Money and Budgeting App Reviews 2016-2017: You Need a Budget
If you’re ready to account for where every cent of your money goes, You Need a Budget could work for you. The app is based on the premise of “giving every dollar a job,” meaning you budget for every expense — fixed, discretionary or otherwise. Want to buy a new purse or pair of shoes? If your monthly clothing budget is $100, then you may not be able to afford it this month. Friends want to double date at that trendy new Italian restaurant? It may not be in your $200 dining out budget.
The app makes budgeting straightforward, allowing you to see how much over or under you are for a particular line item. But it’s best for people who want to get serious about how much they actual spend and where they may need to make sacrifices to achieve a larger goal.
What I Liked
Zero-based budgeting is tough, but I can see its value. You have to account for every dollar coming in, either using it to cover monthly household expenses, pay off debt, for dining out and for what YNAB calls “quality of life” expenses like vacation. During this process, I realized that I’m not as good a budgeter as I thought. I do a good job of tracking our spending after the fact, but I could improve when it comes to setting aside money for specific purposes — basically being more financially proactive. For example, before using this app, I had no idea how much my husband and I spent each month dining out and we never really set aside a specific amount for this purpose. It was more like “we’ll eat out no more than two times a week.” I also had no gauge of my own discretionary spending, since this money comes out of my personal account. Using the tool allowed me to see that we spend less than $200 a month eating out, but that I need to keep a better eye on my discretionary spending for things like beauty and hair products and anything from Amazon.com (Amazon Prime admittedly has turned me into a shopping junkie). We plan to buy a house within a few years, so YNAB allowed me to see that these are two areas where we (or I) could curb spending and put that additional money toward a down payment. Actually seeing the budget also showed me that we could be saving more. We have more cushion than we need in our account for household expenses, so it might be better to put more of that money toward retirement or paying down my student loans.
Hmmm, Not So Much
The set-up process. Before you set up the mobile app, you had to set everything up on desktop. This took me several days because I had difficulty importing information from my bank account.
After some back and forth with YNAB’s customer service, we figured out that the issue was the security settings on my Bank of America account. I had it set up to enter a passcode for every login. I had to remove this security feature to import my transactions into the YNAB app. However, even after it was set up, my transactions weren’t regularly imported. While I troubleshooted this, I had to manually add each of my transactions. I re-authenticated my bank account for a second time, but even after this it didn’t work. I wish this process was a lot less cumbersome. In spite of this hassle, YNAB’s customer service was awesome. Every time I had a question or technical difficulty I received a response the same day or within 24 hours. Once I got in and started using the app, it was pretty user-friendly. YNAB also has plenty of helpful videos and user guides on its site, plus you can attend a free webinar. These self-service options cover most of what you need to navigate the tool or tackle certain issues.
What Others are Saying
Many users say they like the ability to “look under the hood” of their finances and get more visibility into their actual spending. Most of the complaints have to do with the new cost ($5 a month) for the upgraded version of YNAB and all the manual entry required. For some users, it’s just too laborious. One Amazon user said: “Garbage. This app is 100% manual. What’s the difference between this and an excel sheet?”
YNAB is great for families, especially when you have long-term goals like buying a house or getting out of debt. It’s also been beneficial for me as a newlywed who has recently merged my finances with my husband. The app gives you more visibility into how you actually spend and whether the budget you’ve set is realistic. It also gives you more accountability, because having to add transactions on a monthly basis or see them imported from your bank makes you keenly aware of where you’re failing or succeeding financially.
Not Good For:
Anyone who isn’t mentally prepared or doesn’t have the time or patience for zero-based budgeting.
Budgeting (Free or Paid)
This app is available for free download, but the desktop software is $5 a month and you must be a paid YNAB user. However, YNAB offers a 34-day free trial for new users. The app can be used on an Android device as well as iPhone, iPad and Apple Watch.
8 out of 10
About this series:
Welcome to a new weekly series where we test-drive savings and budgeting apps so you can easily find the mobile tool that works for you. Share your experiences in the comments below. If you would like to suggest an app for a completely unbiased review, we’d love to hear from you. Please email us at email@example.com.