Every month, my wife and I track how much time and money we spend growing food. This is the report for September 2009. (Here are the results for 2008.)
After a long productive summer, our September in the garden was kind of anticlimactic. Sure, we continued to harvest our home-grown food, but neither of us was particularly “in” to the garden this month. It was a chore instead of an obsession. September can be that way sometimes.
Still, there’s always something happening with our home food production. This month:
- We’ve been harvesting lots of apples and plums. It took four or five years, but our Jonathan apple tree has finally turned productive. We pulled down nearly 40 pounds of apples this year! And the plum tree was loaded.
- The blackberries are still producing, but we’re sick of them. I can hardly believe I’m saying that (blackberries are my favorite), but I’ve had enough berries. And besides, they’re not very good this late in the season. We stopped harvesting them long ago.
- Kris has been using her food dehydrator to preserve lots of dried pears and plums. This is a great way to extend the harvest and to provide fruit for snacking during the winter. (We also canned lots of applesauce and pickles.)
- As threatened, we tore out the old blueberry plants. They’re over 25 and their production has slowed tremendously. I’ll tear out the gooseberries next weekend. We’ll buy some new blueberries to replace these plants.
Now we’re just waiting for the grapes to ripen (soon, very soon) and the harvest season is done. Kris and I are both disappointed that, for us, this has been the Summer of No Corn. We didn’t grow any ourselves, and we didn’t have another convenient source. When people did give us corn, it was terrible. Ah well — there’s always next year.
But what you really want to know is how much we “earned” from our garden in September, right? Here’s this month’s tally:
- 37.00 pounds (16.798kg) apples @ $0.99/pound = $36.63
- 2.51 pounds (1.140kg) pears @ $0.99/pound = $2.48
- 5.57 pounds (2.528kg) Italian plums @ $1.49/pound = $8.30
- 0.69 pounds (0.315kg) caneberries (blackberries, etc.) @ $2.49/pint = $2.61
- 1.01 pounds (0.460kg) grapes @ $3.00/pound = $3.04
- 0.61 pounds (0.278kg) green beans @ $2.49/pound = $1.52
- 64 cucumbers @ $1.29/pound (about 5 cukes) = $16.51
- 29 chili peppers @ $0.29/each = $8.41
- 18 squash @ $0.99/each = $17.82
- 27.46 pounds (12.468kg) tomatoes @ $1.99/pound = $54.65
As always, we also enjoyed some of the harvest from our friends and neighbors. We obtained 28 pounds of plums from other folks, a bunch of onions from my cousin, and about 30 pounds of fresh-caught salmon and halibut from the millionaire next door when he returned from Alaska. (And Tina offered us as much corn as we wanted, but we weren’t able to pick it.) This “free” food isn’t included in the totals below.
Here are this year’s totals through the end of September:
| Month | Time | Cost | Harvest | Month | Time | Cost | Harvest | |
| Jan 09 | 3.0 hrs | $131.15 | — | Jan 08 | 4.0 hrs | $27.30 | — | |
| Feb 09 | 12.0 hrs | $36.67 | $10.00 | Feb 08 | 2.5 hrs | — | — | |
| Mar 09 | 4.0 hrs | $1.00 | $5.00 | Mar 08 | 3.5 hrs | $130.00 | — | |
| Apr 09 | 3.0 hrs | — | — | Apr 08 | 5.5 hrs | $28.51 | — | |
| May 09 | 15.0 hrs | $98.55 | $5.97 | May 08 | 5.5 hrs | $110.89 | — | |
| Jun 09 | 7.0 hrs | — | $78.37 | Jun 08 | 7.0 hrs | $0.79 | $50.83 | |
| Jul 09 | 7.0 hrs | — | $243.10 | Jul 08 | 11.0 hrs | $20.94 | $123.68 | |
| Aug 09 | 12.0 hrs | — | $186.33 | Aug 08 | 8.0 hrs | — | $123.94 | |
| Sep 09 | 2.5 hrs | — | $151.97 | Sep 08 | 2.0 hrs | — | $152.75 | |
| Total 09 | 65.5 hrs | $267.37 | $680.74 | Total 08 | 49.0 hrs | $318.43 | $451.20 |
I’m a little worried about October. Last year, we harvested over $150 in produce because the tomato season lingered. This year, though, tomatoes are essentially over. Kris and I don’t expect to harvest much more than we already have. Who knows, though…maybe we’ll be surprised. Still, our harvest total for the year is already greater than our total for all of 2008, so we’ve made improvements!
Final word
This garden project is not a formal experiment. Kris and I are long-time hobby gardeners, and we have set ways that we do things. This year, we’re trying to incorporate some new ideas from GRS readers, but most of the time we’ll do things the way we have for nearly 15 years.
We’re not trying to be 100% organic (though we are mostly organic through our normal practices). Nor are we trying to be 100% frugal. Instead, we’re trying to see just what our garden costs and produces based on our normal habits. We hope the results of this experiment will help us find new ways to economize and to improve our crops.
You can read about my goals for this series in The year-long GRS project: How much does a garden really save?
This article is about Food, Frugality, House and Home Saturday, 3rd October 2009 (by J.D. Roth)


RSS Feeds
Facebook
GRS Twitter








October 3rd, 2009 at 7:28 am
Oh. tomatos.
We had an absolutely gorgeous tomato jungle, and then we caught whatever tomato blight is going up and down Ontario and the east coast, and everything died within a week. It was very tragic
October 3rd, 2009 at 8:10 am
Tomato jungle is the word for it! I have harvested roughly 500 pounds of tomatoes off of 13 bushes of Roma. I had six pepper plants for an average total of 80 peppers. I didnt keep exact count but I can sorta tell by the amount of salsa and relish I made this year. I have 70 quarts of salsa made which is equal to 8 batches. Each batch took 5 green bell peppers. Besides that I made 14 pints of garden relish that took about 8 peppers and gave peppers to girl friends for their salsa. I also froze a bunch.
My freezer is absolutly loaded with squash, green beans, green peppers, and broccoli. Between the four of them I have about 150 quarts of food all from my home garden.
I still have about 100 pounds of tomatoes hanging on the vine. Much of that is ready to pick. Anybody want tomotoes?
October 3rd, 2009 at 8:42 am
We had NO tomatoes here in NY -
But we had great peaches and now apple season is just wonderful. Neither my rosemary nor my thyme took — too much rain.
October 3rd, 2009 at 8:43 am
I’m curious, in the section of the garden that you pulled up - if you planted something like roses or sunflowers in the assumption that you would use them in place of some birthday bouquets or hostess gifts, would you consider that part of your harvest? Just an idea to add some color to your garden.
October 3rd, 2009 at 8:54 am
How do you value your time in this scenario? I really like the tracking of it. I often wonder the financial benefit of a garden. I guess if you were to value your time you also need to value your enjoyment, assuming you enjoy gardening.
I wrote a post on it a while back: http://evolutionofwealth.com/2009/07/13/how-do-you-value-your-time/
What are you thoughts?
October 3rd, 2009 at 9:36 am
This was the first year I have tried to garden on my own. Growing up I used to spend a lot of time at my grandmother’s who had Huuuuge gardens (think one physical tonne of potatoes).
So this year, my boyfriend Jordan and I gave it a go.
We decided to just go for things we liked, and then seewhat grew the best so we could plan for next year.
We wound up with
- about 20 lbs of potatoes
- a bread bag full of small carrots
- 14/15 tomoatoes (one tomoatoe plant)
- 2 pumpkins!
- 2 cabbages
- a great number of peas and leaf lettuce
Our pepper plant diddn’t produce. Not too sure wqhy at this point. We also lost a couple heads of cabage to bugs. We lost a few pumpkins who fell of the stems in a horrible rain storm we had a few months ago.
The carrots was my biggest learning. We didn’t thin them out properly so none of them got huge, but we wound up with lots of litle once. They will be sweet tasting I hope.
I’ve got a few pictures up at my blog (under category gardening).
October 3rd, 2009 at 9:53 am
It’s apple season here in San Francisco. Picking many of them today
The pear tree is all tapped out!
October 3rd, 2009 at 9:54 am
I love that you keep track of this in an easy to read/understand manner. I tried my hand at container gardening this summer and didn’t have much success, but I did it more for fun. Once my husband and I get into a house of our own I’d love to plant a small garden. I’m curious as to the size (square footage) of your garden. Thanks for sharing!
October 3rd, 2009 at 10:43 am
My gardening experiment is a bit different from most. I want to try to develop a cheap hydroponic garden setup that can allow urban dwellers in apartments to turn a tiny 3ft by 8ft balcony into a relatively productive hobby garden.
So this year my main goal was to see if I could keep plants alive through the whole season. It worked far better than I expected and now I regret not tracking my harvest as closely.
http://www.smallfish-bigpond.com/index.php?virtualpath=category/hydroponics/blogid/1
October 3rd, 2009 at 11:00 am
I’m a first time gardener with only 36 sq ft of raised beds. I got started with the warm season crops. I’ve tracked total costs and lbs of produce, plus number of tomatoes by plant. So far $534 and 45.1 lbs for a cost of almost $12 a pound. While that sounds ridiculous, most of the costs were start-up and won’t be repeated every season. Also as a southern californian I can garden year round, I’m in the process of planting cool season crops now.
I’ll be thrilled when my cost of produce gets to $1 a pound.
I enjoy your garden posts.
October 3rd, 2009 at 3:17 pm
do you see a garden effect on your grocery bills? Are they less this year than last? If so, you could add those non-expended funds to the profit of the garden. Or does the garden produce end up as “extras” in your diet?
October 3rd, 2009 at 3:55 pm
J.D., I’d like to hear more about Kris’ food drying - what kind of dehydrator, etc. This is something I’m trying to get into myself. I already do some herbs, but not foods yet.
October 3rd, 2009 at 8:13 pm
I love reading your garden posts. I have to say that I was overjoyed when we had our first frost the other day. My squash plants are finally dead, and I don’t have to feel guilty anymore about not keeping up. On the other hand, my tomatoes were just starting to come on after a very bad start so, although I covered them, there just isn’t enough time for them to ripen, and they aren’t big enough to try to ripen inside, although I may give it a shot.
October 3rd, 2009 at 11:30 pm
Kerensky: fascinated by the hydroponics entries, especially the size of the hydro plants to the ground-garden ones. Any idea what you spent on startup equipment?
October 4th, 2009 at 4:55 am
Hmm, if you’re mostly organic, your food prices aren’t reflecting it. At least here in MN, apples are at least $3.50/lb this time of year, same with pears. Tomatoes are more, and heirloom tomatoes are way more, like $5/lb. I don’t know if you just have cheaper organic there (lucky!) or if you’re not quite comparing apples to apples. Or if you spray enough items to disqualify yourselves from organic! I’d be interested to know.
October 4th, 2009 at 10:30 am
Mary,
Can’t speak to Kris’s dehydrating efforts, obviously, but thought I’d share my own…
Did a ton of research into different dehydrators and decided I *really* wanted an Excalibur dehydrator because of the arrangement of the heating element (ie, not so much babysitting of the trays/shifting trays around/away from the bottom heating element on the round ones.) But they’re pricey. I stalked Craigslist in the late winter, narrowly missed a fantastic deal on a near-new Excalibur and finally scored one that must be about 20 years old. It works like a champ, though.
I’ve dehydrated a lot of herbs (and found using an actual dehydrator way easier than what I’ve done in the past–hanging upside down in a paper bag, etc) and a fair amount of fruit. Blueberries and raspberries have been nice additions to granola, sweet cherries were delicious but bear in mind that flavors can really intensify in the dehydrating process. The real stars have been pears and apples. I just toss the slices in water doctored with a bit of citric acid to keep ‘em from browning before lining ‘em up on the trays to dehydrate.
I found rough guidelines for “how long” online (google dehydrate+name of fruit+how to)but quickly discovered that some trial & error was in order because there are so many variables (thickness of fruit, moisture level in air, etc). You might also poke through the books at your local SalVal/thrift store–I found a couple books on dehydrating that way.
October 4th, 2009 at 10:45 am
My husband suggested we get rid of our garden all together and only grow Goji berries. It’s so expensive to buy Goji berries and they really make us feel good when we have two small servings a day.
I think growing food is FUN though - not a money thing.
October 4th, 2009 at 2:01 pm
This Garden Project seems like a good idea. I recall being a kid on a farm and how plentiful (and cheap) food was. You may have wanted for a lot, but you never worried about food.
Anyways, does anyone have any ideas about how to set something up similar in an urban area? I have seen anything really productive/cost-effect yet. But I do know the sunspot cycle is taking a turn for the worse
(http://www.q1publishing.com/blog) and it’d be good to have a system in place. thx.
October 5th, 2009 at 6:00 am
I highly suggest using those excess blackberries to make blackberry cordial and blackberry liquor sauce (excellent on lemon tarts or ice cream).
October 5th, 2009 at 8:14 am
Made an amazing shake last night I want to share with you;
1 cup orange juice
1/2 cup of milk
1/2 cup of strawberries
1/2 cup of goji berries
1 banana
5 ice cubes
Fantastic
October 5th, 2009 at 1:30 pm
re: urban gardening. I live in the bay area, and some of the residents of my building have gotten together to install a garden. We’ve got one bed going now, and have plans to build 2 more 4×4 beds very soon - we should be able to garden year-round here.
We have room for four more same-sized raised beds but want to see how we do with the smaller area for now.
I found a great link for rooftop gardening at this link: http://www.baylocalize.org/reports/use-your-roof
October 5th, 2009 at 2:28 pm
A former college professor did something similar in a completely different climate (Arizona) and came to strikingly similar results. He was netting about $2/hr. I wonder how common that is.
October 5th, 2009 at 3:49 pm
This year I made a new attempt at growing food. I planted rainbow chard, bush beans, pumpkins and corn.
The corn was a complete failure. I didn’t give them enough depth to grow tall, and I’m not willing to spend the babysitting time they seem to need.
The pumpkins also failed completely, though I’ve no idea why. The plant just never took off.
I’ve harvested a few cups each of beans and chard. I could get more chard, as it grows constantly, but I haven’t been cooking at home enough!
Next year I’ll try pumpkins again, just for fun, but instead of corn will try basil and tomatoes. They would do well in our very sunny front yard.
October 5th, 2009 at 6:37 pm
Oooooh… Those chili peppers look mighty tasty!
October 6th, 2009 at 10:30 am
We bought our first house in June. By the time I got around to planting it was too late to really expect much. I’ve gotten maybe a pound of tomatoes and a half pound of green beans and the weather shifted this week, so not much more will be forthcoming.
My lavender is struggling, but the thyme has taken and the white sage has taken off. Let’s hear it for native plants and their drought resistance (I’m in the SF Bay Area). I am forgoing winter crop this year in favor of completely redoing the front yard into terraces and a better planting plan for the spring.
Love the Garden Project!
October 7th, 2009 at 11:31 am
Really enjoy reading about your garden project!
This is the first year I decide to plant a few herbs and veggies just for fun. I planted one basil plant and one spicy basil. I have made batches and batches of pesto this year. The basil went crazy! It’s $3.00 per 2oz at the store so I’ve come out way ahead.
I also planted a few jalepeno plants. These thrived and are still going strong. My green peppers (one plant) finally produced 4 peppers. The rosemary is still thriving. The cilantro did well early on and then died. The dill grew out of control. My mint is still going crazy. Lots of beverages with fresh mint from the garden. It’s been a nice summer.
I know I will plant basil again next year as fresh homemade pesto is wonderful! I might try habeneros and different herbs next year.
Keep the garden reports coming!
October 9th, 2009 at 7:38 am
Jessica: Share your pesto recipe!
Kris and JD: What do you include in your costs? Cost of gardening tools? Cost of dirt? Cost of fertilizer? Or just plants and seeds? I’ve built my spreadsheets since I’m just starting out. I have lots of upfront costs. So any advice would be helpful.
October 12th, 2009 at 9:53 am
Mary,
My recipe for pesto is very basic. I don’t measure so you will need to adjust to your liking. I just throw stuff in the food processor and adjust to taste.
Basil
pine nuts
fresh parmesan (this makes a world of difference if you grate it yourself. Say no to the green container!)
garlic (use fresh cloves that you mince yourself. The more garlic you add, the ’spicier’ it will become)
salt (I use sea salt - not as ’salty’ as table salt)
pepper (fresh - grind myself)
olive oil (use the extra virgin - nice flavor)
Add all ingredients, except olive oil, and pulse until well mixed. (Salt and pepper - start with a little and add as you taste.) Stream the olive oil until the consistency is a wet paste. You do not want dry pesto. Eat within 3 days or freeze.
I freeze in ice cube trays and then transfer to ziplocs. You can pop out a cube at a time. A little pesto goes a long way.
Enjoy in pasta, on garlic toast (this is the best!), and on sandwiches.
I also make versions with a basil/spinach combo and different nuts/oils (walnuts, almond oil, etc). The spinach will add a pretty bright green color which tends to last longer than just the basil. My advice is adjust one thing at a time and have fun with it.
Enjoy!