If you're new here, you may want to learn what this site is about. I encourage you to subscribe to my RSS feed. Thanks for visiting!
An AskMetafilter user wonders:
What things are worth the time and cost of doing or making myself? For example, tomatoes from the store are miles below the ones I grow in my garden. Fresh-baked bread is amazing. But knitting socks or a sweater seems hardly worth it, despite the fact that I can customize it, because of the high cost of the time and materials. Nearly everything is so easy to get from the store. So what is still worth the effort?
There are many things worth the time and effort to do or make yourself, no matter where you are in life.
- Grow your own produce. Home-grown produce is vastly superior to produce from the supermarket. Most people have space for a small garden in which to grow herbs and tomatoes. If you have more space, expand to berries, grapes, or even fruit trees. Kris and I have been enjoying fresh grapes lately. They’re amazing. “It’s like a completely different fruit,” Kris said when comparing them to their store-bought cousins.
- Cook your own meals. This is a valuable skill, especially for young adults. If you can learn to eat well on a budget, you’ll be ahead of your peers.
- Make your own food. I’ve mentioned canning a lot lately, but there are other ways to produce your own food. Make pasta sauce. Make salsa. Bake bread. Brew beer. Make your own soups. Roast your own coffee beans.
- Build or maintain your computer. Unless you’re a Mac user, it’s easy to learn how to muck around inside your computer. Find a friend to teach you the basics. Better yet, find someone to show you how to build a machine. It’s a skill that can save you a lot of money.
- Learn simple sewing. This is great when you’re on a budget. I used to be able to perform basic sewing repairs on my clothes: replacing buttons, mending tears, hemming pants.
- Make greeting cards and gifts. Greeting cards are fun to create, and the recipients are always more pleased to get them than run-of-the-mill Hallmark cards. It’s also worthwhile to make your own gifts. One of the best presents I ever received was simply a customized CD mix. Much better than a gift certificate to Target!
- Maintain and repair a bicycle. Bikes are cheap transportation. A simple bicycle toolkit is easy and inexpensive to assemble. Borrow a bike maintenance book from the public library, and you can learn the essentials in just a weekend.
- Change the oil on your car. For most vehicles, this is a simple task.
- Knitting can be worth the effort, depending on your approach. Knitting produces custom-fitted garments. And if you learn to rip clothing purchased at garage sales and thrift stores, you can save on the cost of yarn.
The original thread features other suggestions of things that are worth the time to do yourself, including: yard work, furniture repair, basic home maintenance, and more.
The cost and convenience of buying in the store or hiring out often outweigh the advantages of making things yourself. But don’t be duped. There are still many reasons to produce things with your own hands:
- Superior quality of goods and workmanship.
- Easy customization to suit your needs.
- The satisfaction of a job well-done.
To make this worthwhile, do what you love. If you’re doing something you enjoy, something you consider fun, then the cost of your time is not a factor. If I’m planting, growing, and picking grapes, I’m having a good time. But I’d hate to replace my own roof, even if it would save me money.
[AskMetafilter: Make it from scratch?]
.jpg)

September 21st, 2006 at 6:03 am
I agree that knitting can be worth it, but it’s more about the satisfaction you get than saving money. I don’t think anyone saves money by knitting clothes, unless you compare the cost of a hand knit sweater in a shop versus the cost of knitting it yourself. In the end, your friends and family will have hand made items that will last for a long time, and that is worth it. If you’re on a tight budget though, I wouldn’t recommend knitting a whole lot, but that doesn’t mean you can’t fit it in to your life, just like any other hobby!
September 21st, 2006 at 6:24 am
I enjoy knitting. But most importantly, I’m a woman who wears a size 11 shoe. Go into the sock section of Target sometime, and see how many socks you see that fit a size 11 shoe. Answer: Zero. They *sell* size 11 shoes, but every sock they have fits up to size 10. (And I suspect they’d be small on a 10.)
So I’m trying to get good enough to knit my own. Not quite there yet–socks mean lots of tiny little stitches!–but I’m getting there, and it’s really a case of near-necessity. Yes, I could wear men’s socks, but I don’t especially want to do that anymore!
But with knitting, you get two things in one. The act of it is a hobby, the result is something you can wear. The cost of the yarn, even nice yarn, on a per-hour basis for a pair of socks is going to be miniscule as entertainment expenses go.
September 21st, 2006 at 6:44 am
Susan, I am a sock-knitter too! I have weird toes that wear through purchased socks very quickly. When I make my own custom pairs, I am able to compensate for my idiosyncratic feet and make socks that last for a very long time.
Knitting is a great way to catch the wasted moments in a day. I mean, I could spend a few hours on the train and have nothing to show for it, or I could spend a few hours on the train and have a pretty scarf at the end of the ride!
September 21st, 2006 at 8:25 am
Great suggestions, some are harder when you live in a city with no means to do a lot of those items. For example living in a big city in a condo with a closet sized balcony its hard to grow produce. But one of the key points I found in your list is cooking your own meals. The difference between going out for dinner and cooking it is staggaring.
September 21st, 2006 at 9:34 am
JD you guys are pretty hard core! But you made a great point- you do it because you like it! I am a working single mother of two, and I don’t have the time to make a lot of things myself- but I do agree that there are somethings yuo can do yourself that will be much better quality. I don;t like to clean- so I used to pay for someone to come in every once in a while- but felt that for the money, they weren’t doing a as good job as I do, when I do.. lol Do what you can yourself is great advice, but also think about how much time it takes, and how much money that time could be making you if you spent it on money making projects.
September 21st, 2006 at 9:35 am
I find that changing your oil doesn’t really make a big difference price-wise but it does ensure a high-quality oil versus the extremely cheap stuff that Wal-Mart (or other bigger chain garages) use.
Oil changes here are usually in the 20$ CDN range and doing it myself with a high quality oil and filter sets me back around 25$. The difference is in quality of the products: high quality oil and filters will get you allot more milegage before you’re due again.
I would deifnitly recommend changing the oil yourself however. If you’ve never done it before, just jack your car (consult your owner’s manual to find the correct way to do it as the reinforced metal spots vary from one car to the next), slide under and find a bolt under the gas tank. Simply undo, let it drip onto a pan and put it back in. Same thing for the filter. Once you oil is drained, twist it off (it can be really hard to take off depending how tight it was put on last time) then lit it drip, screw on the new one and fill ‘er back up.
September 21st, 2006 at 9:50 am
Great article, there are definitely a lot of things that are much better fresh. Just the other day some friends and I set their bread machine to go for 3 hours, then we went on a bike ride. Along the way we stopped repeatedly to munch on blackberries. (It really is amazing how different they taste. I can’t stand store-bought blackberries, but sun-warmed and fresh off the vine is overwhelmingly good.) We got back just in time to have fresh warm bread of our own recipe.
I am curious about your line “Unless you’re a Mac user, it’s easy to learn how to muck around inside your computer”, though. Considering Apple desktops are made especially to be easily opened and accessed, and once you get in there you have the same parts as any other PC, what makes it any harder to learn? Macs are now Linux and Intel-based, and you can even drop down to a command line if you really wanted. Given my years of building and rebuilding computers, I prefer the easy latch open and close to the dozens of tiny screws and awkward sliding sheet metal that i’ve cut myself on with PCs.
As you might be able to tell from my website, the usability of things tends to be important to me, so I put a lot of emphasis and pride in companies that put effort into making their products easy to use and accessible. I am always curious why someone feels that something isn’t simple and usable, so I can add that knowledge into things I create in the future.
Keep up the great articles!
September 21st, 2006 at 10:00 am
My statement “Unless you’re a Mac user, it’s easy to learn how to muck around inside your computer” contains a multitude. With the caveat that I still have not used an intel-based Mac, here’s my reasoning:
I wasn’t knocking Macs when I made that statement. I was simply being pragmatic.
September 21st, 2006 at 10:28 am
J.D.,
Thanks for the impressively prompt and thorough reply. I feel we may be discussing two different things, however. I have been focusing on “easy to learn how to muck around inside”, and it seems your points are aiming toward the expandability and options after you have already learned how.
Your points are all valid, however. I have come close to building my own Mac, but as you cannot buy all of the individual components as a consumer, it was actually a frankenstein of other machines.
My personal favorite point of yours is the “there’s little reason to ever fiddle inside a Mac except to upgrade memory.” Every time I have had a friend with an issue, I just sent them to the Apple Store, who had them up and running again for free within hours, with no interrogation or paperwork. Not having to pay to replace broken parts or wait around while my computer was mailed off has saved me lots of money over the years.
No offense taken, either. I’m certainly not defending Macs or PCs; I use both on a regular basis. I’m just relating my experiences. It’s nice to see you using older computers, as well. Buying older or refurbished computers or parts (what you need, not what you want), as well as hanging on to them for longer can save you a fortune in technology.
Best of luck saving up for the MacBook!
September 21st, 2006 at 10:30 am
If you really enjoy listening to music, build your own loudspeakers.
All it takes is a little reading, a little online research, and maybe a few project ideas to get you going. Companies like Parts Express, Madisound, Meniscus, Solen can supply you with everything you need except for the MDF (Medium Density Fiberboard) to build the enclosures — you can get that at your local lumber yard.
The only bad part about the total DIY method is the time it takes to build a pair of speakers… typically 30-40 hours for a pair by the time you cut, assemble, veneer, install, test, tweak, tune and test again.
Or, if you don’t want to do deal with all the math that comes with designing your own loudspeakers (or if you don’t have time), you can get kits that still offer excellent sound for the money — about all you need is basic soldering skills, a hot glue gun, and a screwdriver. A few hours of assembly gets you speakers comparable to those that retail for twice as much (or more).
September 21st, 2006 at 11:10 am
I experimented this summer with making my own herbal tea blend. From the herb garden I dried various mints, lemon verbena and lemon balm, and added dried rose petals (deep red and fragrant)and dried raspberry cane leaves (for color and body). It turned out pretty well! I think the key was drying and test-tasting each component separately so I could decide what to use. The chamomile flowers I dried were so bitter I had to spit out the resulting tea.
I will enjoy sipping this tea on our cold winter nights and thinking ahead to next year’s garden possibilities.
September 22nd, 2006 at 7:38 am
While I like doing (and would like to do) any number of these things, I think there are very practical results from doing things yourself quite apart from the enjoyment and even the money-saving factor. The more you get into doing these things, the more you hone your attitude. Making things yourself adjusts your attitude vis-a-vis commodity society; it makes you less interested in its blandishments, more resourceful about ways to fill your time, and so forth. I’m not saying people should do things that they hate. But even if my homemade socks are more expensive than the bottom-line store-bought version, the way in which making them affects my attitude is going to serve me better in the long run–and save me more–than buying them (plus, yes, I enjoy it). This is not a hypothetical; I’ve seen this happen in my life again and again.
September 25th, 2006 at 10:05 am
[...] DIY: Buying It vs. Making It Yourself [...]