8 reasons you should throw away your cash-back credit card if you love to travel
Published on - January 26th, 2013 (by Ellen Cannon) This reader post is from Hilary Stockton, who is the founder of TravelSort, which helps savvy travelers earn millions of miles without flying, redeem them for first-class flights, and stay in luxury hotels at wholesale prices. Follow her on Twitter @TravelSort.
My husband and I used to think we were savvy, using a cash-back credit card for most of our spending. But given how much we enjoy international and luxury travel, it was actually a huge mistake. We now strategically apply for travel credit cards that offer attractive sign-up bonuses and we direct our spending to the credit cards that offer the best category bonuses for the type of purchase we’re making. Here’s why:
1. Travel first class or business class internationally
Thanks to four credit card applications, we were able to book two first-class round-trip award tickets on Cathay Pacific to Bali, via Hong Kong, for this past summer. These tickets retail for more than $20,000 each, which we would never pay cash for, but the experience was fantastic and was a memorable part of our vacation. And because we know how to use credit cards to our advantage, this isn’t just a once-in-a-lifetime experience—we plan to travel first class or business class internationally at least once a year, with the miles and points we’re earning. And thanks to using miles and points for award flights, we’re able to use our trip budget for some incredible hotels, restaurants, and unique local experiences that otherwise would have been a stretch to afford, if we had to pay for airfare.
2. Fly great airlines: Lufthansa, Cathay Pacific, Singapore Airlines, Qatar and others
If we were talking about domestic first class or even first or business class internationally on most American carriers, it would be hard to get too excited. But the great thing about the United Airlines and American Airlines miles and points you earn is that they can be redeemed on Star Alliance and oneworld airline partners, respectively, such as Lufthansa, Singapore Airlines, Asiana and others in Star Alliance, and Cathay Pacific, Qatar, Etihad and others in oneworld. These are among the very best airlines in the world, with seats or suites, dining and service to match. Your credit card miles and points can get you access to award seats that let you travel for just the cost of taxes.
3. Be better rested at the start and end of your trip
Flying in a cramped coach seat on a long-haul flight isn’t the most restful or relaxing way to start or end a vacation. Picture instead having your seat turned down into a flat bed more than 6 feet long, with a comfy duvet and complimentary pajamas, so that you can stretch out and sleep en route. By arriving more rested, you’ll lose less of your vacation being sore and sleep deprived. Similarly, when it’s time to fly home and return to work, you’ll actually be able to look forward to the flight and either start to productively get caught up on work, or nap so that you arrive refreshed.
4. Enjoy free nights in 5-star hotels
I won’t lie—you won’t be getting free nights at the Four Seasons or Mandarin Oriental anytime soon with miles and points, at least not at a redemption value I’d recommend. But you can use hotel credit cards to get two nights at a top Park Hyatt worth $800 or more a night, a night at the Ritz-Carlton, and nights at the best Conrad and Radisson properties worldwide.
5. Enjoy elite status perks with airlines and hotels
Ever wish you were an elite frequent flier so you could enjoy the airport lounge, get priority boarding and avoid checked baggage fees? Or that at hotels you could get room upgrades, free Internet and late checkout? You can, with the right airline and hotel credit cards.
6. Get free one-way award flights
Did you know that you can build in a free or cheap one-way award flight across the country or to Hawaii using American or United miles? With a paid ticket, you would, of course, pay for that transcontinental or Hawaii flight, but if for example you’ve earned United miles with a credit card, you can use a United free one-way to maximize your award.
7. Avoid foreign transaction fees
Most cash back cards carry foreign transaction fees, which you don’t want if you’re traveling internationally, or you’re buying something from a foreign seller such that the transaction gets processed in another country. Even better are the credit cards that provide points bonuses for spend on hotels, restaurants, or other travel expenses while also not charging foreign transaction fees.
8. How much are you actually earning with your cash back card?
If you’re like most folks, you’re probably not earning more than a few hundred to $1,000 or so a year with your cash-back credit card. With that same spend, some mileage-earning checking accounts and a few more credit card applications between your spouse or travel partner and you, you could earn 1 million miles and points without flying. And those miles and points will take you a lot farther, and in much greater comfort, than what you would have saved with a cash back card.
Do you have tips for maximizing your travel credit cards?
GRS is committed to helping our readers save and achieve your financial goals.Savings interest rates may be low, but that’s all the more reason to shop for the best rate.Find the highest savings interest rate from Ally Bank, Capital One 360, Everbank, and more.
This article is about Credit Cards, Travel
Disclaimer: This content is not provided or commissioned by American Express. Opinions expressed here are author's alone, not those of American Express, and have not been reviewed, approved or otherwise endorsed by American Express. This site may be compensated through American Express Affiliate Program.
Discover is a paid advertiser of this site. Reasonable efforts are made to maintain accurate information. See the Discover online credit card application for full terms and conditions on offers and rewards.
SEARCH FOR RECENT ARTICLES








We recently did an in depth analysis of travel reward cards (http://everywhereonce.com/2012/05/16/travel-reward-card-smackdown/) and found that the best ones pay less in rewards than the best cash back cards for every day use.
Some caveats: Redeeming rewards for first class travel is a better deal than redeeming them for coach. If you plan on flying first, the reward cards do pay more. But then if your primary goal is to save money, flying coach is always a better deal than flying first class or business. And if your primary goal is travel, you’ll fly more miles and reach more destinations by enduring coach than going with the more comfortable alternatives regardless of how you pay for your flights.
Also, many travel hacking strategies alluded to here don’t require you to use, or even own, a travel reward card. Many just require a frequent flyer number. The big exceptions are the generous signing bonuses awarded for applying for travel reward cards. Even here, you typically only need to put $1,000 on the travel card to get the signing bonus. After that, it still makes sense to switch back to the higher paying cash back cards for every day use.
Oh, and don’t forget to cancel all of those high annual fee cards to avoid paying a bundle for those “free” flights.
loading....
Thanks for your comment. Even for international coach travel, you’ll often come out ahead with the right travel credit card signup and category spend bonuses.
For example, I recently got a an AMEX rewards card that got me 100,000 Membership Rewards points for $3000 spend. If you were able to get 3% cash back for that spend, that would be $90. Instead, the 100,000 points, when transferred to Singapore’s frequent flyer program, get you a roundtrip coach ticket NYC-Singapore that normally is over $1600, or a roundtrip business class ticket NYC to Frankfurt that retails for over $5000. Either way, the highest value use of your credit card spend is meeting signup bonuses on the right travel rewards credit cards if you value international travel.
Actually it’s not always necessary to cancel cards either–it’s often worth seeing if the issuer will give you either an annual fee credit or a retention bonus that offsets the annual fee. That way you get to keep the card open and have it increase your average age of accounts, which helps your credit score. Worst comes to worst, you can usually downgrade to a no annual fee card.
loading....
Yes, of course it’s the sign up bonuses that make it worthwhile, otherwise it’s a pittance.
This last year my spouse and I have flown free to New England, Europe, Florida and the Pacific Northwest. We have had 9 free hotel nights. These were all from sign up bonuses and we have more plans this year.
We don’t pay a nickel in interest and have excellent credit scores.
loading....
I’ve always used a cash back card, but I never considered a travel card. While I was a grad student or a postdoc I never had the money to travel out of the country so I guess it never crossed my mind. But now that I have job that pays enough to satisfy my travel urges this is something I should look into.
loading....
Thanks, hope the post is food for thought. I also used to just use cash back cards, and didn’t really pay attention to the travel rewards cards. But over the course of earning over a million miles and points and booking first and business class international award travel for my family and others, I’ve come to realize the value. The main caveats are that you should only be doing this if you have no high interest debt of any kind, pay your credit card bills off in full, and aren’t about to apply for a mortgage or refinancing. More about that in a future post.
loading....
I don’t like these types of posts. Tells you what you could do, but not how. I’d rater one bullet point with specifics (which cards, how much did they spend on the cards over what period of time, what were the ‘rules’, like did you have to hit spending targets in specific categories, etc), than an 8 bullet point infomercial.
loading....
Thanks for your comment. This was actually intended as an intro to a series of “how to” posts, pending reader interest in understanding more specifics.
loading....
I agree. This is worthless. “Hey! There are ways to spend a ton of money on great travel!”
Was GRS hard up for content today? And I am using the term “content” rather loosely, since this tells us nothing.
loading....
if you click on her link to her website it has a step by step breakdown of how to get up to 1 million points in a year.
loading....
What you’re asking for would be very difficult. The very first thing to do is go to all the airlines, hotels and car rental agencies and sign up for their rewards programs.
Also, a lot of it depends on you; where you live, where you’d like to travel and things like that. If you fly out of Atlanta, you’d want to get a Delta card, if you fly out of Houston, you’d want to get a United card because those airports are hubs for those airlines. If your place of employment requires travel for some employees (maybe not you) find out if they have a preferred airline, if so get that card because you never know if you’ll have to travel. If you like to go to England, look at a British Airways card. Or just see what airline’s flights are usually cheaper out of the airport you like to fly out of.
You may have to do some research on your own to figure out what card is best for you. Hilary doesn’t know you and wont’ be able to tell you exactly what to do but she can point you in the right direction, which she did. Credit cards change constantly so what she puts up today may change tomorrow. Cards have different spending requirements so she can’t list them all for every card. Lots of airlines and hotels have their own credit cards so it would impossible to list them all here.
I traveled for work and met a coworker at a conference. He told me to sign up for everything. I told him I don’t think I’ll be traveling a lot but he said it doesn’t matter and you never know. He had racked up over 2 million miles on AA and flies from LA to London once a year with his wife and always flies at least business.
Also, I’m traveling about 10 times a year now so I got a United card because, after doing research, I found it works best for me.
loading....
I agree with 3 and 4 – this seems to be just an advertisement for her own blog. The article doesn’t give any suggestions on how to achieve what she describes so nicely.
loading....
Geez, get off your butts and do some research. It’s not rocket science. Do you have to be spoon fed the info?
It’s worth a ton of money so stop whining and start with her blog and go from there.
loading....
Evan, I think you miss the point. Yes, of course, I can do my own research, but why would I read GRS then if all it does, is give me pretty pictures of the author’s vacations and no real info. Isn’t that what GRS is supposed to do?
loading....
Wish we had great travel reward cards in Canada!
loading....
I will admit I am now a miles/point junkie. My next trip to Europe next Feb will be almost free airfare and free hotels for 12 nights and the next trip after that will be business class to Asia. If you are really interested in seeing what miles and points can do, you need to explore Flyertalk.com and Milepoint.com and start reading some of the blogs. My favorites are pointsguy.com, frequentmiler.com, frugaltravelguy.com and milevalue.com. Many of the blogs have frequent postings for how to start in the miles and points world.
The biggest thing about miles and points with credit cards is you have to have a good credit score and never ever carry a balance.You also have see value in opening multiple credit cards. I have opened 11 new credit cards in the last year. My credit score did drop slightly but moving from 785 to 770 really does not make a difference. I am not planning on any new loans in the next year.
loading....
I need to get a travel rewards card. Right now we’re working on making our credit perfect though for when we buy our next house in 2014.
loading....
This has nothing to do with increasing net worth, but everything to do with trying to get extreamly expensive and unnessisary things for slightly less (the whole look how much I saved while spending a ton trap). Maybe if you gave some numbers about how much you actually spent (real $s) in a year and how much you got free we could tell if it was worth it. My guess is it is not.
I have looked at a lot of the travel cards as well as the cash ones and agree with the poster about the cash cards being much better return. The caviat here is if you get paid to travel for work, then these programs can be useful. The biggest thing though isn’t to try to maximize spending on your credit card to maximize the number of points etc.. . But to minimize spending to save more $. Getting .01-.05 back on a dolar spent really isn’t worth a whole lot of effort!!!
loading....
My mother-in-law lives in Europe and I live in the US. International travel is a necessity in my house. If you’ve flown coach with an infant AND a toddler, you might think that flying business class is a necessity too! I’m very interested in this post and subsequent how-to for getting free miles.
loading....
Lindsay, I couldn’t agree more, since we travel with a young child as well and have taken him on several long international flights. While some will always be opposed to kids in business and first class, for us it’s worked well, enabling us all to actually sleep on the flight and better ensure he stays well fed, happy, quiet and isn’t disruptive to other passengers. We no longer worry about or dread the flight experience. Look forward to helping you and others interested in earning and using miles and points for travel.
loading....
you know, you can have both cards (some people have 15), but if you don’t have at least one cash back card you aren’t doing it right.
if you are a cash only person and can’t budget yourself with a CC that is one thing. but if not you are just throwing money away.
the idea of a travel card is say you wanted an NYC to LA ticket which is normally $275 but the dates you want it is $350, you can use 25,000 mile and book it. obviously black out dates and other things come into play. or a last minute ticket you can buy for 50,000 miles and would cost $700 cash. it is all relative to how you spend and what your goals are. don’t want to see the rest of the US or the world? then just use a cash back card.
loading....
Thanks for your comment; I agree that if you don’t value international travel at all, a cash back card likely makes more sense.
My family doesn’t use a cash back card at all because we highly value international travel in business and first class, so we get more value out of applying for and putting all our spend on travel rewards cards. We rarely travel domestically, and when we do, a cash ticket (paid for with a card earning 3X points) is usually a better value for us than redeeming points for it. I usually advise my clients to aim for at least 3 cents per mile/point in redemption value for domestic tickets, and of course much higher than that for international premium class tickets.
loading....
I have a card with 0% transaction fees, which is perfect because I spend a lot of time out of the country. Unfortunately there are no travel rewards, european card are rarely as good as US!
loading....
Who wrote this, Ellen Cannon or Hialry Stockton?
loading....
It may be a quirk of web publishing. Many websites are set up so that the name of the person who enters the content into the content management system shows up as the byline. (i.e. “by Ellen Cannon”). Guests don’t have access to the CMS so an editor has to post their articles for them, ergo, Ellen’s name shows up in the byline and then there’s an author byline below.
loading....
I had a CapitalOne “No Hassles” mileage reward card I stopped using in 2009 and it took me 3 years to use the miles at maximum value (1% of the cash spent to accrue them). I’d rather just have the 1% cash.
I can see benefits to points/miles cards if you use the signing bonuses…but I have enough credit cards open…I’m working on increasing my average account age so I don’t want to close them and open new ones.
loading....
Andrew, thanks for your comment. I completely agree with you that the Capital One card isn’t worth it, and mentioned it specifically in my post today as a fixed value award program to avoid, both for the low value of the rewards and because it pulls your credit report from all 3 credit bureaus: http://travelsort.com/blog/how-many-credit-inquiries-or-hard-credit-pulls-is-too-many
What’s much better in my view is to leverage the best transfer opportunities of programs such as Chase Ultimate Rewards (points transfer 1:1 to several airline and hotel programs, with United and Hyatt as the best value uses) and AMEX Membership Rewards, which also transfers 1:1 to several airline and hotel programs, with my favorite being Singapore Airlines.
On the earnings front, you want to ensure you’re getting 2X-5X or more for most spend in a worthwhile program, and not just 1 point per $1.
loading....
Not sure if these are the sort of “specifics” people are looking for, but here’s how we used airline/hotel points, mostly from sign-on bonuses, to plan an around the world trip for my family of four:
http://www.kidsmeetworld.com/2012/08/rtw-with-air-miles-math.html
loading....
I’m glad I ran into this post. I was thinking about signing up for the JetBlue card? I never travelled much but last year I traveled with my rally team to canada, arizona, and california. Then went to 3 weddings and booked flights to miami and orlando! I wonder if it would have been beneficial to have a points card. I get rewards with Jet blue but the card itself would give me a nice bonus… and then points for every dollar! hmmmm
loading....
This really is a question of what you are spending your money on. If you stay at Marriott’s frequently, get a Marriott card and use it when you make reservations. Fly Delta often? Get a Skymiles card and use it when you book your flights. This works because you get a point multiplier when you use the Delta card on the Delta website to buy delta tickets. The same for Marriott and many others. In this situation, the value of the points can be a lot higher than a cashback 2%.
If you don’t actually travel a lot but want to collect travel points, a lot of these cards aren’t worth more than 1 or 2% cashback.
A good travel card option for general spending (not at hotels or on airlines) is the AMEX Starwood preferred card. Depending on how you redeem the points, they can be equivalent to over 3 or even over 4 % cash back, especially if you find a cash+points deal. Booking with points can even keep you from getting burned by foreign exchange rates. Of course, the SPG card has a $65 annual fee and isn’t very good for spending in foreign countries, as it has a foreign transaction fee. Further, you have to be satisfied staying at starwood properties, which aren’t an option at every destination. There is the flexibility to transfer to airline miles, but airline miles are generally not as valuable as starpoints.
Personally, I use the AMEX blue cash card for gas and groceries, amazon card at drugstores and amazon.com and restaurants, and starwood for anything else. It takes me longer to accumulate rewards on any one card, but my overall rewards are maximized. I was thinking about adding in a Discover IT card as well (a good idea if you plan on traveling to Korea, Japan, etc). All of these except the SPG card has no annual fee. Also thinking about adding a Venture Card for no foreign transaction fees.
For me to upgrade to more premium cards e.g. AMEX Gold or add more travel cards I would have to spend substantially more or start traveling a whole lot more.
loading....
Great tips, thanks for posting. All the travel info is really relevant for me right now.
loading....
I think cash back cards (capital one, citi thank you points, amex blue cash, etc) are a good way to cut down the overall cost of travel such as using them for statement credits on train, bus passes, tour tickets, food, etc and other costs that miles cannot be used on. Save the miles/points for use where they are more valuable such as flights and hotels.
loading....
Her’s another potential reason to ged rid of a cashback card. Stating Jan 27 2013 Merchants can start hitting you with a surcharge on credit card transactions. This really applies to all credit cards and just cash back cards. Just thought I’d spread the word. thefindependent.com/beware-of-new-credit-card-surcharges-as-of-january-27-2013/
loading....
I have what is probably a stupid question, but I’m having a hard time understanding the concept of miles as opposed to cash. If you open a card and get bonus miles and then cancel the card, do you keep your bonus miles? Where are they stored? How does the airline know that you have them, when it’s time to book your flight or upgrade your seat?
loading....
Lindsay,
Miles are a fiat currency that the airline or hotel holds for you in an account with your name on it.
You keep the miles, even if you cancel the card.
All airline-specific cards hold the miles with the airline. American Express and Chase both have their own proprietary programs, where the bank itself actually holds the miles for you. But the strength of both programs is that they both have a substantial number of partners where you can transfer your miles to.
loading....
Lindsay, as Dan mentioned, cards that earn specific miles or hotel points keep them in that program, whereas AMEX Membership Rewards and Chase Ultimate Rewards are flexible programs that hold points that you can transfer out to various airline and hotel partners. While airline programs partner with hotels and vice versa, in most cases it’s not worth transferring out due to poor transfer ratios; the main exception is Starwood Preferred Guest, which enables you to transfer to a number of airline programs with a 25% bonus if you transfer in increments of 20,000 points.
I would definitely caution you agains closing a credit card too early, since some cards do have clauses that stipulate that the miles or points can be taken back if you close the card within 6 months or another time frame. So my advice is to keep the card open for at least 9 months before you consider either asking for a retention bonus/fee waiver, downgrading to a no annual fee card or closing the card. If you close it, don’t forget to move your credit line over to another card from the same issuer, since large credit lines help you maintain low utilization of credit, which helps your credit score.
loading....
Good ideas. Foreign transaction fees can actually end up costing you a good amount of money so if you can avoid those (on top of gaining the rest of these perks) it would be beneficial in the long right to throw away your cash-back credit card for travel anyway.
loading....
I’m curious to know about the “mileage-earning checking accounts” mentioned in the last paragraph of the post. What are these?
“With that same spend, some mileage-earning checking accounts and a few more credit card applications between your spouse or travel partner and you …”
loading....
Krishanu, thanks for your question. The mileage account I use is via BankDirect, which enables me to earn American AAdvantage miles. Please see http://travelsort.com/blog/bankdirect-best-way-to-earn-aadvantage-miles-for-half-a-cent-per-mile
loading....
Hilary,
We fly every other year to South Africa and changes to Delta’s Skymiles plan has made it more difficult to earn enough miles for each trip. Unfortunately Delta is nearly the only carrier that offers non-stop service to SA; which is important to us since we fly with young children now. I’m currently waiting on an upgrade offer for the Delta Skymiles card. Is there anything else you can recommend to help us pick up bonus miles/rewards? It looks like most of the nice bonuses are non-Delta. Thanks!
loading....
Jonathan, thanks for your comment. If you need the nonstop Delta flight from ATL, then I’d try to ensure that both your wife and you get a good bonus offer for the Delta Skymiles card. There was a 45K preapproved offer, pls. see the link towards the end of this recent post: http://bit.ly/16F3Q1T As I also mentioned in that post, you could fund a Fidelity brokerage account for up to 50K Delta miles, and the other options are to transfer miles from SPG with a 25% bonus when you transfer in increments of 20K SPG points, or 1:1 transfer from AMEX Membership Rewards points. When the kids are a bit older, you might consider breaking up the trip with 1 stop; check out our tips in http://travelsort.com/blog/tips-for-booking-award-tickets-to-africa A really great award would be biz or first class on Cathay, flying to Johannesburg via Hong Kong using Alaska miles when the kids are older. A good Star Alliance option if you can plan a year in advance is South African, and it’s a lot easier to earn United miles via Chase Ultimate Rewards cards and category bonuses.
loading....