For the next week (or two), we’ll be sharing “audition” pieces from folks interested in being new staff writers at Get Rich Slowly. Your job is to let us know what you think of each of these writers. Pay attention, give feedback, and after a couple of weeks we’ll ask which writers you prefer. This article is from Will Crosswell, who says he’s a young guy who’s made some dumb moves financially. But he wants to learn.
Dr. Moshe A. Milevsky, author of Your Money Milestones and tenured finance professor at the Schulich School of Business at York University in Toronto, Canada, had his class perform an exercise at the beginning of his twelve-week undergraduate course on the topic of wealth management. He asked his students to prepare their own personal balance sheet.
As he admits in his book, the financial status of a twenty-something looks much different from somebody in her thirties or forties. Assets are few and far between. And where they exist, they’re minimal. But liabilities include loans, student loans, and even credit card debt.
After the class filled out their personal balance sheets, he asked them to compute their net worth by subtracting their assets from their liabilities. The results were bleak.
He followed the exercise with two questions:
- Do you think your personal balance sheet will look better ten years from now?
- How many of you got a zero or negative number for your net worth on the balance sheet today?
As you can guess, nearly every hand went up in response to these questions. Dr. Milevsky pointed out: “If they were a publicly traded company… they would immediately be deemed insolvent or even bankrupt.” But there’s a “twist.” Milevesky told the students that they did the exercise incorrectly and they answered his questions all wrong. He suggested that they were probably forgetting the most important and most valuable asset they own: themselves. Or, as Milevsky terms it, Human Capital.
Human capital included the students’ careers, with their salary, bonuses, raises, and wages that would accrue over a lifetime. Milevsky compared Human Capital to a gold mine or an oil well: It has immediate value, but it may take years before you see it total in the six to seven figures in terms of cash flow. His main point was this: Human Capital is the most valuable asset class for most people during their working years .
He then asked the class to include the estimated current value of their human capital to create what he called a “holistic personal balance sheet and net worth calculation.” He asked the class to visit the campus alumni office to obtain projected salary figures for graduates.
Below is an example of what a holistic personal balance sheet might look like:
| My Assets | My Liabilities |
|---|---|
| Explicit Financial Capital | -Visible Debt and Liabilities |
| +Implicit Financial Capital | -Estimated Hidden Liabilities |
| +Estimated Human Capital | |
| =Total Capital | = Holistic Net Worth |
After they completed their new balance sheet, students noticed their new outlooks were drastically different than the ones they had originally projected for themselves. They were upbeat and optimistic about their lives in front of them. Their human capital was worth millions and thus made their worth much more valuable. To estimate your own “human capital, visit this human capital calculator: HC Calculator
What this meant for me
About a year ago, I took a position as a Business Development Manager for a credit union in South Carolina. Much of my position currently entails business-to-business relationships. Another part of it is providing financial education and literacy for our clients’ employees. I was a History major in college and a political operative by trade, so my knowledge on the matter when I took the job was minimal at best. Well, the more I researched and read articles and blogs, such as Get Rich Slowly, the more I learned that my financial behavior was in bad, bad shape.
I was borrowing more than what I was earning. A great portion of my pay was directed toward debts, such as loans and credit cards. And I felt that I had dug myself in a hole that I feared I would never get out of. There were some nights when I even felt paralyzed by the thought that I would forever be in debt.
As many people in this country have done, I read a friend’s copy of The Total Money Makeover by Dave Ramsey. While it hasn’t served as the complete outline for my financial recovery, it has served as the catalyst I needed to attack my debt and increase my net worth.
As many of you have done, I’m sure, I separated my assets and liabilities and had to catch my breath once I saw just how much (or how little) my net worth was. According to that basic personal balance sheet, I felt I was worth nothing. No. Nothing would have been a great place to start. I was worth less than nothing. Besides the determined motivation and an outline to tackle my debt, it was a pretty harrowing place to begin. But once I looked at Dr. Milevsky’s “human capital” exercise, I saw that not only would I get out of this financial pit, but I’d be acquiring assets for years and years to come that would benefit myself and my future family.
The bottom line is self worth can overcome your net worth. Once I saw my projected salary and income, I felt as if my fears were melting away. My human capital gave me that extra push to proclaim and now believe, “I will get out of debt. I will have security for my family and loved ones.” And perhaps more importantly, “I’m going to be okay.”
As in any exercise, there are variables that can affect one’s human capital (i.e. layoffs, getting fired, family tragedy, etc.), but the main point is that you are worth more than your debt. Yes, that mountain of liabilities can be pretty daunting, but knowing that you have the tools and the self confidence to succeed, you have your X-factor to achieve financial freedom and security.
Quotes and excerpts were taken from Dr. Mose A. Miilevsky’s Your Money Milestones: A Guide To Making The 9 Most Important Financial Decisions Of Your Life. You can find it on Amazon “used” for $2.57 or check it out at your local library (like I did!).
GRS is committed to helping our readers save and achieve your financial goals.Savings interest rates may be low, but that’s all the more reason to shop for the best rate.Find the highest savings interest rate from Ally Bank, Capital One 360, Everbank, and more.
This article is about Career, Odds and Ends
Disclaimer: This content is not provided or commissioned by American Express. Opinions expressed here are author's alone, not those of American Express, and have not been reviewed, approved or otherwise endorsed by American Express. This site may be compensated through American Express Affiliate Program.
Discover is a paid advertiser of this site. Reasonable efforts are made to maintain accurate information. See the Discover online credit card application for full terms and conditions on offers and rewards.
SEARCH FOR RECENT ARTICLES



Human capital is incredibly valuable as long as it is kept efficient and engaged. By the way, great book ‘Your Money Milestones’.
loading....
I think so too! Thanks for the comment!
loading....
Wow Will. Great tackle of a topic! I was just having this conversation with my BF about HC and disability insurance and the boondoggle in purchasing it or not. It’s always easier to spell it out with examples of “the car will pay for itself in X years or the star rated appliance will pay for itself in X years.” People get that but they forget about their own X years. Four million votes for a smart writer such as yourself!
loading....
I really liked this article. I’m bummed it’s a late-afternoon showing so it’s not going to be able to garner as many comments as if it had been posted in the morning (since comments are apparently what’s important).
Perhaps a little woo-woo near the end, but there’s a promise of lessons learned and more substantive information in the future. I thought the concept of human capital and how general it can really be was clearly explained, and it is not a simple concept. Human capital is not just your wage earnings, it’s also everything that you do that produces value.
loading....
The link to HC Calculator is broken. Otherwise a very good article that would have benefited from some tough love editing.
loading....
Here’s the link –
http://www.qwema.ca/calc/humancapital.aspx
loading....
I’m not sure I understand the concept fully, are we just adding in the remaining lifetime expected income into holistic net worth? Or are we now including remaining lifetime expenditures?
Is this an effort to predict future net worth or to measure a fair market value of abilities? Does this factor in opportunity costs or inflation? Or is it just a motivational tool to keep from getting discouraged?
loading....
I’d agree, that if you want to include your future ‘human capital’ you need to include your future expenditures related to that human capital’s upkeep if you want a net worth calculation. At a minimum food+healthcare expenses should be taken into account. So it’s not all upside.
It’s like having a rental property and saying that you’ll collect rent for it forever, while ignoring having to pay for expenses like improvement and repairs.
loading....
I think that it refers specifically to your profit producing ability – your “human capital” isn’t just the amount of wages you bring in, but the amount of benefit your employer gets from your work, too. Your cost of housing is essentially an operational cost like paying taxes, but your pre-tax income is still what it is.
loading....
Interesting idea, although I’m curious how optimistic the students were in calculating their human capital. When I calculate my net worth, I like that it’s black and white (I exclude things like cars and houses in my calculation). Human capital sounds like a nice idea, but it seems to dependent a lot on things (having kids, taking time off for a family emergency, or losing my job) that are hard to predict.
loading....
loved this article bc it’s completely different than what i’ve seen on most finance blogs. great job!
loading....
Calculating your human capital is a good way to encourage yourself, especially when working through a difficult financial situation. However, it is just potential, it hasn’t been realized yet. Therefore, I would be very careful with this, because I can see how the concept can be misused and folks take on debt now because they believe in the near future they will be making more money.
Otherwise, I thought this was a decent article, with a different bent.
loading....
THANK YOU! This is one thing that I think is missing from a lot pf blogs or articles. The humanity, the “you” the “me”, the people invovled and what they’re worth, what a life is worth, what your brain power is worth, what your love and caringness is worth… giving to charity might not help out someone a lot financially but it sure increases your human worth. The human capital of going to college is worthwhile as well, great post!
loading....
This is a beautiful article. I don’t really have much to say but I know comments on these audition posts count, and I really like this one.
loading....
Wasn’t there just a study or an article somewhere about how very bad students were at figuring out how much they’d make after schooling?
The idea was that students seemed to have no idea that some of the jobs they were studying/training for would take forever to pay off the loans they were piling up.
This article talked about a professor or teacher who actually had students research starting salaries and average salaries. Students were shocked — in a bad way.
My fear with this exercise is that they have no way really of judging their HC — if anything, at that age, it’s likely to be greatly overinflated. Letting them wander off increasing their debts because they’ve got a lifetime of “HC” ahead of them seems…cart before the horse?
loading....
Aw, really nice article.
loading....
Of course you should not let your self esteem get to be so low that it is getting in the way of finding a solution. But for the rest this calculating your Human Capitol to me just seems a way of fooling yourself into staying in debt. Of course you will be allright… when you do something about your debt. But when you calculate in your Human Capital, you are mortgaging your future free will.
Wouldn’t it be even better for your self-esteem just to accept your situation, not beat yourself up about it, and start doing something about it?
loading....
Using your HC is doing something about it.
That’s the point.
loading....
This is the first of all the audition articles that has really grabbed me. I really like the writing style & tone. I get the feeling that there would be lots more good stuff to come.
loading....
The problem is how the author felt when looking at their networth the first time. If using human capital helps someone feel better about their future, then fine. But there is a fine line between feeling better about the future and feeling so much better that you’re okay with spending money before you earn it. That’s the trap to avoid.
loading....
Of all the potential new staffers, this is the one I have enjoyed the most. It brings us someone at or near the beginning of their financial turn around, which is a nice counter balance to the majority of the current staffers. Plus, I appreciated the tone and style of the writing.
loading....
Agreed! Good balance of quality writing, beginning a debt reduction journey (including student loans), delivering new information/resources (please fix the human capital calculator link!) and an interesting new perspective and tone. This guy has my vote so far.
loading....
“…the main point is that you are worth more than your debt”. What a refreshing observation. I loved the optimistic tone and perspective of this piece. Well written – one of my favs for its original contribution. Every now and then, we need motivation & not just info or train wrecks.
loading....
Great article Will. Shout out from a fellow CU alumni (econ major) & SC resident.
loading....
I wanted to wait and see what the feedback would be before I responded, but I thank each and every one of you for your words of support and criticism. It’s been very helpful and insightful.
Since this one point has been brought up a bit by a few commenters, I wanted to address it and give my response. I need to point out that the human capital itemin Dr. Moshe A. Milevsky’s book was discussed in his first chapter. I feel he began the book with discussing human capital to take readers to the “top of the mountain” before having to discuss items and tasks that the reader is more than likely not doing but needs to do. As many of you know and have pointed out, there are numerous things to consider and factor in when discussing finances and human capital is one of them.
My journey to financial freedom didn’t stop after reading his first chapter about “human capital.” Like BrentABQ pointed out:
“Wouldn’t it be even better for your self-esteem just to accept your situation, not beat yourself up about it, and start doing something about it”
And I fully agree with him. If I stopped after Chapter 1, kept making minimum payments on debts, and continued my financial behavior, then I have done myself an incredible disservice and have crippled myself further. So, I have proceeded to “start doing something about it” and gathered more information.
And like I pointed out at the end, there are numerous variables when calculating human capital, like expenses and life events. One of those just occurred for me about 2 weeks ago: I got married. After I said, “I do,” I went from a “me” to a “we” in seconds. So, that has added another HUGE factor on my path to financial freedom. And to increase my human capital, I’m taken on side jobs and tasks to increase my income and make bigger payments when it comes to my debt.
This has been great to get such a wide range of feedback. But just to clarify again, I didn’t stop after reading Chapter 1 (which I didn’t point out in my article, my mistake), but I have continued reading, learning, and more importantly, taken action to get myself (and now my family) financially secure and prepared. And now I know my “potential” for financial freedom is greater now than before.
Thanks so much again!
loading....
User Hanne (#15) said that, not me…
loading....
My mistake BrentABQ. I apologize. I was trying to write quickly and didn’t double check.
Thanks for reading and commenting.
loading....
I think the younger you are the better this article is. It is a little more depressing if you are older.
)
loading....
Great article! I was just thinking about the value of earning potential and human capital the other day
loading....
I like the writing style and the overall feel of the writer, but I’m not excited about this article.
As someone who took “good” advice to buy a house 5 years ago:
Because: “You’re building equity and not throwing that money away on rent”,
Because: “I’ll be getting raises the longer I stay at the company, so my earnings will just keep getting better.”
And we made considerable extra payments every month except for two…
Fast forward to a year ago, when the company started letting people go, including my husband’s boss, and it was time to get the hell outta Dodge before he got thrown out. We’re trying to sell the house because we had to move 425 miles to get another job, and despite the equity because of the extra principal payments I made, we’re gonna have to pay thousands to get rid of it. We are maintaining an apartment and a house with extra taxes because it’s not our primary residence anymore.
So (the rent vs. buy debate aside–you live and you learn I guess?), because of my own experiences, I think instead of banking on Human Capital and assuming that your future self will have more earning power than your present self, it would be more prudent to not take on debt if you can help it, work your butt off right now to pay down debt you have and save like crazy, and learn as many skills as you can so that you can be prepared for things like tanking housing markets, crappy job markets, an unexpected disability, etc…
Basically, don’t count on Human Capital, because you might not have it. You’re only worth that much money if someone is willing to pay that much for you, just like our house is only worth that much if a buyer thinks it’s worth that much.
So yeah, I’d like to read more articles by Will because I like his style, but I don’t necessarily agree with this article.
loading....
This article plots a course into the heart of a black hole. Value income you don’t have yet. Buy on credit and pay back later. The future will be better than now, so go ahead and splurge. You have “human capital” so don’t worry about debt.
I realize the author’s point but reject it. Just like Warren Buffett uses book value to assess his performance, we should use real money to analyze our situation.
loading....
A great article! As we’re so often told, money management isn’t just a numbers game, it’s a head game – that’s where the whole debt snowball comes from. It is important to realize that we have resources to allocate – that we are worth *something*. Thanks for sharing!
loading....
This is a GREAT article! Keep these coming.
loading....