Buying food: Grocery shopping tips from 1950
The American housewife! Who has a more important or more responsible occupation? Wife, mother, laundress, counselor, maid, chef, purchasing agent. All of these are her duties at one time or another.
So begins Buying Food, a home economics film from 1950. Buying Food is fascinating not just for its shopping tips, but also for the inside look at a grocery store from 60 years ago. (Self-service grocery stores were introduced in 1916 and grew in popularity during the 1920s and 1930s, but they were still relatively young in 1950.)
The condescending narrator e-nun-ci-ates his thesis:
If her income is limited — and most incomes are — it is her duty to be sure that what she has to spend buys the most in healthful, nutritious food for her family. Yes, she feels that she must buy wisely if she can. But what does this mean? What can she do to be sure that her money goes as far as possible?
Most of these tips will probably be quite familiar. But remember, this film is meant to educate future housewives: high school girls. Tips include:
- Use a grocery list to eliminate impulse buying. Notice that the film’s impulse buyer is a man. A man can’t possibly know how to shop properly, right? (Kris would answer “yes”.)
- Buy only what you need. When you buy too much, whether through impulse or through mistaken economy, you run the risk of creating waste. And wasted food is a huge drain on the budget (both then and now).
- Compare unit pricing. The film doesn’t call it unit pricing, but that’s what it is. Viewers are instructed to compare the price per ounce on a can of beans, for example. Search for the best value, which isn’t always the largest lot.
- Buy in bulk. You can often save money by purchasing “case lots”. (Actually, the grocery store we used to shop at in my home town still has a “case sale” every summer. You can order cases of your favorite food in advance. I’d always order a case or two of my favorite canned chili. It was a great way to save money.)
- Don’t buy foods your family won’t eat. And don’t buy too many perishables. Again, you don’t want to waste food.
- Know what you’re buying before you buy. “When you buy canned goods, be sure to read the label. The information on the label is much more reliable than the flowery language of advertisements.”
- Purchase produce in season, when possible. Produce costs less and tastes better when it is in season. (Yes, it’s obvious, but it’s a main point in the film.) The film also notes that “if the housewife’s time is not too highly valued”, home-canned produce can be a savings.
- Frozen foods are a good choice. They’re nearest in quality to fresh produce. They cost a little more, but this cost is offset by the fact that there’s no waste.
- Use the best grade of milk available to you. “Disease may be contracted by drinking unsanitary raw milk.” (Of all the tips, this seems least applicable to modern grocery shoppers.)
But successful meals aren’t just about smart shopping. The film notes that cooking skills are important, too:
The cooking ability of the housewife [is] highly important. It doesn’t take much skill to make an excellent meal from an expensive t-bone steak. But the sign of an accomplished cook is an attractive and tasty dish made from less expensive meat: hamburger, frankfurters. Even a well-prepared, well-seasoned stew is a dish a housewife can be proud to set before her family.
Over the past few weeks, Kris and I have had fun browsing through the Public Domain media at the Internet Archive. There’s a massive collection of old instructional films (like this one) on a variety of subjects — dating, diet, driving — including many on personal finance. If you, too, enjoy films like this, I encourage you to spend some time exploring the site.
Note: This film was created for high school home economics classes of the 1950s. Yes, by modern standards it’s sexist, but if you can put your brain on “pause”, it’s a fun film, and an interesting glimpse at the past. Plus, most of the tips are still applicable today.
Become A Money Boss And Join 15,000 Others
Subscribe to the GRS Insider (FREE) and we’ll give you a copy of the Money Boss Manifesto (also FREE)
There are 51 comments to "Buying food: Grocery shopping tips from 1950".
I need to take the film’s advice to “buy only what you need” to heart. My downfall is succumbing to all the gorgeous fresh veggies in the produce section, then not having time (or being too tired after work) to cook them before they spoil. The problem has worsened since a Fresh Market grocery opened practically next door to my office. I often spend my lunch hour there–grocery shoppping when I’m hungry, another bad strategy. No more. I’m turning over a new lettuce leaf.
This kind of information was the only worthwhile part of the annoying home-ec classes that girls were forced to take in those days. To graduate from high school in California, I had to take a full year of home ec in junior high school, and another semester in high school. No exceptions were granted.
The junior high school experience was a total waste–when I should have been taking a solid subject, I was being taught how to make Jell-O from a package. The high-school course, though, was basically a class in personal finance lite. Although it was assumed that girls didn’t need to worry their pretty little heads about conundrums like how the stock market works (few Americans invested money in anything other than a bank account, and most people got a defined pension plan through their employers), we did at least learn how to make a budget, how to assess products for quality, and how to design a healthful meal.
Boys were required to take shop. They learned to make little wooden boxes and to change the oil in their cars. I don’t recall, though, that they were made to sit through more than a year of that stuff. In high school, they may have been free to take courses that would help them to get into college, such as…oh, say, math and science.
Back then, most did not go to college. You could still have a good life without it.
Debi, I have the same problem with veggies and fruit when I go to the market. It’s hard this time of year with all the fresh produce out there.
One tip I’ve found helpful is to plan a stir fry at least once a week — or another “use up what’s in the fridge” meal (like a big salad).
Kris’s post about dealing with an abundance of berries also came in handy for me. I would never have thought to try freezer jam — but now I’ve made three batches!
These tips are helpful, and it goes to show that great advice can be timeless. Now that my wife has agreed to stay home with our baby triplets and thus losing her income, we have to become a bit more conscientious about the food we buy and to make sure none of it is wasted.
It’s kind of funny, my wife texted me at work yesterday to yell at me about leaving two bananas to over-ripen. While only a few nickels potentially wasted, it shows that we are taking the lessons to heart. In any event, over-ripe bananas make great banana bread, so you learn to economize and maximize value.
This is awesome! I would love to be a housewife. We’re taking steps currently to allow me to be a stay at home mom when the time comes!
Check out my post in which I compare my old coupon-clipping big chain grocery store shopping to my current & NEW experience with getting most of my food from CSAs (Community Supported Agriculture). My experience has been amazing! And I am NOT spending more than I did at Cub. In fact probably less!
http://greenadventuresofacitygirl.blogspot.com/2009/07/is-being-green-affordable.html
@Debi and Elizabeth – I’m with you on that. It’s taken me so long to learn that it’s not “healthier” or “cheaper” to buy fresh veggies by the pound if I can’t use them up in time.
I finally just took the misnamed “crisper” drawer out of my refrigerator. It was just a place where vegetables went to die. I find that the empty space is great for chilling wine bottles, and now I’m less tempted to “stock up” on perishables.
I actually already do these things, probably just by common sense (and not a heap of money in the bank!) but I do break the rules sometimes, and like Debi, come out 2nd. It is good to know that i’m doing the best I can!
This is excellent. How did you get the original video small enough to fit in a post?
Blessings
Mrs. White
Good tips from this video! I am grateful I was raised knowing the importance of a grocery list and not shopping when you are hungry. Although I am guilty of it sometimes!
One tip I would like to comment on is the pasteurized milk bit. Though I accept the best quality pasteurized milk should be bought, there is also raw milk. Raw milk is regulated and humans have drank it for thousands of years!
Just a quick google search found me this information:
“In what microbiologists call the principal of Competitive Exclusion, non-pathogenic bacteria like, say, Lactococcus lactis, can actually limit or kill bad bugs like Listeria monocytogenes, responsible for hundreds of illnesses yearly (2).
But make no mistake, ANY food can be contaminated (3). It usually boils down to how it was produced, handled and packaged. (Certainly, low quality raw milk in the mid-1800’s, contaminated with tuberculosis bacilli, had its unwanted share of the limelight). Lots of variation exists in each of these areas. And besides, not many foods have built-in lactic acid producers policing the neighborhood.
Take the pasteurization process, for instance. While it certainly destroys bacteria, good and bad (and thus reduces the potential for infection), it’s far from flawless (4).
Pasteurized milk still sickens people, and in far greater numbers than the more heavily regulated raw product (5). The real question ought to be, how are pathogens getting anywhere near cows to begin with.”
Found at http://www.raw-milk-facts.com/raw_milk_safety.html
My girlfriend buys raw milk from our local co-op from time to time and I have to admit that it is quite amazing (and amazingly expensive!). The farms raising cows for raw milk production are paying a lot closer attention to the health of their animals than your run of the mill factory farm.
Also, I have to agree with Elizabeth (#3) – The weekly stir fry is a great way to use up vegetables that you had big plans for but, somehow, just never found the time to prepare.
That milk tip is more applicable than you’d think. There is a resurgence of raw milk from dairy farms as a valuable commodity for the all-natural types. I remember a year or two back a couple of kids got very, very ill from it. I wanna say this was in Mcminneville, OR or thereabouts. People think it’s healthier or “purer” or some such, but the truth is it’s just got a lot more bacteria in it… pasteurization was invented for a reason!
Here’s a link to one article (not the one I was thinking of…) about raw milk sickening people:
http://www.oregonlive.com/business/index.ssf/2008/06/two_plead_guilty_in_rawmilk_e.html
“Three children were hospitalized with renal failure” for me is not worth the risk.
There are three grocery stores in my neighborhood: Wholefoods, Safeway, and Trader Joes.
Every time we shop at Wholefoods or Safeway, we come out saying DAMN, that was more than we expected to pay! The opposite is true for Trader Joe’s. Unless there’s that wonder dry aged Rib Eye only available at Wholefoods, or especially desirable fruit at Safeway, we will always go to Trader Joes.
The savings is generally 20%, or $20-50 every single trip, which is about twice a month. Who couldn’t use an extra $400-$1,000/yr!
Another way to save on food is to simply not eat so much. I don’t know about you guys, but there are a lot of big folks in America, especially ones who like to sit next to me at movie theatres, planes, or buses! 🙂 Just eat less, and you’ll probably save $1,000+/yr too.
Rgds,
RB
Rich By 30, Retire By 40
Just a tip for the veggies re Sam at #7: I’ve taken to storing all my veggies in the fridge door. They last several days longer–especially lettuce types (My drawer has a problem with freezing veggies no matter what the fridge is set on…great for meats waiting for tomorrow’s BBQ though.)
On homemaking/frugality sites (especially support sites for SAHA&Es & SAHMs)it is kinda funny/intriguing to me how much we have to dig out our grandparents literature for the best tips and instruction (thank you Guggenheim Project, Google Book Search & Open Library and now this site thanks to JR).
I mean yes, lots of hints from Heloise in our generation…and how to clean four rooms in 20 minutes before guests arrive…but not a whole lot about good old fashioned, daily domestic science/household management.
My class was not required to take home ec per se. We had to take 2 years of gym with one semester of “home arts” in junior high where we could choose either home ec or shop. The boys took home ec thinking that’s where the girls were and the girls took shop thinking the reverse. I can change my oil no problem, but need this site to make a budget. 🙂
Home Ec did not exist in my HS, but then, the HS I went to assumed that I would be wealthy enough to just hire people for that kind of thing (I’m not, I wouldn’t if I could, but there were people that were and did). 😛
I too have the problem of going to the farmer’s market and spending $$$ on delicious fresh fruit and veggies, only to work 10hr days, come home and eat chips and salsa because cooking is too much work. Poor, sad little veggies.
I love these old films! They are a time capsule and I spend at least half the time comparing rituals/attitudes of yore with those of today. 1950 wasn’t THAT long ago but how times have changed.
My grandmother would like to add “be sure and include a casserole made with a can of cream soup or a jello salad with every meal!” (I kid, I kid.)
I notice the list doesn’t mention meal planning. The first thing I do when I make a grocery list is to plan out the meals for the week. Then I list the things I need for them, add the things I like to always have on hand, and I’m done.
@Claire (#17)
Kris and I are just learning about meal planning. We’re drafting our first two-week meal plan for the beginning of August. I’m chronicling it at my personal site. If it works well, I’ll post about it here at Get Rich Slowly.
JD, I’m looking forward to your post on meal planning, especially as another couple who doesn’t yet have kids. My husband and I have been talking about this idea for months but still haven’t really done it.
Oh, another good idea that my wife and i implement all the time is ordering for one. Studies show that humans and animals will generally overeat if more food is placed in front of them than necessary.
By ordering one appetizer and one entre for the both of us, we savor our food more, and eat within our means and save money. If we’re hungry, we’ll just order something else!
Best,
RB
Rich By 30 Retire by 40
Thanks for the info on the Archive of these old videos! I’m going to have to check it out!
one thing I did notice in this film is the size of the carts. Those things are about 1/3 the size of the behemoths that they have in grocery stores now a days! I think that also says alot about buying habits now vs. habits in the 50’s. Also there isn’t an overabundance of choice on products, only a handful of manufacturers for each item.
I suppose that is how progress works!
I haven’t watched the video yet (I’m going to!) but I just gotta say, I love the term “purchasing agent”. I sorta wish I was more of a shopper just so I could correct people from “shopaholic” to “ambitious purchasing agent”! Haha!
“If the housewife’s time is not too highly valued…”
This line made me laugh! My grandfather used to grow his own vegetables and preserve them — in addition to working full time.
My mom made preserves as a hobby, and as gifts for him.
So very true about the unit pricing. I recently started my own business (selling frozen, ready to bake pies & cookies as well as freshly made items) so as part of determining my costs, I priced out all of my ingredients by the cup, teaspoon, etc (oh my WORD that’s a lot of converting and work and time).
I came to realize that buying bigger is sometimes WAY, and I mean WAY more expensive – much to my surprise!!
Great article, thank you. Stumbled!
It’s funny how even after more than 50 years most of the advice from this film is still valuable and relevant. It is comforting to know that managing money doesn’t have to be complicated.
“A man can’t possibly know how to shop properly, right?”
Haha! It’s a trick question… 😉
Mrs Slinkman, why did you send Henry to the grocery store? Obviously he’s in over his head.
Maybe he did such a bad job on purpose so she would never ask him to buy groceries again? Really Henry, oysters? What were you thinking?
I hope the Slinkman’s survived this difficult period of their marriage.
Still I love these movies cause they are so earnest. And the advice, although hokey, makes sense today. I always plan my meals and shop with a list. I usually allow myself 1 impulse buy (favorite impulse buy -tapioca pudding).
It’s interesting to me that it seemed to be assumed that you’d eat meat with every dinner, even if it was just hot dogs (ick!). Also, the assumption that if the food wasn’t eaten in a single meal it would be wasted, like you couldn’t work it into something later in the week. That kind of sounds like the home ec mentality to me, where everything must be made from a recipe, no improvising allowed.
My, she looked young, too. There were times in the 1950s where the median age at first marriage was in the teens for US women.
Amazingly, I have SEEN this film before. There was a DVD called, I believe, “Educational archives” that had a ton of these gems on it. Also one called “Workplace 101” or something like that. If you can – and this is admittedly off-topic – look up “Shake hands with danger,” which is a workplace-safety video from the same era.
That aside, it’s funny. The tips ARE still the same today in many ways. If anything, I think it’s harder now. Many of the primary shoppers now, unlike then, are also working outside the home, so there’s less time to compare and plan. And I think it’s safe to say that there are a LOT more choices available now!
That said, in some ways, that makes it easier. If it weren’t for price wars, I’d probably be paying $3 a liter for diet soda!
Hey Charley!!
Your wife can make those “over-ripened” bananas into banana nut bread. Google a recipe. They don’t have to be thrown away!!
This video was amusing. Yes, some of the “tips” were helpful and applicable to today’s conditions. The “grades” of products is something I don’t see anymore today… Maybe I don’t pay attention, but I haven’t seen ‘Grade A’ lima beans in my canned goods section. Also, I haven’t seen a meat section that carries ground beef like that ever.
It would be interesting to see this updated for the modern “purchasing agent”. I need some tips that help with my specialized diet and lack of grocery store choices in my area. Not eating red meat means that I can only go to stores that have the ground turkey and a significant amount of meat substitutes (egg plant, fresh veggies for good vegetarian meals…etc.) when I do serious grocery shopping. In my area, that means a 15-20 minute drive. Unfortunately, the smaller stores in my area haven’t picked up on the healthier items I need… 🙁
“The American housewife! Who has a more important or more responsible occupation? Wife, mother, laundress, counselor, maid, chef, purchasing agent. All of these are her duties at one time or another.”
What a great way to express what a homemaker does (male or female); Isn’t it amazing that what was once considered a full-time job is now expected to be part-time?
Diana, you make a great point! Women entering the workplace en masse has been celebrated as a great economic driving force, but I wonder if the decline in our eating habits and increase in weight has something to do with that.
It’s funny how small the shopping carts are, as well as the size of the market itself–no supermarkets yet? Even so, I was surprised by how well almost all of the tips still apply today. Strange that no matter what else changes, we still struggle with these basic actions.
@ The Frugal New Yorker — I certainly wouldn’t say so based on how “healthy” those meals were in the video! I think we have healthier choices than we did in the past, and a better awareness of nutrition, but we’re just not putting it to use.
Besides, our increasingly sedentary lifestyles are partly to blame as well. Think of how much time people spend in front of TV or computer screens these days compared to decades ago. Most kids don’t even walk to school anymore, let alone play outside as much as they did decades ago.
I am always surpised at how many people underestimate the potential savings with regards to grcery shopping.
For most, it is our second biggest monthly expense!
I personally view grocery shopping (and getting the best deals) as a weekly challenge, and it has actually made it kind of fun.
Good info..thanks for the tips
@Escape Velocity – do remember that they wouldn’t have had a fridge or freezer, so any uneaten food would have to be eaten very quickly indeed before it would go off.
how fun! 😀
My high school offered home ec as an elective, which my parents forbade me to take. (Not that I wanted to!) My mom said she could teach me cooking & sewing, and school could teach me physics and algebra.
I learned how to balance a checkbook in 6th grade math class. That seems a much more appropriate place for budgeting and other money skills.
In America most milk is actually pasteurized and homogenized, unlike in many other countries where it is merely pasteurized. The homogenization allows it to last a very long time relative to the 2-4 days it lasts without that process. You cannot make milk tarts with it though, because it never sets. Homogenizing just involves breaking down the fatty creamy layer that can separate to the top, so you can safely buy non-homogenized milk (as long as it says it was pasteurized) if you are looking for a better taste but don’t want to risk disease. Just use it quick (and maybe try make a milk tart).
I’ve been safely drinking raw milk all year. I love this stuff. It is from healthy, grass-fed pastured cows and has not been pasteurized or homogenized. It will last 7-8 in the fridge after opening before it starts to go sour.
I think the point about the milk has to be taken in a different direction these days–it’s less about buying pasteurized vs. raw, and more about buying standard vs. organic milk. The health benefits of drinking milk that’s not laced with growth hormones, antibiotics and other nastiness created by the “dairy industry” are huge. Organic milk might cost more, but in my opinion, it’s definitely worth it.
@Wilhelm–No, I think a US household in 1950 would ordinarily have had a refrigerator, although probably nowhere else in the world. Don’t have any statistics handy, though.
i hate how people say that buying in bulk saves money…sure it might save some for those that are fortunate enough to have room to store things in! If you’re broke and live in a small apartment, there’s no room or savings in buying in bulk.
@ sir jorge — I get confused. Sometimes people use the terms “buy in bulk” and “buy bulk” interchangeably. Like you, I don’t see the benefit of buying large quantities of things for just me. However, I buy a lot of stuff at the bulk food store and save money because I only need a little. The cost per unit is lower, and I’m not paying for product that will go bad or go stale.
I was also a little perplexed by the assumption that uneaten food at a meal would get thrown out. During the war, didn’t people use every scrap they had?
Sir Jorge
Buying in bulk works if you are sensible about it, where I buy, they sell boneless chicken breasts for $1.99 Lb for 10Lbs or small pakages of the same for $3.99, 10 Lbs of chicken is a fairly small and will fit into odd spaces in the freezer if divided for meals, buying industrial sized cans takes up a lot of space and usully has waste left over, so it’s a mater of finding out what works for you, not everything is better to buy bulk.
@Slackerjo: I am totally with you on the love for tapioca pudding, but seriously, that stuff in the store cannot compare with good homemade tapioca! It’s not at all difficult – if you can separate an egg, you’re good – and so much better! You can stir in chocolate chips or almond flavoring or raspberries or… There’s always a recipe for pudding on the tapioca box. Plus it’s cheaper too!
While the language and tone is rather sexist, I would like to point out that discounting or belittling this kind of thing is not much better. It takes a LOT of work and planning to effectively run a home on a budget, no matter who is doing it (bachelor to mother of 10), but especially if there are children involved.
Think about the careers that are chronically undervalued and underpaid in our society: nurse, teacher, librarian (all require college work above a BA, usually a masters), also secretaries who really do a lot of work and keep everything running smoothly…..anyway, the thing these careers have in common is that they are traditionally women’s jobs. Now that (thankfully) women are free to enter any career path, these careers, and the work of a “housewife” are very seriously looked down upon, which to me is just latent sexism. We assume that because teachers are traditionally women, they must not be as smart or important as lawyers who were traditionally men. Not so.
Anyway, long rant just to say that, like many of the commenters here obviously know: work that goes towards running a household is time consuming, diverse and very important. Let’s give it and those who do it more respect.
Great advice is timeless (and often obvious!). Thanks for sharing!
I’m glad someone else noticed how much smaller the carts are in this video. Just as homes, cars, etc. have gotten bigger, so have shopping carts.
I noticed some product labels haven’t changed – like Van Camp’s Pork & Beans, in over 50 years!
Also recognized Jolly Green Giant, Barbasol, Bird’s Eye packaging.
I don’t think any shopper today would buy a “Grade C” product, however.
the two things that stood out to me were the comment about if the housewifes time is not very valuable and the part whenever the narrator was talking about being a good cook while it shows the housewife putting an entire stick of butter into a bowl, hilarious!
Hear hear, Catherine!
The Washington Sate dairy responsible for the outbreak was FILTHY, with cow feces a foot deep. No-one should have bought milk from them after seeing their barn. Certified raw milk producers are scrupulously clean and their animals are much healthier than the miserable creatures who produce the pus-laden milk pasteurized to make it edible.
Good raw milk is equivalent to sushi-grade fish. Our farmer’s bacteria counts were consistently lower than the legal requirements for pasteurized milk.
Please educate yourself before forming an opinion. Thanks!
It’s amazing how this kind of films is still valuable even after more than 60 years!
Love the advices and I will put them in my mind in my next visit to the grocery, specially “Buy only what you need”
Thanks for sharing…