Work less, live more: The pros and cons of semi-retirement

In 1988’s Cashing In on the American Dream, Paul Terhorst wrote about retiring at age 35. Although his aim was to show readers the path to early retirement, he also sang the praises of temporary retirement — retiring young with the idea that you might go back to work later in life.

As I mentioned a few days ago in my article on the five types of retirement there’s another way to mix work with financial independence. In Work Less, Live More, Bob Clyatt makes the case for semi-retirement.

The Way to Semi-Retirement

In many ways, Work Less, Live More (published in 2005) reads like an updated (and more detailed) Cashing In on the American Dream. Even the author bios sound similar. Here’s how Clyatt describes his background:

In 2001, after 20 years of sustained high-pressure work, the last seven spent battling in the Internet wars, my wife Wonda and I chucked it in, mothballed our suits, rented a small summer house in Italy, and began our new lives as early retirees.

But early retirement was no paradise for Clyatt and his wife. They were stressed, and their friends were stressed too. Did he really have enough money saved? What about the sluggish stock market? He began to question his assumptions: Had he made a terrible mistake?

Ultimately, he realized the worst-case scenario wasn’t so bad. He probably did have enough to stashed away to sustain his early retirement, but even if he didn’t the downside was that he might have to do a little work. This realization allowed him to embrace the idea of semi-retirement.

“Doing some amount of engaging work offers a comfortable transition between full work mode and full retirement mode,” Clyatt writes. “With a modest income from part-time work, early semi-retirees may not have to face the dramatic downshifting in spending and lifestyle that so often confronts those who live only on savings or pensions.”

What Is Semi-Retirement?

Here’s an extended explanation from the book:

Semi-retirement — reclaiming a proper balance between life and work by leaving a full-time job — offers a way out of the madness of overwork. By reducing spending and switching to a pared-back but more satisfying lifestyle, less money goes out the door.

Tapping into accumulated savings in a sensible way provides a steady annual income. Any shortfall can be filled with a modest amount of work, done in an entirely new state of mind: With less need to work for the largest paycheck possible, you can find low-stress work that you truly enjoy, on a schedule that gives you time to breathe.

How to Semi-Retire

Clyatt divides Work Less, Live More into eight chapters, each of which explores one of his rules for semi-retirement:

  1. Figure out why you want to do this.
  2. Live below your means.
  3. Put your investing on autopilot.
  4. Take 4% forever.
  5. Stop worrying about taxes.
  6. Do anything you want, but do something.
  7. Don’t blow it.
  8. Make your life matter.

Let’s take a closer look at the semi-retirement approach to creating work-life balance.

Figure Out Why You Want to Do This

Pursuing semi-retirement (and early retirement) requires commitment. It takes time and energy. Before you begin, Clyatt says, you should ask yourself why you want to do this. (Do you want to do this? If you love your career and want to keep working, then do so. Don’t give up a good thing!)

If semi-retirement feels like a good fit for you, you should do two things:

  • Examine your current life to determine which aspects don’t work well. Are you spending too much time in the car? Do you hate your neighborhood? Do you wish you had more time for fitness?
  • Conversely, try to imagine what your ideal life would be like. If you had all the time and money in the world, what would you do?

Using the “big rocks” metaphor, Clyatt says the key to a successful semi-retirement is prioritizing the important stuff while allowing the daily distractions to sift to the bottom of your to-do list. This concept is true for everybody, whether you want to pursue early retirement or not. To better manage your time, to increase your well-being, you ought to focus on your big rocks first.

If you decide that semi-retirement is right for you, be sure your partner is on board. You don’t want to be working at cross purposes. Also, be careful to practice moderation. Too many people become obsessed with saving too much too quickly. This can lead to disillusionment and resentment. Instead, practice balance. Remember to enjoy today even as you save for tomorrow.

Live Below Your Means

“If you are planning to semi-retire, you’ll need to spend less than you earn,” Clyatt writes. You’ll need to live below your means.

Anyone who is under 65 and on the path of semi-retirement needs to think of assets as a resource to be carefully planted and harvested. You may long for some material luxury such as a new car or a second home, and you may even have enough cash on hand to pay for it. But because you are building a safe spending and budgeting plan for the long term, you need to keep that money invested and working for you, instead.

According to Clyatt, “Living Below Your Means is spending less than you make, less than you could, less than your peers. It’s a powerful tool.” In Get Rich Slowly terms, he’s talking about the power of personal profit — the gap between your earning and spending. The greater your profit margin, the faster you can achieve your goals.

The advice in Work Less, Live More is standard stuff, but that’s not a bad thing. You hear these recommendations all the time because they work: manage your career to maximize income, cut costs wherever possible (especially on the big stuff). “Don’t even try to keep up with the Joneses,” writes Clyatt. And learn to say “no” — to your friends, to your family, and especially to yourself.

Put Your Investing on Autopilot

What do you do with your personal profit? Build an enormous retirement stash! Clyatt advocates what he calls Rational Investing. Here are its basic tenets:

  • Allocate your investments broadly. Don’t put all of your eggs into one basket. Practice smart diversification, investing in a wide variety of asset classes. In other words, don’t limit yourself to only stocks or only real estate. Own both. Plus bonds. Plus cash. And so on. Own a bit of everything.
  • Rebalance your portfolio. Have a target asset allocation — the way your money is divided among your investments — and strive to maintain that. If stocks have a good year and now your portfolio is weighted to heavily in that direction, then sell some stocks and buy whatever is now under-represented.
  • Keep management fees low. By now, most educated investors understand that fees can wreak havoc on long-term investment performance. The number-one barrier to good returns is investor behavior. But fees and expenses are the second-biggest problem.

“A semi-retiree, particularly a younger one, should not try to simply achieve the highest rate of return if that means an unacceptable level of volatility or risk,” Clyatt writes. “Choose a mix of assets to maintain an acceptable level of return at the lowest risk, which generally means holding lower levels of equity [stock] than some other long-term investing models advocate.”

Although Clyatt likes passive investing, he does not recommend putting your entire stash into a single S&P 500 index fund. He prefers a slightly more complicated (and nuanced) approach.

Take 4% Forever

“Withdrawing money safely from your portfolio each year is the engine that makes semi-retirement viable,” Clyatt writes. There are two steps to starting your economic engine:

  1. Choose a safe rate at which to withdraw.
  2. Withdraw money using a safe method.

There’s a wide range of rigorous statistical research to support the idea that it’s safe to withdraw about 4% from your portfolio each year to use as living expenses. But this number is an estimate. It’s not a rule and it’s not a guarantee. If you knew how long you were going to live and what your investment returns would be each year, it’d be easy to come up with an exact number. But you can’t know these things, so all you can do is estimate.

Studies show that withdrawing about 4% each year will allow you to keep the inflation-adjusted value of your principal intact. Of course, if your goal is to “die broke” — which some people aim to do — your spend rate can be higher. And if you’re an older semi-retiree, you can withdraw more than 4% too.

Clyatt says that in the olden days, people set their withdrawal rate on their first day of retirement — then only adjusted it for inflation in the future. So, if you had $1,000,000 saved when you retired, you’d take $40,000 for living expenses in the first year, and adjust that number annually for inflation thereafter.

Unfortunately, this method runs a high risk of depleting a portfolio if the economy turns sour. Instead, Clyatt recommends the following:

  • Each year, withdraw up to 4% of your portfolio’s value for living expenses. “You can increase the amount to 4.5% with slightly diminished safety,” he writes.
  • After a bad year for the stock market, use what he calls the 95% rule: Reduce your spending to 95% of the previous year. So, if you withdrew $40,000 for living expenses last year but the stock market has crashed, then take $38,000 this year (95% of $40,000).

How do you get your 4% living expenses out of your investment portfolio? Simple. Instead of having distributions reinvested — as most of us do — request that these funds be channeled into a money market account. Pull out more cash when you rebalance your portfolio every year. And if you need more money, then sell some of your investments.

Filling in the Blanks

The first four chapters form the bulk of the book. The last four chapters fill in some blanks, covering topics ranging from taxes to time management. Here are some highlights:

  • As a semi-retiree, your taxes will be comparatively low. Couple this with two other facts — U.S. taxes are low compared to other nations and they’re low compared to our own history — and you should let your mind rest easy. Don’t fret so much. All the same, Clyatt offers a handful of strategies for minimizing your tax burden during retirement.
  • In Cashing In on the American Dream, Paul Terhorst offered the following rule to early retirees: “Do what you wish, but you must do something. The idea is to live, not to dissipate time.” Clyatt echoes this advice. He suggests you imagine yourself as a nineteen-year-old kid going to college. You have no real idea what you want to be or do, so you engage in exploration and discovery to figure out what you like. Fill your time with meaningful hobbies, work, and experiences. (As always, I suggest people start by crafting a personal mission statement.)
  • As awesome as early retirement and semi-retirement are, they’re not without drawbacks. Don’t allow these challenges to sabotage you. Handle the guilt, the boredom, and the panic constructively. Let go of your ego and allow yourself to be ordinary. Honor your own time, and honor the time of your spouse or partner.
  • Finally, make your life matter. “It’s up to you to decide what you will make of your life,” Clyatt writes. “People with more time to stop and talk — or even better, stop and listen — could help make life a little better for everyone.”

Work Less, Live More contains ample examples from real-life people who have opted for semi-retirement. These folks come from all backgrounds and have a variety of motives for choosing this path. And semi-retirement looks different for each individual. For some it’s a chance to travel. For others, it’s a chance to pursue a passion (such as art). And for others it’s a chance to spend more time with their children.

For years, Work Less, Live More has been my go-to book for info about early retirement. I give away copies several times a year. I recommend it when replying to email. I refer to it myself when I have questions.

I like this book because it strikes a balance between the high-level Big Picture stuff (like you’d find in Cashing In on the American Dream) and the low-level nitty-gritty numbers crunching (such as the material in Early Retirement Extreme). Both of those books are great, and I recommend them too, but Work Less, Live More seems to offer the best all-around approach to early retirement planning.

More about...Retirement, Books

Become A Money Boss And Join 15,000 Others

Subscribe to the GRS Insider (FREE) and we’ll give you a copy of the Money Boss Manifesto (also FREE)

Yes! Sign up and get your free gift
Become A Money Boss And Join 15,000 Others

There are 12 comments to "Work less, live more: The pros and cons of semi-retirement".

  1. Jason@WinningPersonalFinance says 13 March 2018 at 05:59

    This sounds like a great read. I’m not sure I buy the “stop worrying about taxes” part. The optimizer in me always wants to get the most bang for my buck. I’m going to try and pay as low taxes as legally possible. It’s my patriotic duty!!! I kid, I kid. Anyway, I’ll just have to pick up the book to read his full point on the subject.

  2. Steveark says 13 March 2018 at 07:01

    I recommend working some even if you don’t need the money. I work about two days a week at various consulting jobs that I enjoy and that provide a real mental challenge as well as a ton of socialization with others. I also work about a day a week doing charitable nonprofit work and while it is important and feels good it doesn’t satisfy the same inner need to be productive that paid work does for me. We also have a lot of active mostly outdoor hobbies but they seem to fill a different set of needs than the work does. The money it makes keeps us at a zero withdrawal rate but that really isn’t the main benefit.

    • AA Wyand says 07 January 2019 at 18:49

      Steveark, this is my dream! How do you find 2 days of consulting work?

  3. Joe says 13 March 2018 at 07:10

    I haven’t read this one. This sounds like a good book. Semi retirement is the way to go for young people. You don’t want to retire to a life of idleness. You really need to keep busy and do something to improve the world or else life will be aimless.

    I’m looking forward to reading the update from Clyatt.

  4. BusyMom @ CountdownToTranquility says 13 March 2018 at 07:52

    Haven’t read this book. Will try and find it. We are probably going to be in semi-retirement forever. Just because of that fear.

  5. brian @ singledadmoney says 13 March 2018 at 08:37

    Thanks for the book recommendation. I like the idea of semi-retirement and since I’m starting out so late in life in getting my financial house in order, semi-retirement might be the only way I’ll be able to get away from the 40+ hour work week.

  6. Rebecca says 13 March 2018 at 12:47

    Starting our retirement saving “over” after the wonderful economic doom four years ago. We literally sold it all, house, business and equipment. The semi-retirement life is what we are aiming for. Somewhere between we get our mail here and work camping there. So I downloaded the book *FREE* on my kindle and will read tonight.

  7. Andy Hough says 13 March 2018 at 13:37

    I’m trying out semi-retirement this year. I talked with my boss and I’ll have 6 1/2 months off this year and should be able to keep that schedule in the coming years. My plans are to do some traveling and get in shape. I live pretty cheap so it won’t be a problem living off of 5 1/2 months income.

    • Lady Dividend says 14 March 2018 at 14:51

      Interesting! Do you do seasonal work? How will that 6.5 months of work look? All in one time of the year or a few days a week?

      • Andy Hough says 15 March 2018 at 09:08

        I’m in the tax field so it is naturally seasonal. The work will all be one time of the year.

  8. Dave @ Accidental FIRE says 14 March 2018 at 02:00

    I am now almost 6 months into my semi-retirement and loving it! Five days off and two days at work every week. I’m still in “detox” status after 26+ years of working full time.

  9. freddy smidlap says 14 March 2018 at 07:37

    i had my first real job in my mid 20’s and resigned after 5 years at age 31. i wanted to move to new orleans and i did just that with a little savings and not much more. i didn’t know if was semi-retired and i had a 20something hour a week as a hotel bartender due to not much of a cash cushion. i only stayed 2 years but it was about the best 2 years of my life. i remember the people at the r+d center where i was working telling me they thought i was crazy to lose the security but i thought i had to do it before any of the big stuff came along like a spouse, house, car, kid. 20 years later i know what it’s like to live free and wild and that i never missed out on that-so no mid-life crisis.

Leave a reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked*