During 2008, my wife and I will be tracking how much time and money we spend growing food in our garden. (Important note: Kris tells me she is not going to track her time, which may throw a monkey wrench into the works, but I’m going to do my best to coax her into providing this information anyhow.) January is always a slow month in the garden, but it’s also full of promise. It’s time for our first chores of the year!
Pruning and staking
Early in January, Kris and I spent fifteen minutes together in the yard re-staking our fruit trees. We have two apples, a pear, and a prune. They’re inclined to grow a little crooked, so every spring we make sure they’re securely fastened to their stakes. It looks like we should also be doing this every autumn. Cost: $0. Time: 0.5 work-hours.
Last weekend, I pruned our grapes and caneberries. This is always a little scary — I don’t exactly know what I’m doing. But once I get started, I’m able to fake it. With the blackberries and raspberries, it’s obvious that last year’s canes are dead. With the grapes, I just make it up as I go along, pruning the vines back to the wire, leaving a couple buds on each spur. This is a fun job for me. I love to prune. Cost: $0. Time: 0.75 work-hours.
The seed order
In the middle of the month, Kris placed an order for seeds. As usual, she exchanged ideas with a couple fellow gardeners, and they pooled their resources. A packet of seeds contains more than we need, so it’s nice to be able to share the cost with friends. Kris says she won’t plant anything until March, but I know that as soon as we get a sunny day or two, she’ll be itching to get to work. Here’s a glimpse of her spreadsheet:

“How long did it take for you to order the seeds?” I asked Kris when I started writing this article.
“I don’t know,” she said. “Maybe three hours.”
“Three hours?!?!?!” I was flabbergasted.
“It’s not like it’s hard work,” she said. “I’m just sitting there with the catalogs, dreaming.” That’s my wife: dreaming about seeds. For our purposes — and in order to get a nice round number at the end — we’re going to say that she spent 2.75 hours selecting and ordering seeds. Her cost was $27.30.
(Update: We use Totally Tomatoes for that fruit, and Territorial Seed for most everything else.)
Year-to-date total
January was quiet. We spent 4.0 hours working on our fruit and vegetable gardens, and spent $27.30 total. February will see more action. We need to fertilize certain plants, prepare our indoor planting material, and prune the fruit trees. Best of all, we’ll plant the peas. Things won’t get really time-consuming until March, however. (Well, there’ll be plenty of other yard-work — it just won’t be food-related.)
You can read about my goals for this series in The year-long GRS project: How much does a garden really save?
GRS is committed to helping our readers save and achieve your financial goals.Savings interest rates may be low, but that’s all the more reason to shop for the best rate.Find the highest savings interest rate from Ally Bank, Capital One 360, Everbank, and more.
This article is about Food, Frugality, House and Home
Disclaimer: This content is not provided or commissioned by American Express. Opinions expressed here are author's alone, not those of American Express, and have not been reviewed, approved or otherwise endorsed by American Express. This site may be compensated through American Express Affiliate Program.
Discover is a paid advertiser of this site. Reasonable efforts are made to maintain accurate information. See the Discover online credit card application for full terms and conditions on offers and rewards.
SEARCH FOR RECENT ARTICLES



Hey JD – where are you that you can be planting in February? I’ve seen snow on Memorial Day, so I’ve got a bit longer to wait.
I plan on placing my seed order (from Burpee – where did you get yours?) in early March, start them inside in April 1, and move them outside early to mid-May. We also don’t have much room for a garden, so we’re looking at alternative techniques, like hanging tomato plants and growing as much as we can vertically.
loading....
JD
I have been reading your blog for a while and love it. I am especially interested in your garden project as it falls in line with one of our future goals of growing most of our food. I have always wondered if it will be cheaper, or just healthier.
Thanks!
Toni
loading....
It will be interesting to see how much you spend, but how do you quantify “enjoyment?” I really enjoy working in our little vegetable garden.
Also, you didn’t show us the full list, I know, but I would encourage you to order some seed that is out of character for you. I’ve raised brussel sprouts, kohlrabi, mesclun mixes, and several off the wall vegetables. It really adds to the fun
loading....
My little container garden is going to be more involved this year than last. I have a worm bin in the kitchen (they came yesterday! Worms! Yay!) and plan to have mostly peppers, because that’s what I’ll eat consistently. I’m starting them from seed inside (yay grow light!) and we’ll see if I impulse buy anything more interesting. Maybe I’ll actually go for herbs this year, too.
loading....
We just “ordered” some tomato seeds from my mother in law. For what ever reason tomatoes here (Spain) are just crap, the only good ones are from Holland. My in-laws have the best tomatoes so we’re planning on growing some on our balcony.
loading....
This is something I will watch with great interest. My father has tried to get me to grow my own vegetables for years. My retort has always been that they are too cheap for me to waste my time growing them.
Best Wishes,
D4L
loading....
Great idea! Your project could confirm or de-confirm a suspicion I’ve harbored for a long time: I’ve begun to think it costs more to have a garden than it does to buy produce in the store. Well…nonorganic produce, anyway.
Prices on organic have come down enough, though, that even if that’s all you buy, gardening may still be higher, by the time you’ve bought seeds and small plants, soil amendments, fertilizers, mesh to deflect insects, shade coverings, frost coverings, fake owl to scare off hungry birds, dog to scare off the neighbor’s toilet-seeking cats, edging to keep the grass out (sort of), chicken wire to keep the dog from digging, stakes and trellises, a shovel or two, a wheelbarrow, trowels, a rake, small nippers, large nippers…gaaaah!
The satisfaction of growing your own is pretty priceless, though. Assuming you can figure out what to do with 500 pounds of zucchini!
loading....
It will be interesting to see what the final breakout is but I do know that you get MUCH better tasting fruits and vegetables, growing them yourselves!!
I lived in apartment and did some container gardening. We lived right by the playground, therefore kids and adults picked my tomatoes clean last year! I have since moved and don’t have as much space, but I’m looking into hanging tomatoes? We’ll see how they turn out!
loading....
Thanks for sharing, I love the spreadsheet idea and I don’t know why I didn’t think of splitting my seed order too. I’ll be working up what we plan to buy, and some items that’d be nice if others wanted to go in on them, and post that to my local social list to see if anyone else wants to go in on the order.
As for vh, I guess I just don’t see the garden even coming close to being as much or more than in store produce. But then again, we buy a TON of produce, and don’t the majority of the stuff you listed to plan our garden. I’d suggest checking out the Square Foot Garden book, it really focuses on how gardening doesn’t need to cost so much.
loading....
We live in Portland, Oregon. There’s nothing (besides peas, perhaps) that we can plant outside right now. But Kris has an elaborate grow-light setup, including little mini-greenhouses. She takes over the living room every spring! I’ll post photos once she gets this set up, which I’m betting is the end of this month
We get our seeds from a variety of sources. Kris swears by Totally Tomatoes for tomatoes, and we use Territorial for most of everything else. They’re a local company that specializes in varieties for “the maritime Pacific Northwest”…
loading....
JD,
I’ve been lurking on your blog for a while and I love it! My wife and I will be moving into our first house in May and we are excited to try Square Foot Gardening (thanks to you!).
Thanks for all the great info!
-Daniel
http://youngandfrugal.wordpress.com
loading....
All I can tell you is I’m with Kris on this one. And I understand you can get great grow-lights from Amsterdam if you’re into dreaming that is.
loading....
Kris, who is standing at the window, staring at the miserable mix of rain and snow, dreaming of spring, wants for me to share a link to this post about her tomatoes. It’s from my personal site in late April 2006 (right around the time I started GRS). This is what she’s wishing for right now, but she has three months to go!
loading....
While I think it’s great to look at how this could be a real frugal opportunity, it also appears to me you folks really like working in the garden. If that’s the case, it’s not just about money; it’s about your personal fulfillment, which is one area I’d like to spend more, not less, time
-
Ryan
http://uncommon-cents.net/
loading....
I can’t wait until we can have a garden. I think of it as frugality on two fronts. One, the very tasty results. But two… it’s also really cheap entertainment, if you enjoy gardening. So you’ve killed two birds with one stone, there. It’s sort of like knitting. If you count the time as labor, the cost of a hand-knit sweater is astronomical. If you count it as entertainment, it’s quite frugal. There’s a certain lesson in learning to have fun doing things which are productive.
loading....
Barbara Kingsolver’s “Animal, Vegetable, Miracle” quantifies her savings from her garden at somewhere around $7,000/year in not spending money at the grocery store, and $4,000+ profit after the cost of garden accessories are factored in.
If you’re smart about it, and start seeing yourself as A MEMBER OF A COMMUNITY OF PEOPLE and work those connections, as opposed to always thinking about buying what the catalog tells you you need to, you’ll save thousands.
loading....
I am very interested in this as well it would be nice to know that all my hard work I put into my vegetable garden also is saving me money.
loading....
I’m not sure how much my few peppers from last year cost. Pots and dirt, stakes, plants, I already had the rope to tie them up but count that anyway, water’s included in rent. Still, everything but the plants is reusable. Once it’s warm enough, I’ll be outside dumping out the pots, breaking them up, mixing in worm compost (okay, that’s an additional fifty dollars, but it’s one-time), and getting ready for another year.
It does count as fun for me, though. I’m not willing to do anything not fun to save money.
loading....
Okay, okay, I exaggerated about the fake owl! And yup, I cruise yard sales and estate sales for gardening tools. Definitely I’ll look up the Square Foot Garden book — thanks, Donna Jean.
A friend recently gave me a special issue of _GreenPrints_ journal called _The Weeder’s Reader_. It’s very mellow, makes you laugh and cry, sometimes at once. Don’t know if you can get it on Amazon.com. But GreenPrints is at Box 1355, Fairview, NC 28730. If you enjoy gardening (and cats, dogs, & people), this strange & sweet little book is worth sending away for.
loading....
Hi J.D.
Gardening is quite time consuming, but the satisfaction of see the literal fruits of one’s labor is quite nice.
Are you two practicing any composting at all? That would save in a couple of ways:
1) less fertilizer need$ to be bought
2) less waste go into our landfills, instead the food scraps will go back into our yards
loading....
I have a small city garden and was never able too use all the seeds in a pack before they became too old to be viable. Also, all those $2.50 packets really added up and limited the number of varieties I could try. Sharing seeds with neighbors (as you are doing) is one option, but wasn’t practical for me.
I couple years back I discovered https://www.artisticgardens.com/ a seed company that sells herb and vegetable seed packets for only 35 cents each. There are always plenty of seeds for my small garden, and usually still enough to share.
loading....
JD,
If you really want to measure every last cost associated with your garden, you should measure the amount of power those grow lights consume. I would suggest using a Kill-A-Watt or a similar usage meter. I would be curious as to to how much money you’re spending on running the grow lights, as I also have a (very small) grow light setup in my home.
loading....
JD,
Great website. Here in South Carolina I can have quite a good winter garden and two plantings in the summer. Right now I have some garlic and cabbage growing and will be planting most of the summer garden the Friday after Easter. One of the ways I like to save money on my garden is by seed saving. Usually there are some left over tomatoes, peppers, cucumbers ect… that never quite get picked. Dry the seeds out dand plant them again next year. This also works great with herbs. I usually just plant the whole seed head and the next spring they sprout back up. Also great to share with fellow gardeners. Also I save on soil and fertlizer buy getting some compost at the county composting center. For $20 I can fill up the back of the pick up truck and will have a supply of soil an compost for the summer. This year I’m working on drip irrigation and a rain collection barrel to cut the biggest expense, the water bill. It gets hot and dry here in the south and my veggies get a bit thirsty.
loading....
Cool post, and timely. I love the idea of pooling seeds. Duh, we always get way too many seeds, so this is a great idea. I giggled at your grape-pruning follies. We also have grapes and just wing it when it comes time to prune. It helps that we live in wine country, so we can get advice from the pros, but until you’ve done it yourself…Also, one of my most joyous garden moments was discovering eggplant grows beautifully in our garden. Yay! So, I second the idea of trying something new each year.
loading....
[...] to your local store where it sat on the shelf for a week before you bought it. Check out this blog if you want to find out if a garden really saves you [...]
loading....
I don’t get the idea that gardening is time consuming. Last year I built 3 raised beds – total time to build and fill was about 6 hours. I watered every morning for about 10 minutes – turn on the sprinkler, make coffee, turn off sprinkler. Come home in the evening, and while I let the dog out I pull a few weeds. That’s it. In exchange, I got fresh produce, full of flavour, and only as much as I wanted – as a single person I get tired of wasting produce because I can’t eat it in time.
Buying local is important to me, so I was saddened read that Territorial Seeds is supplied by Monsanto. I’m ordering from Abundant Life this year.
loading....
[...] and decided one two companies to work with, at least until I read Get Rich Slowly’s recent gardening post. There a commenter left a tip that saved us [...]
loading....
I wanted to give a big thanks to Bekah’s comment about artisticgardens.com — we used them to help reduce our initial seed purchase and saved $68, thanks so much for sharing that site. For someone just getting started, it’s a big plus to shave some off the cost.
loading....
Totally Tomatoes has outrageous shipping rates, depending on where you live in the country. (I’m in Alaska.) I found http://www.tomatogrowers.com was a lot more reasonable.
loading....
[...] to your local store where it sat on the shelf for a week before you bought it. Check out this blog if you want to find out if a garden really saves you [...]
loading....
[...] to your local store where it sat on the shelf for a week before you bought it. Check out this blog if you want to find out if a garden really saves you money. You can read about my garden project [...]
loading....
[...] GRS Garden Project: February UpdateThe GRS Garden Project: March UpdateThe GRS Garden Project: January UpdateThe GRS Garden Project: April UpdateThe Year-Long GRS Project: How Much Does a Garden Really [...]
loading....
[...] The Year-Long GRS Project: How Much Does a Garden Really Save?The GRS Garden Project: June UpdateThe GRS Garden Project: February UpdateThe GRS Garden Project: March UpdateThe GRS Garden Project: January Update [...]
loading....
[...] Project: February UpdateThe GRS Garden Project: March UpdateThe GRS Garden Project: June UpdateThe GRS Garden Project: January UpdateThe Rise of Suburban [...]
loading....
[...] The Year-Long GRS Project: How Much Does a Garden Really Save?The GRS Garden Project: February UpdateThe GRS Garden Project: March UpdateThe GRS Garden Project: June UpdateThe GRS Garden Project: January Update [...]
loading....