If you're new here, you may want to learn what this site is about. I encourage you to subscribe to my RSS feed. Thanks for visiting!
Saving money doesn’t have to be dull. It’s possible to be too frugal, to deny yourself too much. It doesn’t have to be that way. You can enjoy the good life — eating out, spending time with friends, indulging yourself — while exercising thrift. The key is balance.
One way to practice financial prudence while living the good life is to buy quality products, products that are a pleasure to use, products that will last a lifetime. Over the past two years, I’ve compiled a list of companies that sell wonderful products. All of these companies provide quality goods via mail order. All of them have web sites from which you may order their products. Not all of them provide a means for requesting a print catalog. (I’ve provided a link to each company’s catalog request page, if one exists.)
I don’t receive any sort of compensation for touting these company’s products. (Though I’d take it if I could.)
Clothing
- David Morgan (Seattle, 1962) is an an outfit from which one can buy products produced by several of the companies (Filson, Akubra, etc.) listed elsewhere in this entry. (Good website, catalog available.)
- Filson (Seattle, 1897, “Might as well have the best”) for outdoor clothing, hats, bags, and accessories. I own two Filson hats, a Filson vest, a Filson jacket, and a Filson bag. Each piece was moderately spendy, but well worth it. Filson makes high quality products. (Great website, catalog available.)
- The J. Peterman Company (Kentucky) for expensive, oddball pieces of clothing. But still stuff I want. Who wouldn’t want Italian genius pants? (Good website, catalog available.)
- Woolrich (Pennsylvania, 1830, “The original outdoor clothing company”) for outdoor clothing. I am not familiar with this company, but look forward to browsing their catalog. (Good webiste, catalog available.)
- L.L. Bean (Maine, 1912) for clothing. I’ve always been aware of L.L. Bean, but have rarely purchased anything from them. (Good website, catalogs available.)
- Kevin’s (Georgia, 1979, “Fine outdoor gear and apparel”) for outdoor clothing and hunting supplies. This catalog came yesterday. It contains several things I want (but do not need): canvas trousers, a pocketwatch, etc. (Good website, catalog available.)
- Patagonia (California, 1965, “Committed to the core”) for active outdoor clothing and gear. I bought one piece of Patagonia gear at the last REI clearance sale. It has served me well. (Good website, catalog available.)
- Mountain Equipment Co-op (Canada, 1971) for outdoor clothing and gear in Canada. (Good website, catalog available.)
- Devold (Norway, 1853, “Quality outdoor clothing”) for, well, quality outdoor clothing. I’ve only glanced at Devold’s web site, and cannot tell what to think of their offerings. (Fair website, no catalog.)
- Barbour (England, 1894) for outdoor clothing. After browsing the catalog, I don’t think this company’s stuff is for me. Looks very expensive. (Fair website, catalog available though it lists no prices.)
- Holland & Holland (London, 1835) for upscale outdoorswear. Looks similar to Barbour. Again, not my type. (Fair website, no catalog.)
- Le Chameau (France, 1927) for hunting clothes and riding gear. See last two comments. (Fair website, no catalog.)
- French Creek Sheep and Wool Company (Pennsylvania, 1970) for woolen coats and sweaters. These are a bit too wooly for me. (Poor website, catalog available in theory.)
- Pendleton Woolen Mills (Portland, 1909, “Good for life”) for shirts and blankets. I own one Pendleton hat; I wear it all the time. I’ve owned Pendleton shirts, and have always been impressed. (Great website, catalog available.)
- Timberland (Boston, no specific date, “Make it better”) for boots. My only exposure to Timberland is through the pair of work boots I bought last fall. They’ve served me well during the past year, and I’d be happy to purchase Timberland again. (Decent website, catalog available)
Accessories
- Hartmann (Tennessee, 1877) for luggage. They even have some cases that George Bailey might have liked. (Good website, catalog available.)
- Duluth Pack (Duluth, 1882) for bags, packs, and camping gear. The web site has some keen-looking stuff. (Good website, catalog available.)
- Tilley Endurables (Toronto, 1984) for hats and travel clothing. I intend to order at least one Tilley hat before the end of the year. I admire their products. (Good website, catalog available.)
- Akubra Hats (Australia, 1874) for hats. Many of these look too, well, Aussie for me, but I’m willing to spend more time at the site. Lord knows I love hats. (Poor website, no catalog.)
- Geier Glove (Seattle, 1927) for gloves. These gloves look durable and stylish. (Good website, no catalog.)
- Hardy (England, 1879, “Tackling the world”) for fishing supplies. I’m not a fisherman, but some of this stuff still looks appealing. (Fair website, no catalog.)
- Frost River (Duluth, “Reliable softgoods”) for all sorts of outdoor supplies. This would probably be a good place to stock up on camping equipment. (Good website, catalog available.)
- Bosca (Ohio, “Accessories in leather”) for leather goods. All of Bosca’s stuff looks tempting. (Fair website, no catalog.)
- Breitling (Switzerland, 1884, “Instruments for professionals”) for watches. I’m not sure these are the sorts of watches I want. I’d love a pocketwatch! (Terrible website, no catalog.)
Furniture, Etc.
- Gandolfini (England, 1885) for large-format cameras. In my dream world (the world where I have unlimited funds), I’d shoot only large format. (Poor website, no catalog.)
- Apple Computer (California, 1976) for high-quality geek products. (Excellent website, including on-line store.)
- Stickley (New York, 1900, “Collector quality furniture since 1900″) for furniture. I’m currently shopping for a new chair for my library. I’ve considered a Stickley piece. (Decent website with fun extras (including a video tour), catalogs available for a price.)
Paper Products, Etc.
- Waterman (Paris, 1883) for pens. I’ve never purchased and expensive pen of any sort. (I’d probably lose one if I did.) I don’t know if the extra cost purchases extra quality. (Weak website, no catalog.)
- My father-in-law recommends Fountain Pen Hospital (New York, 1946, “The showcase of fine writing instruments”) for “many brands of high end fountain pens and other writing instruments. You will no longer think that Waterman pens are expensive after visiting this site.” (Good website, catalog available.)
- Moleskine notebooks are fantastic, but there is no one centralized source for infromation on them. (This site is good.) Last April I bought ~20 moleskines for 50% off at a going-out-of-business sale. I was in heaven.
- Smythson of Bond Street (London, 1887) for paper products, including bespoke stationery and featherweight paper. Expensive, but appealing. (Good website, catalog available.)
- Dempsey & Carroll (New York, 1878) is another stationeer. I’m tempted to try them. (Decent website, no catalog.)
- Library of America (New York, 1979, “America’s best and most significant writing in durable and authoritative editions”) for classic American books. I own several LoA volumes, and have been impressed by each. (Great website, catalog available, subscription available.)
- Fantagraphics Books (Seattle, 1976) is an outstanding publisher of graphic novels and comic-strip reprints, including The Complete Peanuts. (Great website, catalog available.)
- The Criterion Collection for feature-laden, authoritative film transfers to DVD. If you must ever choose between a Criterion version of a film and a non-Criterion version, choose the former. My Criterion edition of Rushmore is a treasure. (Decent website, no catalog.)
- History Shots (Boston, 2004?) creates wonderful timelines and charts. They currently have ten prints available. I own Race to the Moon and History of U.S. Political Parties. I covet the others, including the most recent: The Genealogy of Pop and Rock Music. (Fantastic website, which incorporates an on-line catalog.)
Foodstuffs
- Bob’s Red Mill (Portland, “Whole grain foods for every meal of the day”) for inexpensive, quality cereals, flours, and more. I just visited the actual Bob’s Red Mill store last weekend &mash; it is barely five miles from my home — and bought a case of my favorite cereal. (Great website, no catalog.)
- Glory Bee Foods (Eugene, 1979) for natural foods and crafts. Excellent honey. (Good website, catalog available.)
- Penzeys Spices (Wisconsin) for herbs, spices, and other kitchen goodness. (Fair website, catalog available.)
It might seem outrageous to pay $200 for a Filson bag when you can pick up a cheap generic bag for $10 at a thrift store. But that $190 packs a lot of wallop. My Filson bag is one of my most prized possessions. The key is to not devote yourself to these luxury goods. Don’t buy these all the time. (And don’t go into debt to buy them.) These are treats. These are things with which to reward yourself. But if you buy one or two nice items a year, it doesn’t take long to build a collection that will last a lifetime.
If you want the best of both worlds — quality goods at frugal prices — use eBay to locate used items from these companies. For example, you might search for vintage Woolrich.
If you know of other sources of quality goods, please let me know. I’d especially love to find a source for globes.
Reader Suggestions
- Birkenstock (US) (Germany, 1897) for quality footwear. I’ve worn these every summer for over 15 years. (Fair website, no catalog.)
- Crane & Co. (Massachusetts, 1801) for stationary, paper goods, and desk accessories. This stuff looks awesome. (Good website, no catalog.)
.jpg)

September 26th, 2006 at 6:44 am
I am a big supporter of quality products. Sure, you sometimes pay more, but you save money in the long run by not having to buy a new item every year. Cheap equals disposable in my book. I love MEC. We’re lucky to have a store in Halifax. I bought a purse and a bookbag there. The prices are good and I know it will last a long time. I also don’t skimp when it comes to shoes. Anything that is going to get a lot of use is worth spending the extra money on.
September 26th, 2006 at 6:59 am
Excellent list - thank you! I have recently begun to change over to buying quality. It means I buy less (because I can’t afford as many items) and also that I think about each purchase more, because I know I’ll be living with it for a long time.
I second the endorsement of Library of American. I joined their subscription service and set my frequency of new books to every 90 days. This puts the cost at about 10 bucks a month, and I am gradually building up a library of quality books. (Plus, every 90 days lets me keep read each one before the new one comes in.)
I’d also like to throw in an endorsement for Moleskine notebooks. They’re more expensive than standard school supply notebooks (about $10 for the pocket size, $15 for the larger size), but they’re more durable, look better, and have better quality paper. If you are a list-maker, note-taker, or journal -keeper (I am all three), you’ll rapidly find your Moleskines becoming indispensable companions.
September 26th, 2006 at 7:04 am
I thought J. Peterman was a creation of the writers of Seinfeld… I had no idea that the company actually exists.
September 26th, 2006 at 7:06 am
My mother’s side of the family is very New England, making LL Bean a staple for us–not so much for clothes as for everything else, though, for me. Their tote bags are basically indestructible, and their backpacks are the best around. I would presume their clothes probably fall into the same categories.
Their guarantee is famous–until the item has worn out and you’re still satisfied with it, you can return it. I wouldn’t know how well they honor it, because I’ve never had to return anything.
September 26th, 2006 at 7:16 am
Great list.
What about Birkenstocks? The most comfortable and hardwearing sandles in the world.
September 26th, 2006 at 7:21 am
September 26th, 2006 at 8:04 am
I love Birks! I bought my first pair this summer, and they were not on sale, but well worth it. I wish we had L.L. Bean in Canada. I am too cheap to pay for shipping and customs
September 26th, 2006 at 8:32 am
Count me among the Birks devotees.
There is a catalog through Birkenstock Express (find it here http://www.birkenstockexpress.com/Forms/catalogrequest.cfm/id.260920060823-496157). Their website has a bargains page (find it here http://www.birkenstockexpress.com/Discounts/sale.cfm/topnav2.231/id.260920060823-496157) — just a quick glance at my shoe size reveals a pair regularly priced at $170 marked down to $77. As an added bonus, Birkenstock Express is a local (for me, anyway) company with stores in Portland, Corvallis, and Eugene.
September 26th, 2006 at 9:15 am
Careful with Birks - I love them and wear them all the time, but they’re expensive and I go through a pair in about a year. (My current pair, bought about a year ago, has very rusty buckles and the soles are coming apart from the main body of the sandle).
September 26th, 2006 at 1:25 pm
What, no mention of Crane’s (www.crane.com) for stationery? What a travesty!
September 26th, 2006 at 1:40 pm
I got a Waterman Phileas fountain pen through Fountain Pen Hospital. I’m not a hardcore pen junkie, but I like fountain pens.
Ye gods. The pen is AMAZING. I get little thrills of joy every time I use it, because it’s smooth and lovely and makes my handwriting better.
Then again, I’m the kind of person who doesn’t lose My Pens. I still have one that’s nearly eight years old, though the cap has disintegrated.
Other pricey luxuries that are nevertheless worth it: for perfume people, Black Phoenix Alchemy Lab. Thinky perfume people, at least. They’re very involved scents.
September 26th, 2006 at 1:45 pm
This article reminded me of a similar ‘Cheap Vs. Frugal’ comparison awhile back at iwillteachyoutoberich.com.
I generally err on the cheap side until I get burned or see recommendations like the above. One of my personal must-haves is very simple: good Orange Juice. I don’t need super-premium $5 a cup Odwalla…but Tropicana is so much better than the generic milk-gallon store brand that I don’t mind paying extra. Plus, whenever I get the cheap stuff it inevitably sits in the fridge until it gets stale and I just throw it out. And that’s not saving me any in the long term…
Link to the cheap vs. frugal is…
http://www.iwillteachyoutoberich.com/archives/2005/09/cheap_versus_fr.html
September 26th, 2006 at 2:18 pm
I second the love for Crane’s. One day I am going to buy nothing but their navy initial correspondance cards.
http://www.crane.com/prdSell.aspx?Name=cc30z1_InitalCards
And every once in awhile, I’ll spend the extra $3 and get an artisanal, high-cacao, chocolate bar. Soooo gooood.
September 26th, 2006 at 4:53 pm
If it’s good, buy two (or three).
I got a pair of nice solid rockports in 1998 or so. They have a solid leather upper and a rubber sole, with a removeable insole.
I first wore them to church and formal school events, then to school, then everywhere, and then for camping and hiking. They always cleaned up well, and held up great. They’ve gotten wet and been dried out so many times…
Now, 8 years later the upper is still in great condition, but the bottom is nearly worn through. Rockport still has what is supposed to be the same model, but the leather isn’t as good and it doesn’t seem as sturdy.
The replacement shoes I bought this spring (not Rockports) had the sole separate from the uppers in less than a month, and I didn’t even take them hiking.
When you find something well made, buy two if you can. When that thing finally wears out, you may not be able to find a suitable replacement.
September 26th, 2006 at 9:53 pm
Don’t forget that manufacturers like the ones listed here often offer lifetime warranties on their wares. REAL lifetime warranites, not like the pseudo lifetime warranties you see on infomercials. I used to buy all of my backpacks and luggage from Eddie Bauer. When the bag would start to wear out or any part of it broke I would bring it back to the store and they would happily give me a new one.
I agree- buy value, not cheap stuff.
September 26th, 2006 at 10:37 pm
[...] Read: The Good Stuff - Get Rich Slowly [...]
October 2nd, 2006 at 1:12 am
[...] I’m a little suspicious of that store owner, though. For instance, the store had a special on oxen where they were 25% off. Fortunately I found out before buying them that the 25% off also applied to the oxen–they only had three legs! So I decided to go with quality over price and opted for 20 four-legged oxen. [...]
October 3rd, 2006 at 9:28 am
[...] Sept. 26th: The good stuff: Choosing quality over price [...]
November 15th, 2006 at 2:26 pm
If you’re tired of your Birks, try Mephistos - my family all wore Birks forever, but my mum finally got a pair of Mephistos and we haven’t looked back. Also European, they are slightly more expensive (around $150 CAD I believe), but they offer much-improved arch support, many styles and colors, and they seem to wear better. I also like that they don’t make my feet look as wide as in my Birks! Try the ‘Helen’ style for a classic, elegant summer sandal - I love mine in the brown pebbled leather.
December 6th, 2006 at 4:46 am
Wonderful to stumble onto your site after secretly shopping for filson + clothing + second hand. It is great to come accross a kindred spirit who has exactly the same take on consumerism as I do; if you are going to splurge, make sure it’s on stuff that’s good and that will last! And Filson is way ahead in the indestructibility game so buying it second hand is usually a safe bet. (here I go spilling the beans and creating competition… oh well!)
December 14th, 2006 at 7:46 pm
I will no longer think that fountain pens are expensive ever again after this site I will KNOW they are expensive. Is that what you meant? =)
December 17th, 2006 at 7:27 pm
I agree with AC, mephisto shoes are quite expensive(an average pair of men’s dress shoes is about $250 US), but its quality is superb. personally i only wear mephisto and ECCO, to me ECCO is just as comfortable as mephisto, and they are comparatively more stylish than the classic styles carried by mephisto. I have had a pair of birks and they didn’t adjust to my feet quite well, perhaps i recommend trying on all 3 brands and decide yourself.
For fountain pens, i think the author meant that you wouldn’t find “waterman” pens expensive after comparing with names like montblanc and ST dupont(the obvious), along with rest of the exotic names like Omas, Aurora, Visconti, Montagrappa, Pelikan, Nekki, etc. the limited edition/special edition ones have appreciation potential, therefore their prices are at least in the high hundres to even several hundred thousand(eg, montblanc 2002 release: year of the golden dragon 8, only 8 pieces were produced). For myself, i have a montblanc 149 with the matching desktop set(inkwell, pen holder) from the 80s, still a smooth writer. When i’m on the move, i use the stylish Smythson sterling silver fountain pen (by Yard-o-led) that i picked up from England last year, couldn’t have been happier.
March 5th, 2007 at 7:45 am
March 22nd, 2007 at 6:48 am
If you’re going to mention L.L. Bean, you need to also include Lands’ End. Amazing quality at amazingly reasonable prices.
March 22nd, 2007 at 6:34 pm
Personally, I don’t think Waterman’s quality lives up to the price. I recommend Pelikan and Montegrappa. Yeah, they’re pricey, but take care of them and you’ll love them forever. Don’t buy one of Montblanc’s resin pens if you think there’s a chance you’ll ever drop it–they crack or even shatter if dropped on a hard surface.
For personal stationery, I love Pineider.
March 22nd, 2007 at 9:45 pm
Try http://www.oscarbraunpens.com for some of the best pen prices around. No affiliation, but a frequent (too frequent, for a frugal-aspirant!) and happy customer.
Pelikans and Moleskines are sweet, and like the value of laser printers over inkjet ones, I think fountain pens are a better deal over the long run than disposable (ballpoint) pens.
Crane’s is just a treat.
June 4th, 2007 at 7:01 am
[...] also begun to purchase quality items. So much of what we threw away Saturday was cheap and shoddy. It’s worthless. Now, for [...]