff like yoga and weight training. You wouldn’t be able to tell how bad my feet are just by a casual look at me.
We should all strive for health within our capabilities.
loading....
JCC, you rock!
Great comment. (I miss the “like” button!)
loading....
This is all good stuff. I did not take her tone as condescending, but rather a point of just taking care of yourself. In general the folks who come into the pharmacy for type-2 diabetes medicines are not in shape. They have allowed themselves to drift into a state of being more susceptible to diseases that are more prevalent in the overweight. I can guarentee you that they spend much more on copays and healthcare than an individual who stays active. You can’t concentrate on medical costs due to accidents. That is why they are called accidents. Type-2 diabetes is not an accident. It is a lifestyle disease.
Keep moving like Louisa suggests. You will feel better for it.
loading....
I agree about the people who come into the pharmacy for Type 2 Diabetes meds, they’re not in the best shape. But, they’re doing well compared to the ones who DRIVE through for the same meds! Every little bit helps, people! Literally, walking in instead of driving through for all your errands could help you get off one of those blood pressure medications. Walking: it’s cheaper & safer than popping a pill.
loading....
Judgmental much? There are a variety of underlying conditions that are invisible to the casual observer. There are also a variety of infectious agents and genetic conditions that affect all sorts of body systems. Try just having some compassion and stop sneering at people who don’t meet your personal critera for looking healthy enough.
Remember: our bodies are DESIGNED to die. All the magical thinking and contempt for people in the world won’t stop it.
loading....
Type II diabetes is not entirely a “lifestyle” disease. The slogan is the 3 f’s: fat, family, and forty. In other words, obesity, genetics, and aging. An individual only has control over one of those.
loading....
I agree that taking care of your health is an important investment, both in terms of money and quality of life.
I did get annoyed by the tone in the post, though I imagine it was unintentional. Someone who hasn’t had a cold in 10 years is just plain lucky! (says the vegetarian marathon-runner, who drinks green tea, washes hands religiously, and sleeps 8 hours every night… and gets two colds per year and every strain of the flu)
loading....
Sorry Louisa, but fitness is not going to do a thing about autoimmune diseases, prostate issues, and a whole host of other ills that come with age and/or genetics.
That’s not to downplay the importance of fitness, but to point out that fitness is no panacea. It’s an adjunct.
loading....
Thank you all for your comments. I’m glad my post has encouraged some, and for those who were put off by my tone, thank you for helping me reflect on how to write about an area I love without annoying people– not my goal! I think one oversight I made was lumping together a list of syndromes / illnesses, implying they’re all the same, and caused and resolved by the same factors. It’s far more nuanced and complex than that, as for example Vivian’s comment that due to her autoimmune disease, exercise makes her crash.
loading....
A little humility and gratitude for the lucky genes you got will go a long ways. The trouble is, so much of what we think we know just isn’t so! This goes in spades for what constitutes a “healthy diet” or “healthy lifestyle.” Almost all of the studies are based on correlation; oddly enough, someone who is underlyingly healthy has enough energy to cook from scratch, exercise vigorously, and do all the other things that we have chosen to define as “healthy lifestyle.”
Louisa, I’m sure some of the comments were painful for you to read. I am a writer too, and to learn that what we meant to say is not what was read hurts! However, before you do any more writing in this area I strongly suggest that you learn some basic science — biology, physiology, and what constitutes a valid scientific study. This should take a few years, but then you will be in a much better position to write things that are medically and scientifically valid, rather than parroting the ignorance of the many.
loading....
wow. look who’s talking about humility.
loading....
If you don’t know the science, don’t spread the BS. I have the credentials. Do you?
loading....
Instead of spending “a few years” she could just do a little research. Especially on a topic where there are very strong but very contradicting opinions – and there usually are with health-related topics – it may be helpful to get some basic info and talk to experts on both sides of opinion, but to suggest that someone spend “a few years” to write an article about the benefits of healthy living is ridiculous.
Surely nobody reads an article on a basic topic – such as the investment of health – and expects every aspect of health to be covered.
I have seen cancer and other diseases destroy health people, but I still see much benefit in having a healthy lifestyle. I enjoyed the article.
loading....
My point is, if you don’t understand the basic science, medicine and what constitutes a well-designed study, then you have no idea whatsoever if any “expert” has any idea what they are talking about. And generally, few if any “experts” on “healthy living” could tell a good, legitimate study that is not being given an unjustified conclusion if the lives of themselves AND their families depended on it. And no, physicians have no scientific training, so don’t expect them to be reliable sources unless they also have a Ph.D. from a highly reputable school.
Lacking that, you are still going to be spreading BS. So no, please don’t “just do a little research” and go to quacks to hear them pontificate on further ignorance.
On the other hand, if spreading ignorance and causing health bigotry doesn’t bother you, and if you don’t actually care about your professional reputation, do it your way! I’m sure lots of people will believe you — like you believe such totally unjustified claims. There shouldn’t be too many people hurt…maybe.
You clearly have no understanding of the sciences, medicine or well-designed studies yourself, or you wouldn’t be so gullible.
loading....
I am not sure if you are referring to anyone in particular, but actually I do have the background, the research experience, understanding of statistics, knowledge of controlled studies, and other scientific “chops”. Please provide studies to demonstrate what you feel is a good study, rather than telling people that what they are doing is spreading BS. And define “good study.” Also, since you state you have the experience and background, then you will understand that while correlation is not necessarily causation, correlation CAN be causation. A correlation can be a first step in determining the cause.
Further, “good genes” is a not a strong argument. Much of our health is based on dietary intake, activity levels, environment (are we next to a chemical factory, etc) as well as age and past history. Even with diseases that we know are genetically based (about 10% of all breast cancers), the genetic mutant can be found in far more people than those that will ever manifest the disease. This is why many researchers still do not recommend radical treatments, like preventative mastectomies. Additionally, many other supposedly genetically related conditions are based on a cascade of events(multiple mutations must occur before onset of the disease).
So please, it would be a far more enlightening discussion if you would keep your “BS” to yourself and, instead, actually discuss and outline the weaknesses of the arguments you are attacking.
loading....
Yeah! Someone who does understand some science! A good study is designed with the null hypothesis, not with a pre-determined conclusion. This prevents the “first draw the curve, then pick the points” approach to fraud — er, research. It does not overreach, concluding things that cannot be supported by the data. It has a properly chosen control group. It is not based on what people think they remember eating for the past 20 years, or even the past week. It has sufficient subjects that there is some potential meaning. It can be replicated. It actually looks to see what underlying mechanisms can explain the correlation, and which might actually dig down to what is happening.
In terms of diet studies, there are very, very few that are actually studies that generate potentially useful results. The Framingham and Nurse’s studies are about the only two that have the number of subjects or the duration. What they don’t have is a reliable information base. The bucket studies, where what you eat is also put into a container for chemical analysis, and captive in-patient studies involve people who are imprisoned in the facility for dietary monitoring, are the only times when researchers actually KNOW what people are eating. Every other diet study is suspect on those grounds. And as Dr. House says, people lie!
Another issue is the correlation is not the same as causation, as you well know. It is never causation. Yes, indeed, correlation is sometimes related to causation. We figured out the whole relationship of tobacco smoking and lung cancer that way. However, researchers did dig deeper, find molecular mechanisms, run animal studies, etc. to find the actual causation. Which chemicals and radioactive elements in the tobacco smoke actually cause the lung cancer have been identified. That is most emphatically NOT happening with diet and exercise and health studies.
The bottom line for me: our life expectancy is getting longer, not shorter. So I am skeptical that tinier and ever more minute exposures to evil “chemicals” that have been used for decades are “killing people.” (BPA is the evil chemical for today.)Sadly, more and more people who know no science are being goaded into spending more and more money to avoid infinitesimal “risks” to their children.
The biggest issue, for me, is the utter ignorance we as human beings have about how our bodies work. We see a lot of correlation. We generally don’t bother to look for causation. My husband has chronic fatigue syndrome. On the bright side, at least some medical practitioners “believe” in it now. Maybe they figured that there really can’t be that many people who don’t know each other all telling the same set of lies while producing “normal” lab results. What causes this set of symptoms? Nobody really knows. And few can be bothered to really look. What infectious organisms might be involved? Who knows? If they don’t grow on blood agar or some other standard medium, they don’t exist as far as our medical industry is concerned.
“Normal values” for blood tests are not the same thing as “optimal values” for individuals. We have no good way to measure how well our mitochondria are working, what may have gone wrong and how to fix it. So people like me, my husband, and many others whose biochemistry has gone haywire are given the brush-off by the people who should be interested in finding out why we are malfunctioning and what to do to fix it. Where does the arthritis pain come from? Why does getting tight control on blood sugar levels for diabetics NOT lead to longer lives? Why does getting cholesterol levels down NOT lead to longer lives? But if you get them down too much, the result is shorter life expectancy. Who knows? Nobody is really looking, either.
We just don’t know. There is room for a lot more research, which simply isn’t happening. What is happening is that those who have the misfortune to have a malfunctioning body that leads to overweight or “obesity” (which has been defined ever lower without any good scientific or medical reason) or exercise intolerance or fatigue end up getting blamed by people who don’t even know how much they don’t know for their poor health.
I can’t think of a scenario much more likely to lead to blaming victims and continued ignorance.
loading....
I just want to say that actually, a lot of medical schools DO provide scientific training. I am a M.D., and learning to evaluate research studies was a significant part of our program. I graduated last spring.
However, there is no doubt that certain doctors manipulate data or choose to present it in a way that supports their own views.
loading....
That is great news, Sara. When we were in grad school with med school friends, the training was extremely sketchy. I hope your training is in depth; sadly, the training of many of your seniors was nonexistent.
loading....
Pardon me, but the writer clearly stated this was her own perspective. This is not an medical/health related publication, it is a blog on personal finance. She also noted she was not sure if her health was due to genetics or healthy living. Your comment that she needed to study for years before writing about HER OWN EXPERIENCES was uncalled for.
loading....
Thanks for challenging us too
You motivated me to go out for a walk after work — despite the dark and the cold!
loading....
Wow, I really enjoyed this post, Louisa. I never thought of investing your time to improve your health. I was always like your friends that invest their money into all these pills that only helped me to spend more money! Thanks you for your encouragement!
loading....
I was laid off at almost 56 and was unable to find work in my industry, which contracted severely between 2001 and 2010. I was unable to afford health insurance and faced the possibility of losing my house as well.
One of the mainstays in keeping me healthy and sane was my YMCA card, which I was able to afford only because I qualified for a scholarship. But I used it a lot, and I worked out hard. And although things are better now, I still work out hard because I enjoy it and because I have no doubt that the old saying “use it or lose it is true.”
loading....
Very thought inspiring article and comments.
I have seen both sides of this argument–is it nature or lifestyle choice? The answer is…no one knows for sure. Coming from the “crap gene pool” myself where my risk factors for breast cancer put me over 100%, I have to say that the only chance I have is to exercise and eat right. My goal is to do 5 things per day to fight cancer. Weird, but I have to have some tracking mechanism that is simple but effective.
Like many of the folks that have commented, I know people who are morbidly obese and have a smorgasbord of health issues and they blame EVERYTHING but their own lifestyles. Then I’ve seen the folks who smoke like chimneys, eat fried food and processed food almost exclusively and stay healthy. It’s crazy. Vegan yoga instructors really can die from cancer.
Hedge your bet–eat right and exercise. I’m not riding a Huffy for 350 miles, but I’m doing my best!
loading....
I do believe that fitness and exercise are things that we all must do. Personally, I do spinning, yoga, Pilates, running, cycling, snowshoeing, hiking and swimming on a regular basis. I also eat pretty healthy, have “regular” blood pressure and a decent heart rate. I’m a tad overweight (about 15 lbs), but I’m working that down. I’ve been exercising pretty extensively since 2001.
I went into the ER with a kidney stone this year. It came out of the blue with absolutely no warning. Some of the people I see at the gym regularly have developed odd ailments for no reason at all.
So while I do think people could do a lot better exercising and eating right, it’s not an ironclad guarantee of good health. It might you have lower life insurance bills or qualify for less expensive health care, but you should still get both life insurance and health insurance. There have been plenty of “healthy” people who expired because of some congenital defects they never, ever knew about.
loading....
I have so little energy and am in pain all the time due to autoimmune thyroid disease and a surgery last year I never really recovered from. I’m 35 and it is already a challenge to get through the day, I can’t imagine what it’s like to be old old! I have spent 1000′s of $ on chiropractic, acupuncture, massage, organic food and ordering my own lab tests since doctors don’t have any answers for me. I am basically hell bent on getting better but it’s an uphill battle for sure. My hope is that I fix myself so that I can be like Louisa in my 60′s.
Just like nobody cares more about your money than you, it is even more true for your health!!!
loading....
Wow, a whole bunch of very defensive commentors on here! Feeling some guilty about your lack of exercise and the extra calories you eat every day?
I think the post was fabulous, and there was nothing wrong with the tone. Do you people even read the things you complain about?? Louisa mentioned repeatedly that exercise doesn’t guarantee good health. She merely says it increases the odds of good health, which is scientifically proven. She also has plenty of other caveats about how individual this is.
Louisa is an inspiration. I wish I were more like her. America would be an infinitely happier place, mentally and physically (and environmentally) if everyone lived a little more like she describes. I hate that I sometimes do things that I know are slowly killing myself, like not exercising or eating processed foods or too much food.
It sounds like Louisa has an incredibly healthy lifestyle nailed down, and people should focus on learning from her and being inspired rather than being defensive or pointing out all of the ways the post doesn’t apply to them.
loading....
“Feeling some guilty about your lack of exercise and the extra calories you eat every day?”
No.
I can’t speak for the others, but my original comment doesn’t stem from my feelings about my lifestyle habits. I’m trained in language, research and analysis so sometimes I pick up on different things than other people do. Doesn’t make me any better or worse, just a different point of view is all.
And I apologize for being blunt, but it’s that kind of attitude I think a lot of people are protesting — that because there is something wrong with us, we must have done something (or are doing something) to deserve it. Environment and genetics can play a bigger role in some conditions than lifestyle choices.
I’m not as active as Louisa because I’m not as healthy as Louisa, not the other way around. She’s right — health is a big business, but a lot of the spending comes from people who are being proactive about their health not just people reacting to a condition. I think she’s an inspiration and I enjoyed her tips, but some of us wanted to present another side to the issue too.
loading....
I think exercise can help a variety of ills, but the thing is, we’ll never know if it prevented anything. My guess is that it would fend off alot of things such as obesity, heart disease,aging,etc… I work out as much as possible.
Being a Type 1 diabetic for 33 years and counting, it doesn’t cure me. But mentally, it makes me feel better. It has the ability to raise my sugar substantially as well, but my doctor says that is common. Go figure. I have other medical problems that require meds and vitamins but doc feels I’m doing pretty good overall.
If you are healthy, you have more riches than most people since it allows you to do more and work more. I would take great health over material things any day. I try my best and feel that exercise really is one of the best cures out there.
loading....
Enjoyed the article…thank you Louisa. Those of us the same age as you know you speak the truth. Overall statistics will back you up even if the odd health nut dies early. I read something the other day that was interesting. A gene has been discovered in some that tends to make those people die early of a heart attack. It has been found in several studies in different parts of the world, that a person who has that gene but eats several fruits and vegetables a day, is healthier and now has the same chance of dying early as the general population.
loading....
I too believe having a healthy lifestyle helps you somehow in your old age assuming you will not have any “major accident or disease”…I’ve been living a few years now here in Japan and everywhere you look old folks in there 60′s even 80′s are still biking…also last year I participated in Japan’s annual Mountain Climbing festival where Japanese gave their respect to their mountains by climbing and I was so surprise that many participants were 60 years old and up , they all not only made it to the top some even reached the four-hour climb summit in less than three hours especially my 75 yr. old Japanese Boss and his friends. I believe years of Healthy lifestyle contributed a lot in their stamina to still climb mountains.
loading....
I had to swallow hard too when I read this article. I see people with good genetics over and over place their good health on lifestyle. My two grandmothers had very different approaches to life. One ate a healthy diet, exercised (yoga and basketball were her favorites), was rarely sick and had a great outlook on life. When she was in her eighties she got sick from a virus and never recovered. My other grandmother drank like a fish, was overweight, had high blood pressure and was a mean gossip. She was given 3 months to live after diagnosed with cancer. She not only lived for 4 more years she was never weakens by chemo and never got a cold or flu!
loading....
I found the responses a little disheartening. Anecdotal evidence can be used to make the assumption that it’s all good genes. But the focus should be overall trends, not one or two people that were obese, smoked, drank and lived to 100.
I also have a mixed bag of genes. Paternal side of the family dies before 70, usually in their late 50s. Maternal side dies in 80s, 90s and 100s. But if you look closely at each side, you see that overall, longevity is based on eating, activity and overall outlook. Those that die young in the maternal line tend to live less active lives and eat more meat, sugar and fat. Those in the paternal line that outlive the average tend to be more active, smoke less, etc. Research also demonstrates that even if certain health issues plague a family, these can be ameliorated by overall healthy habits.
Yes, I can point to my aunt who lived into her 80′s and smoked 2 packs a day and probably never ate a vegetable. That is one person out of about 7 in my family that died of emphysema at a much younger age (youngest was 36, oldest before my aunt at 57). Therefore, 86% died before the average life expectancy even though they all carried many of the same genes (three being her siblings).
While we will all die of something, if you look at the current leading causes of death, many of them are preventable. Heart disease is only modestly genetically related. Only certain types of cancer are genetically related. Even those cancers that are genetically related, it will only be a specific form (certain types of breast cancer). There are exceptions. Autoimmune disorders are a combination of genetic and so widely variable, that any one autoimmune disease is likely caused by variations in multiple genes.
To broadly brush this person as basically lucky to have good genes ignores the research evidence to prove that so many things ARE preventable through diet and exercise. While I do not want to see a medical community to become accusatory when people do develop certain diseases, neither do I want us to throw up our hands in defeat. I could play victim while continuing the eating style (southern to the bone and crave anything deep fried on a daily basis)I grew up with while driving the three blocks to the grocery store. Or I could, like everyone here does on a daily basis with wealth accumulation, decide that there are certain things in this world that I can control. I can control what goes in my mouth, I can control how much I move each day and I can control how much money I spend.
I really hope that this did not sound patronizing or hyper-critical. But I have spent years with cousins and siblings that continually eat at McDonalds, are grossly obese, have Type II diabetes amongst a myriad of other ailments and lament their bad fortune. These same people look at me and talk about my “good” genes, even though I was on the same path not 2 years ago when I gave up fast food, dropped almost 100 lbs, made exercise a part of my daily life and made the conscious decision to stop eating certain foods (basically almost anything processed). That was the hardest thing I have ever done. Food choices cause certain neurological changes, so you are not simply fighting habit, you are fighting real connections. So I suppose I am a little sensitive to this issue.
loading....
Good points
What gets me is that we can carry genes for a variety of things — like a tendency towards autoimmune disorders — and never develop the disease, or we develop it later in life. Experts are just beginning to understand what turns genes “on” and “off”.
I figure healthy lifestyle habits are good for me no matter what. If they can keep the bad genes at bay, all the better!
loading....
The amount of health savings cost I get by working out 4-5 days a week is probably negated by my gym dues of $53 a month, but for me I don’t care. Being in good shape is so personally satisfying to me that it is worth the investment in gym, work out clothes, and new running shoes twice a year. Any long term health benefit is secondary to the present beenfit it imparts. Finishing a 10 mile run drenched in sweat is heaven.
loading....
I was very surprised at the tone of the responses as well. I didn’t feel like the author was trying to negate the part genetics play in health but advocating increased physical activity.
My father was recently diagnosed with Acute Myeloid Leukemia, a very aggressive form of cancer. Typically, it manifests as a cold, sinus infection, etc that doesn’t go away. My father had a ‘sinus infection’ for 6 weeks before finally heading to the doctor.
No one in our family has ever had cancer, so this was a shock. The doctors credit my father’s active lifestyle (he walked everywhere, ate well & was a healthy weight) as one of the primary reasons he was able to tolerate the chemo better than average & endured the 4 week hospital stay with minimal side effects. He was even known as the ‘Healthiest Patient on the Leukemia Floor’.
You cannot mitigate the role an active lifestyle plays, with our without good genes.
loading....
As an university student I have always valued the higher prices of quality food not only for their taste but for the benefit of better health.
Healthy eating has been the best investment in my life, even when I cut back on other things. I am not talking about eating high class, but rather fruits and vegetables in fresh form, meat when available and affordable, and as many fish as I can get my hands on.
This diet has helped me even when I have been lacking in sleep, studying too much, etc. I look forward to everything it will do for me in the future. I hope to write a post about this more niche topic of investing in your food and health in my blog. Thanks for the inspiration.
loading....
And it will be yet another piece of supposition, correlation, lousy studies, etc.
Just what we all need!
loading....