Phishing Scams in Plain English
Published on - November 18th, 2008 (Modified on - November 23rd, 2008) (by J.D. Roth) Internet con artists are clever. Even smart people can be duped sometimes. Even those who keep active watch against scams and schemes can make mistakes.
As I checked e-mail this morning, I was baffled by a notice from Paypal. “Your eCheck payment of $29.90 USD to jdroth@xxxx.com has been deposited into your recipient’s account,” the message read. But why would I be paying myself? “Do you know what this is?” I asked Kris. “Why are we sending money to ourselves?”
“Isn’t that spam?” she asked.
Oh. Of course. Normally, that would have been my first instinct, too, but for a few minutes there, I had relaxed my guard, had opened myself up to be a victim of “phishing”.
Phishing scams in plain English
What is phishing? As penance for nearly committing an internet sin, I made myself re-watch Common Craft’s Phishing Scams in Plain English, which explains how these scams operate, and how best to protect yourself:
You’ve probably seen it. You receive an e-mail from your bank or trusted company, and it’s asking you for information. It looks real, but it’s designed to fool you into handing over important information. This is a scam called phishing, and you need to avoid it. This is Phishing Scams in Plain English.
This video suggests several ways to minimize the risk of being scammed:
- Deal directly with organizations you trust.
- “Always be suspicious of an e-mail that asks for your information. No exceptions!”
- Don’t panic if you receive a suspicious e-mail. There’s no risk to just getting the mail; problems only occur when you respond to phishing attempts.
- Never click a link or fill out a form in an e-mail from your bank, etc. Always navigate directly to the site.
- Forward the suspicious e-mail to reportfishing@antiphishing.gov or spam@uce.gov. (Update: Carrie writes to say that this is the correct e-mail for reporting phishing attempts: phishing-report@us-cert.gov.)
On a related note, my mother sometimes has trouble differentiating hoax warnings from the real thing. Fortunately, she’s learned to use and trust Snopes.com, the urban legends reference site. The Snopes fraud and scams section is a useful resource.
I also think it’s important to periodically review the basics of how to prevent identity theft.
Safe and sound
My story has a mundane ending. The message I received from Paypal wasn’t spam, and it wasn’t phishing — it was a real message, but poorly worded. The $29.90 wasn’t paid to me, but from me to another company.
This could just as easily have been a phishing attempt, however, and I had let my guard down. Despite my constant vigilance, and my frequent warnings to others, I’d suffered a momentary lapse, and that’s all it takes to become a victim.
More about Common Craft
At Common Craft, Lee and Sachi LeFever create short and simple videos to explain complex ideas. You may have seen their work in the past:
- RSS in Plain English
- Twitter in Plain English
- Web Search Strategies in Plain English
- Electing a U.S. President in Plain English
- And, of course, Zombies in Plain English
As their videos have become more successful, the LeFevers have not only been able to make producing them a full-time job, but they’ve also expanded the subjects they cover. They’ve even begun to feature topics related to personal finance, such as compact fluorescent light bulbs. I shared Phishing Scams in Plain English with their permission.
GRS is committed to helping our readers save and achieve your financial goals.Savings interest rates may be low, but that’s all the more reason to shop for the best rate.Find the highest savings interest rate from Ally Bank, Capital One 360, Everbank, and more.
This article is about Odds and Ends
Disclaimer: This content is not provided or commissioned by American Express. Opinions expressed here are author's alone, not those of American Express, and have not been reviewed, approved or otherwise endorsed by American Express. This site may be compensated through American Express Affiliate Program.
Discover is a paid advertiser of this site. Reasonable efforts are made to maintain accurate information. See the Discover online credit card application for full terms and conditions on offers and rewards.
SEARCH FOR RECENT ARTICLES



For me the big giveaway is almost always, Dear Valued Customer or some such thing. Most emails now will put your name in there.
loading....
I wrote a post a while back on how to deal with a phisher: http://weakonomics.com/2008/09/29/how-to-deal-with-a-phisher/
JD, did you hear about the lady that was duped out of $400k by a phisher? She’s located in Sweet Home, OR. What a great name for a town.
loading....
I happen to get quite a bit of phishing attempts in the fake e-mail account I set up for use at websites that require registration that I don’t necessarily want to have my real info. That is the first step in avoiding phishing scams: giving your real information to only a select few sites that you trust.
Another way to identify scams is to look at the sender’s e-mail address. Most of the time, the address is coming from a free e-mail service, which should throw off red flags right from the start. Besides sending the sender’s info to the government, also send the information to the isp’s anti-spam unit. While they may not be able to permanently stop such scams, they are more likely able to trace the ip address of the sender and ban them, which helps a little.
I go a little more in depth in a past blog post regarding indentity protection called Do you really need to pay for identity protection?
loading....
I’m just curious why you have advertisements on your site for getting rich in just 7 years…
loading....
I have come across a few of these in my time. None from paypal though, a few from banks and a lot saying that I have inherited over $1,000,000 in some country I have never heard of.
Scams are to be avoided at all costs. They all play on the ‘money for nothing’ mentality that so many of us possess. We want money but we don’t want to do anything for it
loading....
Once I ignored a bunch of emails from ebay, thinking they were scams, because they asked me to change my credit card info. Then one time when I logged in, they had charged me $20 for not paying the tiny fees on an item I had sold for $10. I complained and explained that I thought the emails were a scam, and they dropped the charge. But I learned my lesson and will always check my account on the website when I get emails like that!
loading....
When you know it’s spam make sure you forward it to the company it supposedly came from so they can take action.
If I get one that’s questionable, I sign into my account through my web browser – Never click on an e-mail link!!!!!!! Then I can tell if it’s legitimate correspondence or spam. I always err on the side of spam just to be safe.
loading....
Susy beat me to my advice, banks like to know when phishers are using their info!
Also, be aware of the security procedures your financial institution uses.
For example, my credit union has a secret word that I selected which is displayed along with a unique graphic on any page I am logged into on their site. This means if I’m ever asked to log in somewhere and I DO NOT see that secret symbol that I’ve been scammed and should report it to my bank immediately.
loading....
Good post. I especially enjoyed the video tutorial. The phishing scams have gotten out of control. But even though they are more common now, it is tragic to see that some people still fall victim to this.
loading....
mozilla’s thunderbird email program has some useful features that help you to identify phishing. it puts up a warning on suspicious emails, and if you hover your pointer over a link in an email, it shows the actual target address in the little info bar at the bottom of the page.
loading....
Just today, I received an email from the IRS regarding a refund. Ha! I almost fell for it! I directed it to phishing@irs.gov
loading....
I take Internet scams, or any kind of consumer fraud, seriously and always try to update my readers with new findings. They always come up with innovative technics to fool you. So you need to be on top of everything. In my book “Invest Now” I dedicated a whole chapter to Internet Scams. Here is a link to all scam related articles readers may find useful. http://adawnjournal.com/?s=scams
Cheers,
A Dawn Journal
loading....
I’ve seen some pretty clever ones, very professional looking. The last one I remember was supposedly from Bank of America regarding my bill pay account, only I don’t use bill pay! It all looked legit except for the web address wasn’t bank of america. I get phishing scams supposedly from paypal all the time too, again I don’t use paypal so I know they are fakes but someone else might not realize.
loading....
Hoax-slayer.com and scamorama.com are also good resources for IDing scams.
Nigerian scams are tangentially related to phishing, but there are some pretty funny sites featuring people who reverse the scams. Some convinced the scammers to get tattoos, and one scammer even wrote out Harry Potter by hand.
http://oddorama.com/2008/02/11/scamming-the-scammers-5-brilliant-419-reverse-scams/
loading....
Forward Paypal phishing e-mails to “spoof@paypal.com”. They will try to track down the culprits. On my new computer now, with Vista, Internet Explorer tells me if a site I am trying to go to is a phishing site. There are a number of good things about Vista!
loading....
Hoax-slayer.com and scamorama.com are also good resources for IDing scams.
Nigerian scams are tangentially related to phishing, but there are some pretty funny sites featuring people who reverse the scams. Some convinced the scammers to get tattoos, and one scammer even wrote out Harry Potter by hand.
http://419eater.com/html/joyce_ozioma.htm
loading....
Outside of learning about spam, scams, phishing etc. and making educated choices, I am a firm believer in proactive defense.
Programs such as Spybot S&D, SpywareBlaster and the mvps.org host file all block many known malicious sites.
I use firefox with NoScript (though this may be more hassle than it is worth to some users).
Get a toolbar or add-on that checks the validity of sites you are on:
Netcraft Toolbar
McAfee SiteAdvisor
WoT (firefox addon)
Then if you really aren’t sure, and choose to click the link rather than manually navigate to the same place – copy the address and scan it here:
http://linkscanner.explabs.com/linkscanner/default.aspx
loading....
@Mom (#15)
Hi, Mom!
(I’ve always wanted to do that. And yes, that’s really my mother.)
loading....
Ok, my fav part of the embedded video is that the crook’s laugh sounds an AWFUL lot like Jon Stewart’s impersonation of George W Bush!
loading....
remember people that almost no official business is transacted via email, never send personal info via email, and always check your websites urls for giveaways, like instead of www, you see wwt or some such, that is another type of phishing (counterfeit web sites)
loading....
This week I got TWO Nigerian Scam emails, which is bad because I’m tempted to pull a scambaiter on them….
loading....
When I used to get a lot of phishing, I would just type in a made-up username and password.
loading....
What a timely post. I received an email from ‘paypail.com’ (notice the spelling) this morning telling me that my account was limited and that I would need to send them confidential information. Just as ‘Mom’ said, make sure to forward all suspicious PayPal emails to spoof@paypal.com. They are generally really great about replying quickly.
loading....
If you can, set up you’re e-mail account only to accept recognized e-mails. Otherwise, only open e-mails from friends and family. Also never open/read an attachment. View your e-mails as 99% junk and advertisement not worth opening.
Also hang up the phone on anyone that is trying to sell you something, or wants you to pay for something. All phone calls should be screened.
loading....
In addition to my earlier post (17), I would recommend the Firefox extension Flagfox. This, like the Netcraft toolbar, will show the country of origin of the website you are on. It will warn you if you reach an address purporting to be from one place, but really in another.
I also suggest that people set up another email account, if not multiple through a service designed for it, so that they can give friends/family their personal email, have one for use with banks/work/trusted places, and one for use at other sites and purchases.
Bugmenot.com is a nice resource for not having to bypass giving out your email too often (I use it to read online newspapers or some forum posts you cant see unless signed in).
loading....
Like many computer savvy people I always thought I was immune to phishing scams, but two years ago I fell for the exact one that JD is describing in his post. The difference was my message actually was a phishing scam. I was tired and had just woken up so I overreacted to the idea that PayPal had associated a charge with my account in error. Since I rarely used PayPal and hadn’t for a very long time I wanted to “follow up” right that second and filled out the information form presented to me despite several obvious warning signs that it was a scam.
It caught up with me just this summer when my credit card number was finally pulled out of whatever scammer’s database it had been sitting in. I was able to catch the fraud and shut down the activity very early (within 12 hours thanks in part to very pro-active and appreciated actions from the customer service department at Crutchfield). Even within that short timeframe more than $4,000.00 worth of charges were already approved from a number of online stores. Discover was quick and helpful and I was not liable for any of the charges of course, but it was both a hassle and lesson that frame of mind can overrule common sense even for informed net users.
To this day I’m still paying for optional credit monitoring and fraud protection services because I’m paranoid that something else will be done with the information stolen from me that day, such as opening a new line of credit. The event shook me up and left lasting damage to the confidence I have in security of my personal information.
loading....
I certainly know better than to provide information based on an email, but sometimes I have trouble distinguishing whether or not an email actually came from a business I’m involved with. My husband (who knows a lot more about this stuff than I do) always tells me that a good way to double-check if something is spam or not is to let your mouse hover over any link in the email (DO NOT CLICK – just hover). The web address for that link will show up at the bottom of your browser. If it doesn’t belong to the company, I know it’s spam. If it does, I can go ahead and click to see what information they are providing.
loading....
Hi JD, I just thought I would point out that the government email address is actually “reportphishing@antiphishing.gov”, not “reportfishing@antiphishing.gov”.
loading....
Never believe anything in an email, simple as that.
No company that I deal with communicates via email (at least not to me) so if I get an email, it’s phoney. I’ve stopped receiving paper bank statements but for serious communication that requires a response I get a letter or a phone call if it’s urgent.
Online communication is for fun only. The internet is a dirty, dirty place and the negative aspects of it massively outnumber the positive.
loading....
I just got an email from a reader that is an even more dangerous scam involving debit cards and home delivery. You can read all the details here – http://www.savingtoinvest.com/2008/11/falling-for-4000-debit-card-scam.html (sorry for the link, but too much detail to write in this comment) it was so easy and so simple. Coming into the holidays, this scam is likely to spread so please be careful online and offline!
loading....
Thanks a bunch for sharing the video and links J.D.!
loading....
A friend at work got a very similar email this morning. We was ready to click on the link in the eamil and login when I stopped him.
http://www.WeLearnAsWeGo.com
loading....