Why NewRetirement is my favorite retirement planning tool

Why NewRetirement is my favorite retirement planning tool

Over the past week, I've shared two terrific retirement planning tools. First, I explored the pros and cons of Personal Capital. Next, I looked at OnTrajectory, which is the best traditional retirement calculator I've found.

NewRetirement logoToday, I want to talk about NewRetirement. Since I discovered it two years ago, NewRetirement has become my favorite tool for retirement planning.

I like NewRetirement because it offers amazing levels of customization. Plus, it explains its assumptions and offers ample information about every subject it tackles. And it does all of this without ever becoming overwhelming. It's comprehensive and customizable, yet clear. Most importantly, NewRetirement is more than just a retirement calculator. When I say it's a retirement planning tool, I mean that.

NewRetirement offers three levels of service.

  • Planner, the basic level of service — and the bulk of what I'll review in this article — is free. You do need to provide an email address, but once you do, you're able to create a personalized retirement plan. (I'll show you what that's like in a moment.)
  • If you like the basic level of service and want more, you can upgrade to PlannerPlus for $6/month. This gives you access to advanced retirement planning tools, more detailed reports, and the ability to print your plan. (NewRetirement is offering GRS readers a 30-day free trial of PlannerPlus, by the way.)
  • At the highest level, you can pay NewRetirement for personalized advice from a Certified Financial Planner. Unlike Personal Capital, NewRetirement won't pester you over and over to use their advisors. But the service is available for those who need it.

As I mentioned, I've been using NewRetirement for a couple of years. In order to give an honest and complete review today, I created a second NewRetirement account and walked through the process of setting everything up from scratch. Do I still like the tool as much as I did in April 2017? Let's find out.

Disclosure: Before I begin this review, I need to make one thing clear: I am an investor in NewRetirement. When I first found the service two years ago, I liked it so much that I started an email conversation with founder Stephen Chen. That grew into a friendship. Since then, I've invested $50,000 of my own money into the company. (Also, I was the first-ever guest on the NewRetirement podcast!) Having said that, I've done my best to provide an honest review here.

Getting Started with NewRetirement

After you register for an account, NewRetirement starts by asking you a series of basic questions. (You can opt to by-pass these questions if all you want is a simple retirement calculator.) Here's how I answered using my current financial state.

NewRetirement setup (#1)

NewRetirement setup (#2)

NewRetirement setup (#3)

When you've finished entering your basic info, you're presented with the NewRetirement dashboard. It's here that you first get a hint that this retirement tool is more robust than any of the others. Front and center is a progress bar…and because you're new, that progress bar is nearly empty.

NewRetirement setup progress

Even if you didn't flesh out your initial data, NewRetirement would give you some useful info. (Meaning that if you read this article and want to look at what the tool does, you can click over and get a quick overview of your financial future in just a couple of minutes.)

The fun really starts, however, when you dig deeper into NewRetirement.

Digging Deeper into NewRetirement

As the dashboard implies, NewRetirement features 33 different retirement planning sections divided into ten broad categories.

In each section, you can enter data and/or change assumptions. If all of this were dumped on the user at once, it'd be overwhelming. Fortunately, it's a step-by-step process that never gets out of control.

The ten main categories that NewRetirement tackles are:

  • Basic profile and goals, including your age, life expectancy, desired legacy, and plans for retirement. (The latter is a written statement. I love it! Most retirement tools are all about the numbers. NewRetirement digs deeper.)
  • Social Security, where you can enter your estimated retirement benefits and start date. If you don't know what to expect from Social Security, NewRetirement links to the official government website and a Social Security calculator.
  • Work and other income. In this section, you can specify how much you earn from your job, but also input money from dividends, interest, rental properties, and other sources.
  • Annuities and pensions. If you have access to an annuity or pension, you can enter your info in this section. I won't have either of these, so I skip this section.
  • Savings and assets. This is a large section in which you list your tax-advantaged retirement accounts, regular investment accounts, bank accounts, large assets, and ongoing retirement contributions. Under “other assets”, I included the various businesses I own pieces of (including NewRetirement itself!). I did not, however, value this website.
  • Expenses and inflation. Here you can choose both an optimistic inflation rate and a pessimistic inflation rate. You can also enter any known large one-time expenses in your future, such as buying a home, sending the kids to college, or charitable giving. You can tell NewRetirement which account the expense will come from, the age it will occur, and the reason for the expense. Pretty cool. Lastly, if you think your core spending will change over time, you can specify that here. Right now, for instance, I think I'm spending $5000 per month. If I think that spending will drop to $3500 per month when I turn 55, I could model that in this section.
  • Housing, where you enter the current value of your home, the balance on your mortgage, and project future home appreciation. Another cool feature: You can model future changes to housing or mortgages. If I think that Kim and I will sell our current home and downsize in a decade, for instance, NewRetirement will let me do that. (Minor quibble: When I'm projecting my future, I assume that we'll sell this house in ten years and then rent a place. NewRetirement won't let me explicitly model that. My workaround is to model buying a new home for $1, then bumping my monthly expenses by $1500 to compensate for rent.)

NewRetirement downsizing

  • Medical and long-term care. As you probably know, medical costs are one of the fastest-rising yet most oft-overlooked chunks of the average American budget. NewRetirement includes an entire section for modeling current and future health-care costs.
  • Debts. NewRetirement allows you to list all of your current debt (plus links to advice on how to manage your debt, if it's problematic).
  • Estate planning. This section doesn't have a lot of resources but offers a bit of information. Plus, it lets you track whether you've completed important estate-planning documents.

Nearly every step of the way, NewRetirement offers you the ability to learn more about relevant topics. For instance, when you enter your expected longevity, NewRetirement links you to a life-expectancy calculator and suggests five related articles.

NewRetirement funding goal

As you tick boxes indicating that you'd like to learn more about a particular topic, relevant articles are added to the “info and opportunities” tab in the main menu. This is an excellent, useful feature, something I've never seen in another retirement tool.

NewRetirement article list

Forecasting Your Future with NewRetirement

Yesterday, it took me about an hour to work through all 33 retirement planning sections in the NewRetirement tool. I've been entering the same info into retirement planning tools for two weeks now, so I know where to find it. If this is your first time, it might take you a bit longer.

When I'd finished, the progress bar in the dashboard was no longer empty. It looked like this:

NewRetirement full progress

The NewRetirement dashboard contains an Analysis section that's available from the start. After you've entered your basic data during registration, you can use this section to look at a forecast for your financial future. But the analysis becomes more useful after you've entered more complete information.

By default, the dashboard displays your Savings Over Time graph (which is very similar to the graph that OnTrajectory keeps front and center at all times).

NewRetirement savings over time

There's a “key metrics” view where you can see the core basic parameters and some of the ramifications.

NewRetirement key metrics

Or, if you want more info, you can access a handful of other charts.

NewRetirement additional charts

I'm a fan of the Savings Timeline chart because it gives me a quick look at my current financial trajectory.

NewRetirement savings timeline

And as much as I preach that you should not compare yourself to others, I like the “compare yourself to others” tool haha. (From my past articles about NewRetirement, I know that other GRS readers like this comparison tool too.)

NewRetirement compare yourself

Just for kicks, here's the same comparison view from when I first reviewed NewRetirement in 2017:

NewRetirement household comparison

As you can see, there's plenty available with the free version of NewRetirement. In fact, it's this free tool that made me rave about the company two years ago. I still love it.

I do think OnTrajectory is a strong competitor for NewRetirement. That's a good thing. For many people, OnTrajectory may be a better choice. But the features I've reviewed so far in this article are free at NewRetirement. OnTrajectory costs money after the first two weeks of use.

In the future, I intend to promote both OnTrajectory and NewRetirement. They're both excellent. (If you haven't read it yet, here's my OnTrajectory review.)

PlannerPlus at NewRetirement

As you can see, the free version of NewRetirement packs quite a punch. Without paying a penny, you can do more with it than with 95% of the other retirement planning tools on the web. But what if you want more?

For $6/month, you can upgrade from the entry-level NewRetirement service to what the company calls PlannerPlus. Doing so unlocks another menu of options.

NewRetirement planner plus

Behind the scenes, NewRetirement takes the data you've entered, crunches it based on the tool's assumptions — investment returns, inflation, health-care spending, etc. — then creates a series of data tables projecting your future financial health. In order to make these raw numbers more accessible, PlannerPlus provides its “Plan Inspector”, which lets you browse dynamic charts to explore your retirement plan.

Here, for instance, I'm looking at how even with optimistic assumptions, my savings will only last until I'm age 75.

NewRetirement plan inspector

With the free version of NewRetirement, you can enter as many expenses as you want, but nothing about the process is guided. It's all sort of free-form. For many folks, that's fine. Others want more help, though. For these people, PlannerPlus includes an advanced budgeting tool.

NewRetirement budgeter features

The budgeting tool in PlannerPlus allows users to model expenses at a far more detailed level. For instance, I could use my existing data from Quicken to enter actual expenses for almost everything.

NewRetirement budgeter detail

Most retirement calculators ask for just a couple of Big Picture numbers. The good ones let you explore some level of detail. Like OnTrajectory, NewRetirement allows you to get as detailed as you want so that you can explore a variety of what-if scenarios.

With the PlannerPlus upgrade, you can also customize the software's alerts. Do you want NewRetirement to pester you when you use faulty assumptions? When your data is incomplete? When you could take steps to improve your future financial health? If so, do nothing. But if the alerts bug you, you can choose which ones to dismiss.

PlannerPlus also allows you to print your plan and/or export it to a spreadsheet.

The Bottom Line

NewRetirement isn't perfect and I don't want to pretend that it is. As I worked through the tool yesterday, I encountered a couple of minor bugs. Sometimes I couldn't figure out how to model my plans for the future. (How do I convey that I think we might sell the house in ten years, then find a place to rent?) For as much reporting as NewRetirement currently offers, it could always offer more. (We money nerds love to have lots of reports and graphs.)

That said, the company is very responsive to bug reports. They update the software regularly, so when users report issues, changes can usually be made within a few days.

Plus, NewRetirement is a work in progress. The company is constantly working to improve things, to give more value to their customers — even the folks who use the free level of service. Every month, founder Stephen Chen sends me a list of coming upgrades and his plans for the company's future. Much has changed in the two years since I first discovered the tool. Much will change in the years to come.

Ultimately, NewRetirement isn't a retirement calculator; it's a retirement planning tool. To me, that's like the difference between a pocket calculator and a spreadsheet. Each has its uses, no doubt. Sometimes, you want the pocket calculator. But sometimes, you want the more powerful option.

If all you're after is a quick overview of your financial future, you can use the basic retirement calculator at NewRetirement — or one of the dozens of other retirement calculators on the web. (Use OnTrajectory if you want a robust retirement calculator.)

But if you want to actually formulate a retirement plan, if you want a retirement planning tool that will actually guide you through the process, NewRetirement is an outstanding choice.

NewRetirement is offering Get Rich Slowly readers a free 30-day trial of PlannerPlus. You do have to enter your credit card info to start the trial, but if you decide that the service isn't right for you, you can cancel without hassle. NewRetirement isn't a scammy company. They want you to be happy.

More about...Apps

Become A Money Boss And Join 15,000 Others

Subscribe to the GRS Insider (FREE) and we’ll give you a copy of the Money Boss Manifesto (also FREE)

Yes! Sign up and get your free gift
Become A Money Boss And Join 15,000 Others
guest
21 Comments
Oldest
Newest Most Voted
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
John
John
1 year ago

I really like the comparison of New Retirement with OnTrajectory here. Interesting to note that New Retirement is basically offering for free what OnTrajectory seems to be charging subscriptions to access, with a whole other level of premium tools available beyond that.

I use New Retirement already so sounds like I can safely stay there without missing anything for now at least.

Ingo
Ingo
1 year ago

I’d love a review of Betterment’s and Wealthfront’s calculators in comparison to these tools.

Steve
Steve
1 year ago

Thanks – great summary – although I am biased 🙂

The ability to model second homes, rental properties and their associated mortgages will be live in the next couple of weeks; along with the ability to model selling your home and renting.

In the near term people will have the ability to do scenarios, better modeling of medical costs, tune their plans for tax efficiency and develop optimized withdrawal / draw down plans. There’s more good stuff following that around Social Security, Asset Allocation, Advanced Modeling, Risk Management, Linking Accounts and Estate Planning.

S.G.
S.G.
1 year ago
Reply to  Steve

I was actually wondering how a mortgaged rental property would work in there. Thanks for the update!

Chris
Chris
7 months ago
Reply to  Steve

I am definitely interested in NewRetirement once the ability to model rental properties is added. Rental properties are our primary source of income and it seems that most retirement planning software and tax planning software do not properly account for this type of income and it nuances like depreciation.

Alice
Alice
1 year ago

I checked it out but was annoyed that it assumed I was male and my spouse female. It’s 2019 and women plan for retirement too. And sometimes we even manage the household finances!

Sandi Kay
Sandi Kay
1 year ago
Reply to  Alice

And sometimes it’s a same-sex relationship. Or the woman makes more money in the hetero marriage or partnership.

Steve
Steve
1 year ago
Reply to  Sandi Kay

You’re right – thanks for the feedback. We’ll look at how to better handle gender & relationships defaults going forward. We are also going to make it more flexible around marital status (divorced, widower, widowed) since that impacts things like Social Security benefits.

Bobby
Bobby
1 year ago
Reply to  Steve

Defaults should be based on national averages, the most likely answer. All settings will need to be looked at by each individual and changes will have to be made as needed (age, income, retirement age, etc.) and no default precludes a correction or alternate input. So to be realistic the defaults are fine and seem to be based on a likely and generic answer. If a default does not comply with your situation (as many did not for me) simply make the change and get on with the task of retirement planning.

Carolyn
Carolyn
1 year ago
Reply to  Alice

This! It would’ve been nice had there not been defaults preselected for me.

Sandi Kay
Sandi Kay
1 year ago

J.D., I agree, NewRetirement is a great tool without being overwhelming. Good for newbies and those who have thought about this in more depth. As a regular Boglehead reader, I have been overwhelmed by their typical recommendation for retirement planning software (i-orp and FireCalc).

I’ve plugged NR on a few forums instead, because it’s a neat way to note the progress you’ve made, *and* you can get nudges/guidance about what to take on next. Plus the embedded links (to Social Security, for example) make it easy to add more info to your planning scenario.

Steve
Steve
1 year ago
Reply to  Sandi Kay

Thanks Sandy – our growth has all come from word of mouth, so we appreciate your support!

Gerhard Burger
Gerhard Burger
1 year ago

Is anyone from Europe using this tool with any success, or is it very USA specific?

Steve
Steve
1 year ago
Reply to  Gerhard Burger

Hi Gerard – we have some paying customers from the UK and people in other EU countries (and other places like Australia) asking us how to manage different tax regimes and social programs. Today it’s mostly US users, but we are looking at how to make it easily work in different countries.

Any suggestions for programs that you see doing this really well are welcome.

Steve
Steve
1 year ago
Reply to  Gerhard Burger

Hi Gerard – a little more color – we have a few hundred people from the EU who have used the Planner so far.

Patrick Austin
Patrick Austin
1 year ago

I’ve been using the free New Retirement for over a year. I’m pretty pleased with it overall. One thing I’ve had problems with is the “what you need” information. While the planner says I will meet my goals through age 90 easily, with a projected $3.4m estimated when I die, when I look at the “needs” information it shows I’m $750K BEHIND what I need at age 62, which is only 2 years away. Something isn’t right. I emailed New Retirement about a year ago asking about this and they couldn’t explain what would cause this. I re-entered my information… Read more »

Steve
Steve
1 year ago
Reply to  Patrick Austin

Hi Patrick – thanks for your feedback – we’re looking into this now and I’ll loop back shortly.

Steve
Steve
1 year ago
Reply to  Patrick Austin

Hi Patrick – we looked into this further and I messaged you directly about our plans here, but in a nutshell we’re going to tune the calculations to more accurately predict what you’d need to retire today (vs. in the near future) and better illustrate see when someone likely reaches “Financial Indpendence”. You can see a simple version of this with the FIRE icon on this one page tool. https://www.newretirement.com/planner/retirement-calculator We’re also going to clarify that this chart “tax effects” your income which is why it shows that you need more than you might expect to retire in the near… Read more »

Kari
Kari
1 year ago

Thanks so much for posting such detailed reviews JD! I had looked at NewRetirement briefly in the past, but the 30-day free trial prompted me to go back and see what new information I could get from it. I was surprised that using real vs nominal values is not configurable. I do all of my projections in real dollars and am many years from retirement. So seeing the very large future values on this website makes it a little more difficult to translate to what I need to save now. This is a great tool that I’m glad you brought… Read more »

Steve
Steve
1 year ago
Reply to  Kari

Hi Kari – agreed and longer time horizons make it a bigger issue. This is on our roadmap and we’ll provide a switch soon.

shares